Control and safety aspects of medical robots for treatment of diseases of the prostate

Abstract

There has been much advancement in the field of minimally invasive surgery in recent years. Medical robots play an important role in these improvements. Surgeons are fast accepting the aid of robots in laparoscopic, thorascopic, endoluminal and arthroscopic interventions, to name just a few. This paper reviews the state-of-the-art of medical robots that have been and are being developed for the purpose of treating diseases of the prostate. The main objective of these robots is to manoeuvre accurately a surgical tool via the transrectal or transurethral route to perform a surgical procedure on the prostate based on ultrasound guidance. The system approaches and control methodologies of these robots are highlighted. However, the main emphasis is on the safety aspects, both hardware and software, which are discussed in detail. Many of these safety features have been incorporated in the mentioned medical robots to enhance their reliability and safety.

Keywords

medical robotics prostate control safety image-guided surgery minimally invasive surgery

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Tendick

Sastry

S. S.

Fearing

R. S.

Cohn

Applications of micro-mechatronics in minimally invasive surgery. IEEE-ASME Trans. Mechatronics, 1998, 3 (1), 34–42.

Dario

Guglielmelli

Allotta

Carrozza

M. C.

Robotics for medical applications. IEEE Robotics Autom. Mag., 1996, 3 (3), 44–56.

Dario

Guglielmelli

Allotta

Carrozza

M. C.

Micromechatronics in medicine. IEEE-ASME Trans. Mechatronics, 1996, 1 (2), 137–148.

Taylor

Lavallee

Burdea

G. C.

Mosges

E. R.

Computer Integrated Surgery Technology and Clinical Applications, 1996 (MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts).

Computer Motion Inc., World's first closed-chest beating bypass surgery successfully performed. 1999.

Computer Motion Inc., World's first closed-chest cardiac hybrid revascularization procedure. 1999.

Computer Motion Inc. World's first baby born following robotically assisted surgery. 1999.

Intuitive Surgical Inc. 2002.

Gould

A guide to the management of prostate cancer. The Massachusetts Prostate Cancer Research Institute.

10.

Lepor

Rigaud

The efficacy of transurethral resection of the prostate in men with moderate symptoms of prostatism. J. Urol., 1990, 143, 533–537.

11.

Malenka

D. J.

Roos

Fisher

E. S.

Further study of the increased mortality following transurethral prostatectomy: A chart-based analysis. J. Urol., 1990, 144, 224–227.

12.

Uchida

Adachi

Clinical analysis in 2266 cases of transurethral resection of the prostate. Jap. J. Urol., 1993, 84, 890–896.

13.

Thorpe

A. C.

Cleary

Coles

Vernon

Reynolds

Neal

D. E.

Deaths and complications following prostatectomy in the northern region of England. Br. J. Urol., 1994, 74, 559–565.

14.

Wasson

J. H.

Reda

D. J.

Bruskewitz

R. C.

Elinson

Keller

A.M.

Henderson

W. G.

A comparison of transurethral surgery with watchful waiting for moderate symptoms of benign prostatic hyperplasia. N. Engl. J. Med., 1995, 332, 75–79.

15.

Arai

Ishitoya

Okubo

Suzuki

Transurethral interstitial laser coagulation for benign prostatic hyperplasia: Treatment outcome and quality of life. Br. J. Urol., 1996, 77, 93–98.

16.

Costello

A. J.

Kabalin

J. N.

Side-firing neodymium:YAG laser prostatectomy. Eur. Urol., 1999, 35, 138–146.

17.

Duc

A. L.

Gilling

P. J.

Holmium laser resection of the prostate. Eur. Urol., 1999, 35, 155–160.

18.

Van Swol

Van Venrooij

Eckhardt

M. D.

Grimbergen

M. C. M.

Verdaasdonk

R. M.

Boon

T. A.

Laser-and electrosurgery as a treatment modality of BPH: A urodynamic evaluation of 7 different techniques in 280 patients. Proc. SPIE, 1999, 3590, 185–192.

19.

Tuhkanen

Heino

Ala-Opas

Contact laser prostatectomy compared to TURP in Prostatic Hyperplasia smaller than 40 ml. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol., 1999, 33, 31–34.

