Both Richard Sylvan's trenchant critique of Deep Ecology and Warwick Fox's illuminating reinterpretation and defence are presented and appraised. Besides throwing light on the nature and the prospects of the defence of Deep Ecology and of its diverse axiological, epistemological and metaphysical strands, the appraisal discloses the range of normative positions open to those who reject anthropocentrism, of which Deep Ecology is no more than one (and, if Fox's account of its nature is right, may not be one at all). A position intermediate between Deep Ecology and anthropocentrism is advocated, which has been called by Wayne Sumner “middle-depth environmentalism – a kind of continental shelf between the shallow and deep extremes”.
AttfieldRobin1981. “The Good of Trees”. Journal of Value Inquiry15: 35–54.
2.
AttfieldRobin1983. “Western Traditions and Environmental Ethics”. In ElliotRobert and GareArran (eds.), Environmental Philosophy, A Collection of Readings, pp. 201–230. St. Lucia, University of Queensland Press; Milton Keynes, Open University Press and University Park, Pennsylvania State University Press.
3.
AttfieldRobin1987. A Theory of Value and Obligation.London, New York and Sydney, Croom Helm.
4.
AttfieldRobin1991. The Ethics of Environmental Concern (1983), second edition.Athens and London, University of Georgia Press.
CallicottJ. Baird1980. “Animal Liberation: A Triangular Affair”. Environmental Ethics2: 311–38.
7.
CallicottJ. Baird1985. “Intrinsic Value, Quantum Theory and Environmental Ethics”. Environmental Ethics7: 257–75.
8.
CallicottJ. Baird1989. “Animal Liberation and Environmental Ethics: Back Together Again”. In Baird CallicottJ., In Defense of the Land Ethic, pp. 49–59. Albany, State University of New York Press.
9.
FoxWarwick1986. “Approaching Deep Ecology: A Response to Richard Sylvan's Critique of Deep Ecology”. Environmental Studies Occasional Paper 20. Hobart, University of Tasmania.
10.
FoxWarwick1989. “The Deep Ecology-Ecofeminism Debate and Its Parallels”, Environmental Ethics11.1: 5–25.
11.
FoxWarwick1990. Toward a Transpersonal Ecology: Developing New Foundations for Environmentalism.Boston & London, Shambhala Publications.
12.
HegelG.W.F., 1977. Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. MillerA.V.Oxford, Clarendon Press.
13.
HodgsonP.E.1984. “Philosophical Implications of Quantum Physics” (unpublished paper). An abbreviated version appears in Proceedings of the Eighth International Wittgenstein Symposium (1983). Wien, Holder-Pichler-Tempsky.
14.
KatzEric1989. “Environmental Ethics, A Select Annotated Bibliography, 1983–1987”. Research in Philosophy & Technology, 9: 251–85.
15.
NaessArne1973. “The shallow and the deep, long-range ecology movement. A summary”, Inquiry16: 95–100.
16.
NaessArne1986. “The Deep Ecology Movement: Some Philosophical Aspects”. Philosophical Inquiry8.2: 10–31.
17.
ReedPeter1989. “Man Apart: An Alternative to the Self-Realization Approach”. Environmental Ethics11.1: 53–69.
18.
RodmanJohn1977. “The Liberation of Nature”. Inquiry20: 83–145.
19.
SchererDonald1983. “Anthropocentrism, Atomism, and Environmental Ethics”. In SchererDonald and AttigThomas (eds.), Ethics and the Environment, pp. 73–81. Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall.
20.
SessionsGeorge1985. “A Postcript”. In DevallBill and SessionsGeorge (eds.), Deep Ecology: Living as if Nature Mattered, pp. 254–5. Salt Lake City, Gibbs M. Smith.
21.
SingerPeter1979. Practical Ethics.Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
22.
SumnerL.W.1986. Review of Robin Attfield, The Ethics of Environmental Concern. Environmental Ethics8: 77–82.
23.
SylvanRichard (formerly Routley) 1985. “A Critique of Deep Ecology”. Radical Philosophy, no. 40, 2–12 (Part I), and no. 41, 10–22 (Part II).
24.
SylvanRichard (formerly Routley) 1991. “A Critique of (Wild) Western Deep Ecology: a Response to an earlier Critique” (unpublished paper).
25.
TalbotCarl1992. Review of Warwick Fox, Toward a Transpersonal Ecology: Developing New Foundations for Environmentalism. Environmental Values1.2: 178–180.
26.
TaylorPaul1981. “The Ethics of Respect for Nature”. Environmental Ethics3.3: 197–218.
27.
TaylorPaul1984. “Are Humans Superior to Animals and Plants?” Environmental Ethics6.2: 149–60.
28.
TaylorPaul1986. Respect for Nature: A Theory of Environmental Ethics.Princeton, Princeton U.P.
