■ This article examines recent developments in social dialogue over
vocational training and lifelong learning. The central concern is how to develop
coherent European polices for increasing social partner influence in this
domain, given the diversity of national systems of VET and structures of social
dialogue across Europe. The study draws on a survey of 13 countries and
concludes that despite these disparities, cross-national differences in social
partner involvement are less than might be anticipated. Initiatives like the
social partners' Framework of Actions are seen as pressures promoting
convergence, but this is likely to occur paradoxically as a result of increasing
diversity within member states.
Ashton, D.
,
Sung, J.
and
Turbin, J.
(2000) `
Towards a Framework for the Comparative Analysis of National Systems of
Skill Formation
', International Journal of Training and Development4(1):
8—25
.
2.
Bridgford, J.
,
Košt'al, M.
,
Martinek, D.
,
Simeonova, Y.
and
Zabiega, J.
(2003) `
Trade Union Education in Central and Eastern Europe
', Transfer6(3):
486—97
.
3.
Calloids, F.
(1994) `
Converging Trends Amidst Diversity in Vocational Training Systems
', International Labour Review133(2):
241—60
.
4.
Campinos-Dubernet, M.
and
Grando, J.-M.
(1988) `
Formation professionelle ouvrière: trois modèles Européens
', Formation/Emploi22:
5—29
.
5.
Claydon, T.
and
Green, F.
(1992) `The Effect of Unions on Training Provision',
Department of Economics Working Paper 92/3,
University of Leicester
.
6.
Crouch, C.
,
Finegold, D.
and
Sako, M.
(1999) Are Skills the Answer? The Political Economy of Skills
Creation in Advanced Industrial Countries.
Oxford : Oxford University Press
.
7.
de Boer, R.
,
Benedictus, H.
and
van der Meer, M.
(2005) `
Broadening without Intensification: The Added Value of the European Social
and Sector Dialogue
', European Journal of Industrial Relations11(1):
51—70
.
8.
DfEE
(1998) The Learning Age.
London: Stationery Office
.
9.
Draus, F.
(2000) Social Dialogue in the European Candidate Countries:
Overview.
Brussels: ETUC
.
10.
Ec/Unice/Ceep/Etuc
(1996) Compendium: Vocational Training —
Innovation and Diversity in Dialogue Practices between Social Partners.
Luxembourg: European Commission
.
11.
EC
(2002) `
The European Social Dialogue: A Force for Innovation and Change
', Communication COM(2002)
314
, 26 June,
Brussels
.
12.
EC
(2003) The Sectoral Social Dialogue.
Brussels: DG Employment and Social Affairs
,
European Commission
.
13.
EC
(2004) `
Partnership for Change in an Enlarged Europe: Enhancing the Contribution of
the European Social Dialogue
', Communication, COM(2004)
557
, 12 August,
Brussels
.
14.
Estevez-Abe, M.
,
Iversen, T.
and
Soskice, D.
(2001) `Social Protection and the Formation of Skills: A
Reinterpretation of the Welfare State', in
P.A. Hall
and
D. Soskice
(eds) Varieties of Capitalism: the Institutional Foundations of
Comparative Advantage , pp. 145—83.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
15.
Etuc, Unice/Ueapme
and
Ceep
(2002) Framework of Actions for the Lifelong Development of
Competencies and Qualifications, 28 February.
Brussels: ETUC, UNICE/UEAPME and CEEP
.
16.
Finegold, D.
and
Soskice, D.
(1988) `
The Failure of Training in Britain: Analysis and Prescription
', Oxford Review of Economic Policy4(3):
21—53
.
17.
Ghelleb, Y.
and
Vaughan-Whitehead, D.
(eds) (2003) Sectoral Social Dialogue in Future EU Member
States: The Weakest Link.
Budapest: International Labour Office
.
18.
Goetschy, J.
(2005) `
The European Social Dialogue in the 1990s: Institutional Innovations and
New Paradigms
', Transfer11(3):
409—22
.
19.
Green, F.
,
Machin, S.
and
Wilkinson, D.
(1999) `
Trade Unions and Training Practices in British Workplaces
', Industrial and Labor Relations Review52(2):
179—96
.
20.
Halvorsen, H.
(1998) `
Role of Social Partners in the Development of Training
', Role of Social Partners in Establishment and Management of a
Continuing Training System and the Financing of Vocational Education and
Training, ETF Seminar, Bucharest, 2—3 October.
21.
Heidemann, W.
(2002) `Lifelong Learning: Current Developments within Social
Dialogue in Selected European Countries',
Hans Böckler Stiftung, Düsseldorf (mimeo)
.
22.
Heidemann, W.
,
Kruse, W.
,
Paul-Kohlhoff, A.
and
Zeuner, C.
(1994) Social Dialogue and Further Education and Training in
Europe: New Challenges for the Trade Unions.
Berlin : Hans Böckler Stiftung
.
23.
Heyes, J.
and
Stuart, M.
(1998) `
Bargaining for Skills: Trade Unions and Training at the Workplace
', British Journal of Industrial Relations36(3):
459—67
.
