Strategic labour inspection in fissured workplaces and transnational employment relations: Lessons from co-enforcement approaches and transgovernmental cooperation

Abstract

This paper examines strategic enforcement approaches relying on co-enforcement and transgovernmentalist. It examines three cases in the construction industry in Austria, Asturias (Spain), and Poland, as well as three cases in maritime shipping in Finland, Spain, and Poland, focussing on Labour Inspection’s (LI)s motivations for engaging in co-enforcement and transnational cooperation. Data collection involved desk research, semi-structured interviews (39 construction and 14 in maritime), observation of inspections, and participant observation in EU seminars we organised together with regulatory actors (specific details are provided in the appendix). Findings show that LI’s selection of co-enforcement and transnational alliances are driven by the specific and highly contingent challenges each organisation faces. LI organisations are seeking to exploit synergies, but both the material reality and perception of these depends on diverse pre-existing infrastructures and organisation-specific assets.

Keywords

labour inspection co- enforcement transgovernmental cooperation fraudulent practices construction maritime shipping

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alho

(2013) Trade union responses to transnational labour mobility in the Finnish-Estonian context. Nordic Journal of Working Life Studies 3(3): 133–154.

Amengual

Fine

(2017) Co-enforcing Labor standards: the unique contributions of state and worker organizations in Argentina and the United States: Co-enforcing labor standards. Regulation & Governance 11(2): 129–142.

Arnholtz

Lillie

(eds) (2019) Posted Work in the European Union: The Political Economy of Free Movement. 1st edn. Routledge.

Arnholtz

Lillie

(2023) Posted work as an extreme case of hierarchised mobility. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 49(16): 4206–4223.

Astleithner

Flecker

(2017) From the golden age to the gilded cage? Austrian trade unions, social partnership and the crisis. In: Lehndorff

Dribbusch

Schulten

(eds) Rough Waters – European Trade Unions in a Time of Crisis, pp. 185–208. Brussels: ETUI.

Behling

Harvey

(2015) The evolution of false self-employment in the British construction industry: a neo-Polanyian account of labour market formation. Work, Employment & Society 29(6): 969–988.

Bernaciak

(2013) Social dialogue revival or “PR corporatism”? Negotiating anti-crisis measures in Poland and Bulgaria1. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 19(2): 239–251.

Čaněk

(2018) Transnational Cooperation Among Labour Regulation Enforcement Agencies in Europe: Challenges and Opportunities Related to the Posting of Workers.

Cremers

Houwerzijl

(2021) Subcontracting and social liability: report & policy recommendations. Brussels: ETUC. Available at: https://pure.uvt.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/57781729/Subcontracting_and_social_liability_EN.pdf.

10.

Czarzasty

Mrozowicki

(2022) ‘Unilateral crisis prevention and crumbling social partnership in Poland’, in Ebbinghaus

Weishaupt

(eds) The Role of Social Partners in Managing Europe’s Great Recession. London/New York: Routledge, pp. 121–143.

11.

De Baets

(2003) The labour inspection of Belgium, the United Kingdom and Sweden in a comparative perspective. International Journal of the Sociology of Law 31(1): 35–53.

12.

DG for Mobility and Transport (EC) (2020) Study on Social Aspects within the Maritime Transport Sector: Final Report. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Available at: https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2832/49520 (Accessed: 3 August 2023).

13.

EPSU (2012) Mapping Report on Labour Inspection Services in 15 European Countries. Brussels: European Federation of Public Service Unions (EPSU).

14.

Eurofound (2017) Fraudulent Contracting of Work: Construction Sector. Dublin: Eurofound. Available at: https://www.eurofound.europa.eu/sites/default/files/wpef17004.pdf.

15.

Fine

(2017) Enforcing labor standards in partnership with civil society: can Co-enforcement succeed where the state alone has failed? Politics & Society 45(3): 359–388.

16.

Fine

(2021) Strategic enforcement and co-enforcement of U.S. labor standards are needed to protect workers through the coronavirus recession. In: Strategic enforcement and co-enforcement of U.S. labor standards are needed to protect workers through the coronavirus recession. Available at: https://equitablegrowth.org/strategic-enforcement-and-co-enforcement-of-u-s-labor-standards-are-needed-to-protect-workers-through-the-coronavirus-recession/ (Accessed 11 October 2022).

