In this article, we draw on critical race theory and critical race feminism to
deconstruct contemporary US welfare policy. The political framing of work
requirements, single motherhood, and ‘citizenship’ under the
Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 are used
to illustrate the racism, sexism, and classism that pervade current regulations.
Drawing on Hurtado’s (1996) conceptualization of the
‘Pendejo Game’, we argue that political elites feign
ignorance of poverty and structural inequities to legitimate policies that
maintain economic disparities. We conclude with suggestions for disrupting the
Pendejo Game and promoting economic justice.
Apfelbaum, E.
(1999)
‘Relations of Domination and Movements for Liberation: An
Analysis of Power Between Groups’ (abridged)
, Feminism and Psychology9(3):
267-272
.
2.
Appelbaum, L.D.
(2001)
‘The Influence of Perceived Deservingness on Policy Decisions
Regarding Aid to the Poor’
, Political Psychology22(3):
419-442
.
3.
Applied Research Center
(2002) ‘Welfare Reform as We Know
It’, accessed 25 November 2002. Available: http://www.arc.org.
4.
Avery, J.M.
and
Peffley, M.
(2003) ‘Race Matters: The Impact of News
Coverage of Welfare Reform on Public Opinion’, in
S.F. Schram
,
J. Soss
and
R.C. Fording
(eds) Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, pp.
131-150.
Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press
.
5.
Bashevkin, S.
(2000)
‘Rethinking Retrenchment: North American Social Policy During the
Early Clinton and Chretien Years’
, Canadian Journal of Political Science33(1):
7-36
.
6.
Berenson, A.
(2000)
‘The Case of the Instant Recession’
, The New York Times 31 December, Section 4:
10
.
7.
Berkowitz, B.
(2002) ‘Welfare Privatization: Prospecting Among
the Poor’, in
G. Delgado
(ed.) From Poverty to Punishment: How Welfare Reform Punishes the
Poor, pp. 73-88.
Oakland, CA: Applied Research Center
.
8.
Bloch, A. and Schuster, L. (eds) (2002)
‘Asylum and Welfare’ (special volume)
, Critical Social Policy22(3).
9.
Brownell, P.B.
(2001)
‘Border Militarization and the Reproduction of Mexican Migrant Labor’
, Social Justice28(2):
69-92
.
10.
Bullock, H.E.
(1995) ‘Class Acts: Middle Class Responses to
the Poor’, in
B. Lott
and
D. Maluso
(eds) The Social Psychology of Interpersonal Discrimination, pp.
118-159.
New York: Guilford Press
.
11.
Bullock, H.E.
and
Lott, B.
(2001)
‘Building a Research and Advocacy Agenda on Issues of Economic Justice’
, Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy1(1):
147-162
.
12.
Bullock, H.E.
,
Williams, W.R.
and
Limbert, W.M.
(2003)
‘Predicting Support for Welfare Policies: The Impact of
Attributions and Beliefs about Inequality’
, Journal of Poverty7(3):
35-56
.
13.
Bullock, H.E.
,
Wyche, K.F.
and
Williams, W.R.
(2001)
‘Media Images of the Poor’
, Journal of Social Issues57(2):
229-246
.
14.
Card, D.E.
and
Blank, R.M.
(2000) Finding Jobs: Work and Welfare Reform.
New York: Russell Sage Foundation
.
15.
Catanzarite, L.
and
Ortiz, V.
(1996) ‘Family Matters, Work Matters? Poverty
Among Women of Color and White Women’, in
D. Dujon
and
A. Wilthorn
(eds) For Crying Out Loud: Women’s Poverty in the United
States, pp. 121-139.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
16.
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
(2003) ‘Labor Market Conditions Worse than when
Temporary Federal Unemployment Benefits Program Created,
Extended’, accessed 2 October 2003. Available: http://www.cbpp.org/5-2-03ui.htm
17.
Center for Law and Social Policy
(2002) Reauthorization Issues: Reproductive Health
(‘Out of Wedlock Bonus’, publication number 01-32d) accessed 3
May 2005. Available: http://www.clasp.org/publications/out_of_wedlock.pdf.
18.
Cohen, A.
(1998, March 23)
‘When Wall Street Runs Welfare’
, Time151(11):
64
.
19.
Collins, P.H.
(1991) Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and
the Politics of Empowerment.
New York: Routledge
.
20.
Daniel, V.
