The present article explores the gender identity development of butch lesbian
women, as conveyed in semi-structured interviews. A grounded theory (Glaser and
Strauss, 1967) analysis of the women’s developmental experiences was
performed. From these results, a model was formed that illustrated the process
of their gender identity development, in interaction with the development of
their sexual orientation. Butch gender identity development is posited as a
healthy process complicated by the societal pressures to conform to gender
roles, and is offered as an alternative to a diagnosis of gender identity disorder.
American Psychiatric Association
(2000) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
- TR (4th edition).
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association
.
2.
Ardill, S.
and
O’Sullivan, S.
(1990)
‘Butch/Femme Obsessions’
, Feminist Review34:
79-85
.
3.
Atkinson, D.R.
,
Morten, G.
and
Sue, D.W.
(1979) Counseling American Minorities: A Cross-cultural
Perspective.
Dubuque, IA: W.C. Brown
.
4.
Bell, A.
,
Weinberg, M.
and
Hammersmith, S.
(1981) Sexual Preference: Its Development in Men and
Women.
Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press
.
5.
Burana, L.
and
Due, L.R.
(eds) (1994) Dagger: On Butch Women.
San Francisco, CA: Cleis Press
.
6.
Butler, J.
(1990) Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of
Identity.
New York: Routledge
.
7.
Calhoun, C.
(1995)
‘The Gender Closet: Lesbian Disappearance under the Sign “Women”’
, Feminist Studies21(1):
7-34
.
8.
Cass, V.C.
(1979)
‘Homosexual Identity Formation: A Theoretical Model’
, Journal of Homosexuality4(3):
219-235
.
9.
Cass, V.C.
(1984)
‘Homosexual Identity Formation: Testing a Theoretical Model’
, The Journal of Sex Research20(2):
143-167
.
10.
Chapman, B.E.
and
Brannock, J.C.
(1987)
‘Proposed Model of Lesbian Identity Development: An Empirical Examination’
, Journal of Homosexuality14(3-4):
69-80
.
11.
Coleman, E.
(1981-82)
‘Developmental stages of the coming out process’
, Journal of Homosexuality7(2-3):
31-43
.
12.
Crawley, S.L.
(2001)
‘Are Butch and Fem Working-class and Antifeminist?’Gender and Society15:
175-196
.
13.
Crawley, S.L. (2002) ‘Narrating and Negotiating Butch and Femme:
Storying Lesbian Selves in a Heteronormative World’, unpublished
dissertation, University of Florida.
14.
Cross, W.E., Jr
(1971)
‘The Negro-to-Black Conversion Experience: Toward a Psychology of
Black Liberation’
, Black World20:
13-27
.
15.
D’Augelli, A.R.
and
Hershberger, S.L.
(1993)
‘Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Youth in Community Settings: Personal
Challenges and Mental Health Problems’
, American Journal of Community Psychology21(4):
1-28
.
16.
Ehrbar, R.
(2001)
‘What is the Relationship between Atypical Gender in Childhood
and Adult Sexual Orientation?’
, paper presented at Gender Variance: Transgender Identities,
Theories, and Practice. Symposium conducted at the annual meeting of the
Association for Women in Psychology, Los Angeles,
CA, chair J.A. Bess.
17.
Faderman, L.
(1991) Odd girls and Twilight Lovers: A History of Lesbian
Life in Twentieth Century America.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
18.
Fausto-Sterling, A.
(2000) Sexing the Body.
New York: Basic Books
.
19.
Feinberg, L.
(1996) Transgender Warriors.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
20.
Feinberg, L.
(1998) Trans liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
21.
Fox, R.C.
(1996) ‘Bisexuality in Perspective: A Review of
Theory and Research’, in
B.A. Firestein
(ed.) Bisexuality: The Psychology and Politics of an Invisible
Minority, pp. 3-50.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
22.
Fukuyama, M.A.
and
Ferguson, A.D.
