Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2019-7
Integrating U-Th,14 C,and 210 Pb methods to produce a chronologically reliable isotope record for the Belize River Valley Maya from a low-uranium stalagmite
Social and environmental changes had great spatiotemporal variability in the Maya Lowlands during the Classic and Postclassic Periods, and stalagmites promise high-resolution paleoclimate data that can refine our understanding of this complex time. Unfortunately, stalagmites in this region are often difficult to date by U-Th methods because of low initial uranium concentrations. Other dating techniques can be used on such stalagmites, and we present here an age–depth model for BZBT1, a low-uranium stalagmite sampled from Box Tunich cave in the Belize River Valley. This age–depth model dates the growth of BZBT1 to between 400 and 1610 yr BP (340–1550 CE) by combining evidence from U-Th results, radiocarbon dating of both stalagmite CaCO3 and trapped organic material, and 210Pb dating. The resulting stable isotope record from BZBT1 reveals paleoclimate changes that affected local Maya populations during the Classic and early Postclassic Periods. This record is further refined by isotopically tuning the BZBT1 data with two other regional stalagmite records. Our work offers additional paleoclimate insight into the relationship between the Maya and their environment from a stalagmite that would typically be disregarded for research purposes. Continued research into alternative dating techniques for speleothems can enable additional scientific discovery while promoting speleothem conservation.
Acuna-SotoRStahleDWCleavelandMKet al. (2002) Megadrought and megadeath in 16th century Mexico. Emerging Infectious Diseases8: 360–362.
2.
AdkinsJFCarolinSACobbKMet al. (2013) U-series dating of tropical stalagmites. In: American Geophysical Union, Fall Meeting, San Francisco, CA, 9–13 December.
3.
AimersJJ (2007) What Maya collapse? Terminal classic variation in the Maya lowlands. Journal of Archaeological Research15: 329–377.
4.
AimersJJIannoneG (2014) The dynamics of ancient Maya developmental history. In: IannoneG (ed.) The Great Maya Droughts in Cultural Context: Case Studies in Resilience and Vulnerability. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado, pp. 21–49.
5.
AkersPD (2011) Climate and Maya cultural change: Detecting connections using Belizean stalagmites. MS Thesis, Department of Geography, University of Georgia, Athens, GA.
6.
AkersPD (2016) Paleoclimate change in southern Indiana determined from speleothem climate proxies and analysis of modern precipitation oxygen isotope variations. Doctoral Dissertation, Department of Geography, University of Georgia, Athens, GA.
7.
AkersPDBrookGARailsbackLBet al. (2016) An extended and higher-resolution record of climate and land use from stalagmite MC01 from Macal Chasm, Belize, revealing connections between major dry events, overall climate variability, and Maya sociopolitical changes. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology459: 268–288.
8.
ApplebyPG (1998) Dating recent sediments by Pb-210: Problems and solutions. In: Proceedings of a Seminar, Helsinki, 2–3 April, 1997, pp. 7–24. Helsinki: Finland Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority.
9.
ApplebyPGShotykWFankhauserA (1997) Lead-210 age dating of three peat cores in the Jura mountains, Switzerland. Water Air and Soil Pollution100: 223–231.
10.
AweJJHoggarthJAHelmkeC (2014) Prehistoric settlement patterns in the Upper Belize River Valley and their implications for models of low-density urbanism. Acta Mesoamericana27: 263–285.
11.
BajoPHellstromJFrisiaSet al. (2016) ‘Cryptic’ diagenesis and its implications for speleothem geochronologies. Quaternary Science Reviews148: 17–28.
12.
BannerJLGuilfoyleAJamesEWet al. (2007) Seasonal variations in modern speleothem calcite growth in Central Texas, USA. Journal of Sedimentary Research77: 615–622.
13.
BaskaranMIliffeTM (1993) Age determination of recent cave deposits using excess 210Pb − A new technique. Geophysical Research Letters20: 603–606.
14.
