This article describes and evaluates three different strands of theorizing European gender systems on a comparative basis. Each strand is associated with a particular concep tual, empirical and disciplinary context. The first strand, 'gendered welfare modelling' is centred around feminist critiques of compara tive social policy and seeks to add gender into the theorization of state welfare regimes. The second strand, 'differentiated patriarchy' is more sociological in origin and attempts to de velop the concept of patriarchy to take account of geographical differences. The final strand, developed in the context of feminist critiques of Scandinavian political science and social history, attempts to delineate different 'gender contracts' on what men and women are, think, expect and do. The paper criticizes all these theorizations for neglecting regional and local processes of gender differentiation, and con cludes that a combination of the 'differentiated patriarchy' and 'gender contract' strands hold the greater promise for accounting for geo graphical difference in systems of gender in equality.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bell, L. and Ribbens, J. (1994) Isolated housewives and complex material worlds: the significance of social contacts between women with young children in industrial societies, Sociological Review42(2).
2.
Borschorst, A. (1990) Political motherhood and child-care policies. a comparative approach to Britain and Scandinavia, in C. Ungerson (ed.) Women and Community Care Gender and Caring m Modern Welfare States , London, Wheatsheaf , pp. 160-79.
3.
Borschorst, A. (1994) Welfare state regime, women's interests and the EC, in D. Sainsbury Gendering Welfare States, London, Sage, Chapter 3.
4.
Bussemaker, J. and van Kersbergen, K. (1994) Gender and welfare states: some theoretical reflections, in D. Sainsbury (1994) Gendering Welfare States, London, Sage.
5.
Charles, N. (1993) Gender Divisions and Social Change , Hemel Hempstead, Harvester.
6.
Cochran, M., Larner, M., Riley, D., Gunnarsson, L. and Henderson, C.R. (1993) Extending Families the Social Networks of Families and their Children, Cambridge , Cambridge University Press.
7.
Cortesi, G. and Marengo, M. (1994) Women in the Italian workplace: evolution of a role, International Geographical Union, Study Group on Gender and Geography Working Paper 17, Newcastle, University of Newcastle.
8.
Daly, M. (1994) Comparing welfare states: towards a gender friendly approach, in D. Sainsbury Gendering Welfare States, London, Sage, Chapter 7.
9.
Deacon, B. (1992) The future of social policy in Eastern Europe , in B. Deacon, et al (eds) The New Eastern Europe Social Policy Past, Present and Future, London, Sage, Chapter 7.
10.
Duncan, S.S. (1989) Uneven development and the difference that space makes, Geoforum20 (2): 131-40.
11.
Duncan, S.S. (1991a) The geography of gender divisions of labour in Britain, Transactions InstBritish Geographers16. 420-39.
12.
Duncan, S.S. (1991b) Gender divisions of labour, in D. Green and K. Hoggart (eds) London: a New Metropolitan Geography , London, Unwin Hyman, pp. 95-122.
13.
Duncan, S.S. (1994a) Theorising differences in patriarchy, Environment and Planning A26(8): 1177-94.
14.
Duncan, S.S. (1994b) Women's and men's lives and work in Sweden: review article, Gender, Place and Culture1(2): 261-68.
15.
Duncan, S.S. (1995) The diverse worlds of European patriarchy, in D. Garcia-Ramon and J. Monk (eds) Women of the European Union. the Politics of Work and Daily Life, London, Routledge.
16.
Edwards, R. and Duncan, S.S. (1995) 'Rational economic man' or women in social context? Lone mothers, paid work and social policy, in E. Bortolala-Silva (ed.) Good Enough Mothering Feminist Perspectives on Lone Motherhood , London, Routledge.
17.
Esping-Anderon, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, London, Polity Press.
18.
Flowerdew, R. and Green, A. (1993) Migration, transport and workplace statistics from the 1991 census, in A. Dale and C. Marsh (eds) The 1991 Census Users' Guide, London, HMSO.
19.
Forsberg, G. (1994) Occupational sex segregration in a 'women friendly' society — the case of Sweden, Environment and Planning A26(8): 1235-56.
20.
Ginsburg, N. (1992) Divisions of Welfare. a Critical Introduction to Comparative Social Policy, London, Sage.
21.
Hakim, C. (1993) The myth of rising female employment, Work, Employment and Society7(1): 97-120.
22.
Hernes, H. (1987) Welfare State and Women Power, Oslo, Norwegian University Press.
23.
Hirdmann, Y. (1988) Genussystemet — reflexioner kring kvinnors socialaunderordning, Kvinnovetenskapligt Tidskrift3: 49-63.
