This article analyses constructions of English manhood during the First World War. As such, it focuses upon cultural representations of masculinity rather the lived experiences of particular men. Such portrayals can have great social power when they gain a widespread cultural currency - not least in the impact they can have upon the lives of individuals. The central purpose is to consider the depiction of the conscientious objector to military service. Once conscription was introduced, objectors became a legally recognized category of men and special statutory provision was made for those who were deemed to be `genuine'. Despite the legitimacy that this might have granted, all objectors (whether recognized as genuine or not), along with those who defended their stance, came to be despised and rejected as deviant. Their story, as presented here, is a study of the construction and contestation of deviance (in terms of both gender and Englishness), yet in this version of the deviant the role of law is a relatively minor one.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agenda for National Convention at Memorial Hall, 27 November 1915 (1915) London: NCF .
2.
Arnold-Foster, Hugh Oakley (1898) `The Army and the Government' , The Nineteenth CenturyXLIII: 341-353 .
3.
Babington, Anthony (1983) For the Sake of Example: Capital Courts-Martial 1914-1920. London: Leo Cooper in association with Secker & Warburg .
4.
Baker, George (1930) Soul of a Skunk. London: Eric Partridge (Scholartis).
5.
Bet-Al, Ilana R. (1991) `Experience into Identity: The Writings of British Conscripts 1916-1918', PhD thesis, University of London.
6.
Bet-Al, Ilana R. (1998) `Men and Soldiers: British Conscripts, Concepts of Masculinity, and the Great War', pp. 73-94 in Billie Melman (ed.) Borderlines: Genders and Identities in War and Peace 1870-1930. London: Routledge .
7.
Bibbings, Lois S. (1995) `State Reaction to Conscientious Objection', pp. 57-81 in Ian Loveland, The Frontiers of Criminality. London: Sweet & Maxwell .
8.
Bourke, Joanna (1996) Dismembering the Male: Men's Bodies, Britain and the Great War. London: Reaktion .
9.
Box, Steven (1971/1981) Deviance, Reality and Society. London: Holt, Rinehart & Winston .
10.
Brace Committee (1919) The Home Office and Conscientious Objectors: A Report Prepared for the Committee of Imperial Defence 1919 Pt. 1. London: Home Office .
11.
Brockway, Fenner (1919) The No Conscription Fellowship: A Souvenir of its Work During the Years 1914-1919. London: NCF .
12.
Buchan, John (1919/1994) Mr Standfast. Ware: Wordsworth Classics .
13.
Buitenhuis, Peter (1987/1989) The Great War of Words: Literature as Propaganda 1914-18 and After. London: Batsford .
14.
Cohen, Stanley (1972) Folk Devils and Moral Panics. London: MacGibbon & Kee .
15.
Connell, R. W. (1995) Masculinities. Oxford: Polity Press .
16.
Cronin, A. J. (1935) The Stars Look Down. London: Gollancz .
17.
Cutbill, Jonathan (1988) `Introduction', in A. T. Fitzroy, Despised and Rejected. London: CW Daniel .
18.
Dawson, Graham (1994) Soldier Heroes: British Adventure, Empire and the Imagining of Masculinities. London: Routledge .
19.
Dicey, A. V. (1918) `The Conscientious Objector' , The Nineteenth Century LXXXIII, 492: 357-373 .
20.
Fitzroy, A. T. (Rose Allatini) (1918/1988) Despised and Rejected. London: CW Daniel .
21.
Fussell, Paul (1975/2000) The Great War and Modern Memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
22.
General Annual Reports of the British Army for the Period from 1 October 1913 to 30 September 1919 (1921) Cmd. 1193.
23.
Gilbert, Martin (1965) Plough My Own Furrow: The Story of Lord Allen of Hurtwood as Told through his Writings and Correspondence. London: Longman .
24.
Gilbert, Sandra M. (1983) `Soldier's Heart: Literary Men, Literary Women, and the Great War' , Signs3: 422-450 .
25.
Girouard, M. (1981) The Return to Camelot: Chivalry and the English Gentleman. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
26.
Graham, John W. (1922) Conscription and Conscience: A History 1916-1919. London: George Allen & Unwin .
27.
Green, M. (1980) Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul .
28.
Greenslade, William (1994) Degeneration, Culture and the Novel 1880-1940. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
Harvey, T. Edmund (1917) `Foreword', in J. Scott Druckers, Handed Over: The Prison Experiences of Mr. J. Scott Druckers, Solicitor of Chancery Lane, Under the Military Service Act. London: CW Daniel .
31.
Hobson, J. A. (1901) The Psychology of Jingoism. London: Grant Richards .
32.
Hynes, Samuel (1922) A War Imagined: The First World War and English Culture. London: Pimlico .
33.
Jackson, H. (1913/1988) The 1890s. London: Cresset Library (Century Hutchinson).
34.
James, Stanley B. (1917) The Men Who Dared: The Story of an Adventure. London: CW Daniel .
