‘Globalist war against humanity shifts into high gear’: Online anti-vaccination websites and ‘anti-public’ discourse

Abstract

Online media has provided unprecedented opportunities for anti-vaccination groups to spread their message. An extensive scholarly literature has consequently emerged to analyse such discourse and develop strategies for countering it. In this article, I take a different approach. My contention is that it is no longer appropriate to approach anti-vaccination discourse as a stand-alone formation. Such sites, I argue, building on work by McKenzie Wark and Bart Cammaerts, are increasingly part of a wider proliferation of ‘anti-public’ discourse that contests fundamental democratic conventions, rules of argumentation and so on. The article uses a mixed methods approach based on a systematic content survey supplemented by the presentation of qualitative examples from 56 anti-vaccination websites. By locating anti-vaccination discourse in these broader contexts, I argue, it is possible to understand it as related to a more general transformation in public deliberation.

Keywords

health and media online media representations of science science experts scientific literacy vaccination

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

(2016a) Globalist war against humanity shifts into high gear: Cars, cash, literature and independent news all targeted for elimination. Available at: https://www.naturalnews.com/2016-12-05-globalist-war-against-humanity-cars-literature-independent-news-targeted-for-elimination.html (accessed 21 December 2016).

Adams

(2016b) Top 10 most delusional ‘facts’ of the lunatic left-wing fact-checkers. Available at: https://www.naturalnews.com/2016-12-18-top-10-most-delusional-facts-mentally-ill-left-news-cartels.html (accessed 22 December 2016).

Andrejevic

(2013) Infoglut: How Too Much Information Is Changing the Way We Think and Know. New York, NY: Routledge.

Baudrillard

(1983) In the Shadow of the Silent Majorities: Or, the End of the Social, and Other Essays. New York, NY: Semiotext(E).

Bean

(2011) Emerging and continuing trends in vaccine opposition website content. Vaccine 29(10): 1874–1880.

Beck

(1992) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. London: SAGE.

Betsch

(2011) Innovations in communication: The internet and the psychology of vaccination decisions. Euro Surveillance: European Communicable Disease Bulletin 16(17): 19849.

Betsch

Brewer

Brocard

Davies

Gaissmaier

Haase

et al . (2012) Opportunities and challenges of Web 2.0 for vaccination decisions. Vaccine 30(25): 3727–3733.

Betsch

Renkewitz

Betsch

Ulshöfer

(2010) The influence of vaccine-critical websites on perceiving vaccination risks. Journal of Health Psychology 15(3): 446–455.

10.

Blume

(2006) Anti-vaccination movements and their interpretations. Social Science & Medicine 62: 628–642.

11.

Bouie

(2015) How to deal with anti-vaxxers. Slate, 2 February. Available at: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2015/02/anti_vaxxers_resist_persuasion_if_they_refuse_we_have_to_force_them_to_vaccinate.html (accessed 3 September 2017).

12.

Bucchi

(2017) Credibility, expertise and the challenges of science communication 2.0. Public Understanding of Science 26(8): 890–893.

13.

Callon

Lascoumes

Barthe

(2009) Acting in an Uncertain World: An Essay on Technical Democracy (trans. Burchell

). Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

14.

Cammaerts

(2007) Jamming the political: Beyond counter-hegemonic practices. Continuum: Journal of Media & Cultural Studies 21(1): 71–90.

15.

Carrion

(2017) ‘You need to do your research’: Vaccines, contestable science, and maternal epistemology. Public Understanding of Science 27: 310–324.

16.

Casiday

(2007) Children’s health and the social theory of risk: Insights from the British measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) controversy. Social Science & Medicine 65(5): 1059–1070.

17.

Clarke

(2011) A case of conflicting norms? Mobilizing and accountability information in newspaper coverage of the autism-vaccine controversy. Public Understanding of Science 20(5): 609–626.

18.

Clarke

Weberling McKeever

Holton

Dixon

(2015) The influence of weight-of-evidence messages on (vaccine) attitudes: A sequential mediation model. Journal of Health Communication 20(11): 1302–1309.

19.

Cook

(n.d.) Mandatory vaccination myth #5: Trust your government. Available at: http://www.stopmandatoryvaccination.com/public-health/myth-5-trust-your-government/ (accessed 13 January 2017).

20.

Corriher

(2014) The communistic lies of socialized medicine in America. Available at: http://healthwyze.org/reports/660-the-communistic-lies-of-socialized-medicine-in-america (accessed 13 January 2017).

21.

