‘A matter for conjecture’: leucotomy in Western Australia,1947

Abstract

Very little has been published on the rise and fall of psychosurgery in Australia. In the mid-twentieth century, Western Australia was the largest but most sparsely-populated of the six Australian States, and its local psychiatry practice was, as one commentator put it, ‘backward’. Nonetheless, electroconvulsive therapy was introduced in 1945, and leucotomy in 1947. This paper will explore the introduction of leucotomy to Western Australia in the context of wider national and international trends in psychiatry, and posit some reasons for its decline and abandonment in the 1970s. It will present a narrative reconstruction of the local introduction and practice of leucotomy, using retrieved, reconstructed and previously unpublished data.

Keywords

Ainslie James P leucotomy Prendergast Francis psychosurgery Western Australia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Treatment of Patients – Leucotomy and Psychosurgery, AU WA S242 cons 3614 1962/336:

Follow Up Report on Leucotomy Cases Arranged Through Heathcote, circa Jan. 1957.

Letter, Adey to ‘Director Mental Hygiene’, 3 Apr. 1950.

Letter, Adey to Thompson, 28 Apr. 1950.

Letter, Ainslie to Thompson, 20 Feb. 1956.

Letter, Prendergast to Thompson, 12 Aug. 1947.

Letter, Repatriation Commission to Thompson, 11 Sep. 1947.

Letter, Thompson to Adey, 12 Apr. 1950.

Letter, Thompson to Repatriation Commission, 18 Aug. 1947.

10.

Letter, Undersecretary for Health to Minister for Health, 12 July 1956.

11.

Memorandum, Thompson, 23 Mar. 1956.

12.

Report, Leucotomy Operation, 7 Dec. 1956.

13.

Report, Leucotomy Patients, 30 Oct. 1957.

14.

Note, Rootes to Ellis, 10 Mar. 1967.

15.

Note, Davidson to Ellis, 10 Apr. 1967.

16.

Notes, Bill Fitzgerald to Board of Visitors, 12 Aug. 1948, Board of Visitors general correspondence, vol. 2, AN 200/3, acc 1374, item 1924/56.

17.

Notes, Board of Visitors meeting 11 Jan. 1952, Claremont Mental Hospital Board of Visitors – minutes and reports, vol. 3, AN 200/3, acc 1374, 1926/129.

18.

Anonymous (1945a) Brain operation not tried here. Daily News (Perth) (3 Oct.): 12.

19.

Anonymous (1945b) Only 200 service mental patients. Sunday Times (Perth) (4 Nov.): 5.

20.

Anonymous (1947a) Mental disorders. Methods of treatment. Big advances in recent years. West Australian (1 Feb.): 18.

21.

Anonymous (1947b) Plans new mental hospital. Mercury (19 Apr.): 4.

22.

Anonymous (1947c) Brain surgery dangers. ‘Intellectual robots’. West Australian (19 Dec.): 3.

23.

Anonymous (1949) Three Sydney stores chiefs here Tuesday. Sunday Times (Perth) (13 Mar.): 3.

24.

Anonymous (1950) Welcome home from youth forum. West Australian (25 Jan.): 12.

25.

Anonymous (1952) Leucotomy illegal in Q. Daily Mercury (21 Oct.): 12.

26.

Anonymous (1953) Ex-servicemen may undergo leucotomy operations. Warwick Daily News (21 Apr.): 6.

27.

Berrios

(1997) The origins of psychosurgery: Shaw, Burckhardt and Moniz. History of Psychiatry 7(1): 61–81.

28.

Blainey

(1966) The Tyranny of Distance: How Distance Shaped Australia’s History. Melbourne: Sun Books.

29.

Braslow

(1997) Mental Ills and Bodily Cures: Psychiatric Treatment in the First Half of the Twentieth Century. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

30.

Crammer

(1994) Britain in the fifties: leucotomy and open doors. History of Psychiatry 5(3): 393–395.

31.

Crossley

(1993) The introduction of leucotomy: a British case history. History of Psychiatry 4(4): 553–564.

32.

Edwards

(1947) Four cases of prefrontal leucotomy. Medical Journal of Australia 2: 512–516.

33.

Ellis

(1984) Eloquent Testimony: The Story of the Mental Health Services in Western Australia, 1830–1975. Crawley: University of Western Australia Press.

34.

Getz

(2009) The ice pick of oblivion: Moniz, Freeman and the development of psychosurgery. Trames: a Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences 13(2): 129–152.

35.

