Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The importance to environmental policy of improving energy efficiency is now widely agreed. It is also well established that levels of energy efficiency are below the optimum for economic efficiency, i.e. there are market barriers to energy efficiency. Neo-c1assical economic theory provides a taxonomy of the barriers in terms of market failure and can evaluate short term policy options to address them. However, this paradigm does not explain the underlying causes or why all the market failures act in the direction of lower energy efficiency. Economic analysis alone cannot identify long term, sustainable approaches to removing the barriers; input is needed from other disciplines. A review of the multi-disciplinary literature identifies some common elements in the nature of the barriers: a dichotomy between producers and consumers, centralisation in energy supply and planning, a commodity view of energy, and complexity of energy efficiency markets. It is concluded that these are fundamental characteristics of energy use in a modem economy. They constitute a meta-barrier - a framework in which the other barriers can be described. Barriers to energy efficiency therefore remain deeply entrenched and, in the short term, optimisation of energy efficiency is unlikely. However, future changes in technology, market structures and institutions may open new opportunities to address the fundamental problems in the longer term.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

(1993) Energy Efficiency Policies. Routledge, London.

Audit Commission (1990) Cutting Energy Consumption in Local Government. Occasional

Paper II. Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales.

Bijker,

(1992) “The Social Construction of Fluorescent Lighting”, in Bijker,

and Law.

(eds.) Shaping Technology/Building Society. Studies in Socio-Technical Change. MIT Press, Cambridge MA.

Blumstein,

and Stoft,

S.E.

(1995) Technical efficiency, production functions and conservation supply curves. Energy Policy 23 (9) 765-768.

Boardman,

(1991) Fuel Poverty. Belhaven Press, London.

Boardman,

(1994) “Energy Efficiency Measures and Social Inequality”, in Bhatti,

, Brooke,

and Gibson,

(eds.) Housing and the Environment: A New Agenda. Chartered Institute of Housing, London.

Boyle,

(1996) DSM Progress and Lessons in the Global Context. Energy Policy 24 (4) 345360.

Calion,

(1987) “Society in the Making - the Study of Technology as a Tool for Sociological Analysis”, in Bijker,

, Hughes,

T.P.

and Pinch,

(eds.) The Social Construction of Technological Systems. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.

10.

Cebon,

P.B.

(1992) Twixt Cup and Lip - Organisational Behaviour, Technical Prediction and Conservation Practice. Energy Policy 20 802-814.

11.

CEC (1991) Commission of the European Communities. Cost Effectiveness Analysis of CO2 Reduction Options. CEC, Brussels.

12.

CEC (1995) Commission of the European Communities. Extern E: Externalities of Energy. Volume I. Summary Report. EUR 16520 EN. CEC, Brussels.

13.

Coltrane,

, Archer,

and Aronson,

(1986) The Social-Psychological Foundations of Successful Energy Conservation Programmes. Energy Policy 14 [33-148.

14.

Cowan,

R.S.

(1987) “The Consumption Junction: a Proposal for Research Strategies in the Sociology of Technology”, in Bijker,

, Hughes,

T.P.

and Pinch,

(eds.) The Social Construction of Technological Systems. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.

15.

De Canio

. (1993) Barriers within Firms to Energy Efficient Investments. Energy Policy 21 906-914.

16.

Donnison,

(1994) Act Local: Social Justicefrom the Bottom Up. IPPR. London.

17.

Ekins,

(1994) “Revisiting the Costs of CO2 abatement”, in Barker,

, Ekins,

and Johnstone,

(eds.) Global Warming and EnergyDemand. Routledge, London.

18.

EST (1996) Energy Saving Trust. Energy Efficiency Standards of Performance. 1995/96 Review. EST, London.

19.

Evans,

R.D.

(1991) Barriers to Energy Efficiency. Report to the Energy Efficiency Office.

20.

Eyre,

. (1990) “Meeting Environmental Objectives in Liberalised Energy Markets”, in Corry,

, Hewett,

and Tindale,

(eds.) Energy '98 - Competing for Power. IPPR, London.

21.

