Many scholars and policy-makers argue that advanced market economies are
converging towards a neoliberal labour market model with diluted labour
standards. However, others insist that `capitalism allows variety'. The primary
purpose of this article is to provide empirical evidence that supports the
latter position, by comparing legally mandated labour standards in Italy through
1979—2003 and by juxtaposing the results against OECD panel data
which allegedly show a decline in labour standards. This comparison suggests
that a more complex regulatory transformation occurred than is allowed for by
the OECD: indeed, labour standards for core workers in Italy were actually
strengthened. This discrepancy reflects the limited focus of the OECD data.
Allen, M.
(2004)
`The Varieties of Capitalism Paradigm: Not Enough Variety?'
, Socio-Economic Review2(1):
87-108.
2.
Baccaro, L.
(1999) `The Organizational Consequences of Democracy: Labor
Unions and Economic Reforms in Contemporary Italy', unpublished PhD
dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, Boston.
3.
Bellardi, L.
(1999) Concertazione e Contrattazione.
Bari:
Cacucci.
4.
Block, R.N.
and
Roberts, K.
(2000)
`A Comparison of Labour Standards in the United States and Canada'
, Relations Industrielles55(2):
273-307.
5.
Block, R.N.
,
Berg, P.
and
Roberts, K.
(2003a)
`Comparing and Quantifying Labour Standards in the United States and the
European Union'
, International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial
Relations19(4):
441-67.
6.
Block, R.N.
,
Roberts, K.
and
Clarke, R.O.
(2003b) Labour Standards in the United States and Canada
Kalamazoo. Michigan: W.E. Upjohn
Institute.
7.
Botero, J.C.
,
Djankov, S.
,
La Porta, R.
,
Lopez-De-Silanes, F.
and
Shleifer, A.
(2004)
`The Regulation of Labor'
, Quarterly Journal of Economics119(4):
1339-82.
8.
Boyer, R.
(1988) The Regulation School: A Critical Introduction .
New York: Columbia University
Press.
9.
Cella, G.P.
(1999) Il Sindacato.
Bari:
Laterza.
10.
Cinelli, M.
(1998) Diritto della Previdenza Sociale.
Torino:
Giappichelli.
11.
Crouch, C.
(2005)
`Models of Capitalism'
, New Political Economy10: 439-56.
12.
Downes, A.
,
Gomez, R.
and
Gunderson, M.
(2004)
`The Two-Way Interaction Between Globalization and Labour Market
Policies'
, Oxford Development Studies32(1):
135-52.
Ebbinghaus, B.
and
Kittel, B.
(2005)
`European Rigidity vs. American Flexibility? The Institutional Adaptability
of Collective Bargaining'
, Work and Occupations32(2):
163-95.
15.
Ferner, A.
and
Hyman, R.
(eds) (1998) Changing Industrial Relations in Europe,
2nd edn. Oxford:
Blackwell.
16.
Fox, A.
(1974) Beyond Contract: Work, Power and Trust Relations
. London:
Faber.
17.
Freeman, R.B.
(2005)
`Labour Market Institutions Without Blinders: The Debate Over Flexibility
and Labour Market Performance'
, International Economic Journal19(2):
129-45.
18.
Garofalo, M.
(2003) `La legge delega sul mercato del lavoro: Prime
osservazioni', paper to Fiom-CGIL,
Rome
.
19.
Grubb, D.
and
Wells, W.
(1993)
`Employment Regulation and Patterns of Work in EC Countries'
, OECD Economic Studies (21):
7-58.
20.
Hall, P.A.
and
Soskice, D.
(2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations
of Comparative Advantage. New York:
Oxford University Press.
21.
ILO
(1998) Declaration of Fundamental Principles and Rights at
Work. Geneva: International
Labour Office.
22.
ILO
(2004) Decent Work: Report of the Director-General.
Geneva:
ILO.
23.
Kapstein, E.B.
(1996)
`Workers and the World Economy'
, Foreign Affairs75(3):
16-37.
24.
Locke, M.R.
(1995) Remaking the Italian Economy: Policy Failures and
Local Successes in the Contemporary Polity. Ithaca,
NY : Cornell University
Press.
25.
Mascini, M.
(2000) Profitti e Salari.
Bologna:
Mulino.
26.
Michelotti, M.
(2003) `Changing Employment Protection Systems: The
Comparative Evolution of Labour Standards in Australia and Italy 1979 to
2000', unpublished PhD thesis, Monash
University, Melbourne,
Australia.
27.
Michelotti, M.
and
Nyland, C.
(2006)
`Measuring Regulatory Changes in Employment Protection Labour Standards in
Australia 1979 to 2000'
, International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial
Relations22(1):
39-80.
28.
Oecd
(1999) Employment Outlook .
Paris:
OECD.
29.
Oecd
(2004) Employment Outlook .
Paris:
OECD.
30.
Posner, R.A.
(1974)
`Theories of Economic Regulation'
, Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science5(2):
988-1011.
31.
Proia, G.
(2002)
`Flessibilità e tutela "nel" contratto di lavoro
subordinato'
, Giornale di Diritto del Lavoro e di Relazioni Industriali95(3):
411-61.
32.
Regini, M.
(2000)
`Between Regulation and Social Pacts: The Response of European Economies to
Globalization'
, Politics and Society28(1):
5-33.
33.
Royo, S.
(2006)
`Beyond Confrontation: The Resurgence of Social Bargaining in Spain in the
1990s'
, Comparative Political Studies39(8):
969-95.
34.
Salvanes, K.G.
(1997)
`Market Rigidities and Labor Market Flexibility: An International
Comparison'
, Scandinavian Journal of Economics99(2):
315-33.
35.
Speziale, V.
(2001)
`La nuova legge sul lavoro a termine'
, Giornale di Diritto del Lavoro e di Relazioni Industriali91(3):
361-415.
36.
Teubner, G.
(2001) `Legal Irritants: How Unifying Law Ends Up in New
Divergences', in
P.A. Hall
and
D. Soskice
(eds) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of
Comparative Advantage, pp. 417-41.
New York: Oxford University
Press.
37.
Thelen, K.
(2001) `Varieties of Labor Politics in the Developed
Democracies' , in
P.A. Hall
(ed.) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of
Comparative Advantage , pp. 71-104.
New York: Oxford University
Press.
38.
Tiraboschi, M.
(2005)
`The Italian Labour Market After the Biagi Reform'
, International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial
Relations21(2):
149-92.
39.
Webb, S.
and
Webb, B.
(1897) Industrial Democracy.
London :
Longmans.
40.
Williamson, O.
(1985) Markets and Hierarchies. New
York: Free Press.
