When reporting health risks, the news media are often criticized for omitting “mobilizing” information that allows readers to act on existing attitudes. Using American and British newspaper coverage of the autism–vaccine controversy as a case study, this article takes a “behind the scenes” look at normative pressures that may influence whether such information appears in coverage. In particular, can holding health officials accountable for their actions potentially “crowd out” mobilizing information? A content analysis suggests that mobilizing information (at least one of four examples) was present in only 16% of articles, compared to 38% that mentioned accountability messages (at least one of two examples). US newspapers were significantly more likely to mention at least one mobilization example. Finally, although only 11% discussed both, articles were more likely to discuss certain mobilizing and accountability examples together. Implications for journalism ethics and vaccine risk communication are discussed.
BanduraA. (2004) “Health Promotion by Social Cognitive Means,” Health Education & Behavior31(2): 143–64.
6.
BarnesM.D.HansonC.L.NovillaL.M.B.MeachamA.T.McIntyreE.EricksonB.C. (2008) “Analysis of Media Agenda Setting during and after Hurricane Katrina: Implications for Emergency Preparedness, Disaster Response, and Disaster Policy,” American Journal of Public Health98(4): 604–9.
7.
BarnettS. (2002) “Will a Crisis in Journalism Provoke a Crisis in Democracy?,” The Political Quarterly73(4): 400–8.
8.
BennettW.L. (1996) “An Introduction to Journalism Norms and Representations in Politics,” Political Communication13: 373–84.
9.
BennettW.L.LawrenceR.G.LivingstonS. (2006) “None Dare Call it Torture: Indexing and the Limits of Press Independence in the Abu Ghraib Scandal,” Journal of Communication56(3): 467–85.
10.
BlumeS. (2006) “Anti-vaccination Movements and their Interpretations,” Social Science & Medicine62: 625–42.
11.
BoseleyS. (2001) “£3m Advert Drive to Promote MMR Jabs: Medical Establishment Seeks to Restore Faith in Vaccine,” The Guardian23January, p. 1.
12.
BoykoffM.T.BoykoffJ.M. (2004) “Balances as Bias: Global Warming and the U.S. Prestige Press,” Global Environmental Change14: 125–36.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (1999) “Notice to Readers. Thimerosal in Vaccines: A Joint Statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Public Health Service,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report48(26): 563–5.
16.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2009) “Thimerosal in Seasonal Influenza Vaccine,” URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.cdc.gov/flu/about/qa/thimerosal.htm
17.
ChoJ.ShahD.V.McLeodJ.M.McLeodD.M.SchollR.M.GotliebM.R. (2009) “Campaigns, Reflection, and Deliberation: Advancing an O-S-R-O-R Model of Communication Effects,” Communication Theory19(1): 66–88.
18.
ClarkeC. (2008) “A Question of Balance: The Autism-Vaccine Controversy in the British and American Elite Press,” Science Communication30(1): 77–107.
19.
DaviesP.ChapmanS.LeaskJ. (2002) “Antivaccination Activists on the World Wide Web,” Archives of Disease in Childhood87: 22–5.
20.
DeSilvaM.MuskavitchM.A.RocheJ.P. (2004) “Print Media Coverage of Antibiotic Resistance,” Science Communication26(1): 31–43.
21.
DonohueG.A.OlienC.N.TichenorP.J. (1985) “Reporting Conflict by Pluralism, Newspaper Type and Ownership,” Journalism Quarterly62(3): 489–507.
22.
DonohueG.A.TichenorP.J.OlienC.N. (1995) “A Guard Dog Perspective on the Role of the Media,” Journal of Communication45(2): 115–32.
23.
DudoA.D.DahlstromM.F.BrossardD. (2007) “Reporting a Potential Pandemic: A Risk-related Assessment of Avian Influenza Coverage in U.S. Newspapers,” Science Communication28(4): 429–54.
24.
DunwoodyS.RossowM. (1989) “Community Pluralism and Newspaper Coverage of a High-level Nuclear Waste Siting Issue,” in GrunigL.A. (ed.) Monographs in Environmental Education and Environmental Studies, pp. 5–21. Troy, Oh: North American Association for Environmental Education.
FrancoisG.DuclosP.MargolisH.LavanchyD.SiegristC.MeheusA.. (2005) “Vaccine Safety Controversies and the Future of Vaccination Programs,” Pediatric Infectious Diseases24: 953–61.
27.
GriffinR.J.DunwoodyS.GehrmannC. (1995) “The Effects of Community Pluralism on Press Coverage of Health Risks from Local Environmental Contamination,” Risk Analysis15(4): 449–58.
28.
GriffinR.J.DunwoodyS.ZabalaF. (1998) “Public Reliance on Risk Communication Channels in the Wake of a Cryptosporidium Outbreak,” Risk Analysis18(4): 367–75.
29.
GriffinR.J.YangZ.ter HuurneE.BoernerF.OrtizS.DunwoodyS. (2008) “After the Flood: Anger, Attribution, and the Seeking of Information,” Science Communication29(3): 285–315.
HaugC.J. (2008) “Human Papillomavirus Vaccination: Reasons for Caution,” New England Journal of Medicine359: 861–2.
32.
HortonR. (2004) “The Lessons of MMR,” Lancet363(9411) (6March): 747–9.
33.
Institute for Vaccine Safety (2009) “Thimerosal Content in Some U.S. Licensed Vaccines,” URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.vaccinesafety.edu/thi-table.htm
34.
