This study investigates how women and men in the Western Cape, South Africa,
construct their gender identities and roles. As part of the development of an
HIV prevention intervention for men, key informant interviews and focus group
discussions were conducted. Several themes regarding the construction of gender
were identified. First, participants reported that traditional gender relations
of male dominance and female subservience were still in evidence, along with
traditional gender roles that mandated a division of labour between the
household and paid workforce. Second, participants reported a shift in gender
roles and relations in the direction of increased power for women. Last, hostile
resistance to changes in gender power relations was evident in the discussions.
Redefining masculinity and femininity and shifting gender relations in the
direction of `power with' instead of `power over' is perhaps a necessary prelude
to lasting social change and curbing the HIV epidemic in South Africa.
Abdool Karim, S.S.
,
Abdool Karim, Q.
,
Preston-Whyte, E.
and
Sankar, N.
(1992)
`Reasons for Lack of Condom Use among High School Students'
, South African Medical Journal82: 107-10.
2.
Banister, P.
,
Burman, E.
,
Parker, I.
,
Taylor, M.
and
Tindall, C.
(1994) Qualitative Methods in Psychology.
Buckingham: Open University
Press.
3.
Boonzaier, F.
(2005)
`Women Abuse in South Africa: A Brief Contextual Analysis'
, Feminism & Psychology15(1):
99-103.
4.
Boonzaier, F.
(2006) `A Gendered Analysis of Woman Abuse', in
T. Shefer
,
F. Boonzaier
and
P. Kiguwa
(eds) The Gender of Psychology, pp. 135-50.
Cape Town: UCT
Press .
5.
Carey, C.M.
and
Mongeau, P.A.
(1996) `Communication and Violence in Courtship
Relationships' , in
D.D. Cahn
and
S.A. Lloyd
(eds) Family Violence from a Communication Perspective (pp.
127-50). Thousand Oaks,
CA: Sage.
6.
Dunkle, K.L.
,
Jewkes R.
,
Brown H.C.
,
Gray, G.E.
,
McIntyre, A.
and
Harlow, S.D.
(2004)
`Gender-Based Violence, Relationship Power and Risk of HIV Infection in
Women Attending Antenatal Clinics in South Africa'
, The Lancet363(9419):
1415-21.
7.
Faludi, S.
(1991) Backlash: The Undeclared War Against American
Women . New York:
Doubleday.
8.
Follingstad, D.R.
,
Rutledge, L.L.
,
McNeill-Hawkins, K.
and
Polek, D.S.
(1992) `Factors Related to Physical Violence in Dating
Relationships', in
E.C. Viano
(ed.) Intimate Violence: Interdisciplinary Perspectives, pp.
121-35. New York:
Hemisphere.
9.
Garcia-Moreno, C.
and
Watts, C.
(2000)
`Violence Against Women: Its Importance for HIV/AIDS'
, AIDS14(suppl. 3):
S253-S265.
10.
Glick, P.
and
Fiske, S.T.
(1996)
`The Ambivalent Sexism Inventory: Differentiating Hostile and Benevolent
Sexism'
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology70(3):
491-512.
11.
Glick, P.
and
Fiske, S.T.
(2001)
`An Ambivalent Alliance: Hostile and Benevolent Sexism as Complementary
Justifications for Gender Inequality'
, American Psychologist56(2):
109-18.
12.
Glick, P.
,
Diebold, J.
,
Bailey-Werner, B.
and
Zhu, L.
(1997)
`The Two Faces of Adam: Ambivalent Sexism and Polarized Attitudes Toward
Women'
, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin23(12):
1323-34.
13.
Glick, P.
,
Fiske, S.
,
Mladinic, A.
,
Saiz, J.
,
Abrams, D.
,
Masser, B.
,
Adetoun, B.
,
Osagie, J.E.
,
Akande, A.
,
Alao, A.
,
Brunner, A.
,
Willemsen, T.M.
,
Chipeta, K.
,
Dardenne, B.
,
Dijksterhuis, A.
,
Wigboldus, D.
,
Eckes, T.
,
Six-Materna, I.
,
Exposito, F.
,
Moya, M.
,
Foddy, M.
,
Kim, H.-J.
,
Lameiras, M.
,
Sotelo, M.J.
,
Mucchi-Faina, A.
,
Romani, M.
,
Sakalli, N.
,
Udegbe, B.
,
Yamamoto, M.
,
Ui, M.
,
Ferreira, M.C.
and
Lopez Lopez, W.
(2000)
`Beyond Prejudice as Simple Antipathy: Hostile and Benevolent Sexism Across
Cultures'
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology79(5):
763-75.
14.
Gouws, A.
