Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

When combining the results of independent studies it often happens that some studies are potentially aberrant either in quality or in actual values. Because aberrant studies are often at the extremes, we may wish to trim some of the largest and smallest effects. In such a case the use of p-values may well serve as a diag-nostic method. However, the use of ordered effects changes the distribution of the underlying statistics. We provide a discussion of the exact distribution of the trimmed version of the Fisher procedure. Because of the complexity of the exact distribution, several approximations are presented. These alternatives are applied to a meta-analysis on the effect of the dose of a drug on the risk of mortality.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hedges L , Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. New York: Academic Press , 1985.

Rosenthal R. Meta-analytic procedures for social research. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Press , 1991.

Cooper H , Hedges LV eds. The handbook of research synthesis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation , 1994.

Sutton AJ , Abrams KR , Jones DR , Sheldon TA , Song F. Methods for meta-analysis in medical research. New York: John Wiley , 2000.

Fisher RA. Statistical methods for research workers. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd , 1925.

Mosteller F , Bush RR. Selected quantitative techniques. In: Lindzey G ed. Handbook of social psychology, I. Cambridge, MA: Addison-Wesley , 1954: 289-334.

Becker BJ. Combining significance levels. In: Cooper H , Hedges LV eds. The handbook of research synthesis, Chapter15, New York: Russell Sage Foundation , 1994: 215-230.

Wallis WA. Compounding probabilities from independent significance tests . Econometrica 1942; 10: 229-248 .

Sukhatme PV. The problem of k samples for Poisson population . Proceedings of the National Institute of Science of India 1937; 3: 297-305 .

10.

David HA. Order statistics. New York: John Wiley , 1970.

11.

Balakrishnan N , Cohen AC. Order statistics and inference estimation methods. San Diego, CA: Academic Press , 1991.

12.

Robbins H , Pitman EJG. Application of the method of mixtures to quadratic forms in normal variables . Annals of Mathematical Sciences 1949; 20: 552-560 .

13.

McGill WJ , Gibbon J. The general-gamma distribution and reaction time . Journal of Mathematical Psychology 1965; 2: 1-18 .

14.

Provost SB. The exact density of a general linear combination of gamma variates . Metron 1988; 46: 61-69 .

15.

Good IJ. On the weighted combination of significance tests . Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B 1955; 17: 264-265 .

16.

Likeš J. Distributions of some statistics in samples from exponential and power-function populations . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1967; 62: 259-271 .

17.

Ali MM , Obaidullah M. Distribution of linear combination of exponential random variables . Communications in Statistics - Theory and Methods 1982; 11: 1453-1463 .

18.

Mathai AM. On linear combinations of independent exponential variables . Communications in Statistics - Theory and Methods 1983; 12: 625-632 .

19.

Satterthwaite FE. Synthesis of variance . Psychometrika 1941; 6: 309-316 .

20.

Box GEP. Some theorems in quadratic forms applied in the study of analysis of variance problems: I. Effects of inequality of variance in the one-way classification . Annals of Mathematical Statistics 1954; 8: 290-302 .

21.

Solomon H , Stephens MA. Distribution of a sum of weighted chi-square variables . Journal of the American Statistical Association 1977; 72: 881-885 .

22.

Tukey JW , Wilks SS. Approximation of the distribution of the product of beta variables by a single beta variable . Annals of Mathematical Statistics 1946; 17: 318-324 .

23.

Gabler S , Wolff C. A quick and easy approximation to the distribution of a sum of weighted chi-square variables . Statistische Hefte 1987; 28: 317-325 .

24.

Bhoj DS. On the distribution of the weighted combination of independent probabilities . Statistics and Probability Letters 1992; 15: 37-40 .

25.

Wolfram S. Mathematica: a system for doing mathematics by computer. London: Addison-Wesley , 1988.

26.

Furberg CD , Psaty BM , Meyer JV. Nifedipine: dose-related increase in mortality in patients with coronary heart disease . Circulation 1995; 92: 1326-1331 .

Approximations for trimmed Fisher procedures in research synthesis

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References