(2002) ‘“The New World of
Welfare” Meets the New Welfare Rights Movement’, in
G. Delgado
(ed.) From Poverty to Punishment: How Welfare Reform Punishes the
Poor, pp. 209-216.
Oakland, CA: Applied Research Center
.
21.
Delgado, R.
and
Stefancic, J.
(2001) Critical Race Theory: An Introduction.
New York: New York University Press
.
22.
Dodson, L.
(1998) Don’t Call Us Out of Name: The Untold Lives
of Women and Girls in Poor America.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
23.
Domhoff, G.W.
(1998) Who Rules America? Power and Politics in the Year
2000 (3rd edition).
Mountain View, CA: Mayfield Publishing Company
.
24.
Dwyer, P.
(2002)
‘Making Sense of Social Citizenship: Some User Views on Welfare
Rights and Responsibilities’
, Critical Social Policy22(2):
273-299
.
25.
Edin, K.
and
Lein, L.
(1997) Making Ends Meet: How Single Mothers Survive Welfare
and Low-Wage Work.
New York: Russell Sage Foundation
.
26.
Ehrenreich, B.
(1990) Fear of Falling: The Inner Life of the Middle
Class.
New York: Perennial Library
.
27.
Ehrenreich, B.
(1997, August)
‘Spinning the Poor into Gold: How Corporations Seek to Profit
from Welfare Reform’
, Harper’s Magazine294(1767):
44-52
.
28.
Fairlie, R.W.
and
London, R.A.
(1997)
‘The Effect of Incremental Benefit Levels on Births to AFDC Recipients’
, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management16(4):
575-597
.
29.
Feldman, S.
and
Steenbergen, M.
(2001) ‘Social Welfare Attitudes and the
Humanitarian Sensibility’, in
J.H. Kuklinski
(ed.) Citizens and Politics: Perspectives from Political
Psychology, pp. 366-400.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
30.
Fine, M.
and
Weis, L.
(1998) The Unknown City: The Lives of Poor and Working-Class
Young Adults.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
31.
Fineman, M.A.
(1995) ‘Images of Mothers in Poverty
Discourse’, in
M.A. Fineman
and
I. Karpin
(eds) Mothers in Law: Feminist Theory and the Legal Regulation of
Motherhood, pp. 205-223.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
32.
Fiske, S.T.
,
Xu, J.
,
Cuddy, A.
and
Glick, P.
(1999)
‘(Dis)respecting versus (Dis)liking: Status and Interdependence
Predict Ambivalent Stereotypes of Competence and Warmth’
, Journal of Social Issues55(3):
473-489
.
33.
Fremstad, S.
(2002) ‘Immigrants and Welfare
Reauthorization’, accessed 6 February 2002. Available: http://www.cbpp.org/1-22-02tanf4.pdf.
34.
Gans, H.J.
(1995) The War Against the Poor.
New York: HarperCollins
.
35.
General Social Survey
(1972-96) ‘Cumulative Data File’,
accessed 25 November 2002. Available: http://sda.berkeley.edu.
36.
Gilens, M.
(1999) Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the
Politics of Antipoverty Policy.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
37.
Goodin, R.E.
(1998) ‘Social Welfare as a Collective Social
Responsibility’, in
D. Schmidtz
and
R.E. Goodin
(eds) Social Welfare and Individual Responsibility, pp.
97-195.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
38.
Gordon, L.
(1994) Pitied but not Entitled: Single Mothers and the
History of Welfare 1890-1935.
New York: Free Press
.
39.
Hall, L.
and
Strege-Flora, C.
(2002) ‘Access Denied’, in
G. Delgado
(ed.) From Poverty to Punishment: How Welfare Reform Punishes the
Poor, pp. 189-198.
Oakland, CA: Applied Research Center
.
40.
Handler, J.F.
and
Hasenfeld, Y.
(1991) The Moral Construction of Poverty: Welfare Reform in
America.
Newbury Park: Sage
.
41.
Handler, J.F.
and
White, L.
(1999) Hard Labor: Women and Work in the Post-Welfare
Era.
New York: M.E. Sharpe
.
42.
Harris (1992, June) IRSS Study Number S921204, accessed 25 November 2002.
Available: http://www.irss.unc.edu/data_archive/pollsearch.html.
43.
Harris (1994, December) IRSS Study Number S941107, accessed 25 November 2002.