(2005) Unthinking Citizenship. Cape
Town: UCT Press.
15.
Hollway, W.
(1989) Subjectivity and Method in Psychology: Gender, Meaning
and Science. London:
Sage .
16.
Jewkes, R.
,
Levin, J.
and
Penn-Kekana, L.
(2002)
`Risk Factors for Domestic Violence: Findings from a South African
Cross-Sectional Study'
, Social Science & Medicine55(8):
1603-17.
17.
Kalichman, S.C.
,
Simbayi, L.C.
,
Kaufman, M.
,
Cain, D.
,
Cherry, C.
,
Jooste, S.
and
Mathiti, V.
(2005)
`Gender Attitudes, Sexual Violence, and HIV/AIDS Risks Among Men and Women
in Cape Town, South Africa'
, Journal of Sex Research42(4):
299-305.
18.
Kelly, K.
(1999) `Hermeneutics in Action: Empathy and Interpretation in
Qualitative Research', in
M. Terre Blanche
and
K. Durrheim
(eds) Research in Practice: Applied Methods for the Social
Sciences, pp. 398-420. Cape
Town: UCT Press.
19.
Lesch, E.
(2000) `Female Adolescent Sexuality in a Coloured
Community' , unpublished doctoral dissertation, University
of Stellenbosch , Stellenbosch,
South Africa.
20.
Mankayi, N.
(2006) `Constructions of Masculinity, Sexuality and Risky
Sexual Practices of Male Soldiers', unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of Stellenbosch,
Stellenbosch, South Africa.
21.
McFadden, P.
(2003)
`Sexual Pleasure as Feminist Choice'
, Feminist Africa2: 50-60.
22.
Miles, L.
(1992)
`Women, AIDS, Power and Heterosexual Negotiation: A Discourse
Analysis'
, Agenda15(1):
14-27.
23.
Morrell, R.
(ed.) (2001) Changing Men in Southern Africa.
Pietermaritzburg: University of
Natal Press.
24.
Morrell, R.
(2002)
`Men, Movements, and Gender Transformation in South Africa'
, The Journal of Men's Studies10(3):
309-28.
25.
Mthembu, P.
(1998)
`A Positive View'
, Agenda39: 26-9.
26.
Ouzgane, L.
and
Morrell, R.
(eds) (2005) African Masculinities.
Cape Town: Palgrave
Macmillan.
27.
POLICY Project, Centre for the Study of AIDS
(University of Pretoria), United States Agency for International
Development (USAID) and Chief Directorate: HIV/AIDS & TB, Department
of Health (2003) Siyam'kela: Examining HIV/AIDS Stigma in Selected South African
Media: January - March 2003: A Summary, accessed 16 January
2008. Available:
http://www.policyproject.com/siyamkela.cfm
28.
Ratele, K.
(2007)
`Native Chief and White Headman: A Critical African Gender Analysis of
Culture'
, Agenda72: 65-76.
29.
Ratele, K.
and
Shefer, T.
(2002) `Stigma in the Social Construction of Sexually
Transmitted Diseases', in
D. Hook
and
G. Eagle
(eds) Psychopathology and Social Prejudice, pp.
185-206. Cape Town:
University of Cape Town Press.
30.
Reitz, R.R.
(1999)
`Batterers' Experiences of Being Violent: A Phenomenological Study'
, Psychology of Women Quarterly23(1):
143-66.
31.
Richter, L.
and
Morrell, R.
(2005) (eds) `Baba': Men and Fatherhood in South
Africa. Cape Town: HSRC
Press.
32.
Seidel, G.
(1993)
`The Competing Discourses of HIV/AIDS in Sub-Saharan Africa: Discourses of
Rights and Empowerment vs. Discourses of Control and Exclusion'
, Social Science and Medicine36(3):
175-94.
33.
Shefer, T.
(1999) `Discourses of Heterosexual Subjectivity and
Negotiation' , unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of the Western Cape,
Cape Town, South Africa.
34.
Shefer, T.
(2005)
`A Critical Look at the Use of Gender Theory in Responses to
HIV/AIDS'
, in B. Prince, S. Pugh and S. Kleintjes (eds) Skills-building for
Gender Mainstreaming in HIV/AIDS: Research and Practice: Seminar
Proceedings, pp. 6-12. Cape Town: HSRC
Press.
35.
Shefer, T.
and
Potgieter, C.
(2006) `Sexualities', in
T. Shefer
,
F. Boonzaier
and
P. Kiguwa
(eds) The Gender of Psychology, pp. 103-20.
Cape Town: UCT
Press.
36.
Shefer, T.
,
Potgieter, C.
and
Strebel, A.
