In this paper, we explore and integrate different currencies that may underlie large-game hunting to guide a trans-Holocene analysis of variation in artiodactyl utilization using massive archaeofaunal data-sets from predominantly open-air sites from the Bonneville and Wyoming basins. The available empirical data continue to suggest that artiodactyls yield consistently higher return rates than lagomorphs allowing us to leverage predictions from both the prey choice and energetic risk-gain models that the relative importance of artiodactyl hunting should scale closely with climate-based change in their abundance on the landscape. We document with modeled climate data that seasonal variables correlated with the relative frequency of artiodactyl hunting, but that summer temperature had a significant overriding effect in both regions. Controlling for the negative relationship between summer temperature and artiodactyl abundances, we then document enhanced artiodactyl hunting in general and bison more specifically during the Fremont period that is consistent with a costly signaling hypothesis and the unique socio-ecological conditions of this context. Thus, climatic variation and its influence on artiodactyl abundances drives the overall trajectory of Holocene large game hunting variation but measurable and more subtle influences of costly signaling are also detected.
AllenMWBettingerRLCoddingBF, et al. (2016) Resource scarcity drives lethal aggression among prehistoric hunter-gatherers in central California. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113: 12120–12125.
2.
AndersonRS (1990) Holocene forest development and paleoclimates within the central Sierra Nevada, California. The Journal of Ecology78: 470–489.
3.
AxelrodDI (1967) Quaternary Extinctions of Large Mammals, vol. 74. Berkeley, CA: University of California Publications in Geological Science, pp.1–42.
4.
BarlowKR (2002) The Archaeology of Regional Interaction: Religion, Warfare and Exchange Across the American Southwest and Beyond, vol. 67, Boulder, CO: University of Colorado Press: Boulder, pp.778–779.
5.
BarnoskyADLindseyELVillavicencioNA, et al. (2015) Variable impact of late-Quaternary megafaunal extinction in causing ecological state shifts in north and South America. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113: 856–861.
6.
BarronJAHeusserLHerbertT, et al. (2003) High-resolution climatic evolution of Coastal Northern California during the past 16,000 years. Paleoceanography18(1): 1020.
7.
BartelinkE (2006) Resource intensification in pre-contact central California: A bioarchaeological perspective on diet and health patterns among hunter-gatherers from the lower Sacramento Valley and San Francisco Bay. PhD Dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Texas A & M University, College Station, Texas. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.
8.
BayhamF (1982) A diachronic analysis of prehistoric animal exploitation at Ventana cave. PhD Dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.
9.
BayhamFE (1979) Factors influencing the archaic pattern of animal exploitation. KIVA44: 219–235.
10.
BirdDWBirdRBCoddingBF (2009) In pursuit of mobile prey: Martu hunting strategies and Archaeofaunal Interpretation. American Antiquity74: 3–29.
11.
BishopAPCMcGroskyATrumbleBC, et al. (2023) What does prey harvest composition signal to a social audience?: Experimental studies with Aché hunter-gatherers of Paraguay. Evolution and Human Behavior44: 411–421.
12.
BroughtonJM (1994) Late Holocene resource intensification in the Sacramento Valley, California: The Vertebrate Evidence. Journal of Archaeological Science21: 501–514.
13.
BroughtonJM (2002) Prey spatial structure and behavior affect archaeological tests of optimal foraging models: Examples from the Emeryville Shellmound vertebrate fauna. World Archaeology34: 60–83.
14.
BroughtonJMBayhamFE (2003) Showing off, foraging models, and the ascendance of large-game hunting in the California Middle Archaic. American Antiquity68: 783–789.
15.
BroughtonJMByersDABrysonRA, et al. (2008) Did climatic seasonality control late quaternary Artiodactyl densities in western North America?Quaternary Science Reviews27: 1916–1937.
16.
BroughtonJMCannonMDBayhamFE, et al. (2011) Prey body size and ranking in Zooarchaeology: Theory, Empirical Evidence, and applications from the Northern Great Basin. American Antiquity76: 403–428.
17.
BroughtonJMO’ConnellJF (1999) On evolutionary ecology, Selectionist archaeology and behavioral archaeology. American Antiquity64: 153–165.
18.
BrownDEFaganWFLeeRM, et al. (2003) Winter Precipitation and Pronghorn Fawn Survival. Tempe, AZ: Arizona Antelope Foundation.
19.
BrownDEWarneckeDMcKinneyT (2006) Effects of midsummer drought on mortality of Doe Pronghorn (Antilocapra americana). The Southwestern Naturalist51: 220–225.
20.
