With more than 20 windfarms now in operation in the UK, public responses to the reality rather than to the idea are emerging. The evidence is mixed: most opinion polls show overall strong support, but there are, equally, signs of strong local opposition in some areas and a general polarisation of views. This paper attempts to explore the way in which local and national attitudes and views have developed, looking in particular at the role of the Government, academic, and the media. It argues for a more constructive debate aimed at developing a consensus on the UK's ‘carrying capacity’ for windfarms.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Press Releases, Dept. of Energy and CEGB, 23 March1988.
2.
PasqualettiM.J. and ButlerE., ‘Public reaction to Wind Development in California’ International Journal of Ambient Energy, Vol. 8 No. 2, pp83-90, April1987.
3.
WrightJ.K., Proof of Evidence on 'Alternative Methods of Electricity Generation' to the Sizewell 'B' Public Inquiry, P-3, CEGB, Nov. 1982
4.
‘Renewables’, British Nuclear Forum feature, ATOM, UKAEA, April1991.
5.
PeterWalker, keynote address to the Engineering Federation, 26 June1986.
6.
MichaelClark MPDr., House of Commons debate on Renewable Energy, 30 Oct.1987.
7.
CecilParkinson, BBC Radio 4 'World at One' 15/1/89.
8.
MichaelSpicer, address to the BWEA, Jan.1988.
9.
quoted in Windpower Monthly, March, 1993.
10.
JaneRoberts, ElliottDavid, TrevorHoughton, ‘Privatising Electricity: the Politics of Power’, Belhaven, London, 1991
11.
DavidElliott, ‘Renewables and the Privatisation and the Electricity Supply Industry: a Case Study’, Energy Policy, Vol. 20, No. 3, pp 257-268, March1992
12.
ThayerR. and FreemenC., ‘Altamont: Public Perceptions of a Wind Energy Landscape’ Landscape and Urban Planning, 14, p379-388, 1987.
BaracCarol, LizSpencer, ElliottDave ‘Public Awareness of Renewable Energy: a pilot study’ International Journal of Ambient Energy, Vol. 4 No. 4 p119-211.
15.
‘Public Attitudes to Wind Turbines; paper to a BWEA Seminar on 'Wind Energy: the environmental issues’ New Perspectives, 9 Nov. 1990. Also see Robin Sadler's Proof of Evidence to the Hinkley C Inquiry on behalf of SHE,(SHE 11) July1989.
16.
BWEA Press release, 24 July1989.
17.
‘Attitudes towards Windpower: A Survey of Opinion in Cornwall and Devon’ ETSU, W/13/00 354/038/REP, 1993.
18.
DavidLindley, from National Wind Power, interviewed in 'The Renewable Present’, the TV component of the DTI/Open University Course Pack on Renewable Energy, T5211994.
19.
TimKirby, from Ecogen, interviewed on BBC Radio 4, ‘Soap Box’, 28/10/83.
20.
Friends of the Earth Press Release, 13 Jan.1994.
21.
House of Commons Select Committee on Energy, Session 1991–92 Fourth Report, Renewable Energy’ Vol. 1, para 51, HMSO, March1992.
22.
Governments Response to the Energy Select Committees Report on Renewable Energy, DTI, 16 July, 1992.
23.
Association of District Councils, Feb. 1992, cited in 'Developing Wind Energy: the Planning Issues’, Report to the National Steering Committee of the Nuclear Free Local Authorities, May1991.
24.
Country Planning Officers Society, Feb.1992, quoted in NFLA report, op cit Ref23.
25.
Dewi LlwydEvans, 'Dyfi Windfarm Worries', Rural Wales, Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales, Spring 1991.
26.
Dept. of the Environment/Welsh Office, Planning Policy Guidance Note, 'Renewable Energy', PPG 22, HMSO, Feb1993.
27.
DTI Press release 15/11/93.
28.
Planning Consent letter and Annex (P62/546), Welsh Office, Cardiff, 19 Sept. 1991.
29.
Daily Telegraph, 26/3/92.
30.
