Activation measures have assumed a prominent role within policy perspectives aimed at increasing labour market participation to support welfare sustainability. Most comparative studies on active labour market policies (ALMPs) have been conducted at the national level, although several scholars recently stressed the need to consider more carefully the territorial dimension of social policies. This article addresses this research gap by providing quantitative estimates of the territorial effect of national ALMPs provision on youth employment in European regions. We find that regional contextual traits, which can present a variety of configurations, play a significant role in moderating the effects of ALMPs. Divergent outcomes per type and level of education also highlight the complexity of the landscape for ALMPs’ design and implementation. Our analysis helps identify the institutional and contextual conditions that require evaluation when designing and implementing policies targeting young people.
AbrassartA (2015) Low-skill jobs or jobs for low-skilled workers? An analysis of the institutional determinants of the employment rates of low-educated workers in 19 OECD countries, 1997-2010. Journal of European Social Policy25(2): 225–241.
2.
BacherJKoblbauerCLeitgöbH, et al. (2017) Small differences matter: how regional distinctions in educational and labour market policy account for heterogeneity in NEET rates. Journal for Labour Market Research51(4): 20–51.
3.
BassaniniADuvalR (2006) Employment patterns in OECD countries: reassessing the role of policies and institutions. In: OECD Economics Department Working Papers 486. Paris: OECD Publishing.
4.
BellDNBlanchflowerDG (2011) Young people and the great recession. Oxford Review of Economic Policy27(2): 241–267.
5.
BendaLKosterFvan der VeenR (2019) Levelling the playing field? Active labour market policies, educational attainment and unemployment. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy39(3/4): 276–295.
6.
BendaLKosterFVan Der VeenR (2020) Activation is not a panacea: active labour market policy, long-term unemployment and institutional complementarity. Journal of Social Policy49(3): 483–506.
7.
BengtssonMde la PorteCJacobssonK (2017) Labour market policy under conditions of permanent austerity: any sign of social investment?Social Policy and Administration51(2): 367–388.
8.
BonoliG (2013) The Origins of Active Social Policy. Labour Market and Childcare Policies in a Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
9.
BonoliGLiechtiF (2018) Good intentions and Matthew effects: access biases in participation in active labour market policies. Journal of European Public Policy25(6): 894–911.
10.
BonoliGTreinP (2022) National–regional–local shifting games in multi-tiered welfare states. In: KazepovYCuccaRBarberisE, et al. (eds) Handbook of Urban Social Policy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 250–265.
11.
BonoliGCantillonBVan LanckerW (2017) Social investment and the Matthew effect: limits to a strategy. In: HemerijckA (ed) The Uses of Social Investment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 66–76.
12.
BrunoGMarelliESignorelliM (2014) The rise of NEET and youth unemployment in EU regions after the crisis. Comparative Economic Studies56(4): 592–615.
13.
CaliendoMSchmidlR (2016) Youth unemployment and active labor market policies in Europe. IZA Journal of Labor Policy5(1): 1–30.
14.
Capsada-MunsechQValienteO (2020) Sub-national variation of skill formation regimes: a comparative analysis of skill mismatch across 18 European regions. European Education52(2): 166–179.
15.
CardDKluveJWeberA (2018) What works? A meta analysis of recent active labor market program evaluations. Journal of the European Economic Association16(3): 894–931.
16.
CaroleoFERoccaAMazzocchiP, et al. (2020) Being NEET in Europe before and after the economic crisis: an analysis of the micro and macro determinants. Social Indicators Research149(3/10): 991–1024.
17.
CefaloRScandurraR (2021) Territorial disparities in youth labour market chances in Europe. Regional Studies, Regional Science8(1): 228–238.
18.
CefaloRScandurraRKazepovY (2020) Youth labor market integration in European regions. Sustainability12(9): 3813.
19.
CicciaRJavornikJ (2019) Methodological challenges for comparative welfare state research: capturing intra-country variation in cross-national analyses. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice21(1): 1–8.
20.
ClasenJCleggDGoerneA (2016) Comparative social policy analysis and active labour market policy: putting quality before quantity. Journal of Social Policy45(1): 21–38.
21.
CrouchCGalesPLTrigiliaC, et al. (2004) Changing Governance of Local Economies: Responses of European Local Production Systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
DaigneaultPMMacéC (2020) Program awareness, administrative burden, and non-take-up of Québec’s supplement to the work premium. International Journal of Public Administration43(6): 527–539.
23.
DaigneaultPMBirchLBélandD, et al. (2021) Taking subnational and regional welfare states seriously: insights from the Quebec case. Journal of European Social Policy31(2): 239–249.
24.
DalzielP (2015) Regional skill ecosystems to assist young people making education employment linkages in transition from school to work. Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit30(1): 53–66.
25.
