Implicit and Explicit Social Policy in the Czech and Slovak Personal Tax Systems

Abstract

We show that the old Czechoslovak personal tax system was opaque, inequitable and neg lected adverse incentive effects, because in large part it was being used as an instrument of social policy to encourage family formation, growth and support. We also show that because the old system's distribution effects can be generated by a simple linear tax system, its extraordinary complexity was entirely unnecessary. An analysis of the new direct tax systems of the Czech Republic and Slovakia show that they are both more progressive than their predecessors, and yet still retain some reduced influences of the now less emphasized pro-natalist policy. The new tax and benefit arrangements of the Czech Republic are incor porated in a tax-benefit model which is used to show that the variety of household preferences and circumstances within any group - social, income or geographical is such that even minor revenue-neutral changes can produce unex pected distributional results which social policy advisors and analysts need to consider.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson, A.B. and Micklewright, J. (1992) Economic Transformation in Eastern Europe and the Distribution of Income, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Bartová, I. (1992) European Value System Study: CSFR 1991 First Look into the Data, Prague, Department of Sociology and Social Policy, School of Social Sciences, Charles University.

Coulter, F. , Heady, C. , Lawson, C. and Smith, S. (1993) Simplifying the Czechoslovak personal income tax , Prague Economic Papers 2(2): 131-46.

Coulter, F. , Heady, C. , Lawson, C. , Smith, S. and Stark, G. (1994a) Microsimulation modelling of personal taxation and social security benefits in the Czech Republic, Mimeo, University of Bath. Forthcoming, OECD, Paris.

Coulter, F. , Heady, C. , Lawson, C. and Smith, S. (1994b) Fiscal systems in transition: the case of the Czech income tax, Mimeo, University of Bath. Forthcoming in Europe-Asia Studies.

Coulter, F. , Heady, C. , Lawson, C. and Smith, S. (1995) The reform of social support and pensions in the Czech Republic: budgetary, incentive and distributional implications, Mimeo , University of Bath

Czech Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs ( 1993a) Draft Principles of the Law on State Social Support

Deacon, B. (ed.) (1992a) Social Policy, Social Justice and Citizenship in Eastern Europe, Aldershot, Avebury.

Deacon, B. (ed.) (1992b) Eastern Europe in the 1990s Past Developments and Future Prospects for Social Policy, London, Sage.

10.

Government of the Slovak Republic (1992) Programmatic Declaration of the Government of the Slovak Republic

11.

Heady, C. , Rajah, N. and Smith, S. (1994) Tax reform and economic transition in the Czech Republic, Fiscal Studies 15(1): 64-80.

12.

Halásek, D. (1994) Social Welfare Policy m the Czech Republic, University Council for Economic and Man agement Education Transfer, Working Paper 2, Krakow.

13.

Holzman, F.D. (1962) Soviet Taxation, Cambridge , Mass., Harvard University Press.

14.

Kamenicková, V. (1990) Tax system in Czechoslovakia, Paper prepared for the First Joint Workshop on Tax Structure and Public Finance, Institute of Economics, Prague, 17 September 1990

15.

Newcity, M.A. (1986) Taxation in the Soviet Union, New York, Praeger.

16.

Potucek, M. (1993) Current social policy developments in the Czech and Slovak Republics, Journal of European Social Policy 3(3) 209-26.

17.

Rys, V. ( 1993) Social security reform in central Europe: issues and strategies, Journal of European Social Policy 3(3): 163-75.

18.

Slovak Ministry of Labour, Social Affairs and the Family (1993) Social Policy of the Slovak Republic

19.

Vecerník, J. (1991) Uvod do studia chudoby v Ceskoslovensku, (Introduction to the Study of Poverty in Czechoslovakia), Sociolgick y časopis 27(5): 577-602.

20.

Wanless, P.T. (1985) Taxation in Centrality Planned Economies, London, Croom Helm.