24.
Infelise, L.
(1996) `Continuing Vocational Training in Italy', in
J. Brandsma
,
F. Kessler
and
J. Münch
(eds) Continuing Vocational Training: Europe, Japan and the United
States , pp. 173—87.
Utrecht: Lemma
.
25.
Jobert, A.
(1997) `Employment, Education and Training in Italy',
in
A. Jobert
,
C. Marry
,
L. Tanguy
and
H. Rainbird
(eds) Education and Work in Great Britain, Germany and Italy, pp.
208—23.
London: Routledge
.
26.
Keller, B.
(2005) `
Europeanisation at Sectoral Level. Empirical Results and Missing Perspectives
', Transfer11(3):
397—408
.
27.
Kerckhofs, P.
and
André, M.-H.
(2003) `European Social Dialogue on Lifelong Learning
', in
E. Gabaglio
and
R. Hoffman
(eds) European Trade Union Yearbook2002, pp. 127—50,
Brussels: European Trade Union Institute
.
28.
Ladó, M.
and
Vaughan-Whitehead, D.
(2003) `
Social Dialogue in Candidate Countries: What For?
', Transfer9(1):
64—87
.
29.
Lane, C.
(1989) Management and Labour in Europe: The Industrial
Enterprise in Germany, Britain and France.
Aldershot
:
Edward Elgar
.
30.
Leisink, P.
(2002) `
The European Sectoral Social Dialogue and the Graphical Industry
', European Journal of Industrial Relations8(1):
101—17
.
31.
Marry, C.
(1997) `Education, Vocational Training and Employment in
Germany', in
A. Jobert
,
C. Marry
,
L. Tanguy
and
H. Rainbird
(eds) Education and Work in Great Britain, Germany and Italy, pp.
13—29.
London: Routledge
.
32.
Meghnagi, S.
(1997) `Connections between Collective Bargaining, Job
Training and Educational Research in Italy', in
A. Jobert
,
C. Marry
,
L. Tanguy
and
H. Rainbird
(eds) Education and Work in Great Britain, Germany and Italy, pp.
253—68.
London: Routledge
.
33.
Méhaut, P.
(1992) `Further Education, Vocational Training and the Labour
Market: The French and German Systems Compared', in
A. Castro
,
P. Méhaut
and
J. Rubery
(eds) International Integration and Labour Market Organisation,
pp. 162—74.
London : Academic Press
.
34.
Rainbird, H.
(1990) Training Matters: Union Perspectives on Industrial
Restructuring and Training.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
35.
Rainbird, H.
(ed.) (2000) Training in the Workplace.
Basingstoke, Macmillan
.
36.
Regini, M.
(2003) `
Tripartite Concertation and Varieties of Capitalism
', European Journal of Industrial Relations9(3):
251—63
.
37.
SZW (Ministerie van Sociale Zaken en Werkgelegenheid)
(2001) Najaarsrapportage CAO-afspraken.
Den Haag: SZW
.
38.
Traxler, F.
(2003) `
Bargaining, State Regulation and the Trajectories of Industrial Relations
', European Journal of Industrial Relations9(2):
141—61
.
39.
Traxler, F.
,
Blaschke, S.
and
Kittel, B.
(2001) National Labour Relations in Internationalized
Markets.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
40.
Tuc
(1998) Union Gateways to Learning: TUC Learning Service
Report.
London: Trades Union Congress
.
41.
Vind, A.
,
Delamare Le Deist, F.
,
Heidemann, W.
and
Winterton, J.
(2004) European Trade Union Policies on Lifelong
Learning .
Copenhagen: Landsorganisationen i Danmark
.
42.
Visser, J.
and
Hemerijck, A.
(1997) `A Dutch Miracle': Job Growth, Welfare Reform and
Corporatism in the Netherlands.
Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press
.
43.
Wallis, E.
,
Stuart, M.
and
Greenwood, I.
(2005) `
“Learners of the Workplace Unite!” An Empirical
Examination of the Trade Union Learning Representative Initiative
', Work, Employment and Society19(2):
283—304
.
44.
Winterton, J.
(2000) `
Social Dialogue Over Vocational Training in Market-led Systems
', International Journal of Training and Development4(1):
8—23
.
45.
Winterton, J.
(2003) Social Dialogue and Vocational Training in the EU:
Analysis of a CEDEFOP Survey.
Thessaloniki: CEDEFOP
.
46.
Winterton, J.
and
Strandberg, T.
(2004) `European Social Dialogue: An Evaluation and Critical
Assessment', in
B. Galgóczi
,
C. Lafoucriere
and
L. Magnusson
(eds) The Enlargement of Social Europe: The Role of the Social Partners
in the European Employment Strategy, pp.
21—75.
Brussels: ETUI/SALTSA/CREER
.
47.
Winterton, J.
and
Winterton, R.
(1994) Collective Bargaining and Consultation over Continuing
Vocational Training, RM.7.
Sheffield: Employment Department
.
