Stitching time and space: The functions of temporal comparisons in utopias and beyond

Abstract

No literary genre seems to be more popular to transport the hopes and fears of humans than the genre of utopia. With the temporalization of Utopia in the 18th century temporal gaps where opened, that had to be somehow closed to explain the reader their present and the fictive future. The means of choice to close the temporal gap is the temporal comparison. On the basis of a corpus of utopian fiction, several thousand temporal comparisons were identified, to find an answer on the question what functions the temporal comparisons fulfill. With the five centuries of modern utopian fiction in mind, also questions about the narration techniques within the history of the genre had to be raised (utopia/dystopia/temporalization) and what these changes do with the temporal comparisons. On the basis of this preparatory work, this article proposes two prototypes of temporal comparisons—the synchronization of different temporalities and the actualization of memory.

Keywords

Functions utopia dystopia political history practices of comparison history of concepts time temporality

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asimov

(2013) I, Robot. Glasgow, Scotland: Harper Voyager.

Bacon

(1968) ‘The Advancement of Learning’ and ‘New Atlantis’. London, UK: University Press.

Bellamy

(1890) Looking Backward 2000-1887. Toronto, ON: Willam Bryce.

Boye

(2019) Kallocain. London, UK: Penguin Classics.

Buonomano

(2017) Your Brain Is a Time Machine. New York, NY: W.W. Norton and Co.

Boulle

(2001) Planet of the Apes. New York, NY: Ballantine.

Bradburry

(2013) Fahrenheit 451. Glasgow, Scotland: Harper Collins Press.

Buwler-Lytton

(1873) The Coming Race. Leipzig, Germany: Bernhard Tauchnitz.

Callenbach

(1975) Ecotopia. Berkeley, CA: Bantam Books.

10.

Campanella

(1896) City of the sun. In: Morley

(ed) Ideal Commonwealths. London, UK: George Routledge, pp. 216–263.

11.

Dick

(1986) Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? New York, NY: Ballantine.

12.

Erhart

(2020) Odysseus, blackbirds, and rain barrels–literature as a comparative practice. In: Epple

Erhart

Grave

(eds) Practices of Comparing–Towards a New Understanding of a Fundamental Human Practice. Bielefeld, Germany: Trancript.

13.

Fischer

Hofer

(2008) Lexikon der Informatik. Lemma: Sand Box. Berlin und Heidelberg: Springer.

14.

Gibson

(2017) Neuromancer. London, UK: Gollancz.

15.

Götzelmann

Postoutenko

Sabelfeld

, et al. (2020) The historical semantics of temporal comparisons through the lens of digital humanities. In: Schwandt

(ed) Digital Humanities Research I. Bielefeld, Germany: Transcript, pp. 269–308.

16.

Hanson

(1998) The great filter–are we almost past it? Available at: http://mason.gmu.edu/∼rhanson/greatfilter.html (Accessed 8 August 2021).

17.

Hartog

(2015/2003) Regimes of Historicity–Presentism and Experiences of Time. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

18.

Harrison

(2008) Make Room! Make Room!. London, UK: Penguin.

19.

Huxley

(2004) Brave New World. London, UK: Vintage Classics.

20.

Jordheim

(2014) 1. Introduction: multiple times and the work of synchronization. History and Theory 53(4): 498–518.

21.

Koselleck

(2000) Zeitschichten. Frankfurt am Main, Germany: Suhrkamp.

22.

Koselleck

(2010) Wiederholungsstrukturen in sprache und geschichte. In: Dutt

(ed) Vom Sinn und Unsinn Der Geschichte. Frankfurt am Main, Germany: Suhrkamp.

23.

London

(2009) The Iron Heel. Morrison, IL: The Floating Press.

24.

Madden

Oman

(1899) The Reign of George VI, 1900-1925 – A Forecast Written in the Year 1763. London, UK: Rivingtons.

25.

Mercier

(1977) Memoirs of the Year 2500. Boston, MA: Gregg Press.

26.

(1684) Utopia. London, UK: Richard Chiswell.

27.

Morris

(1891) News from Nowhere. London, UK: Reeves and Turner.

28.

Munier

(2008) Thomas Morus–Urvater Des Kommunismus und Katholischer Heiliger. Hamburg, Germany: VSA-Verlag.

29.

Murray

(1946) A logic named Joe. Astounding Science Fiction 37: 139–150.

30.

Luhmann

(1973) Weltzeit und systemgeschichte-über die beziehungen zwischen zeithorizonten und sozialen strukturen gesellschaftlicher systeme. Sonderausgabe Soziologie und Sozialgeschichte 16: 81–115.

31.

Ogle

(2015) The Global Transformation of Time 1870-1950. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press.

32.

Orwell

(2008) 1984. London, UK: Penguin.

33.

Postoutenko

(2020) Preliminary typology of comparative utterances–a tree and some binaries. In: Epple

Erhart

Grave

(eds) Practices of Comparing–Towards a New Understanding of a Fundamental Human Practice. Bielefeld, Germany: Trancript

34.

Renouvier

(1876) Uchronie: L’Utopie Dans l’Histoire. Paris, France: Bureau de la critique philosophique.

35.

Shelly

(1965) The Last Man. Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press.

36.

Richter

(1893) Pictures of the Socialistic Future. London, UK: Swan Sonnenschein.

37.

Schaffner

(1968) Planet of the Apes. Los Angeles, CA: 20th Century Fox.

38.

Steinmüller

(2009) Virtuelle geschichte und zukunftswissen–zum gedankenexperiment in zukunftsforschung und geschichtswissenschaft. In: Popp

RES

(ed) Zukunftsforschung und Zukunftsgestaltung–Beiträge aus Wissenschaft und Praxis. Berlin, Germany: Springer, pp. 145–159.

39.

Sternbergh

(2014) Shovel Ready. New York, NY: Crown Publishers.

40.

Swift

(1890) Gulliver’s travels. In: Morley

(ed) Gulliver’s Travels and Other Works – Exactly Reprinted from the First Edition. Glasgow, Manchester and New York: George Routledge.

41.

von Justi

JHG

(1759) Untersuchung Ob Etwan Die Heutigen Europäischen Völker Lust Haben Möchten, Dereinst Menschenfresser Oder Wenigsten Hottentotten Zu Werden. Philadelphia, PA: Jacob Heinrich Lowe.

42.

Wells

(1960) The Time Machine. Portsmouth, NH: William Heinemann, Kingswood.

43.

Zamiatin

(1952) We. New York, NY: E.P.Dutton.