(2000) ‘Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual People of
Color: Understanding Cultural Complexity and Managing Multiple
Oppressions’, in
R.M. Perez
,
K.A. DeBord
and
K.J. Bieschke
(eds) Handbook of Counseling and Psychotherapy with Lesbian, Gay, and
Bisexual Clients, pp. 81-105.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
23.
Garnets, L.D.
and
Kimmel, D.C.
(1993) ‘Gender Differences in Roles and
Behavior’, in
L.D. Garnets
and
D.C. Kimmel
(eds) Psychological Perspectives on Lesbian and Gay Male
Experiences, pp. 287-295.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
24.
Giorgi, A.
(1970) Psychology as a Human Science: A Phenomenological
Approach.
New York: Harper and Row
.
25.
Glaser, B.J.
and
Strauss, A.
(1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for
Qualitative Research.
Chicago, IL: Aldine
.
26.
Halberstam, J.
(1998) Female Masculinity.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press
.
27.
Haldeman, D.C.
(1994)
‘The Practice and Ethics of Sexual Orientation Conversion Therapy’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology62(2):
221-227
.
28.
Helms, J.E.
(1984)
‘Toward a Theoretical Explanation of the Effects of Race on
Counseling: A Black and White Model’
, The Counseling Psychologist12(3-4):
153-165
.
29.
Herek, G.
,
Gillis, R.J.
and
Cogan, J.
(1999)
‘Psychological Sequelae of Hate Crime Victimization among
Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Adults’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology67(6):
945-951
.
30.
Hershberger, S.L.
and
D’Augelli, A.R.
(2000) ‘Issues in Counseling Lesbian, Gay, and
Bisexual Adolescents’, in
R.M. Perez
,
K.A. DeBord
, and
K.J. Bieschke
(eds) Handbook of Counseling and Psychotherapy with Lesbian, Gay, and
Bisexual Clients, pp. 225-247.
Washington. DC: American Psychological Association
.
31.
Innes, S.A.
and
Lloyd, M.E.
(1996) ‘G.I. Joes in Barbie Land:
Recontextualizing Butch in Twentieth-century Lesbian
Culture’, in
B. Beemyn
and
M. Eliason
(eds) Queer Studies: A Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender
Anthology, pp. 9-34.
New York: New York University Press
.
32.
Jeffreys, S.
(1989) ‘Butch and Femme: Now and
Them’, in Lesbian Women’s Group, Not a Passing
Phase: Reclaiming Lesbians in History 1840-1985, pp.
158-187.
London: The Women’s Press
.
33.
Lapovsky-Kennedy, E.
and
Davis, M.D.
(1993) Boots of Leather, Slippers of Gold: The History of a
Lesbian Community.
New York: Penguin
.
34.
Levitt, H.M.
and
Bigler, M.
(2002) ‘Facilitating Lesbian Gender
Exploration’, in
J.S. Whitman
and
C.J. Boyd
(eds) The Therapist’s Notebook for Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual
Clients, pp. 183-196.
Bingham, NY: Haworth Press
.
35.
Levitt, H.M.
and
Hiestand, K.R.
(2004)
‘A Quest for Authenticity: Contemporary Butch Gender’
, Sex Roles50(9/10):
605-621
.
36.
Levitt, H.M.
and
Hiestand, K.R.
(2005)
‘Gender within Lesbian Sexuality: Butch and Femme Perspectives’
, Journal of Constructivist Psychology18:
39-51
.
37.
Levitt, H.M.
and
Horne, S.G.
(2002)
‘Explorations of Lesbian-queer Genders’
, Journal of Lesbian Studies6(2):
25-39
.
38.
Levitt, H.M.
,
Gerrish, E.A.
and
Hiestand, K.R.
(2003)
‘The Misunderstood Gender: A Model of Modern Femme Identity’
, Sex Roles48(3/4):
99-113
.
39.
Martin, J. (1996) ‘The Butch-Fem Relationship: Gender Roles and
Identifications’, unpublished master’s thesis, Eastern Michigan University.
40.
McCarn, S.R.
and
Fassinger, R.E.
