Velle et al. (2010) discussed discrepancies between Scandinavian Holocene chironomid-inferred temperature estimates, which they attribute to the response of chironomids to environmental variables other than temperature and to taxonomic shortcomings. They suggest ways in which the reliability of chironomid-based paleotemperature reconstructions could be improved by taking into account ecological complexity. While we agree with many of their recommendations, based on the results of other work, we think their paper is unnecessarily pessimistic regarding the ability of existing chironomid-based temperature inference models to provide reliable estimates of past temperature. We offer a critique of the main points discussed by Velle et al. (2010) and provide evidence that chironomid-based temperature inference models can reliably reconstruct mean July air temperature in the Lateglacial and Holocene over millennial and centennial timescales.
AndersonNJHarrimanRRyvesDB. (2001) Dominant factors controlling variability in the ionic composition of West Greenland lakesArctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research33: 418–425.
2.
AxfordYBrinerJPFrancisDR. (2011) Chironomids record terrestrial temperature changes throughout arctic interglacials of the past 200,000 years. Geological Society of America Bulletin doi: 10.1130/B30329.1.
3.
AxfordYBrinerJPMillerGH. (2009) Paleoecological evidence for abrupt cold reversals during peak Holocene warmth on Baffin Island, Arctic Canada. Quaternary Research71: 142–149.
4.
AxfordYMillerGHGeirsdóttirA. (2007) Holocene temperature history of northern Iceland inferred from subfossil midges. Quaternary Science Reviews26: 3344–3358.
5.
BedfordAJonesRTLangB. (2004) A Late-glacial chironomid record from Hawes Water, N.W. England. Journal of Quaternary Science19: 281–290.
6.
BirksHJBHeiriOSeppäH. (2010) Strengths and weaknesses of quantitative climate reconstructions based on late-Quaternary biological proxies. The Open Ecology Journal3: 68–110.
7.
BrodersenKPAndersonNJ (2002) Distribution of chironomids (Diptera) in low arctic West Greenland lakes: Trophic conditions, temperature and environmental reconstruction. Freshwater Biology47: 1137–1157.
8.
BrodersenKPLindegaardC (1999) Classification, assessment and trophic reconstruction of Danish lakes using chironomids. Freshwater Biology42: 143–157.
9.
BrodinY-W (1986) The postglacial history of Lake Flarken, southern Sweden, interpreted from subfossil insect remains. Internationale Revue der gesamten Hydrobiologie71: 371–432.
10.
BrooksSJ (2003) Chironomidae (Insecta: Diptera). In: MacKayABattarbeeRWBirksHJB (eds) Global Change in the Holocene. London: Arnold, pp. 328–341.
11.
BrooksSJ (2006) Fossil midges as palaeoclimatic indicators of the Eurasian region. Quaternary Science Reviews25: 1894–1910.
12.
BrooksSJBirksHJB (2000) Chironomid-inferred late-glacial air temperatures at Whitrig Bog, south-east Scotland. Journal of Quaternary Science15: 759–764.
13.
BrooksSJBirksHJB (2001) Chironomid-inferred air temperatures from late-glacial and Holocene sites in north-west Europe: Progress and problems. Quaternary Science Reviews20: 1723–1741.
14.
BrooksSJBennionHBirksHJB (2001) Tracing lake trophic history with a chironomid-total phosphorus inference model. Freshwater Biology46: 511–532.
15.
CaseldineCLangdonPHolmesN (2006) Early Holocene climate variability and the timing and extent of the Holocene thermal maximum (HTM) in northern Iceland. Quaternary Science Reviews25: 2314–2331.
16.
CleggBFClarkeGHChipmanML. (2010) Six millennia of summer temperature variation based on midge analysis of lake sediments from Alaska. Quaternary Science Reviews29: 3308–3316.
17.
DaltonCBirksHJBBrooksSJ. (2005) A multiproxy study of lake-development in response to catchment changes during the Holocene at Lochnagar, north-east Scotland. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology221: 175–201.
18.
