The Frenchness of Marcel Lefebvre and the Society of St Pius X: A new reading

Abstract

The case of Marcel Lefebvre and the Society of St Pius X (SSPX) deserves fresh perspectives. The current historiography is too franco-centric, focused on selective aspects of Lefebvre’s biography and the actions of isolated individuals, rather than with the life of the SSPX itself. After evaluating the current state of the historiography, this article proposes a new analysis of the SSPX’s political discourses in France and internationally and undertakes to reframe the relationship between Lefebvre’s life and his congregation by re-examining his African missionary experiences. Such new perspectives will be helpful as the SSPX moves towards regularisation under the pontificate of Pope Francis.

Keywords

Action française far right Pope Francis Marcel Lefebvre missionary Catholicism Society of St Pius X (SSPX)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

J Jnr

(2002) Conclave: The Politics, Personalities, and Process of the Next Papal Election. New York: Doubleday.

Anderson

(1983) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.

Austermuehl

(2014) The Great American Scaffold: Intertextuality and Identity in American Presidential Discourse. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.

Bastié

(2015) La Révolution silencieuse des catholiques de France. Le Figaro, 30 October.

Benedict

XVI

(2007) Summorum Pontificum. Apostolic letter given motu proprio on the use of the Roman liturgy prior to the reform of 1970. Available at: http://w2.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/en/motu_proprio/documents/hf_ben-xvi_motu-proprio_20070707_summorum-pontificum.html.

Birnbaum

(2006) The new right. In: Kritzman

Reilly

(eds) The Columbia History of Twentieth-Century French Thought. New York: Columbia University Press, pp. 69–73.

Bouchacourt

(2015) Interview with the author, 10 October.

Cacqueray

R de

(2005) Interview with Alain Sanders. Présent, 9 March.

Cacqueray

R de

(2010) Communiqué de l’abbé de Cacqueray – La mort des nations catholiques entraîne la disparition des minorités chrétiennes, 8 November. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/district/france/bo/cacqueray101108/Cacqueray101108.php.

10.

Cacqueray

R de

(2013a) Lettre aux amis et bienfaiteurs 80, June. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/district/france/lab_district_france/lab_district_france_80_1306.pdf.

11.

Cacqueray

R de

(2013b) Message du pape François pour la fin du Ramadan. Dialogue avec l’Islam: notre cri d’alarme. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/vatican/sanctions_indults_discussions/27_juin_2013/02_08_2013_voeux_pape_francois_fin_du_ramadan.php.

12.

Celier

(2007) Benoît XVI et les traditionalistes. Paris: Entrelacs.

13.

Celier

(2010) La Courte Honte d’un historien official, 30 October. Available at: www.dici.org/documents/la-courte-honte-dun-historien-officiel/.

14.

Celier

(2015) Interview with the author, 9 October.

15.

Chombart

Lauwe

P-H

(1991) Vigilance: Vieilles traditions extrémistes et droites nouvelles.Paris: Ligue des droits de l’homme.

16.

CICAD (2013) Propos anti-Juifs à Écône, 8 February. Available at: http://cicad.ch/fr/cicad-news-press-releases-and-feedback-anti-semitism-news-press-releases-and-feedback/propos-anti.

17.

Colard

J-M

Moulène

(2011) Le Saccage du ‘Piss Christ’: révélateur d’une France haineuse. Les Inrocks, 18 April.

18.

Congar

(1977) La Crise dans l’Eglise et Mgr Lefebvre. Paris: Cerf.

19.

Dickès

J-P

(2014) Civitas colloque: le compte rendu. Présent, 12 July.

20.

Ennemond (2015) Interview with the author, 18 October.

21.

Fellay

(2009) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs 74, April. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/74/francais/74.php.

22.

Fellay

(2011) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs, 78, 10 April. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/78/78.php.

23.

Fellay

(2011) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs 78, 21 December. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/78/78.php.

24.

Fellay

(2013) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs 81, 6 December. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/81/81.php.

25.

Fellay

(2014) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs 82, 13 April. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/82/82.php.

26.

Fellay

(2015) Lettres aux amis et bienfaiteurs 84, 24 May. Available at: http://laportelatine.org/publications/bienfait/84/84.php.

27.

Le Figaro (2015) Taubira/Banania: l’abbé Beauvais relaxé, 19 May.

28.

