This case study explores why South Korean journalists overlooked allegations of scientific misconduct against South Korean scientist Dr. Woo Suk Hwang and even indirectly defended him in 2005—6. Nineteen journalists, who covered Hwang’s story for five of South Korea’s leading daily newspapers, were interviewed. The interviewees added insights about the news coverage of the Hwang scandal not identified in previous literature, such as the difficulties among journalists to suspend their personal disbelief about the criticisms and evidence against Hwang. The findings suggest the news judgments that occurred in Korean newsrooms during the Hwang scandal reflected a socially constructed process of negotiation among news media professionals and between journalists and scientists. The findings also suggest it may be best to consider journalistic mores within a multidimensional framework that includes journalistic perceptions of socio-cultural norms, internal newsroom standards for evidence, newsroom competence and training, normative journalism ethics, news gathering techniques, perceived dissonance and professed risk avoidance.
Ban, H. ( 2006) "The Hwang Scandal and TV News," in Y.J. Won and G.C. Jeon (eds) The Fall of Mythology, the Phantom of National Interest, pp. 151-210. Seoul: Hannarae . (in Korean)
2.
Berger, A.A. ( 1998) Media Research Techniques. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
3.
Choi, Y.J. ( 2006) "Trapped by the Development-centered Reporting," in Y.J. Won and G.C. Jeon (eds) The Fall of Mythology, the Phantom of National Interest, pp. 211-46. Seoul: Hannarae. (in Korean)
4.
Chong, S. and Normile, D. (2006) "How Young Korean Researchers Helped Unearth a Scandal," Science 311: 22-3, 25. Cohn, V. and Cope, L. (2001) News & Numbers. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press.
5.
Dunwoody, S. ( 1999) "Scientists, Journalists, and the Meaning of Uncertainty ," in S.M. Friedman, S. Dunwoody and C.L. Rogers (eds) Communicating Uncertainty, pp. 59-79. Mahwah, NJ: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.
6.
Ebeling, M.F.E. ( 2008) "Mediating Uncertainty: Communicating the Financial Risks of Nanotechnologies," Science Communication29(3): 335-61.
7.
Entwistle, V. and Hancock-Beaulieu, M. ( 1992) "Health and Medical Coverage in the UK National Press ," Public Understanding of Science1(4): 367-82.
8.
Fahnestock, J. ( 1986) "Accommodating Science: The Rhetorical Life of Scientific Facts," Written Communication3(3): 275-96.
9.
Han, H. ( 2006) Report on Hwang’s Scandal. Seoul : Sahoepyengron. (in Korean)
10.
Hartz, J. and Chappell, R. ( 1997) Worlds Apart: How the Distance between Science and Journalism Threatens America’s Future. Nashville, TN: First Amendment Center.
11.
Heo, C., Uhm, K. and Chang, J. ( 2000) "South Korea," in S.A. Gunaratne (ed.) Handbook of the Media in Asia, pp. 611-37. London : SAGE.
12.
Jun, B. and Kim, M. ( 2006) "Bioethical Debates on Embryonic Stem Cell Research in Korean Newspapers," Paper presented at the 9th International Conference on Public Communication of Science and Technology , Seoul, Korea.
13.
Jeon, G.C. ( 2006) "Criticism on and Prospect of the Korean Press’s Performance," in Y.J. Won and G.C. Jeon (eds) The Fall of Mythology, the Phantom of National Interest, pp. 341-76. Seoul: Hannarae.
14.
Kang, M., Kim, N., Kim, H. and Lee, S. ( 2007) "Patriotic Passion and ‘Sublime’ Science," Korean Journal of Journalism and Communication Studies51(1): 59-90.
15.
Kim, H. ( 2006) "Mass Media’s Strategy for Covering Uncertainty ," unpublished Master’s Thesis, Sogang University , Korea.
16.
Kim, Y.W. ( 2004) The Accountability System of Korean Journalism. Seoul: Korea Press Foundation.
17.
Lazarsfeld, P.F. ( 1944) "The Controversy over Detailed Interviews," Public Opinion Quarterly8(1): 38-60.
Levi, R. ( 2001) Medical Journalism: Exposing Fact, Fiction, Fraud. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press.
20.
Mun, J.D. ( 2006) "Philosophical Reflection on Korean Journalism," in Y.J. Won and G.C. Jeon (eds) The Fall of Mythology, the Phantom of National Interest, pp. 291-316. Seoul: Hannarae . (in Korean)
21.
Nelkin, D. ( 1995) Selling Science: How the Press Covers Science and Technology . New York: Freeman.
22.
Normile, D. and Vogel, G. ( 2005) "Korean University Will Investigate Cloning Paper," Science310: 1748-9.
23.
Pickard, A.J. ( 2007) Research Methods in Information. London : Facet Publishing.
24.
Rowan, K.E. ( 1999) "Effective Explanation of Uncertain and Complex Science ," in S.M. Friedman, S. Dunwoody and C.L. Rogers (eds) Communicating Uncertainty, pp. 201-24. Mahwah, NJ: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.
25.
Shortland, M. and Gregory, J. ( 1991) Communicating Science: A Handbook. New York: Longman.
26.
Sin, M. and Park, J. ( 2004) A Textlinguistic Analysis of Newspaper Articles. Seoul: Korea Media Research Center.
27.
Smithson, M. ( 1993) "Ignorance and Science: Dilemmas, Perspectives, and Prospects ," Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization15(2): 133-56.
28.
Stilgoe, J. ( 2007) "The (Co-)Production of Public Uncertainty: UK Scientific Advice on Mobile Phone Health Risks," Public Understanding of Science16(1): 45-61.
29.
Stocking, S.H. ( 1999) "How Journalists Deal with Scientific Uncertainty," in S.M. Friedman, S. Dunwoody and C.L. Rogers (eds) Communicating Uncertainty, pp. 23-41. Mahwah, NJ: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.
30.
Stocking, S.H. and Holstein, L.W. ( 1993) "Constructing and Reconstructing Scientific Ignorance: Ignorance Claims in Science and Journalism," Knowledge: Creating, Diffusion, Utilization15(2): 186-210.
31.
Weigold, M.F. ( 2001) "Communicating Science: A Review of the Literature," Science Communication23(2): 164-93.
32.
Wimmer, R.D. and Dominick, J.R. ( 2006) Mass Media Research: An Introduction. New York: Thomson Wadsworth.
33.
Zehr, S.C. ( 1999) "Scientists’ Representations of Uncertainty," in S.M. Friedman, S. Dunwoody and C.L. Rogers (eds) Communicating Uncertainty, pp. 3-21. Mahwah, NJ: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.
