The empirical literature on Self-Defeating Personality Disorder (SDPD) that has appeared since the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-III-R was published is reviewed from several standpoints, including the dangers it poses to women by pathologizing them. It is concluded that there is a paucity of research; that some of what exists is seriously flawed methodologically; that some shows that SDPD criteria lack face validity; that the category has poor diagnostic power and overlaps substantially with other categories; and that SDPD continues to be dangerous for people of both sexes but especially for women. It is concluded, therefore, that SDPD should be excluded from the DSM-IV.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Psychiatric Association
(1980) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-III. Washington, DC: APA.
2.
American Psychiatric Association
(1987) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-III-R. Washington, DC: APA.
3.
Blashfield, F.K.
and Breen, M.J. (1989) `Face Validity of the DSM-III-R Personality Disorders', American Journal of Psychiatry146: 1575-1579.
4.
Blashfield, R.K.
and Haymaker, D. (1988) `A Prototype Analysis of the Diagnostic Criteria for DSM-III-R Personality Disorders', Journal of Personality Disorders2: 272-280.
5.
Braude, M.
(1986) `Concerns about APA Questionnaire on Personality Disorders', American Journal of Psychiatry143(10): 1309.
6.
Brown, L.
(1986) `Report from the Latest Meetings on the DSM-III-R', FTI Interchange4 (July, 3).
7.
Caplan, P.J.
(1987) The Myth of Women's Masochism. New York: Signet.
8.
Caplan, P.J.
(1991) `How Do They Decide Who is Normal? The Bizarre but True Tale of the DSM Process', Canadian Psychology (April).
9.
Carmen, E. (1985) `Masochistic Personality Disorder', critique prepared for American Psychiatric Association's DSM Work Group on Personality Disorders.
10.
Diagnosis Today (1986) Diagnosis Today: The Politics of Diagnosis and Diagnosis Today: Revising the DSM-III (based on 1986 presentations). Intelligence in Media, Inc., Social Science Video Archives 1 and 2.
11.
Fiester, S.J. (1989) `Self-defeating Personality Disorder: A Review of Data and Recommendations for DSM-IV, prepared for DSM-IV Work Group on Personality Disorders.
12.
Frances, A. (1988) `Memorandum to DSM-IV Work Group Re: DSM-IV Process', 19 September.
13.
Frances, A. (1989) Letter to Paula J. Caplan, 24 July.
14.
FTI (Feminist Therapists' Institute)
(1986) `Coalition against Misdiagnosis Formed to Work against DSM-III-R: Demonstration Planned against the American Psychiatric Association', FTI Interchange4 (April, 1 and 3).
15.
Fuller, A.K.
(1986) `Masochistic Personality Disorder: A Diagnosis under Consideration', Jefferson Journal of Psychiatry4: 7-21.
16.
Fuller, A.K.
and Blashfield, R.K. (1989) `Masochistic Personality Disorder: A Prototype Analysis of Diagnosis and Sex Bias', Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease177: 168-172.
17.
Herman, J. (1988) `Review of Self-defeating Personality Disorder', prepared for DSM-IV Work Group on Personality Disorders.
18.
Hess, A.
(1985) `Review of Million Multiaxial Inventory', in J.V. Mitchell, Jr (ed.) Ninth Mental Measurements Yearbook. Vol. 1, pp. 984-986. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
19.
Kaplan, M.
(1983) `A Woman's View of DSM-III', American Psychologist28: 786-792.
20.
Kass, F.
(1987) `In Response: New Controversial Diagnoses: Self-defeating and Sadistic Personality Disorders', Jefferson Journal of Psychiatry5: 92-96.
21.
Kass, F.
, MacKinnon, R.A. and Spitzer, R.L. (1986) `Masochistic Personality: An Empirical Study', American Journal of Psychiatry143(2): 216-218.
22.
Kass, F.
, Spitzer, R.L., Williams, J.B.W. and Widiger, T. (n.d.) `Self-defeating Personality Disorder and DSM-III-R. I: Justification for Inclusion and Development of the Diagnostic Criteria', unpublished, undated paper, Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University, New York (Kass).
23.
Kutchins, H.
and Kirk, S.A. (1986) `The Reliability of DSM-III: A Critical Review', Social Work Research and Abstracts22: 3-12.
24.
Miller, J.B.
(1986) `Self-defeating Personality Disorder', response to American Psychiatric Association's Committee on Women.
25.
Mitchell, J.V., Jr
, ed. (1985) Ninth Mental Measurements Yearbook, Vol. 1. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
26.
Reich, J.
(1987a) `Prevalence of DSM-III-R Self-defeating (Masochistic) Personality Disorder in Normal and Outpatient Populations', Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease175(1): 52-54.
27.
Reich, J.
(1987b) `Instruments Measuring DSM-III and DSM-III-R Personality Disorders', Journal of Personality Disorders1: 220-240.
28.
Rosewater, L.B.
(1987) `A Critical Analysis of the Proposed Self-defeating Personality Disorder', Journal of Personality Disorders1: 190-195.
29.
Siegel, R.J.
(1988) `Women's "Dependency" in a Male-centered Value System: Gender-based Values Regarding Dependency and Independence', Women and Therapy7: 113-123.
30.
Skodol, A.E.
, Rosnick, L., Kellman, D., Oldham, J.M. and Hyler, S.E. (1988) `Validating Structured DSM-III-R Personality Disorder Assessments with Longitudinal Data', American Journal of Psychiatry145: 1297-1299.
31.
Spitzer, R.L.
, Williams, J.B.W., Kass, F. and Davies, M. (1989) `A National Field Trial of the DSM-III-R Diagnostic Criteria for Self-defeating Personality Disorder', American Journal of Psychiatry146: 1561-1567.
32.
Stangl, D.
, Pfohl, B., Zimmerman, M., Bowers, W. and Corenthal, C. (1985) `A Structured Interview for the DSM-III Personality Disorders', Archives of General Psychiatry42: 591-596.
33.
Stoppard, J.M.
(1989) `An Evaluation of the Adequacy of Cognitive/Behavioural Theories for Understanding Depression in Women', Canadian Psychology30: 39-47.
34.
Surgeon General's Conference on Interpersonal Violence (1985) Final Report, Washington, DC, October.
35.
Varga, M.P.
(1985) `An Object Relations Perspective on Dealing with Depressive-masochistic Character Resistances', Issues in Ego Psychology8(1-2): 59-62.
36.
Walker, L.E.A.
(1985) `The American Psychiatric Association's Work Group to Revise DSM-III: Statement on Proposed Diagnosis of Masochistic Personalty Disorder', prepared for APA Work Group, 18 November.
37.
Walker L.E.A.
(1986) `Masochistic Personality Disorder, Take Two: A Report from the Front Lines', FTI Interchange4: 1-2.
38.
Walker, L.E.A.
(1987) `Inadequacies of the Masochistic Personality Disorder Diagnosis for Women', Journal of Personality Disorders1: 183-189.
39.
Widiger, T.A.
(1985) `Review of Millon Multiaxial Inventory', in J.V. Mitchell, Jr (ed.) Ninth Mental Measurements Yearbook, Vol. 1, pp. 986-988. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
