This article examines the link between labour market regulation, in particular in relation to employment security, and the development and maintenance of an adequate skill base. The implications of the different institutional and regulatory contexts within France and the UK are addressed through a comparative study of the civil aerospace sector. The evidence indicates that the institutional framework can have a profound effect on levels of employment security and, therefore, on training and skill development; and thus that labour market flexibility in the UK is a major barrier to the development and maintenance of skills.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Addison, J.
, Barrett, C. and Siebert, S.W. (1997) `The Economics of Labour Market Regulation', in J. Addison and S.W. Siebert (eds) Labour Markets in Europe, pp. 62-104. London: Dryden Press.
2.
Baudet, M.-B.
(1998) `Avec le passage aux 35 heures les difficultes de recrutement risquent de s'aggraver', Le Monde, 28 janvier: 6.
3.
Bertola, G.
(1990) `Job Security, Employment and Wages', European Economic Review34: 851-886.
4.
Borras, I.
and Veneau, P. (1996) Prospective 2010 sur L'Emploi et la Formation dans la Construction Aeronautique et Spatiale, Cereq Document no. 114.
5.
Buechtemann, C.
(1993) `Introduction: Employment Security and Labor Markets', in C. Buechtemann (ed.) Employment Security and Labor Market Behavior, pp. 3-66. Ithaca: ILR Press.
6.
Cadin, L.
, Guérin, F. and Pigeyre, F. (1997) Gestion des Ressources Humaines. Paris: Dunod.
7.
CFDT (Confederation française democratique du travail)
(1997) Salaries Vos droits. Paris: CFDT.
8.
CNPF (Conseil national du patronat franßais)
(1993) Rdussir la Formation Professionnelle des Jeunes. Paris: Editions d'Organisation.
9.
Crouch, C.
and Streeck, W. (1997) `Introduction: The Future of Capitalist Diversity', in C. Crouch and W. Streeck (eds) Political Economy of Modern Capitalism, pp. 1-18. London: Sage.
10.
DfEE (Department for Education and Employment)
(1998) Skill Needs in Great Britain and Northern Ireland 1998. London: IFF Research, DfEE.
11.
Dickens, L.
and Hall, M. (1995) `The State: Labour Law and Industrial Relations', in P.K. Edwards (ed.) Industrial Relations, pp. 255-303. Oxford: Blackwell.
12.
EC (European Commission)
(1997) `The European Aerospace Industry: Meeting the Global Challenge', COM (97) 466, Brussels.
13.
EIRR
(1992) `Apprenticeship under Discussion', European Industrial Relations Review218: 16-18.
14.
EIRR
(1996) `New Bill Reforms Apprenticeship', European Industrial Relations Review265: 6.
15.
Eyraud, F.
, Marsden, D. and Silvestre, J.-J. (1990) `Occupational and Internal Labour Markets in Britain and France', International Labour Review129(4): 501-517.
16.
Fabre, C.
(1996) `Les premiers ingenieurs par l'apprentissage arrivent sur la marche', Le Monde, 10 decembre: 9.
17.
Felstead, A.
and Green, F. (1996) `Training Implications of Regulation Compliance and Business Cycles', in A. Booth and D. Snower (eds) Acquiring Skills, pp. 255-283. Cambridge: CUP.
18.
Fine, B.
and Harris, L. (1985) The Peculiarities of the British Economy. London: Lawrence & Wishart.
19.
Finegold, D.
(1991) `Institutional Incentives and Skill Creation: Preconditions for a High-Skill Equilibrium', in P. Ryan (ed.) International Comparisons of Vocational Education and Training for Intermediate Skills, pp. 93-118. London: Falmer Press.
20.
GIFAS (Groupement des industries françaises aeronautiques et spatiales)
(1998) Newsletter, March.
21.
Goetschy, J.
(1998) `France: The Limits of Reform', in A. Ferner and R. Hyman (eds) Changing Industrial Relations in Europe, pp. 357-394. Oxford: Blackwell.
22.
Hayward, K.
(1994) The World Aerospace Industry: Collaboration and Competition. London: Duckworth.
23.
Heyes, J.
and Stuart, M. (1994) `Placing Symbols before Reality? Re-evaluating the Low Skills Equilibrium', Personnel Review23(5): 34-49.
24.
Hyman, J.
(1992) Training at Work. London: Routledge.
25.
Hyman, R.
(1993) `Labor Law, the Labor Market, and the State: British Industrial Relations Under the Conservatives', in C. Buechtemann (ed.) Employment Security and Labor Market Behavior, pp. 320-327. Ithaca: ILR Press.
26.
IDS
(1997) `France's loi Robien; Money Waster or Job Saver?', European Union Review423: 21-22.
