In the spirit of the Turing test, machines modeled on four theories of emotion are placed in a naturalistic thought experiment and their ability to simulate human emotion is evaluated. Four simulators based on the Darwinian, Jamesian, cognitivist and social constructionist theories of emotion are proposed. Each of the simulators is found to be inadequate to the task. The four theories are deficient because none of them offers explanations for how the simulators could make sense of their particular situations and therefore simulate emotions appropriate to them. It is suggested that this ability to make sense of the particular is at least essential to human emotion and may be precisely what emotions enable persons to do.
Arnold, M. (1960). Emotion and personality (Vol. 1). New York: Columbia University Press .
4.
Averill, J.A. (1980). A constructivist view of emotion. In R. Plutchik & H. Kellerman (Eds.), Emotion: Theory, research, and experience (Vol. 1, pp. 305-339). New York: Academic Press .
5.
Averill, J.A. (1983). Anger and aggression: An essay on emotion. New York: Springer .
6.
Averill, J.A. (1985). The social construction of emotion: With special reference to love. In K.J. Gergen & K.E. Davis (Eds.), The social construction of the person (pp. 89-109). New York: Springer .
7.
Averill, J.A. (1993). Putting the social in social cognition, with special reference to emotion. In R. Wyer & T. Srull (Eds.), Perspectives on anger and emotion (pp. 47-55). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .
8.
Born, R. (Ed.). (1987). Artificial intelligence: The case against. London: Croom Helm .
9.
Bringsjord, S. , Bello, P. , & Ferrucci, D. (2001). Creativity, the Turing test, and the (better) Lovelace test . Minds and Machines, 11, 3-27 .
10.
Chwelos, G. , & Oatley, K. (1994). Appraisal, computational models, and Scherer’s expert system . Cognition and Emotion, 8, 245-257 .
11.
Cooper, J. (1999). Reason and emotion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
12.
Cornelius, R. (1996). The science of emotion. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall .
13.
Davidson, D. (1990). Turing’s test. In K.A.M. Said & W.H. Newton-Smith (Eds.), Modelling the mind (pp. 1-11). New York: Clarendon .
14.
Davis, M. (1990). Is mathematical insight algorithmic?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 13, 659-660 .
15.
Davis, M. (1993). How subtle is Gödel’s theorem? More on Roger Penrose . Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 16, 611-612 .
16.
Davis, M. (2000). The universal computer. New York: Norton .
17.
Davitz, J.R. (1969). The language of emotion. San Diego, CA: Academic Press .
18.
Dennett, D. (1978). Brainstorms. Montgomery, VT: Bradford .
19.
Dennett, D. (1987). The intentional stance. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
20.
Dennett, D. (1998). Brainchildren. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
21.
Dreyfus, H. (1992). What computers still can’t do. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
22.
Ekman, P. (1972). Univeral and cultural differences in facial expressions of emotions . In J.K. Cole (Ed.), Nebraska symposium on motivation, 1971 (pp. 207-283 ). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
23.
Ekman, P. (1994). Strong evidence for universals in facial expressions: A reply to Russell’s mistaken critique . Psychological Bulletin, 115, 268-287 .
24.
Ekman, P. , & Friesen, W. (1971). Constants across cultures in the face and emotion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 17, 124-129 .
25.
Ekman, P. , Sorenson, E.R. , & Friesen, W.V. (1969). Pan-cultural elements in the facial displays of emotion . Science, 164, 86-88 .
26.
Frijda, N. (1986). The emotions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
27.
Geertz, C. (1959). The vocabulary of emotion: A study of Javanese socialization processes . Psychiatry, 22, 225-237 .
28.
Geertz, C. (1973). The interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books .
29.
Gergen, K. (1995). Metaphor and monophony in the 20th-century psychology of emotions . History of Human Sciences, 8, 1-23 .
30.
Gödel, K. (1986). Collected works (Vol. 1). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
31.
Goffman, E. (1959). The presentation of self in everyday life. Garden City, NY: Anchor .
32.
Greenwood, J.D. (1992). The social constitution of emotion . New Ideas in Psychology, 10, 1-18 .
33.
Hanfling, O. (2000). Philosophy and ordinary language: The bent and genius of our tongue. London: Routledge .
34.
Harré, R. (1986). The social construction of emotions. Oxford: Blackwell .
35.
Harré, R. , & Parrott, W.G. (1996). The emotions: Social, cultural and biological dimensions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage .
36.
Haugeland, J. (1985). Artificial intelligence: The very idea. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
37.
Haugeland, J. (1998). Having thought. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
38.
Heidegger, M. (1949). Existence and being (W. Brock, Trans.). Chicago, IL: Henry Regnery .
39.
Heidegger, M. (1996). Being and time (J. Stambaugh, Trans.). Albany: State University of New York Press .
40.
Hofstadter, D. (1999). Godel, Escher, Bach: An eternal braid. New York: Basic Books .