De DekenJ (2017) Conceptualizing and measuring social investment. In: HemerijckA (ed) The Uses of Social Investment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 184–193.
26.
de LangeMGesthuizenMWolbersMHJ (2014) Youth labour market integration across Europe. European Societies16(2): 194–212.
27.
Di CataldoMRodríguez-PoseA (2017) What drives employment growth and social inclusion in the regions of the European Union?Regional Studies51(12): 1840–1859.
28.
DiemerAIammarinoSRodríguez-PoseA, et al. (2022) The regional development trap in Europe. Economic Geography98(5): 487–509.
29.
DijkstraLPoelmanHRodríguez-PoseA (2020) The geography of EU discontent. Regional Studies54(6): 737–753.
30.
EscuderoV (2018) Are active labour market policies effective in activating and integrating low-skilled individuals? An international comparison. IZA Journal of Labor Policy7(1): 1–26.
31.
FouargeDSchilsTde GripA (2013) Why do low-educated workers invest less in further training?Applied Economics45(18): 2587–2601.
32.
FratesiUWishladeFG (2017) The impact of European cohesion policy in different contexts. Regional Studies51(6): 817–821.
33.
FusaroSScandurraR (2023) The impact of the European social fund on youth education and employment. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences88: 101650. ISSN 0038-0121.
34.
GarritzmannJLHäusermannSPalierB (2022) Social investments in the knowledge economy: the politics of inclusive, stratified, and targeted reforms across the globe. Social Policy and Administration57(1): 87–101.
35.
GesthuizenMSolgaHKunsterR (2011) Context matters: economic marginalization of low-educated workers in cross-national perspective. European Sociological Review27(2): 264–280.
36.
GreerSElliottHOliverR (2015) Differences that matter: overcoming methodological nationalism in comparative social policy research. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice17(4): 408–429.
37.
GrottiRRussellHO’ReillyJ (2018) Where do young people work? In: O’ReillyJLeschkeJOrtliebR, et al. (eds) Youth Labor in Transition: Inequalities, Mobility, and Policies in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
HalvorsenRHvindenB (eds) (2018) Youth, Diversity and Employment: Comparative Perspectives on Labour Market Policies. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
39.
HerdPMoynihanDP (2019) Administrative Burden: Policymaking by Other Means. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
40.
HodgsonASpoursK (2015) Tackling the crisis facing young people: building ‘high opportunity progression eco-systems’. Oxford Review of Education39(2): 211–228.
41.
HoraOSirovátkaT (2020) Why targeting matters: the apprenticeship program for youth in the Czech Republic. Social Policy and Administration54(7): 1198–1214.
42.
IammarinoSRodriguez-PoseAStorperM (2019) Regional inequality in Europe: evidence, theory and policy implications. Journal of Economic Geography19(2): 273–298.
43.
ImZJShinY-K (2022) Who gets labour market training? Access biases of social investment in Finland. Journal of European Social Policy32(1): 3–18.
44.
JefferyCSchakelA (2013) Editorial: towards a regional political science. Regional Studies47(3): 299–302.
45.
KazepovY (ed) (2010) Rescaling Social Policies: Towards Multilevel Governance in Europe. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing.
46.
KazepovYBarberisE (2013) Social assistance governance in Europe: towards a multilevel perspective. In: MarxINelsonK (eds) Minimum Income Protection in Flux. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 217–248.
47.
KazepovYCefaloR (2022) The territorial dimension of social investment in Europe. In: KazepovYCuccaRBarberisE, et al. (eds) Handbook of Urban Social Policy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 55–71.
48.
KazepovYRanciC (2017) Is every country fit for social investment? Italy as an adverse case. Journal of European Social Policy27(1): 90–104.
49.
KazepovYCuccaRBarberisE, et al. (eds) (2022) Handbook of Urban Social Policy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
50.
KeatingM (2021a) Beyond the nation-state: territory, solidarity and welfare in a multiscalar Europe. Territory, Politics, Governance9(3): 331–345.
51.
KeatingM (2021b) Rescaling Europe, rebounding territory: a political approach. Regional and Federal Studies31(1): 31–50.
52.
KingRWilliamsAM (2019) Editorial introduction: new European youth mobilities. Population, Space and Place24(1): 1–9.
53.
KluveJ (2010) The effectiveness of European active labor market programs. Labour Economics17(6): 904–918.
54.
KluveJPuertoSRobalinoD, et al. (2017) Interventions to improve the labour market outcomes of youth: a systematic review of training, entrepreneurship promotion, employment services and subsidized employment interventions. Campbell Systematic Reviews13(1): 1–288.
55.
KnizeVJWolfMZabelC (2021) Do disadvantaged young adults benefit less from social investment? Studying Matthew effects in activation measures. Youth and Globalization3(1): 13–55.
56.