Eyre,

. (1996b) “External Costs of Wind Energy - and What They Mean for Energy Policy”, in Hohmeyer,

, Ottinger,

R.L.

and Rennings,

(eds.) Social Costs and Sustalnability. Valuation and Implementation in the Energyand Transport Sectors. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

22.

Ravin,

and Lenssen,

(1994) Reshaping the Electric Power Industry. Energy Policy 22 (12) 1029-1044.

23.

Gates,

R.W.

(1983) Investing in Energy Conservation: are Homeowners Passing up High Yields? Energy Policy II (I) 63-71.

24.

Grubb,

. (1990) Energy Policies and the Greenhouse Effect. RIIA/Dartmouth, London.

25.

Guy,

(1994) Green Houses - Multiple Sites. Energy and the Cultural Dynamics of House Building Worlds. Paper to Ideal Homes? Towards a Sociology of Domestic Architecture and Interior Design. University of Teesside.

26.

Herring,

(1994) Is Britain a Third World Country? The Case of German Refrigerators. Energy Policy 22 (9) 779-787.

27.

Hirst,

, Cavanagh,

and Miller,

(1996) The Future of DSM in a Restructured US Electricity Industry. Energy Policy 24 (4) 303-316.

28.

Huntington,

H.G.

(1994) Been Top Down so Long it Looks like Bottom Up to Me. Energy Policy 22 (10) 833-839.

29.

Hohmeyer,

(1988) Social Costs of Energy Consumption. Springer Verlag, Berlin.

30.

Hughes,

T.P.

(1987) “Evolution of Large Technological Systems”, in Bijker,

, Hughes,

T.P.

and Pinch,

(eds.) The Social Construction of Technological Systems. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.

31.

Hutton,

(1995) The State We're In. Jonathan Cape, London.

32.

lEA (1989) International Energy Agency. Electricity End Use Efficiency. OECD, Paris.

33.

!PCC (1996) Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Climate Change 1995 - Impacts, Adaptations and Mitigation of Climate Change: Scientific-Technical Analyses. Cambridge University Press.

34.

Jackson,

(1992) Efficiency Without Tears. “No Regrets” Energy Policy to Combat Climate Change. Friends of the Earth, London.

35.

Jacobs,

(1994) “The Limits to Neoclassicalism: Towards an Institutional Environmental Economics” in Redclift,

and Benton,

(eds.) Social Theory and the Global Environment. Routledge, London.

36.

Katzev,

and Johnson,

(1987) Promoting Energy Conservation: An Analysis of Behavioural Research. Westview Press. Boulder.

37.

Kempton,

and Layne,

L.L.

(1994) The Consumer's Energy Analysis Environment. Energy Policy 22 (10) 857-866.

38.

Kempton.

and Montgomery,

(1982) Folk Quantification of Energy. Energy: The International Journal 7 (10) 817-827.

39.

Komor,

P.S.

and Wiggins,

L.L.

(1988) Predicting Conservation Choice: beyond Cost Minimisation Assumptions. Energy 13 (8) 633-645.

40.

Koomey,

. and Sanstad,

A.H.

(1994) Technical Evidence for Assessing the Performance of Markets affecting Energy Efficiency. Energy Policy 22 (10) 826-832.

41.

Lazarus,

(1993) Towards a Fossil Free Energy Future. The Next Energy Transition. A Technical Analysis for Greenpeace International. Stockholm Environment Institute, Boston.

42.

Lönnroth,

(1989) “The Coming Reformation of the Electric Utility Industry”, in Johansson,

T.B.

, Bodlund,

and Williams,

R.H.

(eds.) Electricity - Efficient End-use and New Generation Technologies and their Planning Applications. Lund University Press.

43.

Lutzenhiser,

(1993) Social and Behavioural Aspects of Energy Use. Annual Review of Energy and Environment 18 247-289.

44.

Lutzenhiser,

(1994) Innovation and Organisational Networks: Barriers to Energy Efficiency in the US Housing Industry. Energy Policy 22 (10) 867-876.

45.

Meier.

and Whittier.

(1983) Consumer Discount Rates implied by the Purchases of Energy Efficient Refrigerators. Energy 8 (12) 957-962.

