Is migration from Central and Eastern Europe an opportunity for trade unions to demand higher wages? Evidence from the Romanian health sector

Abstract

Industrial relations scholars have argued that east-west labour migration may benefit trade unions in Central and Eastern Europe. By focusing on the distributional aspect of wage policies adopted by two competing Romanian trade unions in the healthcare sector, this article challenges the assumption of a virtuous link between migration, labour shortages and collective wage increases. We show that migration may also displace collective and egalitarian wage policies in favour of individual and marketized ones that put workers in competition with one another. Thus, the question is not so much whether migration leads to wage increases in sending countries, but whether trade unions’ wage demands in response to outward migration consolidate collective solidarity and coordination in wage policy-making or support its individualization and commodification.

Keywords

Collective bargaining healthcare migration Romania trade unions wage distribution wage equality

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adascalitei

Munteanu

(2014) When striking works: The case of unions in the health care sector in Romania. In: Paper to the ECPR general conference, Glasgow, September. Available at: http://ecpr.eu/Filestore/PaperProposal/98aa14dc-bd69-44c9-9e44-d8522c5af795.pdf

Adevarul (2007) Asistentele cu diploma universitara si medicii buni iau calea Europei. Adevarul, 24 January. Available at: http://adevarul.ro/

Agerpres (2014) Guvernul creste salariile angajatilor din Sanatate. Ziare.com, 4 November. Available at: http://www.ziare.com/

Alexa

(2013) Sindicaliştii Sanitas Bucureşti, nemulţumiţi de negocierile cu Ministerul Sănătăţii. Mediafax, 21 October. Available at: http://www.mediafax.ro/

Amos News (2013) Membri ai Federatiei ‘Solidaritatea Sanitara’ protesteaza in strada. Amos News, 16 October. Available at: http://www.amosnews.ro/

Barbuceanu

(2014) 2013: Annual Review of Labour Relations and Social Dialogue in South East Europe: Romania. Belgrade: Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung. Available at: http://www.fessoe.de/english/annual-review-2013.html

Bohle

Greskovits

(2012) Capitalist Diversity on Europe’s Periphery. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Bourdieu

Waquant

Farage

(1994) Rethinking the state. Sociological Theory 12(1): 1–18.

Centrul de Cercetare si dezvoltare Sociala ‘Solidaritatea’ (CCDSS) (2014) Studii. Available at: http://cercetare-sociala.ro/index.php/studii-ghiduri/studii

10.

Chivu

(2011) Romania: Industrial relations in the health care sector. EIROnline. Available at: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/studies/tn1008022s/ro1008029q.htm

11.

Ciocan

(2013) Coalitia profesionistilor din sanatate. Sanitas VIII(2): 2.

12.

Ciutacu

(2013) Romania: Annual update on pay 2012. EIROnline, 11 July. Available at: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/studies/tn1303028s/ro1303029q.htm

13.

Colegiul Medicilor din Romania (CMR) (2014) Certificate CMR 2008–2013. Bucharest: CMR.

14.

Dulf

(2011) Noua lege a sănătăţii limitează accesul asiguraţilor la pachetul de servicii medicale. Mara Media, 18 November. Available at: http://maramedia.ro/

15.

Erne

(2008) European Unions. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

16.

Erne

(2015) A supranational regime that nationalizes social conflict. Labor History 56(3): 345–368.

17.

Flanders

(1970) Management and Unions: The Theory and Reform of Industrial Relations. London: Faber & Faber.

18.

Galan

Olsavszky

Vladescu

(2011) Emergent challenge of health professional emigration. In: Wismar

Maier

Glinos

Dussault

Figueras

(eds) Health Professionals Mobility and Health Systems. Brussels: European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, pp. 449–477.

19.

Greskovits

(2015) Ten years of enlargement and the forces of labour in Central and Eastern Europe. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 21(3): 269–284.

20.

Guvernul Romaniei (GR) (2009a) Ordonanta de urgenta priving ratificarea Aranjamentului stand-by dintre Romania si Fondul Monetar International (Monitorul Oficial al Romaniei, 629), 22 November. Available at: http://discutii.mfinante.ro/static/10/Mfp/pachet_acorduri/OUG99_2009.pdf

21.

Guvernul Romaniei (GR) (2009b) Ordonanță de urgență cu privire la rectificarea bugetară pe anul 2009 (Monitorul Oficial al Romaniei, 249), 14 April. Available at: http://www.cmdb.ro/impozit_forfetar.pdf

22.

Hardy

Fitzgerald

(2010) Negotiating ‘solidarity’ and internationalism. Industrial Relations Journal 41(4): 367–381.

23.

Hardy

Calveley

Kubisa

Shelley

(2014) Labour strategies, cross-border solidarity and the mobility of health workers. European Journal of Industrial Relations 20(1): 1–19.

24.

Hyman

(2007) How can trade unions act strategically? Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 13(2): 193–210.

25.

Infoinsider (2013) Corul sclavilor romani. Infoinsider, 2 November. Available at: http://infoinsider.ro/

26.

Institutul national de Statistica (INS) (2013) Anuarul Statistic 2013. Bucharest: INS.

27.

Institutul national de Statistica (INS) (2015) Comunicat de Presa (No. 9), 12 January. Available at: http://www.insse.ro/cms/files/statistici/comunicate/castiguri/a14/cs11r14.pdf

28.

