Conflicting discourses,shifting ideologies: pharmaceutical,`alternative' and feminist emancipatory texts on the menopause

Abstract

This article uses a close pragmatic analysis to examine three discourses of the menopause, each with identifiably different health and lifespan ideologies, each used to further its own set of economic and/or political agendas. We argue that these texts have potentially powerful influential effects on women's interpretations of their own `change of life'. Discourse 1 (the `pharmaceutical' discourse) is represented by pharmaceutical brochures, which construct the menopause as medical `pathology' caused by physiological decrement and generally advocate correcting or suppressing symptoms by `treatment' with hormone replacement therapy (HRT). Discourse 2 (the `alternative' therapy discourse) as represented in popular printed media texts, rejects both subjection to medical/pharmaceutical intervention, and many of the claims made for HRT, and recommends that women take personal and active `control' by using `natural' remedies and making lifestyle adjustments. Although in ideological conflict, both these discourses are arguably ageist in their reproduction of negative perceptions of menopause. Discourse 3 (the emancipatory feminist discourse) reconstructs the menopause as a positively significant rite of passage — a time of re-evaluation and new-found freedom. Like Discourse 2, feminist discourse rejects the medicalization of menopause and the claims Discourse 1 makes for HRT. But, in addition, Discourse 3 rejects the dominant medical view of the cultural meaning of menopause, with the end of menstruation entextualized as gain, rather than loss, and redefines female midlife as a time of new freedom, wisdom and personal insight.

Keywords

alternative therapies control feminist emancipatory literature hormone replacement therapy (HRT)interpretive resources menopause pharmaceutical brochures redefinition uncertainty women's subjectivities

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atwell, C. , Coupland, J. , Elwyn, G. and Edwards, A. (forthcoming) `Collaborative Consulting: How General Practitioners and Their Patients Share Decision-Making: The Case of HRT'.

Bengston, V.L. (1973) The Social Psychology of Aging. New York: Bobbs Merrill.

Billig, M. (1996) Arguing and Thinking: A Rhetorical Approach to Social Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Coupland, J. (forthcoming) `Time Has a Nasty Habit of Catching Up with Us: Ageist Ideology and Discourses of Control in Skin Care Product Marketing', in J. Coupland and R. Gwyn (eds) Discourse, The Body and Identity. London: Palgrave.

Coupland, J. and Gwyn, R. (eds) (forthcoming) Discourse, The Body and Identity . London: Palgrave.

Dickson, G.L. (1993) `Metaphors of Menopause: The Metalanguage of Menopause Research', in J. Callaghan (ed.) Menopause: A Midlife Passage, pp. 36-58. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Fairclough, N. (1989) Language and Power. London: Longman.

Gannon, L.R. (1996) `Perspectives on Biological, Social and Psychological Phenomena in Middle- and Old-Age Women: Interference or Intervention?', in S. Clancy and L. DiLalla (eds) Assessment and Intervention Issues Across the Lifespan. New York: Erlbaum .

Gannon, L.R. (1999) Women and Aging: Transcending the Myths. London: Routledge.

10.

Gardner, R. (1999) Celebrating the Crone: Rituals and Stories. St Paul, MN: Llewellyn Publications.

11.

Goffman, E. (1981) Forms of Talk. Oxford: Blackwell.

12.

Greer, G. (1991) The Change. London: Hamilton.

13.

Greer, G. (1999) The Whole Woman. London: Doubleday.

14.

Grice, H.P. (1975) `Logic and Conversation', in P. Cole and J.L. Morgan (eds) Syntax and Semantics 3: Speech Acts. New York: Academic Press.

15.

Guillemin, M. (2000) `Blood, Bone, Women and HRT: Co-constructions in the Menopause Clinic' , Australian Feminist Studies 15(32): 191-203.

16.

Hall, J. and Jacobs, R. (1998) Holistic Menopause: A New Approach to Midlife Change . Edinburgh: Findhorn Press.

17.

Harding, J. (1997) `Bodies at Risk: Sex, Surveillance and Hormone Replacement Therapy', in A. Petersen and R. Bunton (eds) Foucault, Health and Medicine. London: Routledge .

18.

Hunt, K. (1984) `A Cure for All Ills? Constructions of the Menopause and the Chequered Fortunes of Hormone Replacement Therapy', in S. Wilkinson and C. Kitzinger (eds) Women and Health: Feminist Perspectives. London: Taylor and Francis.

19.

Hunter, M.S. and O'Dea, I. (1997) `Menopause: Bodily Changes and Multiple Meanings' , in J. Ussher (ed.) Body Talk: The Material and Discursive Regulation of Sexuality, Madness and Reproduction . Routledge: London.

20.

Jones, R. (1997) `Marketing the Damaged Self: The Construction of Identity in Advertisements Directed Towards People with HIV/AIDS', Journal of Sociolinguistics 1(3): 393-418.

21.

Kaufert, P.A. (1982) `Myth and the Menopause', Sociology of Health and Illness 4: 141-66.

22.

Kenton, L. (1996) Passage to Power: Natural Menopause Revolution . London: Random House.

23.

Kress, G. and Hodge, R. (1979) Language as Ideology. London : Routledge and Kegan Paul.

24.

Lee, D. (1992) Competing Discourses: Perspective and Ideology in Language. London: Longman.

25.

Lupton, D. (1994) Medicine as Culture. London : Sage.

26.

Lupton, D. (1996) `Constructing the Menopausal Body: The Discourses on HRT', Body and Society 2(1): 91-7.

27.

Phillips, A. and Rakusen, J. (1996) The New Our Bodies, Ourselves: A Health Book by and for Women. London: Penguin.

28.

Poland, F. and Rakusen, J. (1996) `Women Growing Older', in A. Phillips and J. Rakusen (eds) The New Our Bodies, Ourselves: A Health Book by and for Women. London: Penguin.

29.

Rushton, A. and Bond, S. (1999) Natural Progesterone: The Natural Way to Alleviate Symptoms of Menopause, PMS and Other Hormonal Related Problems. London: Thorsons.

30.

Sheehy. G. (1991/1994) The Silent Passage: Menopause . London: HarperCollins.

31.

Tajfel, H. and Turner, J.C. (1986) `The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behaviour' , in S. Worchel and W.G. Austin (eds) The Psychology of Intergroup Relations, pp. 33-47. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole .

32.

Thomas, J. (1995) Meaning in Interaction: An Introduction to Pragmatics . London: Longman.

33.

Van Dijk, T. (1993) `Principles of Critical Discourse Analysis', Discourse & Society 4(2): 249-83.

34.

Wei Leng, K. (1996) `On Menopause and Cyborgs: Or, Towards a Feminist Cyborg Politics of Menopause', Body and Society 2(3): 33-52.

35.

Williams, A. and Ylänne-McEwen, V. (2000) `Elderly Lifestyles in the 21st Century: "Doris and Sid's Excellent Adventure" ', Journal of Communication 50: 4-8 [Special issue].

36.

Wilson, R.A. (1966) Feminine Forever. New York: Evans.

37.

Woodward, K. (1991) Aging and its Discontents: Freud and other Fictions . Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

38.

Worcester, N. and Whately, M. (1992) `The Selling of HRT: Playing on the Fear Factor' , Feminist Review 41: 1-26.

39.

Zita, J. (1988) `The Premenstrual Syndrome: "Dis-easing" the Female Cysle', Hypatia 3(1): 157-8.

40.

Zita, J.N. (1993) `Heresy in the Female Body: the Rhetorics of Menopause' , in J. Callaghan (ed.) Menopause: A Midlife Passage, pp. 59-78. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.