Institute of Medicine (2004) Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
35.
IsaacsonW. (2008) “How to Save Your Newspaper,” Time173(6) (16February): 30–3.
LeaskJ.ChapmanS. (2002) “‘The Cold Hard Facts’: Immunization and Vaccine-preventable Diseases in Australia’s Newsprint Media, 1993–1998,” Social Science & Medicine54: 445–57.
38.
LemertJ.B. (1984) “News Contexts and the Elimination of Mobilizing Information: An Experiment,” Journalism Quarterly61(2): 243–9.
39.
LemertJ.B.AshmanM.G. (1983) “Extent of Mobilizing Information in Opinion and News Magazines,” Journalism Quarterly60(4): 657–62.
40.
LemertJ.B.MitzmanB.N.SeitherM.A.CookR.H.HackettR. (1977) “Journalists and Mobilizing Information,” Journalism Quarterly54(4): 721–6.
41.
LewisJ.SpeersT. (2003) “Misleading Media Reporting? The MMR Story,” Nature Reviews: Immunology3: 913–18.
42.
McComasK.A. (2004) “Even the ‘Best Laid’ Plans Go Wrong: Strategic Risk Communication for New and Emerging Risks,” EMBO Reports5: S61–S65.
43.
McLeodJ.M.ScheufeleD.A.MoyP. (1999) “Community, Communication, and Participation: The Role of Mass Media and Interpersonal Discussion in Local Political Participation,” Political Communication16: 315–36.
44.
McManusJ. (1992) “Serving the Public and Serving the Market: A Conflict of Interest?,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics7(4): 196–208.
45.
McManusJ. (1995) “A Market-based Model of News Production,” Communication Theory5(4): 301–38.
46.
MasonB.W.DonnellyP.D. (2000) “Impact of a Local Newspaper Campaign on the Uptake of the Measles Mumps and Rubella Vaccine,” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health54: 473–4.
MoriartyC.M.StrykerJ.E. (2008) “Prevention and Screening Efficacy Messages in Newspaper Accounts of Cancer,” Health Education Research23(3): 487–98.
49.
MurchS.H.AnthonyA.CassonD.H.MalikM.BerelowitzM.DhillonA.P.ThomsonM.A.ValentineA.DaviesS.E.Walker-SmithJ.A. (2004) “Retraction of an Interpretation,” Lancet363(9411) (6March): 750.
ParkerS.K.SchwartzB.ToddJ.PickeringL.K. (2004) “Thimerosal-containing Vaccines and Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Critical Review of Published Original Data,” Pediatrics114: 793–804.
58.
PettsJ.NiemeyerS. (2004) “Health Risk Communication and Amplification: Learning from the MMR Vaccination Controversy,” Health, Risk & Society6(1): 7–23.
PolandG.A.JacobsenR.M. (2001) “Understanding Those Who Do Not Understand: A Brief Review of the Anti-vaccine Movement,” Vaccine19: 2440–5.
61.
PrueC.E.LackeyC.SwenarskiL.GanttJ.M. (2003) “Communication Monitoring: Shaping CDC’s Emergency Risk Communication Efforts,” Journal of Health Communication8(3): 35–49.
62.
RocheJ.P.MuskavitchM.A. (2003) “Limited Precision in Print Media Communication of West Nile Virus Risks,” Science Communication24(3): 353–65.
63.
RossowM.D.DunwoodyS. (1991) “Inclusion of ‘Useful’ Details in Newspaper Coverage of a High-level Nuclear Waste Siting Controversy,” Journalism Quarterly68: 87–100.
64.
RyanM. (2001) “Journalistic Ethics, Objectivity, Existential Journalism, Standpoint Epistemology, and Public Journalism,” Journal of News Media Ethics16(1): 3–22.
65.
ScheufeleD.A.ShahD.V. (2000) “Personality Strength and Social Capital: The Role of Dispositional and Informational Variables in the Production of Civic Participation,” Communication Research27(2): 107–31.
ShahD.V. (1998) “Civic Engagement, Interpersonal Trust, and Television Use: An Individual-level Assessment of Social Capital,” Political Psychology19(3): 469–96.
68.
SiebertF.S.PetersonT.SchrammW. (1963) Four Theories of the Press. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
69.
SmithM.J.EllenbergS.S.BellL.M.RubinD.M. (2008) “Media Coverage of the Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccine and Autism Controversy and its Relationship to MMR Immunization Rates in the United States,” Pediatrics121: e836–e843.
70.
StephensL.F. (2005) “News Narrative about Nano S&T in Major U.S. and Non-U.S. Newspapers,” Science Communication27(2): 175–99.
ValentiJ.M. (1998) “Ethical Decision Making in Environmental Communication,” Journal of Mass Media Ethics13(4): 219–13.
73.
VastermanP.YzermansC.J.DirkzwagerA.J.E. (2005) “The Role of the Media and Media Hypes in the Aftermath of Disasters,” Epidemiological Reviews27: 107–14.
74.
WakefieldA.J.MurchS.H.AnthonyA.LinnellJ.CassonD.M.MalikM.BerelowitzM.DhillonA.P.ThomsonM.A.HarveyP.ValentineA.DaviesS.E.Walker-SmithJ.A. (1998) “Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia, Non-specific Colitis, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder in Children,” Lancet351(9103) (28February): 637–41.