Gathorne-HardyFJErlendssonELangdonPG. (2009) Lake sediment evidence for late-Holocene climate change and landscape erosion in western Iceland. Journal of Paleolimnology42: 413–426.
19.
Gathorne-HardyFJLawsonITChurchMJ. (2007) The impact of the Norse Landnám on the Chironomidae (Insecta: Diptera) of lake Gróthúsvatn, Sandoy, Faroe Islands. The Holocene17: 1259–1264.
20.
HannBJWarnerBGWarwickWF (1992) Aquatic invertebrates and climate change: A comment on Walker et al. (1991). Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences49: 1274–1276.
21.
HeiriCBugmannHTinnerW. (2006) A model-based reconstruction of Holocene treeline dynamics in the Central Swiss Alps. Journal of Ecology94: 206–216.
22.
HeiriOLotterAF (2003) 9000 years of chironomid assemblage dynamics in an Alpine lake: Long-term trends, sensitivity to disturbance, and resilience of the fauna. Journal of Paleolimnology30: 273–289.
23.
HeiriOLotterAF (2005) Holocene and Lateglacial summer temperature reconstruction in the Swiss Alps based on fossil assemblages of aquatic organisms: A review. Boreas34: 506–516.
24.
HeiriOLotterAF (2010) How does taxonomic resolution affect chironomid-based temperature reconstruction?Journal of Paleolimnology44: 589–601.
25.
HeiriOMilletL (2005) Reconstruction of Late Glacial summer temperatures from chironomid assemblages in Lac Lautrey (Jura, France). Journal of Quaternary Science20: 33–44.
26.
HeiriOCremerHEngelsS. (2007) Lateglacial summer temperatures in the Northwest European lowlands: A chironomid record from Hijkermeer, the Netherlands. Quaternary Science Reviews26: 2420–2437.
27.
HeiriOTinnerWLotterAF (2004) Evidence for cooler European summers during periods of changing meltwater flux to the North Atlantic. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences101: 15,285–15,288.
28.
JonesFC (2008) Taxonomic sufficiency: The influence of taxonomic resolution on freshwater bioassessmernts using benthic macroinvertebrates. Environmental Reviews16: 45–69.
29.
KorholaAOlanderHBlomT (2000) Cladoceran and chironomid assemblages as quantitative indicators of water depth in subarctic Fennoscandian lakes. Journal of Paleolimnology24: 43–54.
30.
KorholaAVaskoKToivonenHTT. (2002) Holocene temperature changes in northern Fennoscandia reconstructed from chironomids using Bayesian modellingQuaternary Science Reviews21: 1841–1860.
31.
LangBBedfordABrooksSJ. (2010a) Early-Holocene temperature variability inferred from chironomid assemblages at Hawes Water, northwest England. The Holocene20: 943–954.
32.
LangBBrooksSJBedfordA. (2010b) Regional consistency in Lateglacial chironomid-inferred temperatures from five sites in north-west England. Quaternary Science Reviews29: 1528–1538.
33.
LangdonPGBarberKELomas-ClarkeSH (2004) Reconstructing climate and environmental change in northern England through chironomid and pollen analyses: Evidence from Talkin Tarn, Cumbria. Journal of Paleolimnology32: 197–213.
34.
LangdonPGCaseldineCJCroudaceIW. (2011) A chironomid-based reconstruction of summer temperatures in NW Iceland since AD 1650. Quaternary Research75: 451–460.
35.
LangdonPGRuizZBrodersenKP. (2006) Assessing lake eutrophication using chironomids: Understanding the nature of community response in different lake types. Freshwater Biology51: 562–577.
36.
LarocqueI (2008) Nouvelle fonction de transfert pour reconstruire la température à l’aide des chironomides préservés dans les sédiments lacustres. INRS Rapport de Recherche R1032, ISBN 978-2-89146-587-8.
37.
LarocqueIHallRI (2003) Chironomids as quantitative indicators of meanJulyair temperature: Validation by comparison with century-long meteorological records from northern Sweden. Journal of Paleolimnology29: 475–493.