BhattacharyaTByrneRBohnelHet al. (2015) Cultural implications of Late-Holocene climate change in the Cuenca Oriental, Mexico. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America112: 1693–1698.
15.
BhattacharyaTChiangJCHChengW (2017) Ocean-atmosphere dynamics linked to 800-1050 CE drying in Mesoamerica. Quaternary Science Reviews169: 263–277.
16.
BlythAJHartlandABakerA (2016) Organic proxies in speleothems – New developments, advantages and limitations. Quaternary Science Reviews149: 1–17.
17.
BlythAJHuaQSmithAet al. (2017) Exploring the dating of ‘dirty’ speleothems and cave sinters using radiocarbon dating of preserved organic matter. Quaternary Geochronology39: 92–98.
18.
BorsatoAFrisiaSMiorandiR (2015) Carbon dioxide concentration in temperate climate caves and parent soils over an altitudinal gradient and its influence on speleothem growth and fabrics. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms40: 1158–1170.
19.
BorsatoAFrisiaSJonesBet al. (2000) Calcite moonmilk: Crystal morphology and environment of formation in caves in the Italian Alps. Journal of Sedimentary Research70: 1171–1182.
20.
BroeckerWSOlsonEAOrrPC (1960) Radiocarbon measurements and annual rings in cave formations. Nature185: 93–94.
21.
BrookGACherkinskyARailsbackLBet al. (2013) 14C dating of organic residue and carbonate from stromatolites in Etosha Pan, Namibia: 14C reservoir effect, correction of published ages, and evidence of >8-m-deep lake during the Late Pleistocene. Radiocarbon55: 1156–1163.
22.
CaiYJBeckWPengZCet al. (2005) Effect of dead carbon on the 14C dating of the speleothem. Chinese Science Bulletin50: 817–821.
23.
ChaseAFChaseDZ (2007) ‘This is the End’: Archaeological transitions and the terminal classic period at Caracol, Belize. Research Reports in Belizean Archaeology4: 13–27.
24.
ChaseDZChaseAF (2003) Texts and contexts in classic Maya warfare: A brief consideration of epigraphy and archaeology at Caracol, Belize. In: BrownMKStantonT (eds) Ancient Mesoamerican Warfare. Walnut Creek, CA: Alta Mira Press, pp. 171–188.
25.
ChaseAFChaseDZAweJJet al. (2014) Ancient Maya regional settlement and inter-site analysis: The 2013 west-central Belize LiDAR survey. Remote Sensing6: 8671–8695.
26.
ChengHEdwardsRLHoffJet al. (2000) The half-lives of uranium-234 and thorium-230. Chemical Geology169: 17–33.
27.
CzaplewskiNJKrejcaJMillerTE (2003) Late quaternary bats from Cebada Cave, Chiquibul cave system, Belize. Caribbean Journal of Science39: 23–33.
28.
DahlinBHChaseAF (2014) A tale of three cities: Effects of the A.D. 536 in the Lowland Maya heartland. In: IannoneG (ed.) The Great Maya Droughts in Cultural Context: Case Studies in Resilience and Vulnerability. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado, pp. 127–155.
DennistonRFGonzálezLAAsmeromYet al. (1999) Evidence for increased cool season moisture during the middle Holocene. Geology27: 815–818.
31.
DoraleJAEdwardsRLAlexanderECet al. (2004) Uranium-series dating of speleothems: Current techniques, limits, & applications. In: SasowskyIDMylroieJ (eds) Studies of Cave Sediments: Physical and Chemical Records of Paleoclimate. Boston, MA: Springer, pp. 177–197.
32.
DouglasPMJBrennerMCurtisJH (2016) Methods and future directions for paleoclimatology in the Maya Lowlands. Global and Planetary Change138: 3–24.
33.
DreybrodtWScholzD (2011) Climatic dependence of stable carbon and oxygen isotope signals recorded in speleothems: From soil water to speleothem calcite. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta75: 734–752.
34.
DrysdaleRNZanchettaGHellstromJCet al. (2007) Stalagmite evidence for the precise timing of North Atlantic cold events during the early last glacial. Geology35: 77–80.