Christopher Key, quoted in the Sunday Telegraph, 27/2/94.
31.
MarcusRand'Developing Wind Energy in the UK', Friends of the Earth, London 1990; 'Removing the wind brakes', FoE, 1991; 'A Case for Wind in Wales' FoE Cymru, 1992.
32.
NeilCaldwell, 'Where do we stand on Wind Power?', Rural Wales, Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales, Autumn 1993.
33.
Countryside Council for Wales 'Wind Turbine Power Stations'1992.
34.
CPRE Evidence to the Dept. of Energy's Renewable Energy Advisory Group 1991. See also Ben Plowden's article in RE view 17, Dept. of Energy, Autumn 1991.
35.
quoted in Windpower Monthly, Nov. 1992.
36.
AllenG.R., 'the Scramble for Windfarms', Northern Devon Group of the Council for the Protection of Rural England, 1991.
37.
The Times 21/8/91.
38.
SueWalker, 'Down on the Windfarm', NATTA report, Milton Keynes, 1993.
39.
Story of Ugliness of Wind Turbines: Wind Turbines The Truth- Factsheet 1993’ Reprinted in Renew 87, NATTA, Milton Keynes, Jan1994.
40.
For details of the local opposition see reports in Renew issues 85–89, NATTA, Milton Keynes.
41.
Pat Ward, quoted in the Daily Telegraph 21/6/93.
42.
Interview on BBC Radio 4's 'You and Yours' 30/7/93.
43.
quoted in the Cornish Guardian 12/8/93.
44.
quoted in the Guardian 26/6/93.
45.
See Crispin Aubrey's account in the Guardian 5/11/93.
46.
Times Literary Supplement 18/2/94.
47.
See Times 27/4/91 for an early example, followed by Independent 25/1/93, Daily Telegraph 21/6/93, Guardian 26/6/93, Financial Times, 22/12/93.
48.
See for example the Telegraph 19/8/93, 29/1/94, 27/2/94, Guardian 11/3/94.
49.
‘Windfarm Backlash’ press cuttings files Vol. I and IINATTA, Milton Keynes1994.
50.
DTI Press Release 11/3/94.
51.
MikeHarper ‘Wind Energy Still Blowing Strong' Safe Energy 99, SCRAM, Edinburgh, Feb/March 1994.
52.
See for example the quote attributed to John Linington, the vice-chairman of a local Comish anti-wind group, in the Sunday Telegraph 27/2/94, and the 'Save our Skyline' Leaflet produced in response to the windfarm proposed for Pertwood Down, Deverill Valley, Wiltshire, 1994.
53.
MattRidley, Daily Telegraph, 6/2/94.
54.
See for example TimKirby, 'Windfarms: the Ecogen view', Renew 86, NATTA, Milton Keynes, Nov. 1993.
55.
See Windpower MonthlyMay1993.
56.
See for example the Proceedings of the EERU/BWEA conference on 'Local Community Wind Energy Projects' held at the Open University on 22 April1993.
NATTA, memorandum on the Windfarm Debate, submitted to the Welsh Affairs Committee, House of Commons, Network for Alternative Technology and Technology Assessment, Milton Keynes, Feb, 1994.
59.
Welsh Affairs Committee, Hearings on Wind Energy, House of Commons, Feb. 1994 onwards. The Committee reported back in July 1994, apporting the continual development of windfarms in Wales. (Second Report Session 1993–94 HMSO.)
60.
AlexiClarke ‘Comparing the Impacts of Renewables’ Technology Policy Group Occasional Paper 23, Open University, Milton Keynes, Dec. 1993.
61.
See WalkerG. ‘Renewable Energy and the Public’, Paper to the Institute of British Geographers Conference, Planning and Environment Study Group, 4–7 Jan., Nottingham University 1994 (to be published).
62.
The Environmental Councils 'Environmental Resolve' initiative, involving training workshops in conflict resolution techniques, designed for planners, developers, environmental groups and so on, is interesting in this context, although clearly there is also a need for more general social mechanisms for conclusion and conflict resolution.
