Marxism,psychoanalysis,and the critique of psychological dualism: From dualist repression to the return of the repressed in hysteria and class consciousness
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2018
Marxism,psychoanalysis,and the critique of psychological dualism: From dualist repression to the return of the repressed in hysteria and class consciousness
This article discusses how the psychic reality is separated from everything else in modern psychology and argues that this separation may be related to capitalism. It also explores how Marx and Freud, as well as later Marxists and Marxist Freudians, have critically examined the psyche/world and psyche/soma dichotomies. Their critique uncovered a kind of groundless dualism, which was denounced as a way of exerting power over the body and world, as a consequence of the manual/intellectual division of labour, and as the dematerialization of subjectivity by repressing and sublimating-idealizing processes. These denunciations make it possible to appreciate how Marxism and psychoanalysis—by arousing class consciousness among the labourers and by making the unconscious conscious in hysteria—allowed symptomatic disclosures of the truth of monism in the faults of a psychological dualistic knowledge.
AdlerA. (1979). De la psychologie du marxisme [From the psychology of Marxism]. In NunbergH.FedernE. (Eds.), Minutes de la Société Psychanalytique de Vienne II [Minutes from the psychological society of Vienna II] (pp. 171–172). Paris, France: Gallimard. (Original work published 1909)
2.
AdornoT. W. (1986). Postscriptum [Postscript]. In JensenH. (Ed.), Teoría crítica del sujeto [Critical theory of the subject] (pp. 77–83). Mexico City, México: Siglo XXI. (Original work published 1966)
3.
AlthusserL. (1996a). La place de la psychanalyse dans les sciences sociales [Psychoanalysis’ place in the social sciences]. In Psychanalyse et sciences humaines [Psychoanalysis and human sciences] (pp. 17–72). Paris, France: Livre de Poche. (Original work published 1963)
4.
AlthusserL. (1996b). Psychanalyse et psychologie [Psychoanalysis and psychology]. In Psychanalyse et sciences humaines [Psychoanalysis and human sciences] (pp. 73–122). Paris, France: Livre de Poche. (Original work published 1964)
5.
AlthusserL. (1998). Lénine et la philosophie [Lenin and philosophy]. In Solitude de Machiavel et autres textes [Solitude of Machiavelli and other texts] (pp. 103–144). Paris, France: PUF. (Original work published 1968)
6.
AlthusserL. (2005). Pour Marx [For Marx]. Paris, France: La Découverte. (Original work published 1964)
7.
AndradeO. de (1981). La crisis de la filosofía mesiánica [The crisis of messianic philosophy]. In Obra escogida [Selected work] (pp. 175–230). Caracas, Venezuela: Ayacucho. (Original work published 1950)
8.
AndradeO. de (2006). Manifiesto antropófago [Man-eating manifesto]. In SchwartzJ. (Ed.), Las vanguardias latinoamericanas [Latin-American avant gardes] (pp. 171–180). Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1928)
9.
AudardJ. (1989). Du caractère matérialiste de la psychanalyse [On the material character of psychoanalysis]. Littoral, 27/28, 199–208. (Original work published 1933)
10.
AxelosK. (1980). Marx, Freud y las tareas del pensamiento futuro [Marx, Freud, and the tasks of future thinking]. In Horizontes del mundo [Horizons of the world] (pp. 94–110). Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1970)
11.
BadiouA. (1982). Théorie du sujet [Theory of the subject]. Paris, France: Seuil.
12.
BadiouA. (2007). Being and event. London, UK: Continuum. (Original work published 1988)
13.
BadiouA. (2009). L’hypothèse communiste [The communist hypothesis]. Paris, France: Lignes.
14.
BadiouA. (2012). De l’idéologie [Of ideology]. In Les années rouges [The red years] (pp. 99–200). Paris, France: Les prairies ordinaires. (Original work published 1976)
15.
BekhterevV. (1933). General principles of human reflexology. London, UK: Jarrolds. (Original work published 1917)
16.
BernfeldS. (1972). Socialismo y psicoanálisis [Socialism and psychoanalysis]. In GenteH.-P. (Ed.), Marxismo, psicoanálisis y SEXPOL [Marxism, psychoanalysis and SEXPOL] (pp. 15–37). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Granica. (Original work published 1926)
17.
BraunsteinN.PasternacM.BeneditoG.SaalF. (2006). Psicología: ideología y ciencia [Psychology: Ideology and science]. Mexico City, México: Siglo XXI. (Original work published 1975)
18.
BretonA. (1955). Les vases communicants [Communicating vessels]. Paris, France: Gallimard. (Original work published 1932)
19.
CassirerE. (1993). Filosofía de la ilustración [Philosophy of enlightenment]. Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1932)
20.