41.
Hofstadter, D. , & Dennett, D. (1981). The mind’s I. New York: Basic Books .
42.
Husserl, E. (1982). Ideas pertaining to a pure phenomenology and to a phenomenological philosophy (F. Kersten, Trans.). Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic .
43.
Izard, C. (1977). Human emotions. New York: Plenum .
44.
Izard, C. (1980). Cross-cultural perspectives on emotion and emotion communication. In H.C. Triandis & W. Lonner (Eds.), Handbook of cross-cultural pscyhology (pp. 185-221). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon .
45.
James, W. (1884). What is an emotion?Mind, 9, 188-205 .
46.
Kovecses, Z. (2000). Metaphor and emotion: Language, culture, and body in human feeling. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
47.
Laird, J. (1974). Self-attribution of emotion: The effects of expressive behavior on the quality of emotional experience . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 29, 475-486 .
48.
Laird, J. (1984). The real role of facial response in the experience of emotion: A reply to Tourangeau and Ellsworth and others . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 47, 909-917 .
49.
Laird, J. , & Bresler, C. (1990). William James and the mechanism of emotional experience . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 16, 636-651 .
50.
Lakoff, G. , & Johnson, M. (1999). Philosophy in the flesh. New York: Basic Books .
51.
Lazarus, R. (1984). On the primacy of cognition . American Psychologist, 46, 352-367 .
52.
Lazarus, R. (1991). Emotion and adaptation. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
53.
Lazarus, R. (1999). The cognition-emotion debate: A bit of history. In T. Dalgleish & M. Power (Eds.), Handbook of cognition and emotion (pp. 3-19). New York: Wiley .
54.
Lewis, M. , & Haviland-Jones, J. (2000). Handbook of emotions. New York: Guilford .
55.
Loebner, H. (2003). Home page of the Loebner Prize—‘The first Turing test’. Available at: http://www.loebner.net/Prizef/loebner-prize.html
Lutz, C. (1988a). Ethnographic perspectives on the emotion lexicon. In V. Hamilton , G.H. Bower , & N.H. Frijda (Eds.), Cognitive perspectives on emotion and motivation (pp. 399-419). Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic .
60.
Lutz, C. (1988b). Unnatural emotions. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
61.
Mineka, S. , & Öhman, A. (2002). Phobias and preparedness: The selective, automatic, and encapsulated nature of fear . Biological Psychiatry, 52, 927-937 .
62.
Minsky, M. (1985). The society of mind. New York: Simon & Schuster .
63.
Minsky, M. (1988). Emotions and the society of mind. In M. Clynes & J. Panksepp (Eds.), Emotions in psychopathology: Theory and research (pp. 171-179). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
64.
Moor, J. (2001). The status and future of the Turing test . Minds and Machines, 11, 77-93 .
65.
Nagel, E. , & Newman, J. (2001). Gödel’s Proof. New York: New York University Press .
66.
Nagel, T. (1974). What is it like to be a bat?Philosophical Review, 83, 435-450 .
67.
Nussbaum, M.C. (1986). The fragility of goodness: Luck and ethics in Greek tragedy and philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
68.
Nussbaum, M.C. (1994). The therapy of desire: Theory and practice in Hellenistic ethics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
69.
Nussbaum, M.C. (2001). Upheavals of thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
Oatley, K. , & Johnson-Laird, P.N. (1987). Toward a cognitive theory of emotions . Cognition & Emotion, 1, 29-50 .
72.
Öhman, A. (1986). Face the beast and fear the face: Animal and social fears as prototypes for evolutionary analyses of emotion . Pschophysiology, 23, 123-145 .
73.
Öhman, A. (1999). Distinguishing unconscious from conscious emotional processes: Methodological considerations and theoretical implications. In T. Dalgleish & M. Power (Eds.), Handbook of cognition and emotion (pp. 321-352). New York: Wiley .
74.
Ohman, A. , Flykt, A. , & Lundqvist, D. (2000). Unconscious emotion: Evolutionary perspectives, psychophysiological data, and neuropsychological mechanisms. In R. Lane & L. Nadel (Eds.), Cognitive neuroscience of emotion (pp. 296-327). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
75.
Öhman, A. , & Mineka, S. (2001). Fears, phobias, and preparedness: Toward an evolved module of fear and fear learning . Psychological Review, 108, 483-522 .
76.
Ortony, A. , Clore, G. , & Collins, A. (1990). The cognitive structure of emotions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
77.
Parkinson, B. (1995). Ideas and realities of emotions. London: Routledge .
78.
Penrose, R. (1989). The emperor’s new mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
79.
Penrose, R. (1990). The nonalgorithmic mind . Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 13, 692-705 .
80.
Penrose, R. (1993). An emperor still without mind . Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 16, 616-625 .
81.
Picard, R. (1997). Affective computing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
82.
