Chromosomal Aberrations and Sister Chromatid Exchanges in Lymphocytes and Urine Mutagenicity of Migraine Patients: A Comparison of Chronic Feverfew Users and Matched Non-users

Abstract

1 Thirty migraine patients who had taken the leaves, tablets or capsules of feverfew daily for more than 11 consecutive months were compared to 30 feverfew non-user migraine patients who had been individually age- and sex-matched.

2 The frequency of chromosomal aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) were determined from lymphocyte cultures established from blood samples taken over a period of several months. Matched pairs were sampled on the same date for two-thirds of the cases, and the greatest difference in sampling time of the remainder was 20 days. Also, the mutagenicity of urine samples from 10 feverfew user migraine patients was compared to that from 10 matched non-user migraine patients using the Ames Salmonella mutagenicity test system. Paired samples were given on the same date.

3 The mean frequency of chromosomal aberrations in the feverfew user group was lower than that in the non-user group both in terms of cells with breaks (2.13% vs 2.76%) and in terms of cells with all aberrations (4.34% vs 5.11%). However, this difference was small and not significant.

4 The mean frequency of SCE in the feverfew exposed group was lower than that in the control group (8.78 vs 8.80 SCE/cell), but, this difference was not significant as determined by factorial analysis of variance (P = 0.897). There was a highly significant variance between the frequencies of SCE in the matched pairs of migraine patients but this was not related to age, sex or feverfew exposure.

5 The mean number of revertants in the Ames mutagenicity assay was greater for the urine of the feverfew user migraine patients than that of the non-user migraine patients, in both strains of bacteria, with or without the inclusion of an S-9 metabolizing system. However, the increases were small and not significant.

6 The data indicate that the prophylactic use of feverfew for the alleviation of migraine symptoms affects neither the frequency of chromosomal aberrations nor the frequency of SCE in the circulating peripheral lymphocytes. Also, the mutagenicity of urine from feverfew user migraine patients is unaffected compared to urine from non-user migraine patients detectable by the methods used in this study.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Johnson ES , Patients who chew chrysanthemum leaves. Mims Magazine , 1983, 15th May; 32-5.

Johnson ES , Kadam NP , Hylands DM & Hylands PJ Efficacy of feverfew as prophylactic treatment of migraine. British Medical Journal 1985; 291: 569-73.

Herout V. , Soucek M. & Sorm F. Parthenolide, another sesquiterpenic lactone with a ten-membered ring . Chemistry and Industry 1959; 1969.

Hladon B. & Twandowski T. Sesquiterpene lactones. Part XXV. Studies on the mode of action. The cellular and molecular basis of cytostatic action. Polish Journal of Pharmacology and Pharmacy 1979; 31: 35-43.

Kennaway EL The formation of a cancer-producing substance from isoprine (2-methybutadine) . Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 1924 ; 27: 233-8.

Boveri T. The Origin of Malignant Tumours. New York: Williams and Wilkins, 1929.

Ames BN , Durston WE , Yamasaki E. & Lee FD Carcinogens are mutagens: a simple test system combining liver homogenates for activation and bacteria for detection. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA 1973; 70: 2281~5.

Tennant RW , Margolin BH , Shelby MD et al. Prediction of chemical carcinogenicity in rodents from in vitro genetic toxicity assays. Science 1987; 236: 933-41.

Yamasaki E. & Ames BN Concentration of mutagens from urine by adsorption with the non-polar resin XAD-2. Cigarette smokers have mutagenic urine. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA. 1977; 74, 3555-9.

10.

Johnson ES , Kadam NP , Anderson D. , Jenkinson PJ , Dewdney RS & Blowers SD Investigation of possible genetic effects of feverfew in migraine patients . Human Toxicology 1987; 6: 533-4.

11.

Perry P. & Wolff S. New Giemsa method for the differential staining of sister chromatids . Nature (London) 1974; 251: 156-8.

12.

UKEMS. Report of the UKEMS Sub-committee on Guidelines for Mutagenicity Testing, part I, ed. BJ Dean.

13.

Ames BN , McCann J. & Yamasaki E. Methods for detecting carcinogens and mutagens with the Salmonellal mammalian-microsome mutagenicity test. Mutation Research 1975; 31: 347-64.

14.

Bender MA , Griggs HG & Bedford JS Mechanisms of chromosomal aberration production. III. Chemicals and ionizing radiation. Mutation Research 1974 ; 23: 197-212.

15.

Latt SA , Allen J. , Bloom SE et al. Sister chromatid exchanges: a report of the Gene-Tox Program . Mutation Research 1981; 87: 17-62.

16.

Onfelt A. & Ramel C. Some aspects of the organisation of microfilaments and microtubules in relation to non-disjunction. Environmental Health Perspectives 1979; 31: 45-52.

17.

UKEMS (1984). Report of the UKEMS Sub-committee on Guidelines for Mutagenicity Testing, part II, ed. BJ Dean.

18.

Ashby J. & Richardson CR Tabulation and assessment of 113 human surveillance cytogenetic studies conducted between 1965 and 1984. Mutation Research 1985 ; 154: 111-33.

19.

Anderson DA , Dewdney RS , Jenkinson PC , Lovell DP , Butterworth KR & Conning DM Sister chromatid exchange (SCE) analysis in 106 control individuals . In Monitoring of Occupational Genotoxicants, eds M Sorsa & H. Norppa , New York: Alan R. Liss Inc., 1986 .

20.

Hopkin JM & Evans HJ Cigarette smoke induced DNA damage and lung cancer risks. Nature, London 1980; 253: 388-90.

21.

Sorsa M. , Norppa H. , Leppaner A. & Rimpela M. Induction of sister chromatid exchange in human lymphocytes by smoke condensate from different brands of cigarette. Mutation Research 1982; 103: 149-53.

22.

Sarto F. , Faccioli MC , Cominato I. & Levis AG Ageing and smoking increase the frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) in man. Mutation Research 1985; 144: 183-7.

23.

Soper KA , Stolley PD , Galloway SM , Smith JG , Nichols WW & Wolman SR Sister chromatid exchange (SCE) report on control subjects in a study of occupationally exposed workers. Mutation Research 1984; 129: 77-88.

24.

Dutkowski RT , Lesh R. , Staiano-Coico L. , Thaler H. , Darlington GJ & Weksler ME Increased chromosomal instability in lymphocytes from elderly humans. Mutation Research 1985 ; 149: 505-12.