35.
EbertCEHoggarthJAAweJJ (2016) Integrating quantitative lidar analysis and settlement survey in the Belize River Valley. Advances in Archaeological Practice4: 284–300.
36.
EbertCEPeniche-MayNCulletonBJet al. (2017) Regional response to drought during the formation and decline of preclassic Maya societies. Quaternary Science Reviews173: 211–235.
37.
EbertCEPruferKMMacriMJet al. (2014) Terminal long count dates and the disintegration of classic period Maya polities. Ancient Mesoamerica25: 337–356.
38.
EdwardsRLChenJHWasserburgGJ (1987) U-238-U-234-TH-230-TH-232 systematics and the precise measurement of time over the past 500,000 years. Earth and Planetary Science Letters81: 175–192.
39.
FairchildIJBakerA (2012) Speleothem Science: From Process to past Environments. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
40.
FarquharGDEhleringerJRHubickKT (1989) Carbon isotope discrimination and photosynthesis. Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Plant Molecular Biology40: 503–537.
41.
FenstererCScholzDHoffmannDet al. (2010) 230Th/U-dating of a late Holocene low uranium speleothem from Cuba. In: Pages 1st Young Scientists Meeting, Corvallis, OR, 6–7 July 2009. Bristol: IOP Publishing.
42.
FohlmeisterJSchroder-RitzrauASpotlCet al. (2010) The influences of hydrology on the radiogenic and stable carbon isotope composition of cave drip water, Grotta di Ernesto (Italy). Radiocarbon52: 1529–1544.
43.
GentyDBlamartDOuahdiRet al. (2003) Precise dating of Dansgaard–Oeschger climate oscillations in western Europe from stalagmite data. Nature421: 833.
44.
GentyDKonikSValladasHet al. (2011) Dating the Lascaux Cave Gour formation. Radiocarbon53: 479–500.
45.
GentyDMassaultMGilmourMet al. (1999) Calculation of past dead carbon proportion and variability by the comparison of AMS(14)C and TIMS U/Th ages on two holocene stalagmites. Radiocarbon41: 251–270.
46.
GentyDVokalBObelicBet al. (1998) Bomb C-14 time history recorded in two modern stalagmites – Importance for soil organic matter dynamics and bomb C-14 distribution over continents. Earth and Planetary Science Letters160: 795–809.
47.
GoslarTHercmanHPazdurA (2000) Comparison of U-series and radiocarbon dates of speleothems. Radiocarbon42: 403–414.
48.
GriffithsMLFohlmeisterJDrysdaleRNet al. (2012) Hydrological control of the dead carbon fraction in a Holocene tropical speleothem. Quaternary Geochronology14: 81–93.
49.
HartmannABakerA (2017) Modelling karst vadose zone hydrology and its relevance for paleoclimate reconstruction. Earth-Science Reviews172: 178–192.
50.
HaugGHGuntherDPetersonLCet al. (2003) Climate and the collapse of Maya civilization. Science299: 1731–1735.
51.
HealyPFHelmkeCGBAweJJet al. (2007) Survey, settlement, and population history at the ancient Maya site of Pacbitun, Belize. Journal of Field Archaeology32: 17–39.
52.
HellstromJPickeringR (2015) Recent advances and future prospects of the U-Th and U-Pb chronometers applicable to archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Science56: 32–40.
53.
HendyCHWilsonAT (1968) Palaeoclimatic data from speleothems. Nature219: 48–51.
54.
HodellDABrennerMCurtisJH (2005) Terminal classic drought in the northern Maya lowlands inferred from multiple sediment cores in Lake Chichancanab (Mexico). Quaternary Science Reviews24: 1413–1427.
55.
HodgeEMcDonaldJFischerMet al. (2011) Using the C-14 bomb pulse to date young speleothems. Radiocarbon53: 345–357.
56.
HoggarthJA (2012) Social reorganization and household adaptation in the aftermath of collapse at Baking Pot, Belize. PhD Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA.