Dahlberg

(2001) The internet and democratic discourse: Exploring the prospects of online deliberative forums extending the public sphere. Information, Communication & Society 4(4): 615–633.

22.

Daniels

(2009) Cyber Racism: White Supremacy Online and the New Attack on Civil Rights. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

23.

Davies

Chapman

Leask

(2002) Antivaccination activists on the World Wide Web. Archives of Disease in Childhood 87(1): 22–25.

24.

Davies

(2017) Elite power under advanced neoliberalism. Theory, Culture & Society 34: 227–250.

25.

Ditz

(2013) Those lists of papers claiming that vaccines cause autism: They don’t show what they claim (part 1). Available at: http://lizditz.typepad.com/i_speak_of_dreams/2013/08/-those-lists-of-papers-that-claim-vaccines-cause-autism-part-1.html (accessed 21 December 2016).

26.

Driessen

(2015) Climate activists want us prosecuted under RICO. Watts Up with That? Available at: https://wattsupwiththat.com/2015/09/29/climate-activists-want-us-prosecuted-under-rico/ (accessed 14 November 2016).

27.

Durbach

(2000) ‘They might as well brand us’: Working-class resistance to compulsory vaccination in Victorian England. Social History of Medicine 13(1): 45–63.

28.

England

(2015) Six month-old baby dies just five days after receiving 13 vaccines. Available at: https://vactruth.com/2015/04/23/baby-dies-after-13-vaccines/ (accessed 28 January 2018).

29.

Fisher

(2016) CDC wants to expand power to eliminate measles what you need to know and do now. Available at: http://www.nvic.org/nvic-vaccine-news/september-2016/cdc-wants-to-expand-power-to-eliminate-measles.aspx (accessed 22 December 2016).

30.

Goldstein

(2016) Why you can’t find safe vaccines. Available at: https://vactruth.com/2016/09/17/why-you-cant-find-safe-vaccines/ (accessed 22 December 2016).

31.

Grant

Hausman

Cashion

Lucchesi

Patel

Roberts

(2015) Vaccination persuasion online: A qualitative study of two provaccine and two vaccine-skeptical websites. Journal of Medical Internet Research 17: e133. Available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4468570/ (accessed 18 October 2016).

32.

GreenMedInfo (2015) Over 600 cases of sudden infant death syndrome following vaccination were reported from 1990–1997. Available at: http://www.greenmedinfo.com/article/over-600-cases-sudden-infant-death-syndrome-following-vaccination-were-reported-1990-1997 (accessed 19 December 2016).

33.

Habermas

(2001) The Inclusion of the Other. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

34.

Hagopian

(2016) Pizzagate: Podesta pedo perps and Clinton’s international child sex trafficking ring exposed. Available at: http://www.whale.to/c/pizzagate77.html (accessed 22 December 2016).

35.

Handley

(2016) Why are CDC employees ‘crying in the hallways’ after Donald Trump’s election? Available at: http://healthimpactnews.com/2016/why-are-cdc-employees-crying-in-the-hallways-after-donald-trumps-election/ (accessed 20 December 2016).

36.

Hemmer

(2016) Messengers of the Right: Conservative Media and the Transformation of American Politics. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

37.

Heyes

(2016) Hillary Clinton wants to force vaccinate your children, have them owned by the state. Available at: http://www.naturalnews.com/055675_Hillary_Clinton_forced_vaccination_statist.html (accessed 21 December 2016).

38.

Hieg

(2015) How vaccine hysteria could spark totalitarian nightmare. Available at: http://vaccinechoicecanada.com/in-the-news/how-vaccine-hysteria-could-spark-totalitarian-nighmare-by-lee-hieg-md/ (accessed 22 December 2016).

39.

Hodges

(2009) Depopulation by inoculation (part 1): Motive and intent. Available at: https://vactruth.com/2009/09/08/depopulation-by-inoculation-part-1-motive-and-intent/ (accessed 13 December 2016).

40.

Holan

Jacobson

(2011) Michele Bachmann says HPV vaccine can cause mental retardation. Available at: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/sep/16/michele-bachmann/bachmann-hpv-vaccine-cause-mental-retardation/ (accessed 2 September 2017).

41.

Jacoby

(2009) The Age of American Unreason. New York, NY: Vintage Books.

42.

Jane

(2014) ‘Back to the kitchen, cunt’: Speaking the unspeakable about online misogyny. Continuum 28(4): 558–570.

43.

Kahan

(2014) Vaccine risk perceptions and Ad Hoc risk communication: An empirical assessment (ID 2386034). SSRN scholarly paper, Social Science Research Network, Rochester, NY, 27 January. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2386034 (accessed 28 November 2016).