Available: http://www.irss.unc.edu/data_archive/pollsearch.html.
44.
Harris National Study (2000, April) IRSS Study Number S12144, accessed 25
November 2002. Available: http://www.irss.unc.edu/data_archive/.
45.
Hart, M.
(2002, May)
‘From Welfare to Work’
, Congressional Record: H2517. Washington, DC:
US Government Printing Office.
46.
Hart, P.D.
(2002, March) ‘Study #6554: Jobs and Income
Support’, National Campaign for Jobs and Income Support
Memo.
Washington, DC: Peter D. Hart Research Associates
.
47.
Harwood, J.
(1997)
‘Locking Horns: EDS, Lockheed Duel Over Contract to Run
Texas’ Welfare System - Each Firm Forms an Alliance with a State
Agency, Promising Big Savings - the Battle with the Unions’
, Wall Street Journal 19 March:
A1
.
48.
Hays, S.
(2003) Flat Broke with Children: Women in the Age of Welfare
Reform.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
49.
Herger, W.
(2002)
‘Welfare Reform a Success’
, Chico Enterprise-Record 8 May:
10A
.
50.
Holland, J.
(2002)
‘GOP Wary of Immigrant Welfare Cut: Renewal of ’96 Law
has Political Cost’
, San Francisco Chronicle 12 May:
A1
.
51.
hooks, b.
(1981) Ain’t I a Woman: Black Women and
Feminism.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
52.
hooks, b.
(1984) Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
53.
hooks, b.
(2000) Feminism is for Everybody: Passionate Politics.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
54.
Horn, W.F.
(2000)
‘Using Welfare Money to Promote Marriage’
, Fatherly Advice, 4 April, accessed 25 November 2002.
Available: http://archives.his.com/smartmarriages/2000-April/msg00001
55.
Hughes, M.
and
Tuch, S.A.
(2000) ‘How Beliefs about Poverty Influence
Racial Policy Attitudes’, in
D.O. Sears
,
J. Sidanius
and
L. Bobo
(eds) Racialized Politics: The Debate about Racism in America, pp.
165-190.
Chicago: The University of Chicago Press
.
56.
Hurtado, A.
(1996) The Color of Privilege: Three Blasphemies on Race and
Feminism.
Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press
.
57.
Johnson, M.
(2003) ‘Racial Context, Public Attitudes, and
Welfare Effort in the American States’, in
S.F. Schram
,
J. Soss
and
R.C. Fording
(eds) Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, pp.
151-167.
Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press
.
58.
Johnston, D.C.
(2003)
‘Very Richest’s Share of Income Grew Even Bigger, Data Show’
, New York Times 26 June:
A1
.
59.
Kaplan, E.B.
(1997) Not Our Kind of Girl: Unraveling the Myths of Black
Teenage Motherhood.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
60.
Karger, H.J.
and
Stoesz, D.
(1993)
‘Retreat and Retrenchment: Progressives and the Welfare State’
, Social Work38(2):
212-220
.
61.
Katz, M.B.
(1986) In the Shadow of the Poorhouse: A Social History of
Welfare in America.
New York: Basic Books
.
62.
Katz, M.B.
(2001) The Price of Citizenship: Redefining the American
Welfare State.
New York: Metropolitan Books
.
63.
Keister, L.A.
and
Moller, S.
(2000)
‘Wealth Inequality in the United States’
, Annual Review of Sociology26:
63-81
.
64.
Lake, Snell, Perry
, and
Associates
(2002) Economic Stimulus, Welfare, and Minimum Wage:
Presentation on a Nationwide Survey of 800 Likely Voters, January 12-14,
2002, accessed 14 July 2004. Available: http://www.ms.foundation.org/user-assets/PDF/Program/final_lspa_report.pdf.
65.
Lens, V.
(2002)
‘Public Voices and Public Policy: Changing the Societal Discourse
on Welfare’
, Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare29(1):
137-155
.
66.
Lioz, A.
and
Cassady, A.
(2003, July) The Role of Money in the 2002 Congressional
Elections.
Washington, DC: US Public Interest Research Group
.
67.
Lopez, A.A. (2002) ‘From the Farms of West Central Mexico to
California’s Corporate Agribusiness: The Social Transformation of Two
Binational Farming Regions’, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University
of California, Santa Cruz.
68.
Lott, B.
(2002)
‘Cognitive and Behavioral Distancing from the Poor’
, American Psychologist57(2):
100-110
.