BrunelleAAndersonRS (2003) Sedimentary charcoal as an indicator of late-Holocene drought in the Sierra Nevada, California, and its relevance to the future. The Holocene13: 21–28.
21.
ByersDABroughtonJM (2004) Holocene environmental change, Artiodactyl abundances, and human hunting strategies in the Great Basin. American Antiquity69: 235–255.
22.
ByersDASmithCS (2007) Ecosystem controls and the archaeofaunal record: An example from the Wyoming Basin, USA. The Holocene17: 1171–1183.
23.
ByersDASmithCSBroughtonJM (2005) Holocene artiodactyl population histories and large game hunting in the Wyoming Basin, USA. Journal of Archaeological Science32: 125–142.
24.
ByersJAHoggJT (1995) Environmental effects on prenatal growth rate in pronghorn and Bighorn: Further evidence for energy constraint on sex-biased maternal expenditure. Behavioral Ecology6(4): 451–457.
25.
CannonMD (2003) A model of central place Forager Prey Choice and an application to faunal remains from the Mimbres Valley, New Mexico. Journal of Archaeological Science22(1): 1–25.
26.
CarréMBraconnotPElliotM, et al. (2021) High-resolution marine data and transient simulations support orbital forcing of ENSO amplitude since the mid-Holocene. Quaternary Science Reviews268: 107–125.
27.
CarréMCheddadiR (2017) Seasonality in long-term climate change. Quaternaire28: 173–177.
28.
CheverkoCMBartelinkEJ (2017) Resource intensification and osteoarthritis patterns: Changes in activity in the prehistoric Sacramento-San Joaquin delta Region. American Journal of Physical Anthropology164: 331–342.
29.
CoddingBFBirdDWJonesTL (2012) A land of work: Foraging behavior and ecology. In: JonesDLPerryJ (eds) Contemporary Issues in California Archaeology. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, pp.115–131.
30.
CoddingBFBirdRBBirdDW (2011) Provisioning offspring and others: Risk-energy trade-offs and gender differences in hunter-gatherer foraging strategies. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences278: 2502–2509.
31.
ColtrainJBLeavittSW (2002) Climate and diet in Fremont prehistory: Economic variability and abandonment of maize agriculture in the Great Salt Lake Basin. American Antiquity67: 453–485.
32.
CraineJMTowneEGJoernA, et al. (2009) Consequences of climate variability for the performance of Bison in Tallgrass Prairie. Global Change Biology15: 772–779.
33.
DavisOMorattoM (1988) Evidence for a warm dry early holocene in the western Sierra Nevada of California: Pollen and plant macrofossil analysis of Dinkey and Exchequer Meadows. Madrono35: 132–149.
34.
DavisOK (1999) Pollen analysis of a late-glacial and holocene sediment core from Mono Lake, mono County, California. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)52: 243–249.
35.
DavisOKScott AndersonRFallPL, et al. (1985) Palynological evidence for early holocene aridity in the southern Sierra Nevada, California. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)24: 322–332.
36.
DeLgiudiceGDRiggsMRJolyP, et al. (2002) Winter severity, survival, and cause-specific mortality of female white-tailed deer in north-central Minnesota. Journal of Wildlife Management66: 698–717.
37.
DoernerJPCarraraPE (2001) Late Quaternary vegetation and climatic history of the Long Valley area, west-central Idaho, USA. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)56: 103–111.
38.
DouglasC (2001) Weather, disease and Bighorn Lamb Survival during 23 years in Canyonlands National Park. Wildlife Society Bulletin29: 297–305.
39.
ElstonRGZeanahDW (2002) Thinking outside the Box: A new perspective on diet breadth and sexual division of labor in the prearchaic Great Basin. World Archaeology34: 103–130.
40.
ElstonRGZeanahDWCoddingBF (2014) Living outside the Box: An updated perspective on diet breadth and sexual division of labor in the prearchaic Great Basin. Quaternary International352: 200–211.
41.
FordhamDASaltréFHaythorneS, et al. (2017) PaleoView: A tool for generating continuous climate projections spanning the last 21 000 years at regional and global scales. Ecography40: 1348–1358.
42.
FoxLKrausmanPMorrisonM, et al. (2000) Water and nutrient content of forage in Sonoran pronghorn habitat, Arizona. California Fish and Game88: 216–232.
43.
GavinDGBrubakerLBLertzmanKP (2003) Holocene fire history of A coastal temperate rain forest based on soil charcoal radiocarbon dates. Ecology84: 186–201.
44.
GedirJVCainJWHarrisG, et al. (2015) Effects of climate change on long-term population growth of pronghorn in an arid environment. Ecosphere6: 1–20.
