Richard Rows may be an unfamiliar name to historians of psychiatry today, other than for his role as superintendent of the Red Cross Military Hospital at Maghull, near Liverpool, during the First World War. Accordingly, this paper attempts a conspectus of Rows’ career in order to contextualise the psychotherapeutic approach he developed, not only to “shell-shock” patients during the War but also to “functional mental illnesses” encountered in subsequent civilian practice. This examination shows that although Rows adopted some Freudian or quasi-Freudian psychological vocabulary and techniques, as did many of his contemporaries, he also had a long-standing commitment to a physiological conceptualisation of brain disorders. For Rows, this was not incompatible with, but complementary to, his psychodynamic approach in clinical encounters. His work extended beyond the limits of psychiatry to adopt perspectives originating with contemporary neurologists and experimental neurophysiologists.
Anon. (1910) Modern problems in psychiatry. By Ernesto Lugaro. Translated by David Orr, M.D. Edin., and R. G. Rows, M.D. Lond. With a Foreword by T. S. Clouston, M.D. Edin., LL.D. Manchester: At the University Press, 1909. Pp. 305. Price 7s. 6d. Lancet1: 504–505.
2.
Anon. (1918a) The interdependence of the sympathetic and central nervous systems. British Medical Journal2: 471.
3.
Anon. (1918b) Promotion in the asylum. The greatest hardship of the Assistant Medical Officer. Hospital (London 1886)64: 385–386.
4.
Anon. (1922) The interpretation of symptoms. Lancet1: 903.
5.
Anon. (1925) R. G. Rows, C.B.E., M.D. Lond., Hon. D.Sc. Manch., Pathologist, Prestwich Mental Hospital. British Medical Journal1: 433–434.
6.
Anon. (1926) Epilepsy: A functional mental illness. By R. G. Rows and W. E. Bond. Pp. 138. London: Lewis and Co. 1926. Brain49(3): 435.
7.
Anon. (1927) Epilepsy: A functional mental illness. By R. G. Rows, M.D., London and W. E. Bond, M.R.C.S., England, L.R.C.P., London. Price, $3.00. Pp. 138. New York: Paul B. Hoeber, 1926. Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry17(2): 280.
8.
Anon. (1941) Obituary: David Orr, M.D. British Medical Journal2: 634–635.
9.
BarhamP (2004) Forgotten Lunatics of the Great War. Yale University Press.
10.
BassettiCLJagellaEC (2006) Joseph Jules Dejerine (1849–1917). Journal of Neurology253: 823–824.
11.
BogaczT (1989) War neurosis and cultural change in England 1914–22: The work of the War Office Committee of Enquiry into “Shell-shock”. Journal of Contemporary History24: 227–256.
12.
BondCH (1925) The late Dr. R. G. Rows. Journal of Mental Science71: 338.
13.
BrownW (1918–1919) War neurosis: A comparison of early cases seen in the Field with those seen at the Base. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Section of Psychiatry) 12: 52–61.
14.
BrownW (1919) War neurosis: A comparison of early cases seen in the Field with those seen at the Base. Lancet1: 833–836.
DoddsStrahanGreenlees (1890) Assistant Medical Officers in Asylums: Their status in the speciality. Journal of Mental Science36: 43–50.
17.
FerrierD (1914) Presidential address: The cerebro-spinal fluid in health and disease. Transactions of the Medical Society of London37: 1–14.
18.
HeadH (1922) Obituary. W. H. R. Rivers, M.D., D.Sc., F.R.S. An appreciation. British Medical Journal1: 977–978.
19.
JohnsonWRowsRG (1923) Neurasthenia and war neuroses. In: MacPhersonWGHerringhamWPElliottTR, et al. (eds.). History of the Great War Based on Official Documents. Medical Services. Diseases of the War. Vol. II: Including the Medical Aspects of Aviation and Gas Warfare, and Gas Poisoning in Tanks and Mines. HMSO, pp.1–67.
20.