44.

Kata

(2010) A postmodern Pandora’s box: Anti-vaccination misinformation on the Internet. Vaccine 28(7): 1709–1716.

45.

Kata

(2012) Anti-vaccine activists, Web 2.0, and the postmodern paradigm: An overview of tactics and tropes used online by the anti-vaccination movement. Vaccine 30(25): 3778–3789.

46.

Kaufman

(2010) Regarding the rise in autism: Vaccine safety doubt, conditions of inquiry, and the shape of freedom. Ethos 38(1): 8–32.

47.

Kopplin

(2016) Trump met with prominent anti-vaccine activists during campaign. Available at: http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/11/trump-met-prominent-anti-vaccine-activists-during-campaign (accessed 12 December 2016).

48.

Lakoff

(2015) Vaccine politics and the management of public reason. Public Culture 27(377): 419–425.

49.

Larson

de Figueiredo

Xiahong

Schulz

Verger

Johnston

et al . (2016) The state of vaccine confidence 2016: Global insights through a 67-country survey. EBioMedicine 12: 295–301.

50.

Larson

(2016) Autism advocates met with president elect Trump last August. Available at: http://www.ageofautism.com/2016/11/health-choice-leadership-met-with-president-elect-trump-last-august.html (accessed 22 December 2016).

51.

Lockwood

(2010) Seeding doubt: How sceptics have used new media to delay action on climate change. Geopolitics, History and International Relations 2(2): 136–164.

52.

Lord

(2010) Medical martial law in the US – Sleeping giant of tyranny. Available at: http://vaccineresistancemovement.org/?p=5865 (accessed 22 December 2016).

53.

Luyten

Desmet

Dorgali

Hens

Beutels

(2013) Kicking against the pricks: Vaccine sceptics have a different social orientation. European Journal of Public Health 24: 310–314.

54.

Mercola

(2010) New proof that flu shots are unnecessary and ineffective. Available at: http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2010/11/01/flu-vaccine-and-its-side-effects.aspx (accessed 19 December 2016).

55.

Mercola

(2016) Freedom of thought and religious beliefs are under attack. Available at: http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2016/11/13/vaccine-injury-exemptions.aspx (accessed 22 December 2016).

56.

Mihailidis

Viotty

(2017) Spreadable spectacle in digital culture: Civic expression, fake news, and the role of media literacies in ‘post-fact’ society. American Behavioral Scientist 61(4): 441–454.

57.

Moran

Lucas

Everhart

Morgan

Prickett

(2016) What makes anti-vaccine websites persuasive? A content analysis of techniques used by anti-vaccine websites to engender anti-vaccine sentiment. Journal of Communication in Healthcare 9: 151–163.

58.

Mouffe

(2013) Agonistics: Thinking the World Politically. London; New York, NY: Verso Books.

59.

Mudde

(2010) The populist radical right: A pathological normalcy. West European Politics 33(6): 1167–1186.

60.

Nasir

(2000) Reconnoitering the antivaccination web sites: News from the front. Journal of Family Practice 49(8): 731–731.

61.

Natural News Editors (2016) Zika: A masterpiece of public mind control. Available at: http://www.naturalnews.com/055809_Zika_mind_control_propaganda.html (accessed 19 December 2016).

62.

O’Neill

Boykoff

(2011) The role of new media in engaging the public with climate change. In: Whitmarsh

Lorenzoni

O’Neill

(eds) Engaging the Public with Climate Change: Behaviour Change and Communication. Abingdon: Earthscan, pp. 233–251.

63.

Poland

Jacobson

(2001) Understanding those who do not understand: A brief review of the anti-vaccine movement. Vaccine 19(17): 2440–2445.

64.

Robichaud

Hawken

Beard

Morra

Tomlinson

Wilson

(2012) Vaccine-critical videos on YouTube and their impact on medical students’ attitudes about seasonal influenza immunization: A pre and post study. Vaccine 30(25): 3763–3770.

65.

Shelby

Ernst

(2013) Story and science: How providers and parents can utilize storytelling to combat anti-vaccine misinformation. Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics 9(8): 1795–1801.

66.

Silvers

Ellenberg

Wise

Varricchio

Mootrey

Salive

(2001) The epidemiology of fatalities reported to the vaccine adverse event reporting system 1990–1997. Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety 10(4): 279–285.

67.

‘soothsayer’ (2016) Blind belief in authority a hypnotic state. Available at: http://www.vaccinationinformationnetwork.com/blind-belief-in-authority-a-hypnotic-state/ (accessed 18 January 2017).