ChalmersD. (1996). The conscious mind: In search of a fundamental theory. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
21.
CrevelR. (1966). Le clavecin de Diderot [Diderot’s harpsichord]. Utrecht, the Netherlands: Pauvert. (Original work published 1932)
22.
DescartesR. (2014). Méditations métaphysiques. Édition bilingue [Metaphysical meditations. Bilingual edition]. Paris, France: Flammarion. (Original work published 1637)
23.
De VosJ. (2016). Metamorphoses of the brain: Neurologisation and its discontents. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
24.
EngelsF. (1980). La situación de la clase obrera en Inglaterra [Condition of the working class in England]. Moscow, Russia: Progreso. (Original work published 1845)
25.
EngelsF. (1986a). El papel del trabajo en el proceso de transformación del mono en hombre [The role played by labor in the transition from ape to man]. In Obras filosóficas [Philosophical works] (pp. 412–422). Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1876)
26.
EngelsF. (1986b). La subversión de la ciencia por el señor Eugen Dühring [Subversion of science by Mr. Eugen Dühring]. In Obras filosóficas [Philosophical works] (pp. 1–284). Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1878)
27.
FenichelO. (1972). Sobre el psicoanálisis como embrión de una futura psicología dialéctico materialista [Psychoanalysis as the nucleus of a future dialectical-materialistic psychology]. In GenteJ.-P. (Ed.), Marxismo, psicoanálisis y sexpol I [Marxism, psychoanalysis, and SEXPOL] (pp. 160–183). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Granica. (Original work published 1934)
28.
FreudS. (1998a). El malestar en la cultura [Civilization and its discontents]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. XXI [The complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud: Vol. XXI] (pp. 57–140). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1930)
29.
FreudS. (1998b). El porvenir de una ilusión [The future of an illusion]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. XXI [The complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud: Vol. XXI] (pp. 1–56). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1927)
30.
FreudS. (1998c). El yo y el ello [The ego and the id]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. XIX [The complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud: Vol XIX] (pp. 1–66). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1923)
31.
FreudS. (1998d). Introducción del narcisismo [Introduction to narcissism]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. XIV [The complete psychological works of Sigmud Freud: Vol. XIV] (pp. 65–98). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1914)
32.
FreudS. (1998e). La moral sexual cultural y la nerviosidad moderna [“Civilized” sexual morality and modern nervous illness]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. IX [The complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud: Vol. IX] (pp. 159–182). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1908)
33.
FreudS. (1998f). Psicología de las masas y análisis del yo [Mass psychology and ego analysis]. In StracheyJ. (Ed.) & EtcheverryJ. L. (Trans.), Obras completas: Vol. XVIII [The complete psychological Works of Sigmund Freud: Vol. XVIII] (pp. 63–136). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Amorrortu. (Original work published 1921)
34.
FrommE. (1991). The theory of mother right and its relevance for social psychology. In The crisis of psychoanalysis (pp. 109–136). New York, NY: Owl Book. (Original work published 1934)
35.
FroshS. (2003). Psychosocial studies and psychology: Is a critical approach emerging?Human Relations, 56(12), 1545–1567.
GabelJ. (1962). La fausse conscience [False conscience]. Paris, France: Minuit.
38.
GramsciA. (1986a). Cuadernos de la cárcel. Tomo 3 [Prison notebooks. Book 3]. Mexico City, México: Era. (Original work published 1932)
39.
GramsciA. (1986b). Cuadernos de la cárcel. Tomo 5 [Prison notebooks: Book 5]. Mexico City, México: Era. (Original work published 1935)
40.
HerbertT. (1966). Réflexions sur la situation théorique des sciences sociales et, spécialement, de la psychologie sociale [Reflections on the theoretical situation of the social sciences and social psychology in particular]. Cahiers Pour l’Analyse, 2, 137–165.
41.
HoggettP. (2008). What’s in a hyphen? Reconstructing psychosocial studies. Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society, 13(4), 379–384.
42.
HorkheimerM. (2007). Crítica de la razón instrumental [Critique of pure reason]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Terramar. (Original work published 1946)
43.
JacobyR. (1983). The repression of psychoanalysis: Otto Fenichel and the political Freudians. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
44.
JonesE. (1925). Mother-right and the sexual ignorance of savages. International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 6, 109–130.
45.
KornilovK. N. (1930). Psychology in the light of dialectic materialism. In MurchisonC. (Ed.), Psychologies of 1930 (pp. 243–278). Worcester, MA: Clark University Press.
46.
KorschK. (1977). Marxismo y filosofía [Marxism and philosophy]. Mexico City, México: Era. (Original work published 1923)
47.