Goldney

Adams

(2009) Glenside Hospital’s role. Australasian Psychiatry 17(1): 56–58.

36.

Griffin

(1993) Ainslie, James Percival (1899–1973), surgeon. In: Ritchie

(ed.) Australian Dictionary of Biography. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press; accessed (15 Dec. 2017) at: http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/ainslie-james-percival-jim-9318/text16355

37.

Hay

Sachdev

(1992) The present state of psychosurgery in Australia and New Zealand. Medical Journal of Australia 157(6 July): 17–19.

38.

Helmes

Velamoor

(2009) Long term outcome of leucotomy on behaviour of people with schizophrenia. International Journal of Social Psychiatry 55(1): 64–70.

39.

Johnson

(2014) American Lobotomy: A Rhetorical History. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.

40.

Lapidus

Kopell

Ben-Haim

Rezai

Goodman

(2013) History of psychosurgery: a psychiatrist’s perspective. World Neurosurgery 80(3–4): S27.E1–S27.E16.

41.

Linford Rees

(1947) Review of UK Board of Control, Prefrontal Leucotomy in 1000 Cases. Eugenics Review 39(2): 73–74.

42.

McLaughlin

Greenberg

(2011) Other biological approaches to OCD. In: Steketee

(ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Obsessive Compulsive and Spectrum Disorders. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 307–321.

43.

Mashour

Walker

Martuza

(2005) Psychosurgery: past, present and future. Brain Research Reviews 48: 409–419.

44.

Partridge

(1949) Some reflections on the nature of affective disorders, arising from the results of prefrontal leucotomy. British Journal of Psychiatry 95(401): 795–825.

45.

Pippard

(1962) Leucotomy in Britain today. British Journal of Psychiatry 108(454): 249–255.

46.

Pippard

(2001) Leucotomy: a qualified defence of ‘then’. QJM: An International Journal of Medicine 94: 1.

47.

Pressman

(1998) Last Resort: Psychosurgery and the Limits of Medicine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

48.

Royal College of Surgeons (2014) Ainslie, James Percival (1899–1973). Plarr’s Lives of the Fellows Online; accessed (2 Feb. 2017) at: http://livesonline.rcseng.ac.uk/biogs/E005609b.htm

49.

Sachdev

Chen

(2008) Neurosurgical treatment of mood disorders: traditional psychosurgery and the advent of deep brain stimulation. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 22: 25–31.

50.

Sachdev

(2005) Long-term outcome of neurosurgery for the treatment of resistant depression. Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 17(4): 478–485.

51.

Schlich

(2015) Cutting the body to cure the mind. Lancet Psychiatry 2(5): 390–392.

52.

Schmalzbach

(1951) Present day problems of prefrontal leucotomy and its varieties. Medical Journal of Australia 21: 689–697.

53.

Showalter

(1985) The Female Malady: Women, Madness and English Culture 1830–1980. New York: Pantheon.

54.

Stampfer

(2009) History of the School of Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences (formerly the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioural Science), University of Western Australia – a brief overview; accessed (2 Feb. 2017) at: http://www.psychiatry.uwa.edu.au/depricated/home-/history

55.

Stoller

(1955) Report on Mental Health Facilities and Needs of Australia. Canberra: Government Printer.

56.

Swayze

(1995) Frontal leukotomy and related psychosurgical procedures in the era before antipsychotics (1935–1954): a historical overview. American Journal of Psychiatry 152(4): 505–515.

57.

Tooth

Newton

(1961) Leucotomy in England and Wales 1942–1954. London: HMSO.

58.

Western Australia (1919) Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Assembly on the Claremont Hospital for the Insane. Perth: Government Printer.

59.

Western Australia (1922) Report and Appendices of the Royal Commission in Lunacy. Perth: Government Printer.

60.

Western Australia (1935) Annual Report of the Inspector General of the Insane. Perth: Government Printer.

61.

Western Australia (1938) Report of the Royal Commission appointed to inquire into the Heathcote Mental Reception Home and the Administration of Mental Hospitals generally. Perth: Government Printer.

62.

Western Australia (1948) Annual Report of the Inspector General of Mental Hospitals. Perth: Government Printer.

63.

Western Australia (1951) Annual Report of the Inspector General of Mental Hospitals. Perth: Government Printer.

64.

White

McGee-Collett

(2016) The advent of psychosurgery in Australia – with particular attention to its introduction into Sydney. Australasian Psychiatry 25(4): 425–427.

‘A matter for conjecture’: leucotomy in Western Australia,1947–70

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References