45.
GillJLWilliamsJWJacksonST, et al. (2009) Pleistocene megafaunal collapse, novel plant communities, and enhanced fire regimes in North America. Science326: 1100–1103.
46.
GraysonDFisherJ (2009) Holocene Elk (Cervus elaphus) in the Great Basin. In: HockettB (ed) Past, Present and Future Issues in Great Basin Archaeology: Papers in Honor of Don D. Fowler. Cultural Resource Series No. 20. Reno, NV: U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Land Management, pp.67–75.
47.
GraysonDK (2006) Holocene bison in the Great Basin, western USA. The Holocene16: 913–925.
48.
GraysonDK (2011) The Great Basin: A Natural Prehistory. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
49.
GreenwaldAMEerkensJWBartelinkEJ (2016) Stable isotope evidence of juvenile foraging in prehistoric central California. Journal of Archaeological Science Reports7: 146–154.
50.
HallettDJLepofskyDSMathewesRW, et al. (2003) 11 000 Years of fire history and climate in the mountain hemlock rain forests of southwestern British Columbia based on sedimentary charcoal. Canadian Journal of Forest Research/Journal Canadien de la Recherche Forestiere33: 292–312.
51.
HamlinKLMackieRJPacDF (1982) Mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus). In: ChapmanJAFeldhamerGA (eds) Wild Mammals of North America: Biology, Management, and Economics. Baltimore, MA: The Johns Hopkins University Press, pp.862–877.
52.
HawkesK (1991) Showing off: Tests of a hypothesis about men's foraging goals. Ethology and Sociobiology12: 29–54.
53.
HawkesKAltmanJBeckermanS, et al. (1993) Why hunter-gatherers work: An ancient version of the problem of public goods. Current Anthropology34: 341–361.
54.
HawkesKBliege BirdR (2002) Showing off, handicap signaling, and the evolution of men’s work. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews11: 58–67.
55.
HawkesKO'ConnellJFBlurton JonesNG (2001) Hadza meat sharing. Evolution and Human Behavior22: 113–142.
56.
HeusserCJHeusserLEPeteetDM (1985) Late-Quaternary climatic change on the American North Pacific coast. Nature315: 485–487.
57.
HildebrandtWRMcGuireKR (2002) The ascendance of hunting during the California Middle Archaic: An evolutionary perspective. American Antiquity67: 231–256.
58.
HillK (1982) Hunting and human evolution. Journal of Human Evolution11: 521–544.
59.
HillKKaplanHHawkesK, et al. (1987) Foraging decisions among Aché hunter-gatherers: New data and implications for optimal foraging models. Ethology and Sociobiology8(1): 1–36.
60.
HockettBS (1998) Sociopolitical meaning of faunal remains from Baker Village. American Antiquity63: 289–302.
61.
IsaacG (1984) The Archaeology of Human Origins: Studies of the Lower pleistocene in East Africa, 1971-1981. Advances in World Archaeology3: 1–86.
62.
JanetskiJCTalbotRC (2014) Fremont social organization: A Southwestern perspective. In: ParezoNJJanetskiJC (eds) Archaeology in the Great Basin and Southwest: Papers in Honor of Don. D. Fowler. Salt Lake City, UT: University of Utah Press, pp.118–129.
63.
KaplanHHillKLancasterJ, et al. (2000) A Theory of human life history evolution: Diet, intelligence, and Longevity. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues News and Reviews9: 156–185.
64.
KleinDR (1965) Ecology of deer range in Alaska. Ecological Monographs35: 259–284.
65.
KornfeldMFrisonGCLarsonML (2016) Prehistoric Hunter-Gatherers of the High Plains and Rockies. New York, NY: Routledge.
66.
LeslieDDouglasC (1979) Desert bighorn sheep of the river mountains, Nevada. Wildlife Monographs66: 3–56.
67.
LindstromS (1996) Great basin Fisherfolk: Optimal diet breadth modeling the Truckee River Aboriginal subsistence fishery. In: PlewMG (ed.) Prehistoric Hunter-Gatherer Fishing Strategies. Boise, ID: Department of Anthropology, Boise State University, pp.114–179.
68.
LongCJWhitlockCBartleinPJ, et al. (1998) A 9000-year fire history from the Oregon Coast Range, based on a high-resolution charcoal study. Canadian Journal of Forest Research/Journal Canadien de la Recherche Forestiere28: 774–787.
69.
LouderbackLA (2022) Climate-driven dietary change on the Colorado Plateau, USA, and implications for gender-specific foraging patterns. American Antiquity87: 1–17.
70.