LacanJ. (1969). Conversación con Jacques Lacan [Conversations with Jacques Lacan]. In CarusoP. (Ed.), Conversaciones con Lévi-Strauss, Foucault y Lacan [Conversations with Lévi-Strauss, Foucault and Lacan] (pp. 95–124). Barcelona, Spain: Anagrama. (Original work published 1966)
48.
LacanJ. (1986). Le séminaire. Livre VII. L’éthique de la psychanalyse [Seminars : Book VII. Ethics and psychoanalysis]. Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1960)
49.
LacanJ. (1991a). Le séminaire. Livre VIII. Le transfert [Seminars : Book VIII. Transference]. Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1961)
50.
LacanJ. (1991b). Le séminaire: Livre XVII. L’envers de la psychanalyse [Seminars: Book XVII. The reverse of psychoanalysis]. Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1970)
51.
LacanJ. (1998). Le séminaire: Livre I. Les écrits techniques de Freud [Seminars: Book I. Freud’s technical writings]. Paris, France: Seuil (poche). (Original work published 1954)
52.
LacanJ. (1999a). Fonction et champ de la parole et du langage en psychanalyse [Function and field of speech and language in psychoanalysis]. In Écrits I [Writings: Vol. I] (pp. 235–321). Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1953)
53.
LacanJ. (1999b). Subversion du sujet et dialectique du désir [Subversion of the subject and dialectics of desire]. In Écrits II [Writings: Vol. II] (pp. 273–308). Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1960)
54.
LacanJ. (2004). Le séminaire: Livre X. L’angoisse [Seminars: Book X. Agony]. Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1963)
55.
LacanJ. (2006). Le séminaire: Livre XVI. D’un Autre à l’autre [Seminars: Book XVI. From one to the other]. Paris, France: Seuil. (Original work published 1969)
56.
LeibnizG. W. (1995). Monadologie [Monadology]. Paris, France: Gallimard. (Original work published 1720)
57.
LeninV. (1974a). Cuadernos Filosóficos. Obras Completas: Tomo XLII [Philosophical notebooks. Complete works: Vol. XLII]. Madrid, Spain: Akal/Ayuso. (Original work published 1916)
58.
LeninV. (1974b). El Estado y la Revolución [State and revolution]. In Obras escogidas [Selected works] (pp. 272–365). Moscow, Russia: Progreso. (Original work published 1920)
59.
LeontievA. N. (1984). Actividad, consciência y personalidad [Activity, consciousness and personality]. Mexico City, México: Cartago. (Original work published 1978)
60.
LukácsG. (1985). Historia y conciencia de clase [History and class consciousness]. Madrid, Spain: Sarpe. (Original work published 1923)
61.
LuriaA. R. (2002). Psychoanalysis as a system of monistic psychology. Journal of Russian and East European Psychology, 40(1), 26–53. (Original work published 1925)
62.
LuxemburgR. (1978). ¿Qué se propone la Liga Espartaco? [What does the Spartacus league want?] In Obras escogidas [Selected works] (pp. 151–156). Madrid, Spain: Ayuso. (Original work published 1918)
63.
MalinowskiB. (2001). La sexualité et sa répression dans les sociétés primitives [Sexuality and repression in primitive societies]. Paris, France: Payot. (Original work published 1927)
64.
MarcuseH. (2010). El hombre unidimensional [One dimensional man]. Barcelona, Spain: Planeta. (Original work published 1964)
65.
MarxK. (1980). Capital y tecnología. Manuscritos inéditos (1861–1863) [Capital and technology: Unpublished manuscripts]. Mexico City, México: Terra Nova. (Original work published 1863)
66.
MarxK. (1982). Sobre la cuestión judía [The Jewish question]. In Escritos de juventud [Writings of the young Marx] (pp. 463–490). Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1843)
67.
MarxK. (1997). Manuscritos: Economía y filosofía [Manuscripts: Economy and philosophy]. Madrid, Spain: Alianza. (Original work published 1844)
68.
MarxK. (2008). El Capital I [The capital: I]. Mexico City, México: FCE. (Original work published 1867)
69.
MarxK. (2009a). El Capital. Libro I. Capítulo VI (inédito). Resultados del proceso inmediato de producción [The capital: Book 1. Chapter VI (unpublished). Results of the immediate production process]. Mexico City, México: Siglo XXI. (Original work published 1866)
70.
MarxK. (2009b). Elementos fundamentales para la crítica de la economía política (Grundrisse) 1857–1858 [Outlines of the critique of political economy]. Mexico City, México: Siglo XXI. (Original work published 1858)
71.
MarxK.EngelsF. (2014). La ideología alemana [German ideology]. Madrid, Spain: Akal. (Original work published 1846)
72.
