Socioeconomic panel data indicate that numerous employees would prefer to work less, i.e. that they are overemployed. However, due to inconsistent definitions and divergent operationalizations of overemployment, integrating existing research results is challenging and implications for research and practice are difficult to draw. To advance research in this field, we present an analysis of the concept and measurement of overemployment. To analyze the concept, we proceed in two steps. In step 1, we present the range of overemployment definitions in the literature and systematize the similarities and differences in these previous conceptualizations with the aim of arriving at an adequate definition of “overemployment.” In step 2, in view of the partial overlap between existing definitions of overemployment and other concepts used in past research, we demarcate overemployment from related concepts, identify conceptual distinctions between overemployment and other concepts and explore connections between concepts. To analyze the measurement of overemployment, we look at the bandwidth of content, measurement levels and question wording in overemployment measures and discuss the consequences of the different measures used for the overemployment rates found. We then present a consistent approach towards conceptualizing and measuring overemployment which aids future research on overemployment and similar concepts.
AbrahamsenB (2010)
Employment status and commitment to work in professions.Economic and Industrial Democracy31(1): 93–115.
2.
AllanBADuffyRDBlusteinDL (2016)
Under (and over) employment. Measurement and correlates of employment discrepancy.The Counseling Psychologist44(6): 815–840.
3.
AltonjiJGPaxsonCH (1988)
Labor supply preferences, hours constraints, and hours-wage trade-offs.Journal of Labor Economics6(2): 254–276.
4.
AngraveDCharlwoodA (2015)
What is the relationship between long working hours, over-employment and the subjective well-being of workers? Longitudinal evidence from the UK.Human Relations68(9): 1491–1515.
5.
Armstrong-StassenMAl-MaRCameronSJHorsburghME (1999)
The relationship between work status congruency and the job attitudes of full-time and part-time Canadian and Jordanian nurses.International Journal of Human Resource Management9(1): 41–57.
BeckersDvan der LindenDSmuldersPGWet al. (2008)
Voluntary or involuntary? Control over overtime and rewards for overtime in relation to fatigue and work satisfaction.Work & Stress22(1): 33–50.
Bell LA (1998) Differences in work hours and hours preferences by race in the U.S. Review of Social Economy 4: 481--500.
10.
BenderKASkatunJD (2009)
Constrained by hours and restricted in wages: The quality of matches in the labor market.Economic Inquiry47(3): 512–529.
11.
BlochKTaylorT (2012)
Overworked or underworked? Examining hour mismatches for women and men in the United States.Sociological Spectrum32(1): 37–60.
12.
BöheimRTaylorMP (2003)
Option or obligation? The determinants of labour supply preferences in Britain.The Manchester School71(2): 113–131.
13.
BöheimRTaylorMP (2004)
Actual and preferred working hours.British Journal of Industrial Relations42(1): 149–166.
14.
BrownSSessionsJG (2001)
Actual and optimal labour supply.Applied Economics Letters8(2): 111–113.
15.
BryanML (2007)
Free to choose? Differences in the hours determination of constrained and unconstrained workers.Oxford Economic Papers59(2): 226–252.
16.
CampbellIvan WanrooyB (2013)
Long working hours and working-time preferences: Between desirability and feasibility.Human Relations66(8): 1131–1155.
17.
ClarkbergMMoenP (2001)
Understanding the time-squeeze: Married couples' preferred and actual work-hour strategies.American Behavioral Scientist44(7): 1115–1136.
18.
CoginJ (2012)
Are generational differences in work values fact or fiction? Multi-country evidence and implications.International Journal of Human Resource Management23(11): 2268–2294.
19.
DembeAEEricksonJBDelbosRG, et al. (2005)
The impact of overtime and long work hours on occupational injuries and illnesses: New evidence from the United States.Occupational and Environmental Medicine62(9): 588–597.
20.
DevoeSELeeBPfefferJ (2010)
Hourly versus salaried payment and decisions about trading time and money over time. Industrial and Labor RelationsReview63(3): 627–640.
21.
DikBJDuffyRD (2009)
Calling and vocation at work: Definitions and prospects for research and practice.The Counseling Psychologist37(3): 424–450.
22.
DunnL (1990)
An empirical study of labor market equilibrium under working hours constraints.The Review of Economics and Statistics72(2): 250–258.
EuwalsR (2001)
Female labour supply, flexibility of working hours, and job mobility. The Economic Journal111(471): 120–134.
27.
FaganC (2001)
Time, money and the gendered order: Work orientations and working-time preferences in Britain.Gender, Work and Organization8(3): 239–266.
28.
FeatherPMShawWD (2000)
The demand for leisure time in the presence of constrained work hours.Economic Inquiry38(4): 651–661.
29.
FriedlandDSPriceRH (2003)
Underemployment: Consequences for the health and well-being of workers.American Journal of Community Psychology32: 33–45.
30.
FurnerJ (2004)
Conceptual analysis: A method for understanding information as evidence, and evidence as information.Archival Science4: 233–265.
31.