Plutchik, R. (1980). Emotion: A psychoevoulutionary synthesis. New York: Harper & Row .
83.
Plutchik, R. (1994). The psychology and biology of emotion. New York: Harper-Collins .
84.
Putnam, H. (1987). Computational psychology and interpretation theory. In R. Born (Ed.), Artificial intelligence: The case against (pp. 1-17). London: Croom Helm .
85.
Russell, B. (1956). Logic and knowledge. London: George Allen & Unwin .
86.
Sartre, J.-P. (1948). The emotions: Outline of a theory (B. Frechtman, Trans.). New York: Philosophical Library .
87.
Schachter, S. , & Singer, J. (1962). Cognitive, social, and physiological determinants of emotional state . Psychological Review, 69, 379-399 .
88.
Scherer, K. (1984). On the nature and function of emotion: A component process approach. In K. Scherer & P. Ekman (Eds.), Approaches to emotion (pp. 293-317). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .
89.
Scherer, K. (1993). Studying the emotion-antecedent appraisal process: The expert system approach . Cognition and Emotion, 7, 325-355 .
90.
Scherer, K. (1997). The role of culture in emotion-antecedent appraisal . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 902-922 .
91.
Schweizer, P. (1998). The truly total Turing test . Minds and Machines, 8, 263-272 .
92.
Searle, J. (1980). Minds, brains, and programs . Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 3, 417-457 .
93.
Slife, B. (1987). The perils of eclecticism as therapeutic orientation . Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology, 7, 91-103 .
94.
Slife, B. , & Reber, J. (2001). Eclecticism in psychotherapy: Is it really the best substitute for traditional theories? In B. Slife , R. Williams , & S. Barlow (Eds.), Critical issues in psychotherapy: Translating new ideas into practice (pp. 213-233). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage .
95.
Slife, B. , Reber, J. , & Gantt, E. (2002). Eclecticism and the philosophy of science. Manuscript submitted for publication.
96.
Sloman, A. (1987). Motives, mechanisms, and emotions . Cognition and Emotion, 1, 217-233 .
97.
Sloman, A. (2000). Architectural requirements for human-like agents both natural and artificial: What sorts of machines can love? In K. Dautenhahn (Ed.), Human cognition and social agent technology (pp. 162-195). Amsterdam: John Benjamins .
98.
Sloman, A. (2001). Beyond shallow models of emotion . Cognitive Processing, 2, 177-198 .
99.
Smith, C. , & Ellsworth, P. (1985). Patterns of cognitive appraisal in emotion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48, 813-838 .
100.
Smith, C. , & Lazarus, R. (1993). Appraisal components, core relational themes, and the emotions . Cognition & Emotion, 7, 233-269 .
101.
Solomon, R. (1977). Husserl’s concept of the noema. In F.A. Elliston & P. McCormick (Eds.), Husserl: Expositions and appraisals (pp. 168-181). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press .
102.
Solomon, R. (1984). Emotions and choice. In J. Dougherty (Ed.), The good life and its pursuit (pp. 111-132). New York: Paragon House .
103.
Solomon, R. (1988). On emotions as judgments . American Philosophical Quarterly, 25, 183-191 .
104.
Solomon, R. (1993). The passions: Emotions and the meaning of life. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett .
105.
Sorabji, R. (2000). Emotion and peace of mind: From Stoic agitation to Christian temptation. London: Oxford University Press .
106.
Spackman, M.P. (2002). How to do things with emotions . Journal of Mind and Behavior, 23, 393-412 .
107.
Spackman, M.P. , & Parrott, W.G. (2001). Emotionology in prose: A study of descriptions of emotion from three literary periods . Cognition and Emotion, 15, 553-574 .
Turing, A. (1965). On computable numbers with an application to the Entscheidungsproblem. In M. Davis (Ed.), The undecidable (pp. 116-154). Hewlett, NY: Raven Press .
110.
Wehrle, T. , & Scherer, K. (1995). Potential pitfalls in computational modelling of appraisal processes: A reply to Chwelos and Oatley . Cognition and Emotion, 9, 599-616 .
111.
Wierzbicka, A. (1999). Emotions across languages and cultures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
112.
Wittgenstein, L. (1980). Remarks on the philosophy of psychology (G.E.M. Anscombe, Trans.; Vol. 1). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
113.
Wittgenstein, L. (1997). Philosophical investigations. Oxford: Blackwell .
114.
Wright, I. , Sloman, A. , & Beaudoin, L. (1996). Towards a design-based analysis of emotional episodes . Philosophy, Psychiatry, and Psychology, 3, 101-126 .
115.
Zajonc, R. , Murphy, S. , & Ingelhart, M. (1989). Feeling and facial efference: Implications of the vascular theory of emotion . Psychological Bulletin, 96, 395-416 .
116.
Zdenek, S. (2001). Passing Loebner’s Turing test: A case of conflicting discourse functions . Minds and Machines, 11, 53-76 .