KuittoK (2016) From social security to social investment? Compensating and social investment welfare policies in a life-course perspective. Journal of European Social Policy26(5): 442–459.
57.
LødemelITrickeyH (eds) (2001) ‘An Offer You Can’t Refuse’: Workfare in International Perspective. Bristol: Policy Press.
58.
Lo PianoSBorgonovoEPuyA, et al. (2022) Improving the reliability of cohesion policy databases. PLoS One17(4): e0266823. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0266823.
59.
MorelNPalierBPalmeJ (eds) (2012) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges. Bristol: Policy Press.
60.
NordlundM (2011) Who are the lucky ones? Heterogeneity in active labour market policy outcomes. International Journal of Social Welfare20(2): 144–155.
61.
O’ReillyJEichhorstWGábosA, et al. (2015) Five characteristics of youth unemployment in Europe: flexibility, education, migration, family legacies, and EU policy. Sage Open5(1): 1–19.
62.
PastoreF (2019) Why so slow? The school-to-work transition in Italy. Studies in Higher Education44(8): 1358–1371.
63.
PlavgoIHemerijckA (2021) The social investment litmus test: family formation, employment and poverty. Journal of European Social Policy31(3): 282–296.
64.
PrenzelPIammarinoS (2021) Labor force aging and the composition of regional human capital. Economic Geography97(2): 140–163.
65.
RaffeD (2014) Explaining national differences in education–work transitions. European Societies16(2): 175–193.
66.
RamblaXScandurraR (2021) Is the distribution of NEETs and early leavers from education and training converging across the regions of the European Union?European Societies23(5): 563–589.
67.
Rodríguez-PoseA (2018) The revenge of the places that don’t matter (and what to do about it). Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society11(1): 189–209.
68.
RoggeNSelfR (2019) Measuring regional social inclusion performances in the EU: looking for unity in diversity. Journal of European Social Policy29(3): 325–344.
69.
SabatinelliSSemprebonM (2017) The vertical division of responsibility for social services within and beyond the state: issues in empowerment, participation and territorial cohesion. In: AnttonenAMätzkeM (eds) Social Services Disrupted. Changes, Challenges and Policy Implications for Europe in Times of Austerity. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 114–133.
70.
SahnounMAbdennadherC (2018) The assessment of active labor market policies: evidence from OECD countries. Economia Politica35(2): 257–283.
71.
ScaliseGHemerijckA (2022) Subnational social investment in three European cities: an exploratory comparison. Journal of Social Policy; 1–21.
72.
ScandurraRHermannssonKCefaloR (2020) Assessing young adults’ living conditions across Europe using harmonised quantitative indicators: opportunities and risks for policy-makers. In: Parreira Do AmaralMKovachevaSRamblaX (eds) Lifelong Learning Policies for Young Adults in Europe: Navigating between Knowledge and Economy. Bristol: Policy Press.
73.
ScandurraRCefaloRKazepovY (2021a) School to work outcomes during the Great Recession, is the regional scale relevant for young people's life chances?Journal of Youth Studies24(4): 441–465.
74.
ScandurraRCefaloRKazepovY (2021b) Drivers of youth labour market integration across European regions. Social Indicators Research154: 835–856.
75.
SengenbergerW (2011) Beyond the Measurement of Unemployment and Underemployment. ILO Working Paper. Geneva: International Labour Organization.
76.
SergiVCefaloRKazepovY (2018) Young people's disadvantages on the labour market in Italy: reframing the NEET category. Journal of Modern Italian Studies23(1): 41–60.
77.
SforziFAminA (eds) (2018) The Institutions of Local Development. Abingdon: Routledge.
78.
SimõesF (2022) School to Work Transition in the Resilience and Recovery Facility Framework. Brussels: European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS).
79.
SpeckesserSSGonzalez CarrerasFJKirchner SalaL (2019) Active labour market policies for young people and youth unemployment. International Journal of Manpower40(8): 1510–1534.
80.
StorperM (2018) Separate worlds? Explaining the current wave of regional economic polarization. Journal of Economic Geography18(2): 247–270.
81.
SykesO (2008) The importance of context and comparison in the study of European spatial planning. European Planning Studies16(4): 537–555.
82.
TomićI (2018) What drives youth unemployment in Europe? Economic vs non‐economic determinants. International Labour Review157(3): 379–408.
83.
TosunJUntMWadensjöE (2017) Youth-oriented active labour market policies: explaining policy effort in the Nordic and the Baltic states. Social Policy and Administration51(4): 598–616.
84.
WaplerRWolfKWolffJ (2022) Do active labor market policies for welfare recipients in Germany raise their regional outflow into work?Journal of Policy Modeling44(3): 550–563.
85.
ZwiersMKosterF (2015) The local structure of the welfare state: uneven effects of social spending on poverty within countries. Urban Studies52(1): 87–102.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