GareisKCBarnettRC (2002)
Under what conditions do long work hours affect psychological distress? A study of full-time and reduced-hours female doctors.Work and Occupations29(4): 483–497.
32.
GoldenL (1996)
The economics of worktime length, adjustment, and flexibility: A synthesis of contributions from competing models of the labor market.Review of Social Economy54: 1–45.
33.
GoldenL (2006a) How long? The historical, economic and cultural factors behind working hours and overwork. In: BurkeRJ (ed.) New Horizons in Management. Research Companion to Working Time and Work Addiction.
Northampton:
Edward Elgar, pp.36–57.
34.
GoldenL (2006b) Overemployment in the US: Which workers are willing to reduce their work hours and income? In: BoulinJ-YLallementMMessengerJC, et al. (eds) Decent Working Time: New Trends, New Issues.
Geneva:
International Labor Organization, pp.209–234.
35.
GoldenL (2009)
A brief history of long work time and the contemporary sources of overwork.Journal of Business Ethics84(2): 217–227.
36.
GoldenL (2014) Distinctions between overemployment, overwork, workaholism and heavy investments in work time. In: HarpazISnirR (eds) Heavy Work Investment. Its nature, Sources, Outcomes and Future Directions.
New York:
Routledge, pp.140–169.
37.
GoldenL (2016)
FLSA working hours reform: Worker well-being effects in an economic framework.Industrial Relations54(4): 717–749.
38.
GoldenLGebreselassieT (2007)
Overemployment mismatches: The preference for fewer work hours. Monthly Labour Review130: 18–37.
39.
GoldenLFigartG (2000)
Doing something about long hours.Challenge43(6): 15–37
40.
GroezingerGMatiaskeWTobschV (2010)
Employee-friendly labour time: A key element to a sustainable pattern of production and consumption.International Journal of Public Policy5(4): 357–372.
41.
HajivassiliouVAIoannidesYM (2007)
Unemployment and liquidity constraints.Journal of Applied Econometrics22(3): 479–510.
HolstESeifertH (2012)
Arbeitszeitpolitische Kontroversen im Spiegel der Arbeitszeitwünsche. WSI Mitteilungen65: 141–149.
45.
HoltomBCLeeTWTiddST (2002)
The relationship between work status congruence and work-related attitudes and behaviors.Journal of Applied Psychology87(5): 903–915.
Institute for Social Research (2017) Panel study of income dynamics. Available at: https://psidonline.isr.umich.edu/ (accessed 30 July 2017).
48.
JacobsJAGersonK (1998)
Who are the overworked Americans?Review of Social EconomyLV(1): 71–95.
49.
JahodaM (1981)
Work, employment, and unemployment. Values, theories, and approaches in social research.American Psychologist36: 184–191.
50.
JohnsonWR (2010)
Fixed costs and hours constraints.Journal of Human Resources46(4): 775–799.
51.
KahnSLangK (1995)
The causes of hours constraints: Evidence from Canada.Canadian Journal of Economics28(4a): 914–928.
52.
KallebergAL (2008)
The mismatched worker: When people don’t fit their jobs.Academy of Management Perspectives22(1): 24–40.
53.
KallebergALMasdenPV (2013)
Changing work values in the United States, 1973–2006.Social Science Research42: 255–270.
54.
KnightKRosaEASchorJB (2013) Reducing growth to achieve environmental sustainability: The role of work hours. In: Wicks-LimJPollinR (eds) Capitalism on Trial.
Cheltenham, UK:
Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.187–204.
55.
KrauszMSagieABidermannY (2000)
Actual and preferred work schedules and scheduling control as determinants of job-related attitudes.Journal of Vocational Behavior56: 1–11.
56.
KurodaSYamamotoI (2013)
Firms' demand for work hours: Evidence from matched firm-worker data in Japan.Journal of the Japanese and International Economies29(C): 57–73.
57.
LandersRRebitzerJTaylorL (1996)
Rat race redux: Adverse selection in the determination of work hours. American Economic Review86: 329–348.
58.
LeeBYWangJWeststarJ (2014)
Work hour congruence: The effect on job satisfaction and abasement.International Journal of Human Resource Management26(5): 657–675.
59.
LoughlinCMurrayR (2013)
Employment status congruence and job quality.Human Relations66(4): 529–553.
60.
MattaVI (2015)
Do self-managed work schedules lead to an increase in the number of hours worked?Zeitschrift für Soziologie44(4): 253–271.
61.
MerzJ (2002)
Time and economic well-being – A panel analysis of desired versus actual working hours.Review of Income and Wealth48(3): 317–346.
62.
MoenPKellyELLamJ (2013)
Healthy work revisited: Do changes in time strain predict well-being?Journal of Occupational Health Psychology18(2): 157–172.
63.
Odle-DusseauHNBrittTWBobkoP (2012)
Work–family balance, well-being, and organizational outcomes: Investigating actual versus desired work/family time discrepancies.Journal of Business and Psychology27(3): 331–343.
64.