57.
HoggarthJABreitenbachSFMCulletonBJet al. (2016) The political collapse of Chichén Itzá in climatic and cultural context. Global and Planetary Change138: 25–42.
58.
HoggarthJACulletonBJAweJJet al. (2014) Questioning postclassic continuity at Baking Pot, Belize, using direct AMS 14C dating of human burials. Radiocarbon56: 1057–1075.
59.
HoggarthJARestallMWoodJWet al. (2017) Drought and its demographic effects in the Maya Lowlands. Current Anthropology58: 82–113.
60.
HuaQMcDonaldJRedwoodDet al. (2012) Robust chronological reconstruction for young speleothems using radiocarbon. Quaternary Geochronology14: 67–80.
IannoneG (2014) The Great Maya Droughts in Cultural Context: Case Studies in Resilience and Vulnerability. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado.
63.
IannoneGChaseAFChaseDZet al. (2014) An archaeological consideration of long-term socio-ecological dynamics on the Vaca Plateau, Belize. In: IannoneG (ed.) The Great Maya Droughts in Cultural Context: Case Studies in Resilience and Vulnerability. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado, pp. 271–300.
64.
JamiesonRABaldiniJULBrettMJet al. (2016) Intra- and inter-annual uranium concentration variability in a Belizean stalagmite controlled by prior aragonite precipitation: A new tool for reconstructing hydro-climate using aragonitic speleothems. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta190: 332–346.
65.
KennettDJBeachTP (2013) Archeological and environmental lessons for the Anthropocene from the Classic Maya collapse. Anthropocene4: 88–100.
66.
KennettDJBreitenbachSFMAquinoVVet al. (2012) Development and disintegration of Maya political systems in response to climate change. Science338: 788–791.
67.
LachnietMS (2009) Climatic and environmental controls on speleothem oxygen-isotope values. Quaternary Science Reviews28: 412–432.
68.
LachnietMSBernalJPAsmeromYet al. (2012) Uranium loss and aragonite-calcite age discordance in a calcitized aragonite stalagmite. Quaternary Geochronology14: 26–37.
69.
LambertWJAharonP (2011) Controls on dissolved inorganic carbon and delta C-13 in cave waters from DeSoto Caverns: Implications for speleothem delta C-13 assessments. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta75: 753–768.
70.
LechleitnerFABaldiniJULBreitenbachSFMet al. (2016a) Hydrological and climatological controls on radiocarbon concentrations in a tropical stalagmite. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta194: 233–252.
71.
LechleitnerFAFohlmeisterJMcIntyreCet al. (2016b) A novel approach for construction of radiocarbon-based chronologies for speleothems. Quaternary Geochronology35: 54–66.
72.
LiJ-YLiH-CLiT-Yet al. (2017) High-resolution δ18O and δ13C records of an AMS 14C and 230Th/U dated stalagmite from Xinya Cave in Chongqing: Climate and vegetation change during the Late-Holocene. Quaternary International447: 75–88.
73.
McDermottF (2004) Palaeo-climate reconstruction from stable isotope variations in speleothems: A review. Quaternary Science Reviews23: 901–918.
McGarrySFCaseldineC (2004) Speleothem palynology: An undervalued tool in Quaternary studies. Quaternary Science Reviews23: 2389–2404.
76.
MarkowskaMBakerAAndersenMSet al. (2016) Semi-arid zone caves: Evaporation and hydrological controls on δ18O drip water composition and implications for speleothem paleoclimate reconstructions. Quaternary Science Reviews131: 285–301.
77.
MartinSGrubeN (2008) Chronicle of Maya Kings and Queens: Deciphering the Dynasties of the Ancient Maya. 2nd Edition.London: Thames and Hudson.
78.
MartinsonDGPisiasNGHaysJDet al. (1987) Age dating and the orbital theory of the ice ages: Development of a high-resolution 0 to 300,000-year chronostratigraphy. Quaternary Research27: 1–29.
79.
