We present and discuss a replication and reassessment of the welfare-state decommodification index, and introduce a new, publicly available data set of key welfare-state programme characteristics. Using the same programme features used to create the ‘decommodification index’ in The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, one of the most widely cited sources in the field, we are able to replicate the results quite closely. However, our investigation suggests a number of likely errors in the original formulation. Once these are accounted for, we find very limited empirical support for the ‘three worlds’ typology in the decommodification data. Though some clear differences remain, there is also much less overall variation among countries. Furthermore, there is little evidence of ‘clustering’ among programme scores, a finding which is at odds with the idea of distinctive national regimes. Our results point to the need for a detailed re-investigation of welfare-state benefits in advanced industrial democracies. Our data set helps to provide a basis for such an assessment.
Adema, W. (1998) ‘Uncovering Real Social Spending’ , The OECD Observer211 (April/May).
2.
Adema, W. (2001) ‘New Social Expenditure’, 2nd edn, Labour and Social Policy Occasional Papers No. 52. Paris: OECD .
3.
Allan, J. and Scruggs, L. (2004) ‘Political Partisanship and Welfare State Reform in Advanced Industrial Societies’ , American Journal of Political Science48 (3): 496-512 .
4.
Arts, W. and Gelissen, J. (2002) ‘Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism or More?’ , Journal of European Social Policy12 (2): 137-158 .
5.
Carroll, E. (1999) ‘Emergence and Structuring of Social Insurance Institutions: Comparative Studies on Social Policy and Unemployment Insurance’, Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Sociology, Stockholm University (1999). Stockholm: Akademitryck AB.
6.
Castles, F. (1998) Comparative Public Policy: Patterns of Post-war Transformation. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar .
7.
Castles, F. (2001) ‘Reflections on the Methodology of Comparative Type Construction: Three Worlds or Real Worlds?’ , Acta Politica36 (Summer): 141-154 .
8.
Castles, F. (2004a) The Future of the Welfare State - Crisis Myths and Crisis Realities. New York: Oxford University Press .
9.
Castles, F. (2005) ‘Social Spending in the 1990s: Data and Determinants’ , Policy and Politics33(3): 411-430 .
10.
Castles, F. and Mitchell, D. (1993) ‘Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism or Four?’, in F. Castles (ed.) Families of Nations. Brookfield, VT: Dartmouth .
11.
Crepaz, M. (1998) ‘Inclusion Versus Exclusion: Political Institutions and Welfare Expenditures’ , Comparative Politics31 (1): 61-80 .
12.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
13.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1999) The Social Foundations of Post-industrial Economies. New York: Oxford .
14.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1997) ‘Hybrid or Unique? The Distinctiveness of the Japanese Welfare state’ , Journal of European Social Policy7(3).
15.
FaCS (Australia Family and Community Services) (n.d.) Income Support Customers: a Statistical Overview 1999. Canberra: Australia Family and Community Services . Accessed on 30.9.2004 at: [http://www.facs.gov.au/internet/facsinternet.nsf/aboutfacs/income_support_customers.htm].
16.
Ferrera, M. (1987) ‘Italy’, in P. Flora (ed.) Growth to Limits: the Western European Welfare States since World War Two. New York: Walter de Gruyter .
17.
Gal, J. (2004) ‘Decommodification and Beyond: a Comparative Analysis of Work-injury Programmes’ , Journal of European Social Policy14 (1): 55-69 .
18.
Green-Pedersen, C. and Haverland, M. (2002) ‘The New Politics of the Welfare State and the New Scholarship of the Welfare State’ , Journal of European Social Policy12 (2): 243-251 .
19.
Hicks, A. (1999) Social Democracy and Welfare Capitalism: a Century of Income Security Politics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
20.
Hicks, A. and Kenworthy, L. (2003) ‘Varieties of Welfare Capitalism’Socioeconomic Review1: 27-61 .
21.
Huber, E. and Stephens, J. (2002) Development and Crisis of the Welfare State. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
22.
Huber, E. , Ragin, C. and Stephens, J. (1993) ‘Social Democracy Christian Democracy Constitutional Structure and the Welfare State’ , American Journal of Sociology99 (3): 711-749 .
23.
Iversen, T. (1998) ‘Wage Bargaining, Hard Money and Economic Performance: Theory and Evidence for Organized Market Economies’ , British Journal of Political Science28 (1): 31-61 .
24.
Kangas, O. (1991) ‘Politics of Social Rights: Studies in the Dimensions of Sickness Insurance in OECD Countries’, Swedish Institute for Social Research Dissertation Series number 19.
25.
Kenworthy, L. (1999) ‘Do Social-welfare Policies Reduce Poverty? A Cross-national Assessment’ , Social Forces77 (3): 119-139 .
26.
Kitschelt, H. (2001) ‘Partisan Competition and Welfare State Retrenchment: When do Politicians Choose Unpopular Policies?’, in P. Pierson (ed.) The New Politics of the Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
27.
Korpi, W. and Palme, J. (2003) ‘New Politics and Class Politics in the Context of Austerity and Globalisation’ , American Political Science Review97 (3): 425-446 .
28.
Maguire, M. (1987) ‘Ireland’, in P. Flora (ed.) Growth to Limits: the Western European Welfare States since World War Two. New York: Walter de Gruyter .
29.
Messner, S. and Rosenfeld, R. (1997) ‘Political Restraint of the Market and Levels of Criminal Homicide: a Cross-national Application of Institutional-anomie Theory’ , Social Forces75 (4): 1393-1416 .
30.
Ministry of Social Development (New Zealand) (2003) The Statistical Report for the Year Ending June 2002. Wellington: Ministry of Social Development .
31.
Mitchell, N. (1996) ‘Theoretical and Empirical Issues in the Comparative Measurement of Union Power and Corporatism’ , British Journal of Political Science26 (3): 419-428 .
32.
Nordic Social Statistical Committee (2003) Social Protection in the Nordic Countries 2001: Scope, Expenditures Financing. Copenhagen: NOSOSCO .
33.
Orloff, S. (1993) ‘Gender and Social Rights of Citizenship: the Comparative Analysis of Gender Relations and Welfare States’ , American Sociological Review58 (3): 303-329 .
34.
Palme, J. (1990) ‘ Pension Rights in Welfare Capitalism. The Development of Old-age Pensions in 18 OECD Countries 1930 to 1985’, dissertation. Stockholm University: Swedish Institute for Social Research.
35.
Pampel, F. and Gartner R. (1995) ‘Age Structure Socio-Political Institutions and National Homicide Rates’ , European Sociological Review11: 243-260 .
36.
Pampel, F. and Willliamson, J. (2001) ‘Age Patterns of Suicide and Homicide Mortality Rates in High Income Countries’ , Social Forces80 (1): 251-282 .
37.
Powell, M. and Barrientos R. (2004) ‘Welfare Regimes and the Welfare Mix’ , European Journal of Political Research43(1): 83-105 .
38.
Radcliff, B. (2001) ‘Politics Markets and Life Satisfaction: the Political Economy of Human Happiness’ , American Political Science Review95 (4): 939-952 .
39.
Room, G. (2000) ‘Commodification and Decommodification: a Developmental Critique’ , Policy and Politics28 (3): 331-351 .
40.
Shalev, M. (2002) ‘Limits and Alternatives to Multiple Regressions in Comparative Political Economy’, unpublished manuscript. Accessed on 21.3.2005 at: [http://www.geocities.com/michaelshalev/Papers/ShalevRegressionOct2002.pdf].