JonesE (2010) Shell shock at Maghull and the Maudsley: Models of psychological medicine in the UK. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences65: 368–395.
21.
LarnerAJ (2024) William Aldren Turner (1864–1945). Journal of Neurology271: 5699–5701.
22.
LoughranT (2017) Shell-Shock and Medical Culture in First World War Britain. Cambridge University Press.
23.
Medical Directory (1924) J & A Churchill.
24.
OrrD (1902) A contribution to the pathology of acute insanity. Brain25(2): 240–298.
25.
OrrD (1903) A contribution to our knowledge of the course of the lymph stream in the spinal roots and cord. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry1: 639–659.
26.
OrrD (1912) Some points complementary to the institution of postgraduate instruction in psychiatry. Journal of Mental Science58: 39–47.
27.
OrrD (1915) Some introductory remarks on the organisation of research. Journal of Mental Science61: 412–423.
28.
OrrD (1920) The interdependence of the sympathetic and central nervous systems in relation to the psychoneuroses. Edinburgh Medical Journal25: 243–259.
29.
OrrD (1925) Lieut.-Col. Richard Gundry Rows, C.B.E., D.Sc., M.D., Pathologist, County Mental Hospital, Prestwich. Journal of Mental Science71: 350–351.
30.
OrrDRowsRG (1901) The nerve-cells of the human posterior root ganglia and their changes in general paralysis of the insane. Brain24(2): 286–309.
31.
OrrDRowsRG (1904a) Lesions of the posterior columns in general paralysis. British Medical Journal2: 978–979.
32.
OrrDRowsRG (1904b) System lesions of the posterior columns in general paralysis, and their bearing on the point of origin of tabes dorsalis. Brain27(4): 460–489.
33.
OrrDRowsRG (1906) Lesions of the spinal cord, the result of absorption from localised septic foci, with a preliminary note on experimental research. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry4: 25–30.
34.
OrrDRowsRG (1907a) Report XCIX. Lesions of spinal and cranial nerves experimentally produced by toxins. British Medical Journal1: 987–988.
35.
OrrDRowsRG (1907b) A clinical and experimental investigation into the lymphogenous origin of toxic infection of the central nervous system. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry5: 345–360.
36.
OrrDRowsRG (1907c) A demonstration of the lesions, experimentally produced, in the spinal cord and cranial nerves by the action of toxins. Journal of Mental Science53: 367–369.
37.
OrrDRowsRG (1908) Some points in the histology of lymphogenous and haematogenous toxic lesions of the spinal cord. Journal of Mental Science54: 560–561.
38.
OrrDRowsRG (trans.) (1909) Modern Problems in Psychiatry. By Ernesto Lugaro. University Press.
39.
OrrDRowsRG (1910a) The histological evidence that toxins reach the spinal cord via the spinal roots; with special reference to plasma cells. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry8: 721–748.
40.
OrrDRowsRG (1910b) The histological evidence that toxins reach the spinal cord via the spinal roots; with special reference to plasma-cells. Journal of Mental Science56: 86–89.
41.
OrrDRowsRG (1912a) The acute and subacute lesions induced in the spinal cord by infection of its lymph system. British Medical Journal2: 1105–1106.
42.
OrrDRowsRG (1912b) Subacute and acute inflammatory reactions produced in the spinal cord by infection of its lymph stream. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry10: 405–438.
43.
OrrDRowsRG (1914a) Lymphogenous infection of the central nervous system. Brain36(3–4): 271–340.
44.
OrrDRowsRG (1914b) Toxi-infection of the central nervous system. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Neurology Section) 7: 43–48.
45.
OrrDRowsRG (1914c) Further observations on the influence of toxins on the central nervous system. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Section of Psychiatry) 7: 21–31.
46.
OrrDRowsRG (1914d) Further observations on the influence of toxins on the central nervous system. Journal of Mental Science60: 184–191.
47.
OrrDRowsRG (1916) Toxi-infection of the central nervous system: A clinical and experimental investigation. Edinburgh Medical Journal17: 78–89.