69.
Mandell, B.R.
(1999)
‘A Debate about Work: Ingram vs. Mandell’
, Survival News13(2), accessed 10 December 2002. Available: http://www.sojourner.org/welfareorganizingmediaproject/articles/survival/vol13no2/debate_bottom.html.
70.
Markus, G.B.
(2001) ‘American Individualism
Reconsidered’, in
J.H. Kuklinski
(ed.) Citizens and Politics: Perspectives from Political
Psychology, pp. 401-432.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
71.
Mink, G.
(1998) Welfare’s End.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
.
72.
Moffitt, R.A.
(ed.) (1998) Welfare, the Family, and Reproductive Behavior:
Research Perspectives.
Washington, DC: National Academy Press
.
73.
Neubeck, K.J.
and
Cazenave, N.A.
(2001) Welfare Racism: Playing the Race Card Against
America’s Poor.
New York: Routledge
.
74.
Newman, K.S.
(1993) Declining Fortunes: The Withering of the American
Dream.
New York: Harper Collins
.
75.
Newman, K.S.
(1999) No Shame in My Game: The Working Poor in the Inner
City.
New York: Sage
.
76.
O’Connor, B.
(2002)
‘Policies, Principles, and Polls: Bill Clinton’s Third
Way Welfare Politics 1992-1996’
, Australian Journal of Politics and History48(3):
396-411
.
77.
Office of Immigration Statistics
(2003) ‘Table 2: Immigration by Region and Selected
Country of Last Residence: Fiscal Years 1820-2002’, accessed 15
August 2003. Available: http://uscis.gov/graphics/shared/statistics/yearbook/IMM2002list.htm.
78.
Orloff, A.S.
(1993)
‘Gender and Social Rights of Citizenship: The Comparative
Analysis of Gender Relations and Welfare States’
, American Sociological Review58(3):
303-328
.
79.
Orloff, A.S.
(2002)
‘Explaining US Welfare Reform: Power, Gender, Race, and the US
Policy Legacy’
, Critical Social Policy22 (1):
96-118
.
80.
Parrott, S.
,
Fremstad, S.
and
Neuberger, Z.
(2002, August) ‘Key Issues in the House TANF
Reauthorization Bill’, accessed 18 August 2003. Available: http://www.cbpp.org.
81.
Pear, R.
(2002)
‘Democrats Hitch Stricter Welfare Work Rules to Child Care’
, New York Times 3 May:
A16
.
82.
Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, Pub.
L. No. 104-193, 110 Stat. 2105 (1997).
83.
Personal Responsibility, Work, and Family Promotion Act of 2002, H.R. 4090,
107th Cong. (2002).
84.
Personal Responsibility, Work, and Family Promotion Act of 2002, H.R. 4737,
107th Cong. (2002).
85.
Peterson, J.
,
Song, X.
and
Jones-DeWeever, A.
(2002, May) ‘Life After Welfare Reform: Low-Income
Single Parent Families, Pre- and Post-TANF’, accessed 15 August
2003. Available: http://www.iwpr.org.
86.
Phillips, K.P.
(2002) Wealth and Democracy: A Political History of the
American Rich.
New York: Broadway Books
.
87.
Piven, F.F.
and
Cloward, R.A.
(1993) Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public
Welfare (2nd edition).
New York: Random House
.
88.
Proctor, B.D.
and
Dalaker, J.
(2002, September) ‘Poverty in the United States:
2001’, accessed 29 September 2002. Available: http://www.census.gov/prod/2002pubs/p60-219.pdf.
89.
Quadagno, J.
(1994) The Color of Welfare: How Racism Undermined the War on
Poverty.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
90.
Riemer, F.J.
(2001) Working at the Margins: Moving off Welfare in
America.
Albany, NY: State University of New York Press
.
91.
Roberts, D.E.
(1995) ‘Racism and Patriarchy in the Meaning of
Motherhood’, in
M.A. Fineman
and
I. Karpin
(eds) Mothers in Law: Feminist Theory and the Legal Regulation of
Motherhood, pp. 224-249.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
92.
Rothman, R.A.
(2002) Inequality and Stratification: Race, Class and
Gender (4th edition).
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
93.
Sanger, M.B.
(2003) The Welfare Marketplace: Privatization and Welfare
Reform.
Washington, DC: Brookings Institution
.
94.
Savner, S.
