Many of the leading contributors to the field of environmental ethics demonstrate a preference for foundationalist approaches in their theoretical justifications of environmentalism. In this paper, I criticise this tendency as it figures in the work of Holmes Rolston III, J. Baird Callicott, and Eric Katz. I illustrate how these writers’ desire for philosophical absolutes leads them to reject the moral resources present within human culture; a move that carries with it a number of troubling philosophical and political problems. I conclude that environmental theorists would be better served by taking a more contextual, social, and pragmatic approach to justifying their moral projects regarding nature, and that this mode of inquiry will ultimately lead toward a more philosophically sound and democratically authentic environmental ethics.
Callicott, BairdJ.1989. In Defense of the Land Ethic. Albany: State University of New York Press.
2.
Callicott, BairdJ.1990. ‘The Case Against Moral Pluralism’. Environmental Ethics12: 9–24.
3.
Callicott, BairdJ.1995. ‘Environmental Philosophy Is Environmental Activism: The Most Radical and Effective Kind’, in MariettaDon E.Jr. and EmbreeLester (eds) Environmental Philosophy and Environmental Activism, pp. 19–35. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.
4.
DeesRichard1994. ‘Living With Contextualism’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy24: 243–260.
5.
DeweyJohn1929. Experience and Nature. La Salle: Open Court.
6.
DeweyJohn1957 (Orig 1920). Reconstruction in Philosophy. Boston: Beacon Press.
7.
DeweyJohn1985 (Orig 1931). ‘Context and Thought’, in BoydstonJo Ann (ed) The Later Works of John Dewey6. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press.
8.
DunlapRiley1992. ‘Trends in Public Opinion Toward Environmental Issues:1965–1990’, in DunlapRiley and MertigA. (eds) American Environmentalism: The U.S. Environmental Movement, 1970–1990, pp. 89–116. Washington DC: Taylor and Francis.
9.
GeertzClifford1984. ‘Distinguished Lecture: Anti Anti-Relativism’. American Anthropologist86: 263–278.
10.
GouinlockJames1993. Rediscovering the Moral Life: Philosophy and Human Practice. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.
11.
HerzogDon1985. Without Foundations. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
12.
JamesWilliam1996 (Orig 1909). A Pluralistic Universe. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
13.
KatzEric1987. ‘Searching for Intrinsic Value: Pragmatism and Despair in Environmental Ethics’. Environmental Ethics9: 231–241.
14.
KatzEric1996. ‘Unfair to Foundations? A Reply to Weston’, in LightAndrew and KatzEric (eds) Environmental Pragmatism, pp. 322–323. London: Routledge.
15.
KirkmanRobert1997. ‘The Problem of Knowledge in Environmental Thought: A Counterchallenge’, in GottliebRoger S. (ed.) The Ecological Community, pp. 193–207. New York: Routledge.
16.
LightAndrew1996. ‘Callicott and Naess on Pluralism’. Inquiry39: 273–294.
17.
LoebDon1996. ‘Generality and Moral Justification’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research56: 79–96.
18.
NortonBryan1991. Toward Unity Among Environmentalists. New York: Oxford University Press.
19.
NortonBryan1997. ‘Convergence and Contextualism: Some Clarifications and a Reply to Steverson’. Environmental Ethics19: 87–100.
20.
RolstonHolmesIII1988. Environmental Ethics. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
21.
RolstonHolmesIII1991. ‘Environmental Ethics: Values in and Duties to the Natural World’, in BormannF.H. and KellertStephen R. (eds) Ecology, Economics, Ethics: Closing the Broken Circle, pp. 73–96. New Haven: Yale University Press.
22.
RolstonHolmesIII1994. ‘Winning and Losing in Environmental Ethics’, in FerréFrederick and HartelPeter (eds) Ethics and Environmental Policy: Theory Meets Practice, pp. 217–234. Athens: University of Georgia Press.
23.
SchlisselLillian (ed.) 1965. World of Randolph Bourne. New York: E.P. Dutton.
24.
TaylorBob Pepperman1996. ‘Democracy and Environmental Ethics’, in LaffertyWilliam and MeadowcroftJames (eds) Democracy and the Environment, pp. 86–107. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
25.
TaylorCharles1991. The Ethics of Authenticity. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
26.
TaylorPaul1986. Respect for Nature. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
27.
MichaelWalzer1981. ‘Philosophy and Democracy’. Political Theory9: 379–399.
28.
WalzerMichael1987. Interpretation and Social Criticism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
29.
WestonAnthony1992. Toward Better Problems. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
30.
WolfeAlan1993. The Human Difference: Animals, Computers, and the Necessity of Social Science. Berkeley: University of California Press.