MeyersonI. (1948). Les fonctions psychologiques et les oeuvres [Psychological functions and works]. Paris, France: Vrin.
73.
PannekoekA. (1973). Lenin filósofo [Lenin, philosopher]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Pasado y Presente. (Original work published 1938)
74.
ParkerI. (1997). Psychoanalytic culture: Psychoanalytic discourse in Western society. London, UK: Sage.
75.
ParkerI. (2007). Revolution in psychology: Alienation to emancipation. London, UK: Pluto.
76.
Pavón-CuéllarD. (2014). Narcisismo, ideología y psicología [Narcissism, ideology and psychology]. In EspinosaA.Levi HambraA.CapetilloJ. (Eds.), A cien años de “Introducción del narcisismo” [One hundred years of “Introduction to Narcissism”] (pp. 225–262). Xalapa, México: Universidad Veracruzana.
77.
Pavón-CuéllarD. (2016). Marx’s destruction of the inner world: From the colonial internalisation of the psyche to the critique of the psychological roots of political economy. Crisis and Critique, 3(3), 286–309.
78.
Pavón-CuéllarD. (2017). Marxism and psychoanalysis: In or against psychology?London, UK: Routledge.
79.
Pérez SotoC. (2009). Sobre la condición social de la psicología [The social condition of psychology]. Santiago, Chile: LOM.
80.
Plato. (trans. 1975). Phaedo. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
81.
PlekhanovG. V. (1956). The development of the monist view of history. Moscow, Russia: Progress. (Original work published 1895)
82.
PlekhanovG. V. (1967). Materialismo militante [Militant materialism]. Mexico City, Mexico: Grijalbo. (Original work published 1907)
83.
PolitzerG. (1974). Critique des fondements de la psychologie [Critiques of the foundations of psychology]. Paris, France: PUF. (Original work published 1928)
84.
PrilleltenskyI. (1994). The morals and politics of psychology: Psychological discourse and the status quo. New York: SUNY.
85.
ReichW. (1973). La psicología de masas del fascismo [Mass psychology of fascism]. Mexico City, México: Roca. (Original work published 1933)
86.
ReichW. (1989). Materialismo dialéctico y psicoanálisis [Materialism and psychoanalysis]. Mexico City, México: Siglo XXI. (Original work published 1934)
87.
RevueltasJ. (1976). Dialéctica de la conciencia [Dialectics of consciousness]. Mexico City, México: Era.
88.
RóheimG. (1950). Psychoanalysis and anthropology: Culture, personality and the unconscious. Oxford, UK: International Universities Press.
89.
SaleclR. (2006). Choice and the ultimate incurable. Umbr(a), 1, 85–98.
90.
SastreC. L. (1974). La psicología, red ideológica [Psychology: Ideological network]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Tiempo contemporáneo.
91.
SchmidtV. (1979). Éducation psychanalytique en Russie Soviétique [Psychoanalytic education in Soviet Russia]. In Pulsions sexuelles et éducation du corps [Sexual impulses and body education] (pp. 49–84). Paris, France: Union Générale D’Éditions. (Original work published 1924)
92.
SèveL. (1989). Marxisme et théorie de la personalité [Marxism and theory of personality]. Paris, France: Editions Sociales. (Original work published 1969)
93.
TodesD. P. (2014). Ivan Pavlov: A Russian life in science. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
94.
TortM. (1970). La psychanalyse dans le matérialisme historique [Psychoanalysis in historical materialism]. Nouvelle Revue de Psychanalyse, 1, 146–166.
95.
TosquellesF. (1991). Une politique de la folie [Politics of folly]. Chimères, 19, 66–81.
96.
TosquellesF. (1992). L’enseignement de la folie [Teaching folly]. Paris, France: Privat.
TrotskyL. (2004). El materialismo dialéctico y la ciencia [Dialectical materialism and science]. In DíazA. (Trans.), Escritos filosóficos [Philosophical writings] (pp. 127–146). Buenos Aires, Argentina: CEIP León Trotsky. (Original work published 1925)
99.
TzaraT. (1981). Grains et issues [Grains and issues]. Paris, France: Flammarion. (Original work published 1935)
100.
VoloshinovV. N. (1999). Freudismo: un bosquejo crítico [Freudism: A critical approach]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Paidós. (Original work published 1927)
101.
WallonH. (1968). L’evolution psychologique de l’enfant [Psychological evolution of the child]. Paris, France: Armand Colin. (Original work published 1940)
102.
WozniakR. H. (1992). Mind and body: René Descartes to William James. Washington, DC: National Library of Medicine and American Psychological Association.
103.
ŽižekS. (1989). The sublime object of ideology. London, UK: Verso.