48.
OrrDRowsRG (1917) Further observations on experimental toxi-infection of the central nervous system. Brain40(1): 1–14.
49.
OrrDRowsRG (1918a) The interdependence of the sympathetic and central nervous systems. Brain41(1): 1–22.
50.
OrrDRowsRG (1918b) Further observations on experimental toxi-infection of the central nervous system. Journal of Mental Science64: 18–29.
51.
OrrDRowsRGStephensonJL (1913a) The spread of infection by the ascending lymph stream of nerves from peripheral inflammatory foci to the central nervous system. Journal of Mental Science59: 411–428.
52.
OrrDRowsRGStephensonJL (1913b) The spread of infection by the ascending lymph stream of nerves from peripheral inflammatory foci to the central nervous system. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry11: 349–365.
53.
OrrDSturrockAC (1922) Toxi–infective lesions in the central nervous system. The influence of disturbance of the sympathetic mechanism on their localisation. Lancet2: 267–271.
54.
PearTH (1918) The war and psychology. Nature102: 88–89.
55.
PearTH (1960) Some early relations between English ethnologists and psychologists. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute90: 227–237.
56.
PierceBRowsRG (1914) Report of the Committee re status of British psychiatry and of medical officers. Journal of Mental Science60: 667–674.
57.
Report of the War Office Committee of Enquiry into “Shell-Shock” [RWOCESS]. (1922) HMSO, 70–71, 96, 117, 129.
58.
RiversWHR (1920) Instinct and the Unconscious. A Contribution to a Biological Theory of the Psycho-Neuroses. Cambridge University Press.
RiversWHRHeadH (1908) A human experiment in nerve division. Brain31: 323–450.
61.
Roberts-PedersenE (2015) Impelled to reminiscence: Millais Culpin, military psychiatry, and the politics of therapy. Health and History17: 1–16.
62.
RowlandsJK (1985) A mental hospital at war. The story of Moss Side Military Hospital, Maghull during the First World War [Typescript, 17 pages, of a lecture given by Dr John Rowlands to the Liverpool Medical History Society, February 1985. Liverpool Medical Institution, catalogue Class RA 988, Standard No. B10095.]
63.
RowsRG (1902) The bearing of recent research in the posterior root ganglia upon the new theories concerning the aetiology of tabes dorsalis. Journal of Mental Science48: 308–312, 369–371.
64.
RowsRG (1903a) Ein fall von cerebropathia psychica toxaemica (Korsakoff), gastro-intestinalen ursprunges. Emil Raimann, Monatsschr. F. Psychiat. u. Neurolog., Oct. 1902. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry1: 56–57.
65.
RowsRG (1903b) Lo sviluppo della cellula nervosa nel midollo spinale di pollo. O. Fragnito, Ann. di Nevrolo., 1902, f. 3. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry1: 19–22.
66.
RowsRG (1903c) Pathogénie du tabes dorsal. Nageotte, La Presse Médicale, Dec 10, 1902. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry1: 99–100.
67.
RowsRG (1903d) Cavities in the cord. British Medical Journal2: 1069.
68.
RowsRG (1903e) Cavities in the cord. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry1: 659–666.
69.
RowsRG (1906) Two cases of embryoma in the frontal lobe of the brain. Review of Neurology and Psychiatry4: 338–344.
70.
RowsRG (1912a) The development of psychiatric science as a branch of public health. Journal of Mental Science58: 25–39.
71.
RowsRG (1912b) A report on the conditions of the lunacy service and of the teaching of psychiatric medicine in Germany. Journal of Mental Science58: 610–622.
72.
RowsRG (1913) The status of British psychiatry and of medical officers. Journal of Mental Science59: 701–702.
73.
RowsRG (1914a) Clinics and centres for teaching. Journal of Mental Science60: 674–680.
74.
RowsRG (1914b) Proposal by Dr Rows on behalf of the Medical Officer and Psychiatry Committee. Journal of Mental Science60: 654–655.