68.

Thomas

(2015) Is the US medical mafia murdering alternative health doctors who have real cures not approved by the FDA? Available at: https://healthimpactnews.com/2015/is-the-u-s-medical-mafia-murdering-alternative-health-doctors-who-have-real-cures-not-approved-by-the-fda/ (accessed 13 January 2017).

69.

Thomas

(2016) The battle for America’s soul: Ways to combat mind control. Available at: http://healthimpactnews.com/2016/the-battle-for-americas-soul-ways-to-combat-mind-control/ (accessed 19 December 2016).

70.

Vaccine Facts (n.d.) VacFacts. Info – Home page. Available at: http://www.vacfacts.info/ (accessed 19 December 2016).

71.

Vaccine Impact (2015) Why you cannot trust the mainstream media for accurate vaccine news: Measles vaccine coverup. Available at: https://vaccineimpact.com/2015/why-you-cannot-trust-the-mainstream-media-for-accurate-vaccine-news-measles-vaccine-coverup/ (accessed 14 January 2017).

72.

Vaccine-Injury (n.d.-a) Brain damage/death from vaccines is not rare. Available at: http://vaccine-injury.info (accessed 19 December 2016).

73.

Vaccine-Injury (n.d.-b) The origin of AIDS: The polio vaccine. Available at: http://vaccine-injury.info/polio-vaccine.cfm (accessed 16 December 2016).

74.

Vaccine Liberation Army (2015) Breaking news: Climate change-man made carbon dioxide is NOT the problem. Available at: http://vaccineliberationarmy.com/2015/10/05/breaking-news-climate-change-man-made-carbon-dioxide-is-not-the-problem/ (accessed 22 December 2016).

75.

Vaccine Liberation Army (2016a) Birther document forensics. Available at: http://vaccineliberationarmy.com/2016/12/21/birther-document-forensics/ (accessed 22 December 2016).

76.

Vaccine Liberation Army (2016b) WACO documentary film – The FACTS – A new revelation. Available at: http://vaccineliberationarmy.com/2016/01/20/waco-documentary-film/ (accessed 22 December 2016).

77.

Vaccine Resistance Movement (n.d.) VRM Articles. Available at: http://vaccineresistancemovement.org/ (accessed 19 December 2016).

78.

Vaccine Risk Awareness (n.d.-a) Did vaccines really halt killer diseases? Available at: http://vaccineriskawareness.com/history-of-vaccines/ (accessed 19 December 2016).

79.

Vaccine Risk Awareness (n.d.-b) Vaccination DESTROYS natural immunity! Available at: http://vaccineriskawareness.com/vaccination-and-natural-immunity/ (accessed 19 December 2016).

80.

VacLib (n.d.) Questions and answers. Available at: http://vaclib.org/intro/qandaone.htm (accessed 19 December 2016).

81.

Van Dijk

(1997) What is political discourse analysis. Belgian Journal of Linguistics 11(1): 11–52.

82.

Wakefield

Murch

Anthony

Linnell

Casson

Malik

et al . (1998) RETRACTED: Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children. The Lancet 351(9103): 637–641.

83.

Wark

(1997) Black thunder. In: Bayliss

Holt

(eds) Transit Lounge. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Craftsman House, pp. 180–184.

84.

Wells

(2016) Vaccine ‘herd immunity theory’ dismantled and debunked. Available at: http://www.naturalnews.com/053756_herd_immunity_theory_vaccine_industry_science_propaganda.html (accessed 19 December 2016).

85.

Wilson

Keelan

(2013) Social media and the empowering of opponents of medical technologies: The case of anti-vaccinationism. Journal of Medical Internet Research 15(5): e103.

86.

Wilyman

(2014) The truth behind vaccinations. What the government doesn’t tell you. Available at: http://vaccinationdecisions.net (accessed 21 December 2016).

87.

Wolfe

Sharp

Lipsky

(2002) Content and design attributes of antivaccination web sites. JAMA 287(24): 3245–3248.

88.

Worthington

(2001) Chemtrails: Delivery system for dept. of defense’s toxic cocktails. Available at: http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2001/08/08/chemtrails.aspx (accessed 4 December 2016).

89.

Zimmerman

Wolfe

Fox

Nowalk

Troy

et al . (2005) Vaccine criticism on the World Wide Web. Journal of Medical Internet Research 7(2): e17.

90.

Žižek

(1999) The Ticklish Subject: The Absent Centre of Political Ontology. London: Verso Books.