,
Strawn, J.
and
Greenberg, M.
(2002, January) ‘TANF Reauthorization:
Opportunities to Reduce Poverty by Improving Employment
Outcomes’, accessed 6 February 2002. Available: http://www.clasp.org.
95.
Schlesing, A.
(2002)
‘Welfare Reformer Sees Woes in NLR’
, Arkansas Democrat-Gazette 11 May:
A1
.
96.
Schram, S.F.
(2002) Praxis for the Poor: Piven and Cloward and the Future
of Social Science in Social Welfare.
New York: New York University Press
.
97.
Schram, S.F.
and
Soss, J.
(2001)
‘Success Stories: Welfare Reform, Policy Discourse, and the
Politics of Research’
, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science577(1):
49-65
.
98.
Seccombe, K.
,
James, D.
and
Walters, K.B.
(1998)
‘“They Think You Ain’t Much of
Nothing”: The Social Construction of the Welfare Mother’
, Journal of Marriage and the Family60(4):
849-865
.
99.
Solot, D.
and
Miller, M.
(2002) ‘Let Them Eat Wedding
Rings’, accessed 4 February 2002. Available: http://www.unmarried.org/rings.html.
100.
Soss, J.
,
Schram, S.F.
,
Vartanian, T.P.
and
O’Brien, E.
(2001)
‘Setting the Terms of Relief: Explaining State Policy Choices in
the Devolution Revolution’
, American Journal of Political Science45(2):
378-395
.
101.
Sniderman, P.M.
,
Crosby, G.C.
and
Howell, W.G.
(2000) ‘The Politics of
Race’, in
D.O. Sears
,
J. Sidanius
and
L. Bobo
(eds) Racialized Politics: The Debate about Racism in America, pp.
236-279.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
102.
Sparks, H.
(2003) ‘Queens, Teens, and Model Mothers: Race,
Gender, and the Discourse of Welfare Reform’, in
S.F. Schram
,
J. Soss
and
R.C. Fording
(eds) Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, pp.
171-195.
Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press
.
103.
Steinitz, V.
and
Mishler, E.G.
(2001)
‘Reclaiming SPSSI’s Radical Promise: A Critical Look at
JSI’s “Impact of Welfare Reform” Issue’
, Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy1(1):
163-173
.
104.
US Census Bureau
(2002a) ‘Table 4. Poverty Status Status of
Families, by Type of Family, Presence of Related Children, Race, and Hispanic
Origin: 1959 to 2001’, accessed 10 December 2002. Available: http://www.census.gov/hhes/poverty/histpov/hstpov4.html.
105.
US Census Bureau
(2002b) ‘Table IE-6. Measures of Household Income
Inequality: 1967 to 2001’, accessed 30 September 2002.
Available: http://www.census.gov/hhes/income/histinc/ie6.html.
106.
US Government
(2002a) ‘President Announces Welfare Reform
Agenda’, accessed 7 March 2002. Available: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/02/print/20020226-11.html.
107.
US Government
(2002b) ‘Working Toward
Independence’, accessed 7 March 2002. Available http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/02/welfare-reform-announcement-book.pdf.
108.
US House of Representatives Committee on Ways and Means
(2000) Green Book (WMCP 106-14).
Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office
.
109.
Wikkering, B.
(2002)
‘Drop in Teen Birth Rate Could be Anticipated’
, San Diego Union Tribune 17 July:
B9
.
110.
Wilcox, B.L.
,
Robbennolt, J.K.
,
O’Keefe, J.E.
and
Pynchon, M.E.
(1996)
‘Teen Nonmarital Childbearing and Welfare: The Gap Between
Research and Political Discourse’
, Journal of Social Issues52(3):
71-90
.
111.
Williams, F.
(1987)
‘Racism and the Discipline of Social Policy: A Critique of
Welfare Theory’
, Critical Social Policy2(20):
4-29
.
112.
Williams, F.
(1989) Social Policy: A Critical Introduction: Issues of
Race, Gender, and Class.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
113.
Williams, F.
(2001)
‘In and Beyond New Labour: Towards a New Political Ethics of Care’
, Critical Social Policy21(4):
467-493
.
114.
Williams, F.
(2002)
‘The Presence of Feminism in the Future of Welfare’
, Economy and Society31(4):
502-519
.
115.
Wilson, W.J.
(1987) The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the
Underclass, and Public Policy.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