Kahancová

(2015) Central and Eastern European trade unions after the EU enlargement: Successes and failures for capacity building. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 21(3): 343–358.

29.

Kahancová

Szabó

(2015) Hospital bargaining in the wake of management reforms. European Journal of Industrial Relations 21(1): 1–18.

30.

Kaminska

Kahancová

(2011) Emigration and labour shortages: An opportunity for trade unions in the New Member States? European Journal of Industrial Relations 17(2): 189–203.

31.

Lethbridge

(2011) Challenging privatisation and access to healthcare services. In: Bieler

Lindberg

(eds) Global Restructuring, Labor and the Challenges of Transnational Solidarity. London: Routledge, pp. 133–146.

32.

Lévesque

Murray

(2010) Understanding union power: Resources and capabilities for renewing union capacity. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 16(3): 333–350.

33.

Marginson

(2014) Coordinated bargaining in Europe: From incremental corrosion to frontal assault? European Journal of Industrial Relations 21(2): 97–114.

34.

Meardi

(2007) More voice after more exit? Industrial Relations Journal 38(6): 503–523.

35.

Meardi

(2012) Social Failures of EU Enlargement: A Case of Workers Voting with Their Feet. London: Routledge.

36.

Ministerul Muncii (MM) (2014) Contracte colective de munca. Available at: http://www.mmuncii.ro/j33/index.php/ro/dialog-social/info/protectie-sociala/dialog-social/953-contracte-colective-de-munca

37.

Ministerul Sanatatii (MS) (2014) Comunicat. MS, 3 September. Available at: http://www.ms.ro/index.php?pag=62&id=13400&pg=1

38.

Mosher

(2007) U.S. wage inequality, technological change, and decline in union power. Politics & Society 35(2): 225–264.

39.

Petre

(2013) Cateva comentarii si critici privid legislatia salarizarii personalului bugetar. Juridice, 20 June. Available at: http://www.juridice.ro/267090/cateva-comentarii-si-critici-privind-legislatia-salarizarii-personalului-bugetar.html

40.

Ragin

Zaret

(1983) Theory and method in comparative research: Two strategies. Social Forces 61(3): 731–754.

41.

rNews (2009) Sindicatele obtin reducerea coeficientilor de salarizare. Ziare.com, 30 August. Available at: http://www.ziare.com/

42.

Rotila

(2006) The quality of professional life of medical personnel and tendency of working abroad. Analele Universităţii Dunărea de Jos, Galaţi XX(1): 77–120.

43.

Rotila

(ed.) (2011) Calitatea vieții profesionale si tendința de migrație a personalului din sistemul sanitar. Galati: Solidalitas. Available at: http://www.cercetare-sociala.ro/index.php/studii-ghiduri/

44.

Rotila

(2013) Studiu privind sistemul de salarizare din sănătate în România. Galati: Solidaritas. Available at: http://www.cercetare-sociala.ro/st-gh/16/

45.

Sanitas (2009) Informare privind sedinta Consiliului National din 19.11.2009. Sanitas, Ziar Profesional si de Sindicat al Federatiei Sanitas IV(6): 1.

46.

Sassen

(1988) The Mobility of Labour and Capital. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

47.

Schulten

(2002) A European solidaristic wage policy? European Journal of Industrial Relations 8(2): 173–196.

48.

Stan

(2012) Neither commodities nor gifts: Post-socialist informal exchanges in the Romanian healthcare system. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 18(1): 65–82.

49.

Stan

(2015) Transnational healthcare practices of Romanian migrants in Ireland: Inequalities of access and the privatisation of healthcare services in Europe. Social Science & Medicine 124(1): 346–355.

50.

Stan

Erne

(2014) Explaining Romanian labor migration: From development gaps to development trajectories. Labor History 55(1): 21–46.

51.

Tempo Online (2014) Forta De Munca. INS. Available at: http://statistici.insse.ro/shop/index.jsp?page=tempo2&lang=ro&context=15 (accessed 26 May 2014).

52.

Timpolis (2009) Noua grila de salarizare, antidot la exodul medicilor. Timpolis, 25–28 June. Available at: http://timpolis.ro/

53.

Traxler

(2009) Representativeness of the European social partner organisations: Hospitals. Dublin: Eurofound. Available at: http://eurofound.europa.eu/sites/default/files/ef_files/docs/eiro/tn0802017s/tn0802017s.pdf

54.

Trif

(2008) Opportunities and challenges of EU accession. European Journal of Industrial Relations 14(2): 461–478.

55.

Trif

(2013) Romania collective bargaining institutions under attack. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 19(2): 227–237.

56.

Ursu

(2009) Gheorghe Pogea i-a convocat pe bugetari la negocieri. Ziare.com, 6 November. Available at: http://www.ziare.com/

57.

Varga

(2015) Trade unions and austerity in Central and Eastern Europe: Did they do something about it? Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 21(3): 313–326.

58.

Visser

(2013) ICTWSS database on institutional characteristics of trade unions, wage setting, state intervention and social pacts in 34 countries between 1960 and 2012. Available at: http://www.uva-aias.net/208

59.

World Health Organization (WHO) (2015) Romania: National expenditure on health (Romania Lei). Global Health Expenditure Database. Available at: http://apps.who.int/nha/database/

60.

Ziare.com (2009) Legea unica de salarizare: Guvernul taie 25 percent din coeficientii de ierarhizare. Ziare.com, 12 August. Available at: http://www.ziare.com/