MatteyDPFairchildIJAtkinsonTCet al. (2010) Seasonal microclimate control of calcite fabrics, stable isotopes and trace elements in modern speleothem from St Michaels Cave, Gibraltar. In: PedleyHMRogersonM (eds) Tufas and Speleothems: Unravelling the Microbial and Physical Controls. London: Geological Society of London (Special Publications 336), pp. 323–344.
80.
Medina-ElizaldeMRohlingEJ (2012) Collapse of classic Maya civilization related to modest reduction in precipitation. Science335: 956–959.
81.
Medina-ElizaldeMBurnsSJLeaDWet al. (2010) High resolution stalagmite climate record from the Yucatán Peninsula spanning the Maya terminal classic period. Earth and Planetary Science Letters298: 255–262.
82.
Medina-ElizaldeMBurnsSJPolanco-MartínezJMet al. (2016) High-resolution speleothem record of precipitation from the Yucatan Peninsula spanning the Maya Preclassic Period. Global and Planetary Change138: 93–102.
83.
MeyerKWFengWMBreeckerDOet al. (2014) Interpretation of speleothem calcite delta C-13 variations: Evidence from monitoring soil CO2, drip water, and modern speleothem calcite in central Texas. Geochimica Et Cosmochimica Acta142: 281–298.
84.
MixterDW (2016) Surviving collapse: Collective memory and political reorganization at Actuncan, Belize. PhD Dissertation. Washington University, St. Louis.
85.
MoquetJSCruzFWNovelloVFet al. (2016) Calibration of speleothem δ18O records against hydroclimate instrumental records in Central Brazil. Global and Planetary Change139: 151–164.
86.
NoronhaALJohnsonKRHuCYet al. (2014) Assessing influences on speleothem dead carbon variability over the Holocene: Implications for speleothem-based radiocarbon calibration. Earth and Planetary Science Letters394: 20–29.
87.
NoronhaALJohnsonKRSouthonJRet al. (2015) Radiocarbon evidence for decomposition of aged organic matter in the vadose zone as the main source of speleothem carbon. Quaternary Science Reviews127: 37–47.
88.
O’LearyMH (1988) Carbon isotopes in photosynthesis. Bioscience38: 328–336.
89.
PennMGSuttonDAMonroA (2004) Vegetation of the greater Maya mountains, Belize. Systematics and Biodiversity2: 21–44.
90.
Peuramaki-BrownM (2012) The integration and disintegration of ancient Maya urban centres: Charting households and community at Buenavista del Cayo, Belize. PhD Dissertation, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada.
91.
PolkJSvan BeynenPEReederPP (2007) Late-Holocene environmental reconstruction using cave sediments from Belize. Quaternary Research68: 53–63.
92.
PowersJSVeldkampE (2005) Regional variation in soil carbon and δ13C in forests and pastures of northeastern Costa Rica. Biogeochemistry72: 315–336.
93.
PuJWangAShenLet al. (2016) Factors controlling the growth rate, carbon and oxygen isotope variation in modern calcite precipitation in a subtropical cave, Southwest China. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences119: 167–178.
94.
RailsbackLB (2018) A comparison of growth rate of Late-Holocene stalagmites with atmospheric precipitation and temperature, and its implications for paleoclimatology. Quaternary Science Reviews187: 94–111.
95.
RailsbackLBBrookGAWebsterJW (1999) Petrology and paleoenvironmental significance of detrital sand and silt in a stalagmite from Drotsky’s Cave, Botswana. Physical Geography20: 331–347.
96.
RailsbackLBAkersPDWangLXet al. (2013) Layer-bounding surfaces in stalagmites as keys to better paleoclimatological histories and chronologies. International Journal of Speleology42: 167–180.
97.
Sanchez-CabezaJARuiz-FernándezAC (2012) 210Pb sediment radiochronology: An integrated formulation and classification of dating models. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta82: 183–200.
98.