(1999)
`Teaching Gender in Psychology at a South African University'
, Feminism and Psychology9(2):
127-33.
37.
Shefer, T.
,
Strebel, A.
and
Foster, D.
(2000)
`Discourses of Power and Violence in Students' Talk on Heterosexual
Negotiation'
, South African Journal of Psychology30(2):
28-36.
38.
Shefer, T.,Ratele, K.,Strebel, A.,Shabalala, N.
and
Buikema, R.
(eds) ( 2007) From Boys to Men: Social Constructions of
Masculinity in Contemporary Society. Cape
Town: UCT Press.
39.
Shefer, T.
,
Airhihenbuwa, C.
,
Shisana, O.
,
Simbayi, L.
,
Adam, M.
,
Zungu-Dirwayi, N.
,
Smith, E.
and
Okoror, T.
(2005)
`Gendered and Racialised HIV/AIDS Stigma: South African Local Community
Responses to HIV and People Living with HIV/AIDS'
, paper presented at the Third African Conference on Social
Aspects of HIV/AIDS Research, 10-14 October, Dakar,
West Africa.
40.
Shisana, O.
,
Rehle, T.
,
Simbayi, L.C.
,
Parker, W.
,
Zuma, K.
,
Bhana, A.
,
Connoly, C.
,
Jooste, S.
and
Pillay, V.
(2005) South African National HIV Prevalence, HIV Incidence,
Behaviour and Communication Survey, 2005.
Cape Town
, South Africa:
HSRC Press
.
41.
Simbayi, L.
,
Strebel, A.
,
Wilson, T.
,
Andipatin, M.
,
Msomi, N.
,
Potgieter, C.
,
Ratele, K.
and
Shefer, T.
(1999) `Sexually Transmitted Diseases in the South African
Public Health Sector', unpublished report compiled for
the National Department of Health, University of the
Western Cape, Cape Town, South
Africa.
42.
Strebel, A.
(1992)
`"There's Absolutely Nothing I can Do, Just Believe in God": South African
Women with AIDS'
, Agenda12: 50-62.
43.
Strebel, A.
(1993) `Women and AIDS: A Study of Issues in the Prevention
of HIV Infection', unpublished doctoral thesis,
University of Cape Town, Cape
Town, South Africa.
44.
Strebel, A.
,
Crawford, M.
,
Shefer, T.
,
Henda, N.
,
Cloete, A.
,
Simbayi, L.
,
Kaufman, M.
,
Kalichman, S.
and
Magome, K.
(2006)
`Gender Roles, Gender-Based Violence and HIV/AIDS: An Exploratory Study in
Two Communities of the Western Cape, South Africa'
, SAHARA Journal3(3):
516-28.
45.
United Nations
(2003) The Seventh United Nations Survey on Crime Trends and
the Operations of Criminal Justice Systems (1998-2000), accessed 29
September 2006. Available:
http://www.unodc.org/unodc/crime_cicp_survey_seventh.html
46.
UNAIDS/World Health Organization
(2007) AIDS Epidemic Update, December 2007, accessed 21
November 2007 . Available:
http://www.data.unaids.org/pub/EPISlides/2007/2007_epiupdate_en.pdf
47.
Van der Straten, A.
,
King, R.
,
Grinstead, O.
,
Vittinghoff, E.
,
Serufilira, A.
and
Allen, S.
(1998) `
Sexual Coercion, Physical Violence, and HIV Infection Among Women in Steady
Relationships in Kigali, Rwanda
', AIDS and Behavior2(1):
61-73.
48.
Varga, C.
and
Makubalo, L.
(1996)
`Sexual Non-Negotiation'
, Agenda28: 31-8.
49.
Vetten, L.
and
Bhana, K.
(2001) Violence, Vengeance and Gender: A Preliminary
Investigation into the Links between HIV/AIDS and Violence against Women in
South Africa . Johannesburg: The
Centre for the Study of Violence and
Reconciliation.
50.
Wood, K.
and
Foster, D.
(1995)
`"Being the Type of Lover . . .": Gender-Differentiated Reasons for Non-Use
of Condoms by Sexually Active Heterosexual Students'
, Psychology in Society20(1):
13-35.
51.
Wood, K.
and
Jewkes, R.
(1998) `Love is a Dangerous Thing': Micro-dynamics of
Violence in Sexual Relationships of Young People in Umtata.
Tygerberg: Medical Research
Council.
52.
Wood, K.
,
Maforah, F.
and
Jewkes, R.
(1996) Sex, Violence and Constructions of Love among Xhosa
Adolescents: Putting Violence on the Sexuality Education Agenda.
Tygerberg: Medical Research
Council.
