The goal of this paper is to unveil possible correlations between the political orientation of newspapers and their treatment of police violence. We consider three different news publications with diverging political orientations, namely Jacobin (Left), Breitbart (Right), and The New York Times (Center). We performed a corpus study that relies on two different categorizations: a new ontology for police violence situations, identifying a set of recurrent themes, and the use and distributions of modal adjectives across these themes as revealing stances toward them. Modal adjectives are highly polysemous, and our analysis distinguishes between the epistemic readings as relating to factual truth, and evaluative readings as relating to norms. Our study shows that left and right leaning journals share similar uses of themes, but differ in their use of modal adjectives. These results could suggest that political orientation is responsible for differences that lie in the stance that the newspapers adopt.
AlicH (2020) Klobuchar previously declined to prosecute officer involved in George Floyd’s Death. Breitbart.
2.
BankoleM (2020) Unconscious bias training is not the answer. Jacobin.
3.
BonyadiA (2011) Linguistic manifestations of modality in newspaper editorials. International Journal of Linguistics3(1): E30.
4.
Breitbart (2020) National guard activated to respond to Minneapolis violence. Breitbart.
5.
BylininaL (2017) Judge-dependence in degree constructions. Journal of Semantics34(2): 291–331.
6.
CaffarelARechniewskiE (2009) A systemic functional approach to analysing and interpreting ideology: An illustration from French editorials. Revista Alicantina de Estudios Ingleses22: 27–43.
7.
DarderAFletcherBJ (2020) Black lives matter is part of a global struggle against oppression. Jacobin.
8.
DelingpoleJ (2020) Delingpole: Black lives matter and Antifa in London: Where are the grown ups?Breitbart.
9.
DongBWuX (2022) Reaching and engaging people: Analyzing tweeting practices of large U.S. police departments pre- and post- the killing of George Floyd. PLoS One17(7): e0269288.
10.
EmlerN (2003) Morality and political orientations: An analysis of their relationship. European Review of Social Psychology13(1): 259–291.
11.
EntmanRM (2007) Framing bias: Media in the distribution of power. Journal of Communication57(1): 163–173.
12.
EpsteinRJEligoJ (2020) Biden’s ‘most cops are good’ comment rankles some progressives. The New York Times.
13.
ErnstT (2009) Speaker-oriented adverbs. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory27: 497–544.
Fox PivenF (2020) Frances Fox Piven on why protesters must “defend their ability to exercise disruptive power. Jacobin.
16.
FrimerJABrandtMJMeltonZ, et al. (2019) Extremists on the left and right use angry, negative language. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin45(8): 1216–1231.
17.
GiannakidouAMariA (2021) Truth and Veridicality in Grammar and Tought. Mood, Modality, and Propositonal Attitudes. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
18.
GibbonsC (2020) Donald Trump’s “Antifa” hysteria is absurd. But it’s also very dangerous. Jacobin.
19.
GiorgiSGuntukuSCHimelein-WachowiakM, et al. (2022) Twitter Corpus of the #BlackLivesMatter movement and counter protests: 2013 to 2021. Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media16(1): 1228–1235.
20.
GoddardCTaboadaMTrnavacR (2019) The semantics of evaluational adjectives: Perspectives from natural semantic metalanguage and appraisal. Functions of Language26(3): 308–342.
21.
GrahamJHaidtJKolevaS, et al. (2013) Chapter two - moral foundations theory: The pragmatic validity of moral pluralism. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology47: 55–130.
22.
HammondCNcubeMFidoD (2021) A foucauldian discourse analysis of the construction of people of colour (POC) as criminals in UK and US print media following the Black Lives Matter protests of May 2020. Race and Crime in Print Media. PsyArXiv Preprints. DOI: 10.31234/osf.io/3yp45.
23.
HughesD (2020) I’m a Black police officer. Here’s how to change the system. The New York Times.
24.
JostJTFedericoCMNapierJL (2009) Political ideology: Its structure, functions, and elective affinities. Annual Review of Psychology60: 307–337.
25.
KarjusACuskleyC (2024) Evolving linguistic divergence on polarizing social media. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications11(1): 1–14.
26.
KarpM (2020) How the antislavery movement ignited a political revolution. Jacobin.
27.
KennedyCWillerM (2022) Familiarity inferences, subjective attitudes and counterstance contingency: Towards a pragmatic theory of subjective meaning. Linguistics and Philosophy45(6): 1395–1445. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-022-09358-x
28.
KratzerA (1981) The notional category of modality. In: EikmeyerH-JRieserH (eds) Words, Worlds, and Contexts. Berlin: de Gruyter, pp.38–74.
29.
LasersohnP (2005) Context dependence, disagreement, and predicates of personal taste. Linguistics and Philosophy28(6): 643–686.
30.
LeonhardtD (2020) The persistence of police killings. The New York Times.
31.
LyonsJ (1977) Semantics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
McCarthyMA (2020) To recover from this crisis, we need to defund wall street. Jacobin.
33.
McCloskyHChongD (1985) Similarities and differences between left-wing and right-wing radicals. British Journal of Political Science15(3): 329–363.
34.
McQuadeB (2020) The “Camden model” is not a model. It’s an obstacle to real change. The New York Times.
35.
MarceticB (2020) American authoritarianism runs deeper than Trump. Jacobin.
36.
Myart-CruzC (2020) The union has to be about social justice. Jacobin.