38.
LarocqueIHallRI (2004) Holocene temperature estimates and chironomid community composition in the Abisko Valley, northern Sweden. Quaternary Science Reviews23: 475–493.
39.
LarocqueIGrosjeanMHeiriO. (2009) Comparison between chironomid-inferred July temperatures and meteorological data AD 1850–2001 from varved Lake Silvaplana, Switzerland. Journal of Paleolimnology41: 329–342.
40.
LarocqueIHallRIGrahnE (2001) Chironomids as indicators of climate change: A 100-lake training set from a subarctic region of northern Sweden (Lapland). Journal of Paleolimnology26: 307–322.
41.
LarocqueIPienitzRRollandN (2006) Factors influencing the distribution of chironomids in lakes distributed along a latitudinal gradient in northwestern Quebec, Canada. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences63: 1286–1297.
42.
Larocque-ToblerIGrosjeanMHeiriO. (2010b) Thousand years of climate change reconstructed from chironomid subfossils preserved in varved lake Silvaplana, Engadine, Switzerland. Quaternary Science Reviews29: 1940–1949.
43.
Larocque-ToblerIHeiriOWehrliM (2010a) Late glacial and Holocene temperature changes at Egelsee, Switzerland, reconstructed using subfossil chironomids. Journal of Paleolimnology43: 649–666.
44.
LevesqueAJMayleFEWalkerIR. (1993) A previously unrecognised late-glacial cold event in eastern North America. Nature361: 623–626.
45.
LotterAFBirksHJBHofmannW. (1997) Modern diatom, Cladocera, chironomid, and chrysophyte cyst assemblages as quantitative indicators for the reconstruction of past environmental conditions in the Alps. I. Climate. Journal of Paleolimnology18: 395–420.
46.
OlanderHBirksHJBKorholaA. (1999) An expanded calibration model for inferring lakewater and air temperatures from fossil chironomid assemblages in northern Fennoscandia. The Holocene9: 279–294.
47.
QuinlanRSmolJP (2001) Chironomid-based inference models for estimating end-of-summer hypolimnetic oxygen from south-central Ontario shield lakes. Freshwater Biology46: 1529–1551.
48.
RenssenHSeppäHHeiriO. (2009) The spatial and temporal complexity of the Holocene thermal maximum. Nature Geoscience2: 410–413.
49.
SchnellOAWillassenE (1996) The chironomid (Diptera) communities in two sediment cores from Store Hovvatn, S. Norway, an acidified lake. Annales de Limnologie32: 45–61.
50.
SeppäHNymanMKorholaA. (2002) Changes of treelines and alpine vegetation in relation to post-glacial climate dynamics in northern Fennoscandia based on pollen and chironomid recordsJournal of Quaternary Science17: 287–301.
51.
TelfordRJBirksHJB (2011) A novel method for assessing the statistical significance of quantitative reconstructions inferred from biotic assemblages. Quaternary Science Reviews30: 1272–1278.
52.
VelleGBrooksSJBirksHJB. (2005) Chironomids as a tool for inferring Holocene climate: An assessment based on six sites in southern Scandinavia. Quaternary Science Reviews24: 1429–1462.
53.
VelleGBrodersenKPBirksHJB. (2010) Midges as quantitative temperature indicator species: Lessons for palaeoecology. The Holocene20: 989–1002.
54.
WalkerIRMathewesRW (1989) Much ado about dead Diptera. Journal of Paleolimnology2: 19–22.
55.
WarwickWF (1989) Chironomids, lake development and climate: A commentary. Journal of Paleolimnology2: 15–17.
56.
WoodcockTLongcoreJMcAuleyD. (2005) The role of pH in structuring communities of Maine wetland macrophytes and chironomid larvae (Diptera). Wetlands25: 306–316.
57.
YoungNEBrinerJPStewartHAM. (2011) Response of Jakobshavn Isbræ, Greenland, to Holocene climate change. Geology39: 131–134.
