Using horseshoe prior for incorporating multiple historical control data in randomized controlled trials

Abstract

Meta-analytic approaches and power priors are often used to incorporate historical controls into the analysis of a current randomized controlled trial. In this study, we propose a method for incorporating multiple historical controls based on a horseshoe prior, which is a type of global–local shrinkage prior. The method assumes that historical controls follow the same distribution as the current control. In the case in which only a few historical controls are heterogeneous, we consider them to follow a potentially biased distribution from the distribution of the current control. We analyze two clinical trial examples with binary and time-to-event endpoints and conduct simulation studies to compare the performance of the proposed and existing methods. In the analysis of the clinical trial example, the posterior standard deviation of the treatment effect is decreased by the proposed method by considering the bias between the current control and heterogeneous historical control. In the scenarios in which the current and historical controls follow the same distribution, the statistical power using the proposed method is higher than that using existing methods. The proposed method is advantageous when few or no heterogeneous historical controls are expected.