46.

Metcalf,

G.E.

(1994) Economics and Rational Conservation Policy. Energy Policy 22 (10) 819-825.

47.

Morell,

(1981) Energy Conservation and Public Policy. Journal of Social Issues 37 (2) 8-30.

48.

Nadel,

and Geller,

(1996) Utility DSM. What have we learned? Where are we going? Energy Policy 24 (4) 289-302.

49.

Nichols,

A.L.

(1994) Demand Side Management. Overcoming Market Barriers or Obscuring Real Costs? Energy Policy 22 (10) 840-847.

50.

ORNL (1994) Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Resources for the Future. Estimating Externalities of the Coal Fuel Cycle. McGraw Hill.

51.

Ottinger,

R.L.

, Wooley,

D.R.

, Robinson,

N.A.

, Hodas,

D.R.

and Babb,

S.E.

(1990) Environmental Costs of Electricity. Oceana Publications, New York.

52.

Owen,

(1996) A Market in Efficiency: Providing Energy Savings through Competition. IPPR, London.

53.

Pearce,

D.W.

, Bann,

and Georgiou,

(1992) The Social Costs of Fuel Cycles. HMSO, London.

54.

Rennings,

(1996) “Economic and Ecological Concepts of Sustainable Development: External Costs and Sustainability Indicators”, in Hohmeyer,

, Ottinger,

R.L.

and Rennings,

(eds.) Social Costs and Sustainabi/ity. Valuation and Implementation in the Energy and Transport Sectors. Springer-Verlag, Berlin.

55.

Robinson,

J.B.

(1991) The Proof of the Pudding - Making Energy Efficiency Work. Energy Policy 19 631-645.

56.

Rowe,

R.D.

, Lang,

C.M.

, Chestnut,

L.G.

, Latimer,

D.A.

, Rae,

D.A.

, Bernow,

S.M.

and White,

D.E.

(1995) The New York Electricity Externality Study. Oceana Publications, New York.

57.

Sanstad,

A.H.

and Howarth,

R.B.

(1994) “Normal” Markets, Market Imperfections and Energy Efficiency. Energy Policy 22 (10) 811-818.

58.

Schipper,

and Meyers,

(1992) Energy Efficiency and Human Activity. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

59.

Shove,

(1995) Gaps. Barriers and Conceptual Chasms - Theories of Technology Transfer and Energy in Buildings. Paper to the European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy.

60.

Stem,

P.C.

and Aronson,

(eds.) (1984) Energy Use: the Human Dimension. Freeman, New York.

61.

Sutherland,

. (1991) Market Barriers to Energy Efficiency Investments. The Energy Journal 12 (3) 15-34.

62.

Sutherland,

. (1996) The Economics of Energy Conservation Policy. Energy Policy 24 (4) 361-370.

63.

Tindale,

and Holtham,

(1996) Green Taxes: Pollution Payments and Labour Tax Cuts. IPPR Briefing Report. IPPR, London.

64.

Train,

(1985) Discount Rates in Consumers' Energy Related Decisions - a Review of the Literature. Energy 10 (12) 1243-1253.

65.

UKDEn (1989) UK Department of Energy. An Evaluation of Energy Related Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Measures to Ameliorate Them. Energy Paper 58. HMSO, London.

66.

UKDOE (1995) UK Department of the Environment. Climate Change - The UK Programme. Progress Report on Carbon Dioxide Emissions. Central Office of Information, London.

67.

USEPA (1989) United States Environmental Protection Agency. Policy Options for Stabilising Global Climate. Report to US Congress, Washington DC.

68.

Waddams,

(1996) “Will Liberalisation of the Domestic Market Benefit the Consumer?" in Corry,

, Hewell,

and Tindale

, S.

(eds.) Energy '98 - Competing for Power. IPPR, London.

69.

WEC (1993). World Energy Council. Energy for Tomorrow's World. Kogan Page, London.

70.

Yarrow,

(1993) Notes on Energy Prices and Regulatory Policy. International Workshop on Energy and Environment Regulation. Oxford, 1993.

Barriers to Energy Efficiency: More Than Just Market Failure

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References