Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2025-3
The ‘pathologically state dependent’ versus ‘middle-aged ministers on mammoth salaries’: The legitimation contest over a 2013 austerity measure in the Republic of Ireland
This paper provides a discourse analysis of the political and media debate surrounding a 2013 austerity measure that targeted unemployed young people in the Republic of Ireland. Applying Van Leeuwen’s ‘justificatory schema’ it reveals the legitimation of this measure relied on an ‘anti-welfare populist’ framing of the young unemployed as ‘welfare dependent’ and thus ‘undeserving’. Furthermore, this analysis finds that those opposed to this austerity measure sought to de-legitimate it and to re-legitimate the young unemployed. At times by singling out alternative ‘undeserving’ figures to be targeted with austerity in their place. This process thus remained open to contestation and resignification, albeit in a manner that failed to challenge the underlying political-economic logic at play. The antagonistic framings revealed by these findings complicate the emphasis on ‘de-politicisation’ in the pre-existing literature using discourse analysis methods to investigate the legitimation of austerity.
AllenM (1998) The Bitter Word: Ireland’s Job Famine and Its Aftermath. Dublin: Poolbeg Press.
2.
BorrielloA (2017) ‘There is no alternative’: How Italian and Spanish leaders’ discourse obscured the political nature of austerity. Discourse & Society28(3): 241–261.
3.
BrowneC (2013) “To hell or Canada” for our youth - Cromwell would’ve been proud. Irish Independent, 16October, 94.
4.
BurtonJ (2013a) Statement by minister for social protection Joan Burton T.D. Department of Social Protection. 15October.
5.
BurtonJ (2013b) Dáil Debate. 24October, 818(3).
6.
Central Statistics Office (2009) Live register September 2009. Dublin: CSO.
ClarkeA (2013) I never dreamt I’d spend the next four years on the dole. Irish Independent, 6November, 46.
9.
CohenS (2011) Folk Devils and Moral Panics the Creation of the Mods and Rockers. New York, NY: Routledge.
10.
CooperM (2017) Family Values: Between Neoliberalism and the New Social Conservatism. Brooklyn, NY: Zone Books.
11.
DevereuxEPowerMJ (2019) Fake news? A critical analysis of the ‘Welfare cheats, cheat us all’ campaign in Ireland. Critical Discourse Studies16(3): 347–362.
12.
DonohoeM (2013) Brave step away from a culture of dependency. Irish Independent, 16October, 95.
13.
DuboisV (2020) Cuando las élites políticas transforman la vida de la población precaria: la construcción política del fraude social como problema público en Francia. Miríada: Investigación en Ciencias Sociales12(16): 13–28.
14.
Eurofound (2012) NEETs: Young People Not in Employment, Education or Training: Characteristics, Costs and Policy Responses in Europe. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
15.
Eurostat (2020a). TEPSR_WC170: Unemployment Rate by Age. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
16.
Eurostat (2020b) YTH_EMPL_140: Youth Unemployment Ratio by Sex, Age and NUTS 2 Regions. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
17.
Eurostat (2020c) EDAT_LFSE_20: Young People Neither in Employment Nor in Education and Training by Sex, Age and Labour Status. Luxembourg: Eurostat.
18.
FergussonRYeatesN (2021) Global Youth Unemployment: History, Governance and Policy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
19.
FinnPMurphyMP (2022) A multi-dimensional view of stigma experienced by lone parents in Irish homeless and employment services. Social Policy and Society21(4): 679–689.
20.
FonsecaPFerreiraMJ (2015) Through ‘seas never before sailed’: Portuguese government discursive legitimation strategies in a context of financial crisis. Discourse & Society26(6): 682–711.
21.
FraserNGordonL (1994) A genealogy of dependency: Tracing a keyword of the US welfare state. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society19(2): 309–336.
22.
GaffneyS (2022) A sleight of hand? The problematisation of youth unemployment in Ireland 2008-2014. PhD Thesis, University of Galway, IE.
23.
GaffneySMillarM (2020) Rational skivers or desperate strivers? The problematisation of fraud in the Irish social protection system. Critical Social Policy40(1): 69–88.