35.
Kennedy, Thomas C. (1973) `Public Opinion and the Conscientious Objector, 1915-1919' , Journal of British Studies12: 105-119 .
36.
Lacey, Nicola (1988) State Punishment: Political Principles and Community Values. London: Routledge .
37.
Lacey, Nicola (1995) `Contingency and Criminalisation', pp. 1-27 in Ian Loveland (ed.) The Frontiers of Criminality. London: Sweet & Maxwell .
38.
Langdon-Davies, B. N. (1935) `Alternative Service', pp. 179-194 in Julian Bell (ed.) We Did Not Fight: 1914-18 Experiences of War Resisters. London: Cobden-Saunderson .
39.
Leed, Eric J. (1979) No Man's Land: Combat and Identity in World War I. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
40.
Lives and Adventures of Great Soldiers in the British Army (1885) London: General Publishing Company .
41.
Lloyd George, David (1933/1938) War Memoirs of David Lloyd George, vol. I. London: Odhams .
42.
Macaulay, Rose (1916/1986) Non-Combatants and Others. London: Methuen .
43.
Manual of Military Law (1914) London: War Office .
44.
Marwick, Arthur (1964) Clifford Allen: The Open Conspirator. London: Oliver & Boyd .
45.
Mitchel, D. (1966) Women on the Warpath: The Story of the Women of the First World War. London: Jonathan Cape .
46.
Mosse, George, (1990) Fallen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of the World Wars. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
47.
Nevinson, H. W. (1916) `The Conscientious Objector' , Atlantic Monthly November: 686-694 .
48.
Playne, C. E. (1933) Britain Holds On, 1917, 1918. London: George Allen & Unwin .
49.
Plowman, Max (1944) Bridge Into the Future: Letters of Max Plowman, edited by Dorothy Lloyd Plowman. London: Andrew Dakers .
50.
Powell, E. C. Reminiscences. Imperial War Museum PP/MCR/37.
51.
Rae, John (1970) Conscience and Politics: The British Government and the Conscientious Objector to Military Service 1916-1919. London: Oxford University Press .
52.
Reader, W. J. (1988) At Duty's Call: A Study in Obsolete Patriotism. Manchester: Manchester University Press .
53.
Report on Recruiting by the Earl of Derby, K.G., Director General of Recruiting (1916) Cd. 8149.
54.
Roberts, David (1996) Minds at War: The Poetry and Experience of the First World War. Burgess Hill: Saxon .
55.
Rothstein, Andrew (1980) The Soldier Strikes of 1919. London: Macmillan .
56.
Scott Druckers, J. (1917) Handed Over: The Prison Experiences of Mr. J. Scott Druckers, Solicitor of Chancery Lane, Under the Military Service Act. London: CW Daniel .
57.
Shaw, George Bernard (1944/1945) `Conscientious Objection Versus General Strike', pp. 303-308 in Everybody's Political What's What? London: Constable .
58.
Showalter, Elaine (1987) The Female Malady: Women, Madness and English Culture 1830-1980. London: Virago .
59.
Showalter, Elaine (1992) Sexual Anarchy: Gender and Culture at the Fin de Siècle. London: Virago .
60.
Sinfield, Alan (1994) The Wilde Century: Effeminacy, Oscar Wilde and the Queer Moment. London: Cassell .
61.
Smith, Janet A. (1965) John Buchan. London: Rupert Hart-Davis .
62.
Snowden, Philip (1916) British Prussianism: The Scandal of the Tribunals. Manchester: National Labour Press .
63.
Statistics of the Military Effort of the British Empire During the Great War (1922) War Office. London: HMSO .
64.
Stone, Martin (1985) `Shellshock and the Psychologists', in W. F. Bynum, Roy Porter and Michael Shepherd (eds) The Anatomy of Madness: Essays on the History of Psychiatry, vol. 2, London: Tavistock .
65.
Tate, Trudi (1995) Women, Men and the Great War: An Anthology of Stories. Manchester: Manchester University Press .
66.
Taylor, A. J. P. (1975) English History 1914-45. Harmondsworth: Penguin .
67.
Thomis, Malcolm I. (1959) `The Labour Movement in Great Britain and Compulsory Military Service, 1914-1916', M.A. thesis, University of London.
68.
Tosh, John (1994) `What Should Historians do with Masculinity? Reflections on Nineteenth-Century Britain' , History Workshop Journal38: 179-202 .
69.
Tylee, C. M. (1990) The Great War and Women's Consciousness: Images of Militarism and Womenhood in Women's Writings, 1914-64. London: Macmillan .
70.
Williams, B. (1918) Raising and Training the New Armies. London: Constable .
71.
Winter, Jay Murray (1980) `Military Unfitness and Civilian Health in Britain During the First World War' , Journal of Contemporary HistoryXV: 211-244 .
72.
Wyatt, H. F. (1911) `God's Test by War' , Nineteenth CenturyLXIX: 591-606 .
