Negotiating the hairless ideal in Āotearoa/New Zealand: Choice,awareness,complicity,and resistance in younger women's accounts of body hair removal

Abstract

Hair removal amongst Western women is ubiquitous, and research continues to highlight the ongoing conformity of almost all women with hair removal practices. Often women are presented as either cultural dupes, following the expectations of the Western hairless ideal without question, or highly engaged participants in the rigours of aesthetic labour, using it for their own agentic purposes. This paper seeks to explore the various ways that younger women (18–35) made sense of their own and others’ hair removal practices. We report on a thematic analysis of data generated from an online (mostly) qualitative survey with 299 female-identified respondents. Four themes were constructed: (1) women should do what they want with their body hair, (2) removing hair is socially shaped, (3) begrudging complicity, and (4) resistance to hair removal norms takes a particular kind of woman. We discuss the ways in which women described their practices and thinking where they seemed simultaneously complicit with and resistant to idealised notions of feminine embodiment.

Keywords

aesthetic labour beauty work body work embodiment qualitative survey thematic analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agence France-Presse. (2016). ‘Princesses have hair' – French women fight body hair stigma on Twitter. The Guardian. Retrieved from www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/13/princesses-have-hair-french-women-fight-body-hair-stigma-on-twitter.

Basow

(1991) The hairless ideal: Women and their body hair. Psychology of Women Quarterly 15: 83–96.

Basow

Braman

(1998) Women and body hair: Social perceptions and attitudes. Psychology of Women Quarterly 22: 637–645.

Bordo

(1993) Unbearable weight: Feminism, Western culture & the body, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Boroughs

Cafri

Thompson

(2005) Male body depilation: Prevalence and associated features of body hair removal. Sex Roles 52: 637–644.

Braun

(2009) “The women are doing it for themselves”: The rhetoric of choice and agency around female genital ‘cosmetic surgery.'. Australian Feminist Studies 24: 233–249.

Braun

Clarke

(2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3: 77–101.

Braun

Tricklebank

Clarke

(2013) “It shouldn't stick out from your bikini at the beach”: Meaning, gender, and the hairy/hairless body. Psychology of Women Quarterly 37: 478–493.

Butler

Smith

Collazo

Caltabiano

Herbenick

(2015) Pubic hair preferences, reasons for removal, and associated genital symptoms: Comparisons between men and women. The Journal of Sexual Medicine 12: 48–58.

10.

Crann, S. Jenkins, A., Money, D., & O’Doherty, K. (2017). Women’s genital body work: Health, hygiene and beauty practices in the production of idealized female genitalia. Feminism & Psychology, Online First.

11.

Elias

Gill

Scharff

(2017) Aesthetic labour: Beauty politics in neoliberalism. In: Elias

Gill

Scharff

(eds) Aesthetic labour: Rethinking beauty politics in neoliberalism, London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, pp. 3–49.

12.

Fahs

(2011) Dreaded “Otherness”: Heteronormative patrolling of women's body hair rebellions. Gender and Society 25: 451–472.

13.

Fahs

(2012) Breaking body hair boundaries: Classroom exercises for challenging social constructions of the body and sexuality. Feminism and Psychology 22: 482–506.

14.

Fahs

(2014) Perilous patches and pitstaches: Imagined versus lived experiences of women’s body hair growth. Psychology of Women Quarterly 38: 167–180.

15.

Gill

(2016) Post-postfeminism? New feminist visibilities in postfeminist times. Feminist Media Studies 16: 610–630.

16.

Gill

Donaghue

(2013) As if postfeminism had come true: The turn to agency in cultural studies of ‘sexualisation’. In: Madhok

Phillips

Wilson

(eds) Gender, agency, and coercion, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan UK, pp. 240–258.

17.

Herbenick

Hensel

Smith

Schick

Reece

Sanders

Fortenberry

(2013) Pubic hair removal and sexual behavior: Findings from a prospective daily diary study of sexually active women in the United States. The Journal of Sexual Medicine 10: 678–685.