17.

Geyer

Premrov

Danaj

(2022) Posted workers from and to Austria: characteristics, violations and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Leuven. Available at: https://www.euro.centre.org/downloads/detail/4317

18.

Graham

Walters

(2021) Representation of seafarers’ occupational safety and health: limits of the maritime labour convention. Economic and Labour Relations Review 32(2): 266–282.

19.

Graziano

(2017) Port state control inspections in the European Union: do inspector’s number and background matter? Marine Policy 88: 230–241.

20.

Graziano

Mejia

Hinrichs

S-

(2018) Achievements and challenges on the implementation of the European directive on port state control. Transport Policy 72: 97–108.

21.

Hardy

Howe

(2015) Chain reaction: a strategic approach to addressing employment noncompliance in complex supply chains. Journal of Industrial Relations 57(4): 563–584.

22.

Hartlapp

Heidbreder

(2018) Mending the hole in multilevel implementation: administrative cooperation related to worker mobility. Governance 31(1): 27–43.

23.

Huwiler

Mauron

(2019) Flankierende Massnahmen: 15 Jahre Lohnschutz. Die Volkswirtschaft, 43–46.

24.

Iannuzzi

Sacchetto

(2019) Italian labour inspectors facing posted workers phenomena. In: Arnholtz

Lillie

(eds) Posted Work in the European Union. Routledge, 109–127.

25.

Keohane

Nye

(1974) Transgovernmental relations and international organizations. World Politics 27(1): 39–62.

26.

Keune

Pedaci

(2020) Trade union strategies against precarious work: common trends and sectoral divergence in the EU. European Journal of Industrial Relations 26(2): 139–155.

27.

Lillie

(2006) A Global Union for Global Workers: Collective Bargaining and Regulatory Politics in Maritime Shipping. New York: Routledge.

28.

Lillie

(2010) Bringing the offshore ashore: transnational production, industrial relations and the reconfiguration of Sovereignty1. International Studies Quarterly 54(3): 683–704.

29.

Lillie

(2016) The right not to have rights: posted worker acquiescence and the European union labor rights framework. Theoretical Inquiries in Law 17(1): 39–62.

30.

Lipsky

(1980) Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. Russell Sage Foundation.

31.

Martínez Lucio

(2016) Incertidumbre, indecisión y neoliberalismo emergente: El papel dual y complejo del Estado español en las relaciones laborales y de empleo. Sociologia del Trabajo 87(2): 68–88.

32.

Meardi

Martín

Riera

(2012) Constructing uncertainty: unions and migrant labour in construction in Spain and the UK. Journal of Industrial Relations 54(1): 5–21.

33.

Ostrom

(1996) Crossing the great divide: coproduction, synergy, and development. World Development 24: 1073–1087.

34.

Państwowa Inspekcja Pracy (2021) On the National Labour Inspectorate’s Activity in 2020 - Abbreviated Version for the International Labour Organization. Warsaw. Państwowa Inspekcja Pracy.

35.

Pestoff

(2012) Co-Production and third sector social services in Europe: some concepts and evidence. Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 23(4): 1102–1118.

36.

Piñeiro

(2016) Port state jurisdiction over labour conditions: a private international law perspective on extra-territoriality. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 31(3): 531–551.

37.

Sanz de Miguel

(2021) Corporatismo y coproducción en la lucha contra el empleo irregular: un estudio de caso. Revista Española De Sociología 30(4): a77.

38.

Walters

(2016) Labour Inspection and Health and Safety in the EU. The European Trade Union Institute’s (ETUI) health and safety at work magazine, pp. 12–17.14

39.

Weil

(2014) The Fissured Workplace. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

40.

Weil

(2018) Creating a strategic enforcement approach to address wage theft: one academic’s journey in organizational change. Journal of Industrial Relations 60(3): 437–460.

41.

Wispelaere

Smedt

Pacolet

(2022) Posting of Workers. Collection of Data from the Prior Declaration Tools - Reference Year 2020. Brussels: European Commission - DG EMPL. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=738&langId=en&pubId=8536&furtherPubs=yes

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.38 MB