37.
NetworkTL (2020) What students are saying about the George Floyd Protests. The New York Times.
38.
NguyenTTCrissSMichaelsEK, et al. (2021) Progress and push-back: How the killings of Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd impacted public discourse on race and racism on Twitter. SSM - Population Health15: 100922.
39.
NolteJ (2020) Nolte: NYT says ‘sacred’ site of George Floyd’s death spiraling into Chaos—‘Constant Gunshots Every Night.’Breitbart.
40.
NuytsJ (2001) Subjectivity as an evidential dimension in epistemic modal expressions. Journal of Pragmatics33: 383–400.
41.
ParrottGBrownL (1972) Political bias in the Rokeach Dogmatism Scale. Psychological Reports30(3): 805–806.
42.
PegoloV (2020) How K-Pop’s record labels exploit its “idols”. Jacobin.
43.
PéloquinOFortinFPaquetteS (2022) Examining negative online social reaction to police use of force: The George Floyd and Jacob Blake events. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice64(1): 53–81.
44.
PortnerP (2009) Modality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
PortnerPRubinsteinA (2012) Mood and contextual commitment. In: CherechesA (ed.) Semantics and Linguistic Theory. pp.461–487. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
46.
PortnerPRubinsteinA (2016) Extreme and non-extreme deontic modals. In: CharlowNChrismanM (eds) Deontic Modality. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.256–282.
47.
PriniskiJHMokhberianNHarandizadehB, et al. (2021). Mapping moral valence of tweets following the killing of George Floyd. arXiv.
RecasensMDanescu-Niculescu-MizilCJurafskyD (2013) Linguistic models for analyzing and detecting biased language. In: Proceedings of the 51st Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers) (ed. SchuetzeH.FungP.PoesioM.), Sofia, Bulgaria, August 2013, pp.1650–1659. Association for Computational Linguistics. Canadian Center of Science and Education (CSCE).
50.
Rodriguez-SanchezRTaylorJ (2020) Police are not designed to solve the problems people are facing. Jacobin.
51.
RokeachM (1960) The Open and Closed Mind. New York, NY: Basic Books.
52.
RossCT (2015) A multi-level Bayesian analysis of racial bias in police shootings at the county-level in the United States, 2011–2014. PLoS One10(11): e0141854.
53.
SadiaSGhaniM (2018) Modality in editorials of Pakistani English newspapers: A corpus based study. International Journal of English Linguistics9(1). DOI: 10.5539/ijel.v9n1p144.
54.
SilkA (2021) Evaluational adjectives. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research102(1): 127–161.
55.
SmetanaJG (1993) Understanding of social rules. In: BennettM (ed.) The Development of Social Cognition: The Child as Psychologist. New York, NY: Guilford Press, pp. 111–141.
56.
Soria-RuizA (2019) The place of value in natural language: A non-factualist approach to evaluative terms and judgment. These de doctorat. Paris Sciences et Lettres (ComUE), Paris.
57.
Soria-RuizAFaroldiFLG (2022) Moral adjectives, judge-dependency and holistic multidimensionality. Inquiry65(7): 887–916.
58.
Soria-RuizAFranzénN (2023) Moral and Moorean incoherencies. Ergo an Open Access Journal of Philosophy10(0). DOI: 10.5539/ijel.v9n1p144.
59.
SouthallA (2020) N.Y.P.D. officer charged with using illegal chokehold. The New York Times.
60.
StanleyJ (2015) How Propaganda Works, 1st edn. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
61.
StephensonT (2007) Judge dependence, epistemic modals, and predicates of personal taste. Linguistics and Philosophy30: 487–525.
62.
StojanovicI (2019) Disagreements about Taste vs. Disagreements about Moral Issues. American Philosophical Quarterly56(1): 29–41.
63.
StojanovicIMcNallyL (2023) Are moral predicates subjective? A Corpus study. In: PlouDB (ed.) Experimental Philosophy of Language: Perspectives, Methods and Prospects. Cham: Springer, pp.103–120.
64.
StoneWFSmithLD (1993) Authoritarianism: Left and right. In: StoneWFLedererGChristieR (eds) Strength and Weakness: The Authoritarian Personality Today. New York, NY: Springer, pp.144–156.
65.
TavassoliFJalilifarAWhitePR (2019) British newspapers’ stance towards the Syrian refugee crisis: An appraisal model study. Discourse & Society30(1): 64–84.
66.
ThelwallMThelwallS (2021) Twitter during COVID-19: George Floyd opening a space to address systematic and institutionalized racism?SSRN.
67.
TimesTNY (2020) Explosive anger hits twin cities, and the nation. The New York Times.
68.
TraversoE (2020) Tearing down statues doesn’t erase history, it makes us see it more clearly. Jacobin.
69.
TravisCCacoullosR (2023) Form and function covariation: Obligation modals in Australian English. Language Variation and Change35: 1–27.
70.
TurielE (1983) The Development of Social Knowledge: Morality and Convention. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
71.
UmbachC (2016) Evaluative propositions and subjective judgments. In: MeierCvan Wijnbergen-HuitinkJ (eds) Subjective Meaning Alternatives to Relativism. Berlin: De Gruyter, pp.127–168.
72.
WilkersonI (2020) America’s enduring caste system. The New York Times.
73.
WongK (2020) Leftists have been calling to ‘defund the police’ for over a decade. Breitbart.
