Nonparametric kernel estimation of the probability of cure in a mixture cure model when the cure status is partially observed

Abstract

Cure models are a class of time-to-event models where a proportion of individuals will never experience the event of interest. The lifetimes of these so-called cured individuals are always censored. It is usually assumed that one never knows which censored observation is cured and which is uncured, so the cure status is unknown for censored times. In this paper, we develop a method to estimate the probability of cure in the mixture cure model when some censored individuals are known to be cured. A cure probability estimator that incorporates the cure status information is introduced. This estimator is shown to be strongly consistent and asymptotically normally distributed. Two alternative estimators are also presented. The first one considers a competing risks approach with two types of competing events, the event of interest and the cure. The second alternative estimator is based on the fact that the probability of cure can be written as the conditional mean of the cure status. Hence, nonparametric regression methods can be applied to estimate this conditional mean. However, the cure status remains unknown for some censored individuals. Consequently, the application of regression methods in this context requires handling missing data in the response variable (cure status). Simulations are performed to evaluate the finite sample performance of the estimators, and we apply them to the analysis of two datasets related to survival of breast cancer patients and length of hospital stay of COVID-19 patients requiring intensive care.