24.
Hirdmann, Y. (1990a) Genussystemet, in Statens Offentliga Utredningar, Demokrati och Makt i Sverige, Stockholm, SOU.
25.
Hirdmann, Y. (1990b) Att Lagga Livet till Ratta studier i svensk folkhemspolitik , Stockholm, Carlssons.
26.
Kytir, J. (1992) Zwischen 'vermodern' and 'post-modern' - familiengrundungen in Osterreich, 1984 bis 1990, Zeitschrift fur Bevolkerungswissenschaft18(1): 117-33.
27.
Langan, M. and Ostner, I. (1991) Gender and welfare: towards a comparative framework , in G. Room, Towards a European Welfare State?, Bristol, School for Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, pp. 127-50.
28.
Leibfried, S. (1993) Towards a European welfare state?, in C. Jones (ed.) New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe , London, Routledge , pp. 133-50.
29.
Leira, A. (1992) Welfare States and Working Mothers the Scandinavian experience, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
30.
Lewis, J. (1992) Gender and the development of welfare regimes , Journal of European Social Policy2(3): 159-73.
31.
McDowell, L. and Massey, D. (1984) A woman's place?, in D. Massey and J. Allen (eds) Geography Matters Milton Keynes, Open University Press, pp. 195-215.
32.
McLaughlin, E. and Glendinning, C. (1994) Paying for care in Europe: is there a feminist approach?, in L. Hantrais and S. Morgan (eds) Family Policy and the Welfare of Women, Cross-National Research Papers, Third Series, 3, Loughborough, European Research Centre, University of Loughborough.
33.
Makkai, T. (1994) Social policy and gender in Eastern Europe, in D. Sainsbury Gendering Welfare States London, Sage, Chapter 12.
34.
Mark-Lawson, J. (1988) Occupational segregation and women's politics , in S. Walby (ed.) Gender Segregation at Work , Milton Keynes, Open University Press.
35.
Mark-Lawson, J., Savage, M. and Wade, A. (1985) Gender and local politics: struggle over welfare policies 1918-1939, in L. Murgatroyd, M. Savage, D. Shapiro, J. Urry, S. Walby and A. Warde (eds) Locality, Class and Gender , London, Pion.
36.
Massey, D. (1984) Spatial Divisions of Labour, London, Macmillan.
37.
Orloff, A.S. (1993) Gender and the social rights of citizenship: the comparative analysis of gender relations and welfare states, American Sociological Review58(3): 303-8.
38.
Ostner, I. (1994) The women and welfare debate, in L. Hantrais and S. Morgan (eds) Family Policy and the Welfare of Women , Cross-National Research Papers, Third Series, 3, Loughborough , European Research Centre, University of Loughborough.
39.
Perrons, D. (1994) Measuring equal opportunities in European employment , Environment and Planning A26(8): 1195-1220.
40.
Pfau-Effinger, B., (1994) The 'gender contract' and part-time work by women: Finland and West Germany compared, Environment and Planning A26(9): 1257-76.
41.
Quack, S. and Maier, F. (1994) From state socialism to market economy: women's employment in East Germany, Environment and Planning A26: 1257-76.
42.
Sackmann, R. and Haussermann, H. (1994) Do regions matter? Regional differences in female labour market participation in Germany, Environment and Planning A271377-97.
43.
Townsend, A. (1986) Spatial effects of the growth of part-time employment in Britain, Regional Studies20: 313-30.
44.
Sayer, R.A. (1984) Methods m Social Science a Realist Approach , London, Hutchinson.
45.
Sayer, R.A. and Walker, R. (1992) The New Social Economy Reworking the Division of Labour, Oxford, Blackwell.
46.
Siaroff, A. (1994) Work, welfare and gender equality: a new typology , in D. Sainsbury Gendering Welfare States, London , Sage.
47.
Viazzo, P. (1989) Upland Communities: Environment, Population and Social Structure in the Alps since the Sixteenth Century, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
48.
Walby, S. (1986) Patriarchy at Work: Patriarchal and Capitalist Relations m Employment, Cambridge, Policy Press.
49.
Walby, S. (1990) Theorising Patriarchy, Oxford , Basil Blackwell.
50.
Walby, S. (1994) Methodological and theoretical issues in the comparative analysis of gender relations in western Europe, Environment and Planning A27(9): 1339-54.
51.
Williams, F. (1995) Race, ethnicity, gender and class in welfare states. a framework for comparative analysis, in Social Politics International Studies m Gender, States and Society2(2): 127-159.