20.

Muschter

De La Rosette

J. J.M.C.D.

Whitfield

Pellerin

Madersbacher

Gillatt

Initial human clinical experience with diode laser interstitial treatment of benign prostatic hyperplasia. Urology, 1996, 48, 223–228.

21.

Williams

J. C.

Interstitial laser coagulation of the prostate: Introduction of a volume-based treatment formula with 12-month follow-up. World J. Urol., 1998, 16, 392–395.

22.

Davies

B. L.

Hilbert

R. D.

Coptcoat

M. J.

Wickham

J. E. A.

A surgeon robot prostectomy—a laboratory evaluation. J. Med. Engng Technol., 1989, 13 (6), 273–277.

23.

Davies

B. L.

Safety of medical robots. In Safety of Software Book, Spring 1993, Ch. 3 (Software Safety Club, Department of Trade and Industry).

24.

Davies

B. L.

Hilbert

R. D.

Timoney

A. G.

Wickham

J. E. A.

A surgeon robot for prostatectomies. In Proceedings of the 2nd Workshop on Medical and Healthcare Robots, Newcastle, September 1989, pp. 91–101.

25.

Davies

Ng. W. S.

Hilbert

B. L.R. D.

Timoney

A. G.

A firsthand experience in transurethral resection of the prostate. IEEE, EMBS J., March 1993, 120–125.

26.

27.

Shee

C. Y.

Development of robotics interstitial laser therapy for benign prostatic hyperplasia. MEng thesis, School of Mechanical and Production Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, 1999.

28.

CALRP—computer-assisted laser resection of the prostate. MEng thesis, School of Mechanical and Production Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, 2000.

29.

Gelet

Chapelon

J. Y.

High intensity focused ultrasound experimentation on human benign prostatic hypertrophy. Eur. J. Urol., 1993, 23, 44–47.

30.

Gelet

Chapelon

J. Y.

Margonari

Prostatic tissue destruction by high intensity focused ultrasound; experimentation on canine prostate. J. Endourol., 1993, 7, 249–253.

31.

Gelet

Chapelon

J. Y.

Bouvier

Treatment of localized prostatic cancer by transrectal route: Preliminary results. EAU Congress, Abstracts, 1994, p. 267.

32.

W. S.

Tan

C. K.

On safety enhancements for medical robots. Reliability Engng System Safety, 1996, 54, 35–45.

33.

Davies

B. L.

Hibberd

R. D.

Fan

K. L.

Jakopec

Harris

S. J.

Synergistic robots in surgery—surgeons and robots working co-operatively. In Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Experimental Robotics (ISER ‘97), June 1997, pp. 395–403.

34.

Davies

B. L.

Lin

W. J.

Hibberd

R. D.

Cobb

J. C.

Active compliance in robotic surgery—the use of force control as a dynamic constraint. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine, 1997, 211 (H4), 285–292.

35.

Dijkstra

E. W.

Why correctness must be a mathematical concern? In The Correctness Problem in Computer Science (Eds Boyer

R. S.

Moore

J. S.

), 1981, pp. 1–8 (Academic Press, London).

36.

Hoare

C. A. R.

An anxiomatic basis for computer programming. Commun. ACM, 1989, 12, 576–580, 583.

37.

Avizienis

The N-version approach to fault tolerant software. IEEE Trans. Software Engng, 1985, SE11, 1491–1501.

38.

Wika

K. G.

Knight

J. C.

Software safety in a medical application. In Proceedings of the 1st Symposium on Medical Robotics and Computer Assisted Surgery, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 22–24 September 1994, pp. 218–223.

39.

Rendell

System structure for software fault tolerance. IEEE Trans. Software Engng, 1975, SE1, 220–232.

40.

Anderson

Lee

P. A.

Fault tolerance. Principles and Practice, 1981, pp. 3–5 (Prentice-Hall, London).

41.

Wei

W. S.

Kwoh

C. K.

The hazard identification and safety insurance control for medical robot. In Proceedings of the 22nd Annual EMBS International Conference, July 2000, pp. 3022–3026.