(1996)
‘Revisioning Sexual Minority Identity Formation: A New Model of
Lesbian Identity and its Implications for Counseling and Research’
, The Counseling Psychologist24(3):
508-534
.
41.
McClintock, M.K.
and
Herdt, G.
(1996)
‘Rethinking Puberty: The Development of Sexual Attraction’
, Current Directions in Psychological Science5(6):
178-183
.
42.
McConaghy, N.
,
Armstrong, M.S.
and
Blaszczynski, A.
(1981)
‘Controlled Comparison of Aversive Therapy and Covert
Sensitization in Compulsive Homosexuality’
, Behavior Research and Therapy19(5):
425-434
.
43.
Minton, H.L.
and
McDonald, G.J.
(1984)
‘Homosexual Identity Formation as a Developmental Process’
, Journal of Homosexuality9(2-3):
91-104
.
Nestle, J.
, ed. (1992) The Persistent Desire.
Boston, MA: Alyson Publications
.
46.
Nestle, J.
(1998) A Fragile Union.
San Francisco, CA: Cleis
.
47.
O’Sullivan, S.
(1999)
‘I Don’t Want You Anymore: Butch/Femme Disappointments’
, Sexualities2(4):
465-473
.
48.
Patton, M.Q.
(1990) Evaluation and Research Method (2nd
edition).
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
49.
Rennie, D.L.
(2000)
‘Grounded Theory Methodology as Methodical Hermeneutics:
Reconciling Realism and Relativism’
, Theory and Psychology10(4):
481-502
.
50.
Rennie, D.L.
,
Phillips, J.R.
and
Quartaro, G.K.
(1988)
‘Grounded Theory: A Promising Approach to Conceptualization in Psychology?’
, Canadian Psychology29(2):
139-150
.
51.
Rifkin, L.
(2002)
‘The Suit Suits Whom? Lesbian Gender, Female Masculinity, and Women-in-Suits’
, Journal of Lesbian Studies6(2):
157-174
.
52.
Rubin, G.
(1992) ‘Of Catamites and Kings: Reflections on
Butch, Gender, and Boundaries’, in
J. Nestle
(ed.) The Persistent Desire, pp. 466-483.
Boston, MA: Alyson Publications
.
53.
Scholinski, D.
and
Adams, J.M.
(1997) The Last Time I Wore a Dress.
New York: Riverhead Books
.
54.
Singh, D.
,
Vidaurri, M.
,
Zambarano, R.J.
and
Dabbs, J.M., Jr
(1999)
‘Lesbian erotic role identification: Behavioral, morphological,
and hormonal correlates’
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology76(6):
1035-1049
.
Sophie, J.
(1985-86)
‘A Critical Examination of Stage Theories of Lesbian Identity Development’
, Journal of Homosexuality12(2):
39-51
.
57.
Strickland, B.R.
(1999)
‘Beauty and the Butch’
, Journal of Lesbian Studies3(4):
107-115
.
58.
Strickland, B.R.
(2002)
‘A Butch among the Belles’
, Journal of Lesbian Studies6(1):
75-84
.
59.
Swann, S.K.
(2001)
‘Understanding Lesbian Identity as a Phenomenon with Two Separate
but Inclusive Processes during Adolescence and Young Adulthood’,
dissertation, Smith College School for Social Work
, Dissertation Abstracts International62(4-A):
1585
.
60.
Troiden, R.R.
(1989)
‘The formation of homosexual identities’
, Journal of Homosexuality17(1-2):
43-73
.
61.
Unger, R.K.
and
Crawford, M.
(1993)
‘Commentary: Sex and Gender: The Troubled Relationship between
Terms and Concepts’
, Psychological Science4(2):
122-124
.
62.
Weston, K.
(1993)
‘“Do Clothes Make the Woman?” Gender
Performance Theory and Lesbian Eroticism’
, Genders17:
1-21
.
63.
Zevy, L.
(1999) ‘Sexing the Tomboy’,
in
M. Rottnek
(ed.) Sissies and Tomboys: Gender Nonconformity and Homosexual
Childhood, pp. 180-195.
New York: New York University Press
.
