This paper presents a review of crossover designs for use in medical applications which have three or more treatment periods. Only outcomes which can be analysed as continuous variables are considered. Designs which purport to allow for carryover effects are reviewed in detail, as are methods for analysing data collected in such trials. In practice, it is often possible to eliminate carryover by interposing sufficiently long 'washout' periods between successive treatments, and suitable designs for this case are also mentioned. Much current practice revolves around a model which has been widely criticized: the shortcomings of this model and the implications of possible remedies, for design as well as analysis, are discussed.
Hedayat A., Zhao W.Optimal two-period repeated measurements designs. Annals of Statistics1990; 18: 1805-16. Correction , 1992, 20: 619.
3.
Carriere KC, Reinsel GCOptimal two-period repeated measurement designs with two or more treatments . Biometrika1993; 80: 924-29.
4.
Matthews Jns , Altman DG, Campbell MJ, Royston P.Analysis of serial measurements in medical research. British Medical Journal1990; 300: 230-35.
5.
Jones B., Kenward MGDesign and analysis of cross-over trials. London: Chapman and Hall, 1989.
6.
Matthews Jns.Modelling and optimality in the design of crossover studies for medical applications. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference1994; in press.
7.
Kiefer J.Construction and optimality of generalized Youden designs. In: Srivastava, JN ed. A survey of statistical design and linear models. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1975, 333-41.
8.
Hedayat A., Afsarinejad K.Repeated measurements designs, I. In: Srivastava, JN ed. A survey of statistical design and linear models . Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1975, 229-42.
9.
Hedayat A., Afsarinejad K.Repeated measurements designs, II. Annals of Statistics1978; 6: 619-28.
Kunert J.Optimality of balanced uniform repeated measurements designs. Annals of Statistics1984; 12: 1006-17.
12.
Shah KR, Sinha BKTheory of Optimal Designs. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989.
13.
Williams EJExperimental designs balanced for the estimation of residual effects of treatments. Australian Journal of Scientific Research1949; A2: 149-68.
14.
Cochran WG, Autrey KM, Cannon CYA double change-over design for dairy cattle feeding experiments. Journal of DairyScience1941; 24: 937-51.
15.
Sheehe PR, Bross Idj.Latin squares to balance immediate residual and other effects. Biometrics1961; 17: 405-14.
16.
Lucas HLExtra-period Latin square change-over designs. Journal of DairyScience1957; 40: 225-39.
17.
Quenouille MHThe design and analysis of experiments. London: Griffin, 1953.
18.
Kunert J.Optimal design and refinement of the linear model with applications to repeated measurements designs. Annals of Statistics1983; 11: 247-57.
19.
Stufken J.Some families of optimal and efficient repeated measurements designs. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference1991; 27: 75-83.
20.
Bishop SH, Jones B.A review of higher order crossover designs. Journal ofApplied Statistics1984; 11: 29-50.
21.
Patterson HD, Lucas HL, Change-over designs: technical bulletin No. 147. 1962, North CarolinaAgricultural Experiment Station and United States Department of Agriculture.
22.
Ratkowsky DA, Evans MA, Alldredge JRCross-over experiments: design, analysis, and application. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1993.
23.
Prescott P. , Ryan J., Shuttleworth P.A comparative study of several antibiotic formulations using a design based on a combination of balanced incomplete blocks and Latin squares. Statistics in Medicine1994; 13: 11-21.
24.
Armitage P., Berry G.Statistical methods in medical research. Oxford: Blackwell, 1987.
25.
Cochran WG, Cox GMExperimental designs. New York: Wiley, 1957.
26.
Patterson HDThe construction of balanced designs for experiments involving sequences of treatments. Biometrika1952; 39: 32-48.
27.
Davis AW, Hall WBCyclic change-over designs. Biometrika1969 ; 56: 283-93.
28.
Fletcher DJ , John JAChangeover designs and factorial structure . Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B1985; 47: 117-24.
29.
John JAGeneralized cyclic designs in factorial experiments. Biometrika1973; 60: 55-63.
30.
John JACyclic designs. London: Chapman and Hall, 1987.
31.
Fletcher DJA new class of change-over designs for factorial experiments. Biometrika1987; 74: 649-54.
32.
Fletcher DJ , Lewis SM, Matthews Jns.Factorial designs for crossover clinical trials. Statistics in Medicine1990; 9: 1121-29.
33.
Pearce SCThe agricultural field experiment. Chichester: Wiley, 1983.
34.