LouderbackLAGraysonDKLloberaM (2011) Middle-holocene climates and human population densities in the Great Basin, western USA. The Holocene21: 366–373.
71.
LouderbackLARhodeDMadsenDB, et al. (2015) Rapid vegetation shifts in the Uinta Mountains (Utah and Wyoming, USA) during the Late Pleistocene and holocene. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology438: 327–343.
72.
LouderbackLARhodeDE (2009) 15,000 Years of vegetation change in the Bonneville Basin: The Blue Lake pollen record. Quaternary Science Reviews28: 308–326.
73.
LundeenZBrunelleABurnsSJ, et al. (2013) A speleothem record of holocene paleoclimate from the Northern Wasatch Mountains, Southeast Idaho, USA. Quaternary International310: 83–95.
74.
LundeenZJBrunelleA (2016) A 14,000-year record of fire, climate, and vegetation from the bear river range, Southeast Idaho, USA. The Holocene26: 833–842.
75.
LupoKSchmittD (1997) On late-Holocene variability in bison populations in the northeastern Great Basin. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology19: 50–69.
76.
LupoKDSchmittDNMadsenDB (2020) Size matters only sometimes: The energy-risk trade-offs of holocene prey acquisition in the Bonneville basin, western USA. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences12: 1–18.
77.
MackieRJPacDFHamlinKL, et al. (1998) Ecology and Management of Mule Deer and White-Tailed Deer in Montana. Helena, MT: Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks, Wildlife Division.
78.
MadsenDBSchmittDN (1998) Mass collecting and the diet breadth model: A Great Basin example. Journal of Archaeological Science25: 445–455.
79.
MadsenDBSimmsSR (1998) The Fremont complex: A behavioral perspective. Journal of World Prehistory12: 255–336.
80.
MalhiYDoughtyCEGalettiM, et al. (2016) Megafauna and ecosystem function from the pleistocene to the anthropocene. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113: 838–846.
81.
MartinE (2019) An examination of the role of costly signaling and projectile optimization in prehistoric large game hunting in the Great Basin. PhD Dissertation, University of Utah.
82.
MassminoJMetcalfeD (1999) New form for the formative. Utah Archaeologist12: 1–16.
83.
McGuireKRHildebrandtWR (2005) Re-thinking Great Basin foragers: Prestige hunting and costly signaling during the Middle Archaic Period. American Antiquity70: 695–712.
84.
MechLDMcRobertsREPetersonRO, et al. (1987) Relationship of deer and moose populations to previous winters' Snow. The Journal of Animal Ecology56: 615–627.
85.
MinckleyTAWhitlockCBartleinPJ (2007) Vegetation, fire, and climate history of the northwestern Great Basin during the last 14,000 years. Quaternary Science Reviews26: 2167–2184.
86.
MohrJAWhitlockCSkinnerCN (2000) Postglacial vegetation and fire history, eastern Klamath Mountains, California, USA. The Holocene10: 587–601.
87.
MorinEBirdDWinterhalderB, et al. (2022) Deconstructing hunting returns: Can we reconstruct and predict payoffs from pursuing prey?Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory29: 561–623.
88.
O'ConnellJFHawkesKLupoKD, et al. (2002) Male strategies and plio-Pleistocene archaeology. Journal of Human Evolution43: 831–872.
89.
OommenMAShankerK (2021) Signals from the hunt: Widening the spectrum on male pursuits of dangerous animals. Journal of Anthropological Research77: 362–396.
90.
PeekJMDennisBHersheyT (2002) Predicting population trends of mule deer. Journal of Wildlife Management66: 729–736.
91.
PinsonA (1999) Foraging in uncertain times: The effects of risk on subsistence behavior during the Pleistocene–Holocene transition in the Oregon Great Basin. PhD Dissertation, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.
92.
PurdueJR (1989) Changes during the holocene in the size of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) from central Illinois. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)32: 307–316.
93.
RamptonD (1999) Human patch choice and its effect on mobility: An archaeofaunal examination of the sudden shelter materials. Master’s Thesis, Department of Anthropology, University of Utah.
94.
R Core Team (2021) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Available at: https://www.r-project.org/ (accessed June 2020).
95.
ReimerPJAustinWENBardE, et al. (2020) The IntCal20 Northern Hemisphere radiocarbon age calibration curve (0–55 cal kBP). Radiocarbon62: 725–757.
96.
SeveringhausC (1947) Relationship of weather to winter mortality and population levels among deer in the Adirondack Region of New York. Transactions of the North American Wildlife Conference12: 212–223.
97.