18.

Hershman

(1974) Hair, sex and dirt. Man 9: 274–298.

19.

Herzig

(2009) The political economy of choice. Australian Feminist Studies 24: 251–263.

20.

Herzig

(2015) Plucked: A history of hair removal, New York: New York University Press.

21.

Jackson

Scott

(2004) The personal is still political: Heterosexuality, feminism and monogamy. Feminism & Psychology 14: 151–157.

22.

Krantz, R. (2017). 12 Reasons to Rock a Full Bush. Retrieved from www.bustle.com/articles/138169-12-reasons-to-rock-a-full-bush.

23.

Krawczyk

Thompson

J. K.

(2015) The effects of advertisements that sexually objectify women on state body dissatisfaction and judgments of women: The moderating roles of gender and internalization. Body Image 15: 109–119.

24.

Kwan

Trautner

(2009) Beauty work: Individual and institutional rewards, the reproduction of gender, and questions of agency. Sociology Compass 3: 49–71.

25.

Braun

(2017) Pubic hair and its removal: A practice beyond the personal. Feminism & Psychology 27: 336–356.

26.

Lorber

Moore

(2007) Gendered bodies: Feminist perspectives, Los Angeles: Roxbury Publishing Company.

27.

McRobbie

(2004) Post-feminism and popular culture. Feminist Media Studies 4: 255–264.

28.

McRobbie

(2015) Notes on the perfect. Australian Feminist Studies 30: 3–20.

29.

Peixoto Labre

(2002) The Brazilian wax: New hairlessness norm for women? Journal of Communication Inquiry 26: 113–132.

30.

Rice

(2009) Imagining the Other? Ethical challenges of researching and writing women's embodied lives. Feminism & Psychology 19: 245–266.

31.

Riddell

Varto

Hodgson

(2010) Smooth talking: The phenomenon of pubic hair removal in women. The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality 19: 121–130.

32.

Stone

Graham

Baysal

(2017) Women's engagement in pubic hair removal: Motivations and associated factors. International Journal of Sexual Health 29: 89–96.

33.

Stuart

Donaghue

(2012) Choosing to conform: The discursive complexities of choice in relation to feminine beauty practices. Feminism and Psychology 22: 98–121.

34.

Terry

Braun

(2013) To let hair be, or to not let hair be? Gender and body hair removal practices in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Body Image 10: 599–606.

35.

Terry

Braun

(2016) “I think gorilla-like back effusions of hair are rather a turn-off” – Men, body hair removal and the concept of ‘excessive’ hair. Body Image 17: 14–24.

36.

Terry

Braun

(2017) Short but often sweet: The surprising potential of qualitative survey methods. In: Braun

Clarke

Gray

(eds) Collecting qualitative data: A practical guide to textual, media and virtual techniques, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 15–44.

37.

Terry

Hayfield

Clarke

Braun

(2017) Thematic analysis. In: Willig

Stainton-Rogers

(eds) The Sage handbook of qualitative research in psychology, 2nd ed. London: SAGE, pp. 17–37.

38.

Tiggemann

Hodgson

(2008) The hairlessness norm extended: Reasons for and predictors of women’s body hair removal at different body sites. Sex Roles 59: 889–897.

39.

Tiggemann

Lewis

(2004) Attitudes toward women's body hair: Relationship to disgust sensitivity. Psychology of Women Quarterly 28: 381–387.

40.

Toerien

Wilkinson

(2003) Gender and body hair: Constructing the feminine woman. Women's Studies International Forum 26: 333–344.

41.

Toerien

Wilkinson

(2004) Exploring the depilation norm: A qualitative questionnaire study of women's body hair removal. Qualitative Research in Psychology 1: 69–92.

42.

Williamson

(2015) Social pressures and health consequences associated with body hair removal. Journal of Aesthetic Nursing 4: 131–133.

43.

Willig

(2013) Introducing qualitative research in psychology, 3rd ed.. Berkshire: Open University Press.