24.
GarrettPM (2018) Welfare Words: Critical Social Work & Social Policy. Los Angeles: Sage.
25.
GilmoreE (2013) Dáil Debates. 17October, 817(3).
26.
GlynnIKellyTMac EinríP (2015) The Re-emergence of Emigration From Ireland: New Trends in An Old Story. Washington: Migration Policy Institute.
27.
GoldingPMiddletonS (1982) Images of Welfare: Press and Public Attitudes to Poverty. Oxford: Robertson.
28.
GriffinC (1993) Representations of Youth: The Study of Youth and Adolescence in Britain and America. Cambridge: Polity Press.
29.
HanafinM (2009) Dáil Debates. 23April, 680 (4).
30.
HanssonS (2015) Discursive strategies of blame avoidance in government: A framework for analysis. Discourse & Society26(3): 297–322.
31.
HarjuniemiT (2020) The Economist’s depoliticisation of European austerity and the constitution of a ‘euphemised’ neoliberal discourse. Critical Discourse Studies17(5): 494–509.
32.
Irish Independent (2013) A false economy as cheap labour and rickety internships get the hard sell. Irish Independent, 16November, 104.
33.
KennyE (2013) I will not shirk any measure to get this country working. Irish Independent, 21October,27.
34.
KrzyżanowskiM (2018) Discursive shifts in ethno-nationalist politics: On politicization and mediatization of the “refugee crisis” in Poland. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies16(1–2): 76–96.
35.
LeeJJ (1989) Ireland, 1912-1985: Politics and Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
MeadLM (1989) The logic of workfare: The underclass and work policy. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science501(1): 156–169.
MillarMCrosseR (2018) Lone parent activation in Ireland: Putting the cart before the horses?Social Policy & Administration52(1): 111–129.
40.
MiróJ (2021) Abolishing politics in the shadow of austerity? Assessing the (De) politicization of budgetary policy in crisis-ridden Spain (2008–2015). Policy Studies42(1): 6–23.
41.
MurrayC (2008) Losing Ground: American Social Policy, 1950-1980. New York, NY: Basic Books.
42.
NaughtonC (2013) Why the grey army soldiers on; The Facebook generation is suffering but silent while their grandparents are keeping up the fight against austerity. Irish Independent, 25October, 42–43.
43.
O’ConnorB (2001) The intellectual origins of ‘welfare dependency’. Australian Journal of Social Issues36(3): 221–236.
44.
O’FlynnMMonaghanLFPowerMJ (2014) Scapegoating during a time of crisis: A critique of post-Celtic Tiger Ireland. Sociology48(5): 921–937.
45.
O’KeefeJ (2013) At last, justice for working families with cut in dole and free GP care. Irish Daily Mail, 15October, 14.
46.
O’ReillyJEichhorstWGábosA, et al. (2015) Five characteristics of youth unemployment in Europe: Flexibility, education, migration, family legacies, and EU policy. Sage Open5(1): 1–19.
47.
PowerMJDevereuxERyanM (2022) Framing and shaming: The 2017 welfare cheats, cheat us all campaign. Social Policy and Society21(4): 646–656.
Taylor-GoobyPDeanH (1992) Dependency Culture: The Explosion of a Myth. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
54.
TylerI (2013) Revolting Subjects Social Abjection and Resistance in Neoliberal Britain. London: Zed Books.
55.
Van LeeuwenT (2008) Discourse and Practice: New Tools for Critical Discourse Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
56.
WacquantL (2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham: Duke University Press.
57.
WatsonDMaîtreBWhelanC (2012) Work and poverty in Ireland: An analysis of CSO survey on income and living conditions 2004-2010. Economic and Social Research Institute [ESRI] Research Series. Dublin: ESRI.
WhelanJ (2021) We have our dignity, yeah? Scrutiny under suspicion: Experiences of welfare conditionality in the Irish social protection system. Social Policy & Administration55(1): 34–50.
61.
WhiteV (2013) Sacrificing young for good of the old not good enough anymore. Irish Examiner, 14November, 12.