OlsthoornJ (2017). Conceptual analysis. In: BlauA (ed.) Methods in Analytical Political Theory.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, pp.153–191.
65.
OsornoPAcostaJ (2007)
Overemployment in the Spanish labour market.International Advances in Economic Research13: 525–526.
66.
PaganR (2017)
Impact of working time mismatch on job satisfaction: Evidence for German workers with disabilities.Journal of Happiness Studies18: 125–149.
67.
RamirezJV (1998)
Unemployment rate and working-hour constraints: Empirical evidence from the Swiss labour force.International Journal of Manpower19(6): 449–460.
68.
ReynoldsJ (2003)
You can't always get the hours you want: Mismatches between actual and preferred work hours in the U.S.Social Forces81(4): 1171–1199.
69.
ReynoldsJ (2004)
When too much is not enough: Actual and preferred work hours in the United Stated and abroad.Sociological Forum19(1): 89–120.
70.
ReynoldsJ (2014)
Prevailing preferences: Actual work hours and work-hour preferences of partners.Industrial and Labor Relations Review67(3): 1017–1041.
71.
ReynoldsJAletrarisL (2010)
Mostly mismatched with a chance of settling: Tracking work hour mismatches in the United States.Work and Occupations37(4): 476–511.
72.
ReynoldsJJohnsonDR (2012)
Don't blame the babies: Work hour mismatches and the role of children.Social Forces91(1): 131–155.
73.
RosaH (2005) Beschleunigung. Die Veränderung der Zeitstruktur in der Moderne.
Frankfurt am Main:
Suhrkamp.
SeifertH (2004) Arbeitszeitpolitischer Modellwechsel. Von der Normalarbeitszeit zu kontrollierter Flexibilität. Available at www.boeckler.de/pdf/p_wsi_diskp_127.pdf (accessed 9 July 2017).
76.
SlaneyKLGarciaDA (2015)
Constructing psychological objects: The rhetoric of constructs.Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology35(4): 244–259.
77.
Sousa-PozaAHennebergerF (2002)
An empirical analysis of working-hours constraints in twenty-one countries.Review of Social Economy LX(2): 209–242.
78.
Sousa-PozaAZieglerA (2003)
Asymmetric information about workers' productivity as a cause for inefficient long working hours.Labour Economics10(6): 727–747.
79.
StierHLewin-EpsteinN (2003)
Time to work: A comparative analysis of preferences for working hours.Work and Occupations30(3): 302–326.
80.
SzollosA (2009)
Toward a psychology of chronic time pressure.Conceptual and methodological review. Time & Society18(2–3): 332–350.
81.
TamH (2010)
Characteristics of the underemployed and the overemployed in the UK.Economic & Labour Market Review4(7): 8–20.
82.
TijdensKDragstraA (2007)
How many hours do you usually work?: An analysis of the working hours questions in 26 large-scale surveys in six countries and the European Union.Time & Society16(1): 119–130.
83.
UlfertsHKorunkaCKubicekB (2013)
Acceleration in working life: An empirical test of a sociological framework.Time & Society22(1):161–185.
84.
UsuiEShimizutaniSOshioT (2016)
Are Japanese men of pensionable age underemployed or overemployed?Japanese Economic Review67(2): 150–168.
85.
van EchteltPEGlebbeekACLindenbergS (2006)
The new lumpiness of work: Explaining the mismatch between actual and preferred hours. Work, Employment and Society20(3): 493–512.
86.
van EmmerikIJSandersK (2005)
Mismatch in working hours and affective commitment: Differential relationships for distinct employee groups.Journal of Managerial Psychology20(8): 712–726.
87.
VirtanenMSingh-ManouxAFerrieJE, et al. (2009)
Long working hours and cognitive function: The Whitehall II Study.American Journal of Epidemiology 196(5): 596–605.
88.
WangJReidF (2015)
The impact of work hours discrepancy on employee absence.International Journal of Manpower36(5): 668–693.
89.
WebsterJWatsonRT (2002)
Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: Writing a literature review. MIS Quarterly26(2): 13–23.
90.
WernerAGastJKrausS (2014)
The effect of working time preferences and fair wage perceptions on entrepreneurial intentions among employees.Small Business Economics43(1): 137–160.
91.
WielersRMunderleinMKosterF (2014)
Part-time work and work hour preferences. An international comparison.European Sociological Review30(1): 76–89.
92.
WolfswinkelJFFurtmuellerEWilderomCPM (2013)
Using grounded theory as a method for rigorously reviewing literature.European Journal of Information Systems22: 45–55.
93.
WoodenMWarrenDDragoR (2009)
Working time mismatch and subjective well-being.British Journal of Industrial Relations47(1): 147–179.
94.
WunderCHeineckG (2013)
Working time preferences, hours mismatch and wellbeing of couples: Are there spillovers?Labour Economics24(C): 244–252.
95.
ZallerJFeldmanS (1992)
A simple theory of the survey response: Answering questions versus revealing preferences.American Journal of Political Science36(3): 579–616.