75.
RowsRG (1914c) The importance of disturbance of the personality in mental disorders. Journal of Mental Science60: 192–224.
76.
RowsRG (1914d) The importance of disturbances of the personality in mental disorders. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Section of Psychiatry) 7: 33–64.
77.
RowsRG (1916) Mental conditions following strain and nerve shock. British Medical Journal1: 441–443.
78.
RowsRG (1920a) Anxiety states. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Neurology Section) 13: 61–65.
79.
RowsRG (1920b) Functional mental illnesses. The Morison Lectures, 1920. Edinburgh Medical Journal25: 76–91, 166–177, 228–242.
80.
RowsRG (1921) “Pseudotumors” of the brain. A remarkable combination of psychic, neurologic and autonomic symptoms. Journal of the American Medical Association77(21): 1643–1646.
81.
RowsRG (1922) The application of modern methods in the treatment of the psychoses. Lancet1: 522–526.
82.
RowsRGBondWE (1926) Epilepsy, a Functional Mental Illness: Its Treatment. HK Lewis.
83.
RowsRGOrrD (1920). Functional Mental Illnesses (The Morison Lectures, 1920) and The Interdependence of the Sympathetic and Central Nervous Systems in Relation to the Psychoneuroses (Reprinted from the Edinburgh Medical Journal). Oliver & Boyd.
84.
ShephardB (1996) “The early treatment of mental disorders”: R. G. Rows and Maghull 1914–1918. In: FreemanHBerriosGE (eds.) 150 Years of British Psychiatry Volume II: The Aftermath. Athlone Press, pp.434–464.
85.
ShephardB (2000) A War of Nerves. Soldiers and Psychiatrists 1914–1994. Jonathan Cape.
86.
SlobodinR (1978) W. H. R. Rivers. Columbia University Press.
87.
SmithGEPearTH (1917) Shell-Shock and Its Lessons. Manchester University Press.
88.
StoneM (1985) Shellshock and the psychologists. In: BynumWFShepherdMPorterR (eds) The Anatomy of Madness. Essays in the History of Psychiatry. Volume II. Institutions and Society. Routledge, pp.242–271.
89.
ThomsonDG (1914) Presidential Address on the progress of psychiatry during the past hundred years, together with the history of the Norfolk Asylum during the same period. Journal of Mental Science60: 541–572.
90.
TriarhouLC (2020) Pre-Brodmann pioneers of cortical cytoarchitectonics II: Carl Hammarberg, Alfred Walter Campbell and Grafton Elliot Smith. Brain Structure and Function225: 2591–2614.
91.
TurnerWA (1916a) Arrangements for the care of cases of nervous and mental shock coming from overseas. Lancet1: 1073–1075.
92.
TurnerWA (1916b) Arrangements for the care of cases of nervous and mental shock coming from overseas. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps27: 619–626.
93.
TurnerWA (1918) Neuroses and psychoses of war. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps31: 399–413.
94.
TurnerWA (1920) Influence of psychogenic factors in nervous disorders. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Neurology Section) 13: 1–16.
95.
TurnerWA (1927) Epilepsy: A functional mental illness. By R. G. Rows and W. E. Bond. London: H.K. Lewis and Co., Ltd., 1926. Demy 8vo. Pp. viii + 138 Price 8s. Journal of Mental Science73: 300–302.
96.
WalsheMR [sic] (1919) On the pathogenesis of diphtheritic paralysis. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps33: 328–342.
97.
WalsheFMR (1920) Forms of peripheral neuritis among troops serving with the Egyptian Expeditionary Force, 1915–19. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine (Neurology Section) 13: 49–60.
98.
WhiteEW (1918) Observations on shell shock and neurasthenia in the hospitals in the Western Command. British Medical Journal1: 421–422.
99.
WhiteE (1921) Discussion of: Good TS. The Oxford Clinic. Journal of Mental Science67: 529.
100.
YoungA (1999) W. H. R. Rivers and the war neuroses. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences35: 359–378.