Laska E., Meisner M.A variational approach to optimal two treatment crossover designs: application to carryover effect models. Journal of the American Statistical Association1985; 80: 704-10.
Ebbutt AFThree-period crossover designs for two treatments. Biometrics1984; 40: 219-24.
37.
Kershner RP , Federer WTTwo-treatment crossover designs for estimating a variety of effects. Journal of the American Statistical Association1981; 76: 612-18.
38.
Carrière KC , Reinsel GCInvestigation of dual-balanced crossover designs for two treatments. Biometrics1992; 48: 1157-64.
39.
Fleiss JLA critique of recent research on the two-treatment crossover design. Controlled Clinical Trials1989; 10: 237-43.
40.
John JA, Lewis SMFactorial experiments in generalized cyclic row-column designs. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B1983; 45: 245-51.
41.
Gerami A., Lewis SMComparing dual with single treatments in block designs. Biometrika1992; 79: 603-10.
42.
Matthews Jns , Hoenich NAStatistical aspects of the design and analysis of studies to compare haemodialysis membranes. Nephrology, Dialysis, Transplantation1994; 9S2: 176-83.
43.
Abeyasekera S., Curnow RNThe desirability of adjusting for residual effects in a crossover design. Biometrics1984; 40: 1071-78.
44.
Chi EMRecovery of inter-block information in cross-over trials. Statistics in Medicine1991; 10: 1115-22.
45.
Laska EM, Meisner M., Kushner HBOptimal crossover designs in the presence of carryover effects. Biometrics1983; 39: 1089-91.
46.
Senn SJ, Hildebrand H.Crossover trials, degrees of freedom, the carryover problem and its dual. Statistics in Medicine1991; 10: 1361-74.
47.
Kenward MGA method for comparing profiles of repeated measurements. Applied Statistics1987; 36: 296-308. Correction : 1991; 40: 379.
48.
Cruddas AM, Reid N., Cox DRA time series illustration of approximate conditional likelihood. Biometrika1989; 76: 231-37.
49.
Cox DR, Solomon PJOn testing for serial correlation in large numbers of small samples. Biometrika1988; 75: 145-48.
50.
Matthews Jns.Estimating dispersion parameters in the analysis of data from crossover trials. Biometrika1989; 76: 239-44.
51.
Chi EMAnalysis of cross-over trials when within-subject errors follow an AR( 1 ) process. Biometrical Journal1992; 34: 359-65.
52.
Kenward MG, Jones B.The analysis of data from 2×2 cross-over trials with baseline measurements . Statistics in Medicine1987; 6: 911-26.
53.
Senn SJCross-over trials in clinical research. Chichester: Wiley, 1993.
54.
Patel HIAnalysis of incomplete data in a two-period crossover design. Biometrika1985: 72: 411-18.
55.
Diggle P., Kenward MGInformative dropout in longitudinal data analysis (with discussion). Applied Statistics1994; 43: 49-93.
56.
Guyatt G., Sackett D., Taylor DW, Chong J., Roberts R., Pugsley S.Determining optimal therapy - randomized trials in individual patients. New England Journal of Medicine1986; 314: 889-92.
Larsen S., Farup P., Flaten O., Osnes M.The multi-crossover model for classifying patients as responders to a given treatment. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology1991; 26: 763-70.
59.
Mukhopadhyay AC, Saha R.Repeated measurement designs. Calcutta Statistical Association Bulletin1983; 32: 153-68.
60.
Kunert J.Optimal repeated measurements designs for correlated observations and analysis by least squares. Biometrika1985; 72: 375-89.
61.
Gill PS, Shukla GKEfficiency of nearest neighbour block designs with balance for residual effects . Biometrika1985; 72: 539-44.
62.
Matthews Jns.Optimal crossover designs for the comparison of two treatments in the presence of carryover effects and autocorrelated errors. Biometrika1987; 74: 311-20. Correction: 1988; 75: 396.
63.
Kunert J.Cross-over designs for two treatments and correlated errors. Biometrika1991; 78: 315-24.
64.
Matthews Jns.The analysis of data from crossover trials: the efficiency of ordinary least squares. Biometrics1990; 46: 689-96.
65.
Sen M., Mukerjee R.Optimal repeated measurements designs under interaction. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference1987; 17: 81-91.
66.
Senn SJIs the 'simple carry-over' model useful? Statistics in Medicine1992; 11: 715-26. Correction : 1992; 11: 1619.
67.
Hedayat AS, Chi Gyh, Mahjoob K.Blends of statistical designs for dose-response studies. Communications in Statistics (A) Theory and Methods1994; 23: 341-60.