SimmsSR (1987) Behavioral Ecology and Hunter-Gatherer Foraging: An Example From the Great Basin, vol. 381. Oxford: BAR International Series.
98.
SimmsSRO’ConnellJFJonesKT (2014) Some thoughts on evolution, ecology, and archaeology in the Great Basin. In: ParezoNJJanetskiJC (eds) Archaeology in the Great Basin and Southwest: Papers in Honor of Don D. Fowler. Salt Lake City, UT: University of Utah Press, pp.177–188.
99.
SlaughterBH (1967) Animal ranges as a clue to late-Pleistocene extinction. In: MartinPSWrightHE (eds) Pleistocene Extinctions: The Search for a Cause. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, pp.153–167.
100.
SmithEA (1991) Inujjuamiut Foraging Strategies: Evolutionary Ecology of an Artic Hunting Economy. New York, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
101.
SmithEABliege BirdR (2005) Costly signaling and cooperative behavior. In: Gintis H, Bowles S and Boyde R (eds) Moral Sentiments and Material Interests: The Foundations of Cooperation in Economic Life, vol. 6, MIT Press: Cambridge, p.115.
102.
SmithSJAndersonRS (1992) Late Wisconsin paleoecologic record from Swamp Lake, Yosemite National Park, California. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)38: 91–102.
103.
SpethJD (2010) Big-game hunting: Protein, fat, or politics? In: SpethJD (ed.) The Paleoanthropology and Archaeology of Big-Game Hunting: Protein, Fat, or Politics?New York, NY: Springer, pp.149–161.
104.
SpethJDNewlanderKWhiteAA, et al. (2013) Early Paleoindian Big-Game hunting in North America: Provisioning or politics?Quaternary International: the Journal of the International Union for Quaternary Research285: 111–139.
105.
StephensonTEHolecheckJLKuykendallCB (1985) Drought effect on pronghorn and other ungulate diets. Journal of Wildlife Management49: 146–151.
106.
StrongWLHillsLV (2003) Post-Hypsithermal plant disjunctions in Western Alberta, Canada. Journal of Biogeography30: 419–430.
107.
StuiverMReimerPJ (1993) Extended 14C data base and revised CALIB 3.0 14C age calibration program. Radiocarbon35: 215–230.
108.
ThompsonKPastorJ (1995) People of the Sage: 10,000 Years of Occupation in Southwest Wyoming. Archaeological Services, Western Wyoming Community College, Cultural Resource Management Report No. 67, Rock Springs.
109.
ThompsonRSOviattCGHonkeJS, et al. (2016) Late Quaternary changes in lakes, vegetation, and climate in the Bonneville basin reconstruction from sediment cores from Great Salt Lake. In: OviattCGShroderJF (eds) Lake Bonneville: A Scientific Update. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier, pp.221–291.
110.
UganABrightJRogersA (2003) When is technology worth the trouble?Journal of Archaeological Science30: 1315–1329.
111.
UganASimmsS (2012) On prey mobility, prey rank, and foraging goals. American Antiquity77: 179–185.
112.
Van VurenDBrayMP (1986) Population dynamics of bison in the henry Mountains, Utah. Journal of Mammalogy67: 503–511.
113.
WaguespackNM (2005) The organization of male and female labor in foraging societies: Implications for early Paleoindian archaeology. American Anthropologist107: 666–676.
114.
WalkerIRPellattMG (2003) Climate change in coastal British Columbia — A paleoenvironmental perspective. Canadian Water Resources Journal28: 531–566.
115.
WestG (2004) A late Pleistocene–Holocene Pollen Record of Vegetation Change from Little Willow Lake, Lassen Volcanic National Park, California. In: Proceedings of the Twentieth Annual Pacific Climate Workshop, Asilomar Conference Grounds (eds StarrattSWBlomquistNL), Pacific Grove, CA, Pacific Grove, CA: Department of Water Resources, pp.65–80.
116.
WhitlockCBartleinPJ (1993) Spatial variations of holocene climatic change in the Yellowstone region. The Quaternary Research (Daiyonki-Kenkyu)39: 231–238.
117.
WhitlockCDeanWEFritzSC, et al. (2012) Holocene seasonal variability inferred from multiple proxy records from Crevice Lake, Yellowstone National Park, USA. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 331–332: 90–103.
118.
WinterhalderB (1981) Foraging strategies in the boreal forest: An analysis of Cree hunting and gathering. In: WinterhalderBSmithEA (eds) Hunter-Gatherer Foraging Strategies: Ethnographic and Archaeological Analyses. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp.66–98.
119.
WoodSN (2017) Generalized Additive Models: An Introduction With R. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press/Taylor & Francis Group.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