27.
IDS
(1998) `Labour Flexibility OK - But We're Doing It Our Way', European Union Review434: 11-18.
28.
IRS
(1989) Termination of Contract in Europe. European Industrial Relations Review Report 1. London: IRS.
29.
IRS
(1992) Recruitment in Europe. European Industrial Relations Review Report 8. London: IRS.
30.
IRS
(1998) `Solving the Skills Crisis: An IRS Survey of Practice', Employee Development Bulletin99: 6-20.
31.
Janes, M.
and Roberts, B. (1990) `Labour Costs in 1988', Employment GazetteSeptember: 431-437.
32.
Keep, E.
and Mayhew, K. (1998) `Vocational Education and Training and Economic Performance', in T. Buxton, P. Chapman and P. Temple (eds) Britain's Economic Performance, pp. 367-395. London: Routledge.
33.
Keep, E.
and Rainbird, H. (1995) `Training', in P.K. Edwards (ed.) Industrial Relations, pp. 515-542. Oxford: Blackwell.
34.
Le Coeur, P.
(1998a) `Les entreprises peinent a trouver les 10,000 informaticiens dont elles ont besoin', Le Monde, 19 fevrier: 17.
35.
Le Coeur, P.
(1998b) `Le manque d'ingenieurs risque de freiner la croissance dans les semi-conducteurs', Le Monde, 2 mars: 14.
36.
Lyon-Caen, A.
(1993) `Workers' Protection and the Regulation of Labor Relations in France during the 1980s', in C. Buechtemann (ed.) Employment Security and Labor Market Behavior, pp. 347-357. Ithaca: ILR Press.
37.
Mehaut, P.
(1992) `Further Education, Vocational Training and the Labour Market: The French and German Systems Compared', in A. Castro, P. Mehaut and J. Rubery (eds) International Integration and Labour Market Organisation, pp. 162-174. London: Academic Press.
38.
Morin, M.-L.
, Amann, B., Dauty, F., Larre, F. and Teyssier, F. (1996) `Soustraitance et relations salariales', Les cahiersJuin 2, LIRHE/CNRS Toulouse.
39.
Mosley, H.
(1991) `Evaluation of Employment Protection Regulation: Policy Regimes of Employment Security in France, Germany, Italy and the United Kingdom', Report prepared for the Commission of the European Communities; cited in C. Buechtemann, ed. (1993) Employment Security and Labor Markets. Ithaca: ILR Press.
40.
Noble, C.
(1997) `International Comparisons of Training Policies', Human Resource Management Journal7(1): 5-18.
41.
O'Donnell, P.
(1997) `Skill Needs in Britain 1997', Labour Market TrendsDecember: 517-520.
42.
Ourtau, M.
(1998) `L'Apprentissage: Chiffres et Points de Vue D'Acteurs', Note278 (98-17) LIRHE/CNRS, Universite des Sciences Sociales Toulouse.
43.
Rainbird, H.
(1990) Training Matters. Oxford: Blackwell.
44.
Rainbird, H.
(1993) `Vocational Education and Training', in M. Gold (ed.) The Social Dimension, pp. 184-202. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
45.
Regini, M.
(1995) `Firms and Institutions: The Demand for Skills and their Social Production in Europe', European Journal of Industrial Relations1(2): 191-202.
46.
Robinson, P.
(1996) `Skill Shortages and Full Employment: How Serious a Constraint?', in J. Michie and J. Grieve Smith (eds) Creating Industrial Capacity, pp. 93-112. Oxford: OUP.
47.
SBAC (Society of British Aerospace Companies)
(1997) UK Aerospace Statistics 1997. London: SBAC.
48.
SBAC
(1998a) Annual Review 97-98. London: SBAC.
49.
SBAC
(1998b) People Management in Aerospace: Report Summary. London: SBAC.
50.
Shackleton, J.
, Clarke, L., Lange, T. and Walsh, S. (1995) Training for Employment in Western Europe and the United States. Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
51.
Skapinker, M.
(1996) `Aerospace Industry Sees 30,000 Job Cuts', Financial Times4 June: 7.
52.
Skapinker, M.
(1997) `Skills Shortage Forces BAe to Recruit Abroad', Financial Times11 March: 11.
53.
Skapinker, M.
(1998) `Aerospace Groups Back Merger', Financial Times28 March: 2.
54.
Streeck, W.
(1992) Social Institutions and Economic Performance. London: Sage.
55.
Streeck, W.
(1997) `German Capitalism: Does it Exist? Can it Survive?', in C. Crouch and W. Streeck (eds) Political Economy of Modern Capitalism, pp. 33-54. London: Sage.
