Cure models are a class of survival models used to analyze time-to-event data that allow the possibility that the event never occurs for a certain percentage , of the population. These methods allow for direct modelling of the cure rate and the influence of covariates on this rate. A common goal is to test whether the cure rate depends on a specific covariate or a set of covariates. The availability of methods to test the effect of covariates on the cure rate is limited in the literature. This paper proposes nonparametric hypothesis tests for the effect of covariates on the cure probability based on the martingale difference correlation. Two methods are used to approximate the null distribution of the test statistic: A permutation test and a chi-square test. The methodology is further extended to the case of two covariates using the partial martingale difference correlation. The performance of the proposed tests is evaluated through a simulation study under various scenarios, and the method is applied to a dataset on rheumatoid arthritis patients.
PengYYuB. Cure models: Methods, applications, and implementation. New York: Chapman and Hall/CRC, 2021.
2.
AmicoMVan KeilegomI. Cure models in survival analysis. Annu Rev Stat Appl2018; 5: 311–342.
3.
MallerRResnickSShemehsavarS, et al.Mixture cure model methodology in survival analysis: Some recent results for the one-sample case. Stat Surv2024; 18: 82–138.
4.
MorbiducciMNardiARossiC. Classification of “cured” individuals in survival analysis: The mixture approach to the diagnostic–prognostic problem. Comput Stat Data Anal2003; 41: 515–529.
5.
PatileaVVan KeilegomI. A general approach for cure models in survival analysis. Ann Stat2020; 48: 2323–2346.
6.
López-ChedaAJácomeMAVan KeilegomI, et al.Nonparametric covariate hypothesis tests for the cure rate in mixture cure models. Stat Med2020; 39: 2291–2307.
7.
MallerRAZhouS. Testing for sufficient follow-up and outliers in survival data. J Am Stat Assoc1994; 89: 1499–1506.
8.
LiYTiwariRCGuhaS. Mixture cure survival models with dependent censoring. J R Stat Soc Ser B: Stat Methodol2007; 69: 285–306.
9.
MüllerUUVan KeilegomI. Goodness-of-fit tests for the cure rate in a mixture cure model. Biometrika2019; 106: 211–227.
10.
SzekelyGJRizzoMLBakirovNK. Measuring and testing dependence by correlation of distances. Ann Stat2007; 35: 2769–2794.
11.
GrettonAHerbrichRSmolaA, et al.Kernel methods for measuring independence. J Mach Learn Res2005; 6: 2075–2129.
12.
HellerRHellerYGorfineM. A consistent multivariate test of association based on ranks of distances. Biometrika2013; 100: 503–510.
13.
ShaoXZhangJ. Martingale difference correlation and its use in high-dimensional variable screening. J Am Stat Assoc2014; 109: 1302–1318.
14.
BernhardtPW. A flexible cure rate model with dependent censoring and a known cure threshold. Stat Med2016; 35: 4607–4623.
15.
LaskaEMMeisnerMJ. Nonparametric estimation and testing in a cure model. Biometrics1992; 48: 1223–1234.
16.
BetenskyRASchoenfeldDA. Nonparametric estimation in a cure model with random cure times. Biometrics2001; 57: 282–286.
17.
SafariWCLópez-de UllibarriIJácomeMA. A product-limit estimator of the conditional survival function when cure status is partially known. Biomet J2021; 63: 984–1005.
18.
SafariWCLópez-de UllibarriIJácomeMA. Nonparametric kernel estimation of the probability of cure in a mixture cure model when the cure status is partially observed. Stat Methods Med Res2022; 31: 2164–2188.
19.
SafariWCLópez-de UllibarriIJácomeMA. Latency function estimation under the mixture cure model when the cure status is available. Lifetime Data Anal2023; 29: 608–627.
20.
WuYLinYLuS. Extension of a Cox proportional hazards cure model when cure information is partially known. Biostatistics2014; 15: 540–554.
21.
ChenXChenXWangH. Robust feature screening for ultra-high dimensional right censored data via distance correlation. Comput Stat Data Anal2018; 119: 118–138.
22.
EdelmannDHummelMHielscherT, et al.Marginal variable screening for survival endpoints. Biomet J2020; 62: 610–626.
23.
EdelmannDWelchowskiTBennerA. A consistent version of distance covariance for right-censored survival data and its application in hypothesis testing. Biometrics2022; 78: 867–879.
24.
López-ChedaAJácomeMALópez-de UllibarriI. npcure: An R package for nonparametric inference in mixture cure models. R Journal2021; 13: 21–41.
25.
SzekelyGJRizzoML. Partial distance correlation with methods for dissimilarities. Ann Stat2014; 42: 2382–2412.
26.
ParkTShaoXYaoS. Partial martingale difference correlation. Electron J Stat2015; 9: 1492–1517.
SzékelyGJRizzoML. The energy of data and distance correlation. New York: Chapman and Hall/CRC, 2023.
29.
HuoXSzekelyGJ. Fast computing for distance covariance. Technometrics2016; 58: 435–447.
30.
ZhangXYaoSShaoX. Conditional mean and quantile dependence testing in high dimension. Ann Stat2018; 46: 219–246.
31.
AmicoMVan KeilegomIHanB. Assessing cure status prediction from survival data using receiver operating characteristic curves. Biometrika2021; 108: 727–740.
KaplanELMeierP. Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations. J Am Stat Assoc1958; 53: 457–481.
35.
WangLDuPLiangH. Two-component mixture cure rate model with spline estimated nonparametric components. Biometrics2012; 68: 726–735.
36.
GrettonAFukumizuKTeoC, et al.A kernel statistical test of independence. Adv Neural Inf Process Syst2008; 20: 585–592.
37.
PfisterNBühlmannPSchölkopfB, et al.Kernel-based tests for joint independence. J R Stat Soc Ser B: Stat Methodol2018; 80: 5–31.
38.
RindtDSejdinovicDSteinsaltzD. Consistency of permutation tests of independence using distance covariance, hsic and dhsic. Stat2021; 10: e364.
39.
ShenCPandaSVogelsteinJT. The chi-square test of distance correlation. J Comput Graph Stat2022; 31: 254–262.
40.
R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2025. https://www.R-project.org/.
41.
JinZYaoSMattesonDS, et al.EDMeasure: Energy-Based Dependence Measures. R package version 1.2, 2018.
42.
Monroy-CastilloBEJácomeMACaoR, et al.MDCcure: Martingale Dependence Tools and Testing for Mixture Cure Models2025b. DOI: 10.32614/CRAN.package.MDCcure. R package version 0.1.0.
43.
Monroy-CastilloBEJácomeMACaoR. MDCcure: An R package for martingale difference correlation and hypothesis testing in mixture cure models. Comput Methods Programs Biomed2026; 273: 109131.
44.
WassermanAM. Diagnosis and management of rheumatoid arthritis. Am Fam Physician2011; 84: 1245–1252.
45.
AjeganovaSHuizingaT. Sustained remission in rheumatoid arthritis: Latest evidence and clinical considerations. Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis2017; 9: 249–262.
46.
XiePEscobar-BachMVan KeilegomI. Testing for sufficient follow-up in censored survival data by using extremes. Biomet J2024; 66: e202400033.