SchwakeSAIannoneG (2016) Destruction events and political truncation at the Little Kingdom of Minanha, Belize. In: IannoneGHoukBASchwakeSA (eds) Ritual, Violence, and the Fall of the Classic Maya. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, pp. 134–158.
99.
ScroxtonNGaganMKDunbarGBet al. (2016) Natural attrition and growth frequency variations of stalagmites in southwest Sulawesi over the past 530,000 years. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology441: 823–833.
100.
ShackletonNJ (2000) The 100,000-year ice-age cycle identified and found to lag temperature, carbon dioxide, and orbital eccentricity. Science289: 1897–1902.
101.
ShenCCEdwardsRLChengHet al. (2002) Uranium and thorium isotopic and concentration measurements by magnetic sector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Chemical Geology185: 165–178.
102.
StahleDKCookERCleavelandMKet al. (2000) Tree-ring data document 16th century megadrought over North America. Eos, Transactions American Geophysical Union81: 121–125.
103.
StahleDWDiazJVBurnetteDJet al. (2011) Major Mesoamerican droughts of the past millennium. Geophysical Research Letters38: L05703.
104.
StuiverMReimerPJ (1993) Extended 14C data base and revised CALIB 3.0 14C age calibration program. Radiocarbon35: 215–230.
105.
TanaharaATairaHYamakawaKet al. (1998) Application of excess Pb-210 dating method to stalactites. Geochemical Journal32: 183–187.
106.
TherrellMDStahleDWSotoRA (2004) Aztec drought and the ‘curse of one rabbit’. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society85: 1263.
107.
TrumboreS (2000) Age of soil organic matter and soil respiration: Radiocarbon constraints on belowground C dynamics. Ecological Applications10: 399–411.
108.
TrumboreSE (1993) Comparison of carbon dynamics in tropical and temperate soils using radiocarbon measurements. Global Biogeochemical Cycles7: 275–290.
109.
TurnerBLSabloffJA (2012) Classic period collapse of the central Maya lowlands: Insights about human–environment relationships for sustainability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America109: 13908–13914.
110.
VogelJSSouthonJRNelsonDEet al. (1984) Performance of catalytically condensed carbon for use in accelerator mass spectrometry. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research5: 289–293.
111.
WahlDByrneRAndersonL (2014) An 8700 year paleoclimate reconstruction from the southern Maya lowlands. Quaternary Science Reviews103: 19–25.
112.
WallingDE (1999) Linking land use, erosion and sediment yields in river basins. Hydrobiologia410: 223–240.
113.
WangYJChengHEdwardsRLet al. (2001) A high-resolution absolute-dated late pleistocene monsoon record from Hulu Cave, China. Science294: 2345–2348.
114.
WassenburgJAScholzDJochumKPet al. (2016) Determination of aragonite trace element distribution coefficients from speleothem calcite–aragonite transitions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta190: 347–367.
115.
WebsterJWBrookGARailsbackLBet al. (2007) Stalagmite evidence from Belize indicating significant droughts at the time of preclassic abandonment, the Maya Hiatus, and the classic Maya collapse. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology250: 1–17.
116.
WesterholdTRohlURaffiIet al. (2008) Astronomical calibration of the Paleocene time. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology257: 377–403.
117.
WilleyGRBullardGlassJBet al. (1965) Prehistoric Maya settlements in the Belize Valley (Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology). Cambridge: Harvard University.
118.
WongCIBreeckerDO (2015) Advancements in the use of speleothems as climate archives. Quaternary Science Reviews127: 1–18.
119.
WoodheadJPickeringR (2012) Beyond 500 ka: Progress and prospects in the UPb chronology of speleothems, and their application to studies in palaeoclimate, human evolution, biodiversity and tectonics. Chemical Geology322–323: 290–299.
120.
WynnPMBrocksJJ (2014) A framework for the extraction and interpretation of organic molecules in speleothem carbonate. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry28: 845–854.
121.
YaegerJ (2008) Charting the collapse: Late classic to postclassic population dynamics in the Mopan valley, Belize. Research Reports in Belizean Archaeology5: 13–21.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