Fouilloux

(1997) Intégrisme catholique et droits de l’homme. In: Le Berre

(ed.) Fondamentalismes, intégrismes: Une menace pour les droits de l’homme. Paris: Bayard Éditions/Centurion, pp. 11–27.

29.

Francis (2016) Misericordia et misera. Apostolic letter, 20 November. Available at: https://w2.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_letters/documents/papa-francesco-lettera-ap_20161120_misericordia-et-misera.html.

30.

Greeley

(2001) The Catholic Imagination. Berkeley: University of California Press.

31.

Hoffner

Gaulmyn

I de

(2010) La Carte de France des prêtres. Le Figaro, 21 May.

32.

John Paul

(1988) Ecclesia Dei. Apostolic letter given motu proprio, 2 July. Available at: www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_commissions/ecclsdei/documents/hf_jp-ii_motu-proprio_02071988_ecclesia-dei_en.html.

33.

Lefebvre

(1976) J’accuse le concile. Martigny: Éditions Saint Gabriel.

34.

Lefebvre

(1985) Lettre ouverte aux catholiques perplexes. Paris: Albin Michel.

35.

Lefebvre

(1987) Ils l’ont découronné. Paris: Éditions Fideliter.

36.

Lefebvre

(1989) Itinéraire spiritual. Paris: Éditions Fideliter.

37.

Lefebvre

(1999) Petite histoire de ma longue histoire: Vie de Mgr Lefebvre racontée par lui-même. Paris: Sœurs de la Fraternité Saint Pie X.

38.

Leo

XIII

(1891) Rerum Novarum, encyclical letter, 15 May.

39.

Levillain

(2010) Rome n’est plus dans Rome: Mgr Lefebvre et son église. Paris: Perrin.

40.

Libération (2012) Enquête. Saint Nicolas-du-Chardonnet: avec foi mais sans loi, 11 May.

41.

Michel

(2009) L’Action française et l’intégrisme catholique: les paradoxes d’un antiromanisme ultraromain. In: F Michel and B Sesboüé, De Mgr Lefebvre à Mgr Williamson: Anatomie d’un schisme. Paris: Lethielleux / Desclée de Brouwer, pp. 11–76.

42.

Nardi

(2015) The traditional Mass is changing the face of the French clergy. In: The Eponymous Flower Blogspot. Available at: http://eponymousflower.blogspot.co.uk/2015/11/the-traditional-mass-is-changing-face.html?m=1.

43.

Pius

(1905) Il Fermo Proposito, encyclical letter, 11 June.

44.

Pius

(1927) Apostolicorum in Missionibus, papal decree, 14 December.

45.

Poulat

(1985) La Querelle de l’intégrisme en France. Social Compass 32(4): 343–51.

46.

Prévotat

(2009) La Condemnation de l’Action française et les Spiritains: le cas du Séminaire français. Histoires et mission chrétiennes 10 (June): 69–94.

47.

Priest

(2015) Interview with the author, 14 October.

48.

Rémond

(1989) L’Intégrisme catholique: portrait intellectual. Études (January): 95–105.

49.

Roberts

(2000) Secularisation and the (re)formulation of French Catholic identity. In: Chadwick

(ed.) Catholicism, Politics and Society in Twentieth-Century France. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, pp. 260–79.

50.

Rostand

(2015) Interview with the author, 12 October.

51.

Sauvaget

(2015) À cheval, civitas veut ‘délivrer la France’. Libération, 10 May.

52.

Senèze

(2012) Civitas, dans la mouvance du nationalisme catholique. La Croix, 19 November. Available at: www.la-croix.com/Religion/Actualite/Civitas-dans-la-mouvance-du-nationalisme-catholique-_NG_-2012-11-19-877665.

53.

Sudlow

(2011) The untameable Provence of Charles Maurras. Nottingham French Studies 50(1): 19–30.

54.

Tincq

(1986) Les Intégristes et le FN. Le Monde, 7 March.

55.

Tissier

Mallerais

(2002) Marcel Lefebvre: Une vie. Paris: Clovis.

56.

Van Der Krogt

(1992) Catholic fundamentalism or Catholic integralism. In: Veitch

(ed.) To Strive and Not to Yield: Essays in Honour of Colin Brown. Wellington (NZ): Victoria University of Wellington, pp. 123–35.

57.

Wenger

(2000) Communities of practice and social learning systems. Organization 7(2): 225–46.

58.

White

Daughton

(2012) In God’s Empire: French Missionaries in the Modern World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.