Students have provided cheap successful labour for routine retrospective cataloguing projects. The current article examines a library project which went further, using university students with minimum training to catalogue its undergraduate stock from the book in hand to AACR2, level 2, allegedly to professional standard. The article discusses the faults made in MARC coding, descriptive cataloguing and subject cataloguing, noting the nature of the errors and their results. The investigation concludes that intelligence alone does not guarantee library ability, and that cataloguing beyond the creation of minimum records is not an intuitive task to be picked up without training. Hidden expenses are attached. A derisory attitude towards library skills is unjustified, and a place remains for qualified librarians to do qualified library work.
American Library Associationet al. (1967) Anglo-American Cataloguing Rules: British text. London: Library Association.
2.
Attar, K. E. (2002) ‘Jane Austen at King’s College, Cambridge’ , Book Collector51: 197-221 .
3.
Bowman, J. H. (2003) Essential Cataloguing. London: Facet .
4.
Bridge, Jeremy (2000) ‘Retrospective Conversion at the Tate Gallery Library’ , Catalogue & Index136: 1-3 .
5.
British Library Bibliographic Services Division (1980) UK MARC Manual. 2nd edn.London: British Library .
6.
Brunt, Rodney M. (2004) ‘The Education of Cataloguers’ , Catalogue & Index153: 1-7 .
7.
Chan, Lois Mai (1995) Library of Congress Subject Headings: Principles and Application. 3rd edn.Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited .
8.
Consortium of University and Research LibrariesCURL minimum standards. http://www.curl.ac.uk/database/bibstandards.html.
9.
Cutter, Charles A. (1904) Rules for a Dictionary Catalogue.4th edn.Washington: Government Printing Office .
10.
Douglas, Nancy E. (1985) ‘REMARC Retrospective Conversion: What, Why and How’ , Technical Services Quarterly2 (3/4): 11-16 .
11.
Dyson, Brian (1984) ‘Data Input Standards and Computerization at the University of Hull’ , Journal of Librarianship16: 246-261 .
12.
Gorman, Michael (2002) ‘Why Teach Cataloguing and Classification?’ , Cataloging & Classification Quarterly34 (1-2): 1-13 .
13.
Hill, Janet Swan (2002) ‘Pitfalls and the Pendulum: Reconsidering Education for Cataloging and the Organization of Information: Preface’ , Cataloging & Classification Quarterly34 (1-2): xix-xxiii .
14.
Hoare, Peter A. (1986) ‘Retrospective Catalogue Conversion in British University Libraries: A Survey and a Discussion of Problems’ , British Journal of Academic Librarianship1: 95-131 .
15.
Hoerman, Heidi Lee (2002) ‘Why does Everybody Hate Cataloging?’ , Cataloging & Classification Quarterly34 (1-2): 31-41 .
16.
Joint Steering Committee for Revision of AACR (1988) Anglo-American Cataloguing Rules. 2nd edn, 1988 revision. Ottawa: Canadian Library Association .
17.
Kgosiemang, Rose Tiny (1999) ‘Retrospective Conversion: The Experience at the University of Botswana Library’ , Cataloging & Classification Quarterly28 (3): 67-94 .
18.
Law, Derek (1988) ‘The State of Retroconversion in the United Kingdom: A Review’ , Journal of Librarianship20: 81-93 .
19.
Maurer, Hansjürgen (1991) ‘Retrospektive Katalogkon-version in einem Verbundsystem’ , Zeitschrift für Bibliothekswesen und Bibliographie38: 109-128 .
20.
Mayer, Constance (2002) ‘Variations: Creating a Digitial Music Library at Indiana University’, in Wayne Jones , Judith R. Apronheim and Josephine Crawford (eds) Cataloging the Web: Metadata, AACR and MARC 21, pp. 149-154. Lanham, MD and London: Scarecrow Press .
21.
Modern Humanities Research Assocation (1991) MHRA Style Book. 4th edn.London: Modern Humanities Research Assocation .
22.
Peters, Stephen H. and Butler, Douglas J. (1984) ‘A Cost Model for Retrospective Conversion Alternatives’ , Library Resources & Technical Services28: 149-162 .
23.
Quedens, Jenny (1991) ‘Retrospektive Konversion in den USA’ , Bibliothek: Forschung und Praxis15: 62-111 .
24.
Read, Jane M. (2003) Cataloguing without Tears: Managing Knowledge in the Information Society. Oxford: Chandos .
25.
Trickey, Keith (2004) ‘Revive the Lost Art - or We’ve only Ourselves to Blame’ , Library & Information Gazette 26 Mar.: 1-2 .
26.
Ward, Ray (2004) ‘Appalling Downgrading of Cat and Class’ , Update, May: 20.
27.
Watkins, Diane (1985) ‘Record Conversion at Oregon State’ , Wilson Library Bulletin60 (4), 31-33 .
28.
Wessendorf, Berthold (1991) ‘Catalogue Conversion in Switzerland’ , European Research Libraries Cooperation1: 55-60 .
