During the First World War injured servicemen were constructed as a better class of patient than civilians, and their care was prioritized in social and political discourses. For the mentally disordered servicemen themselves, however, these distinctions were permeable and transient.
This article will challenge the reality of the ‘privileged’ service patient in civil asylums in Scotland. By examining the impact of the war on asylum structures, economies and patient health, this study will explore exactly which patients were valued in these difficult years. In so doing, this paper will also reveal how the lives of institutionalized ex-servicemen and the civilian insane inside district asylums were not quite as distinct as political and social groups would have liked.
Scottish Branch of the British Red Cross Society (SBBRCS) (n.d.) Report to the Scottish Council by the Chairman on the War Work of the Scottish Branch, N5/RC BTO1.
2.
SBBRCS (1921) Memorandum by the Scottish Branch of the British Red Cross Society on its War work, with maps. Edinburgh, London: HMSO.
3.
EDBC (1923) Report of Bangour Village, 1914–1923. Leith: William R. Duff & Co., LHB44/3/10.
4.
EDBC (27Apr. 1915) Special Committee. Minutes of Board and Committees, LHB44/1/16.
5.
MPDA (1917–33) Abstract of Accounts, vols 1 and 2, LHB33/15/3-4.
6.
MPDA (1874–1943) Register of Deaths, LHB33/6/1.
7.
WoodAD (1915) Meeting of the Board. Midlothian and Peebles Lunacy Board Minutes, 1913–1916, LHB33/1/6.
Commons Sitting (19May1915) Provision for Insane Soldiers, HC Deb., vol. 71, cc2331.
23.
Commons Sitting (10June1915) Army Casualties (mental strain), HC Deb., vol. 72, cc367-9.
24.
Commons Sitting (14June1915) Army Casualties (mental strain), HC Deb., vol. 72, cc491-3.
25.
Commons Sitting (16Sep. 1915) Mental and Nervous Cases (military), HC Deb., vol. 74, cc154-6.
26.
Written Answers (20July1915) Mental Troubles (treatment), HC Deb., vol. 73, cc1323-4.
27.
Yate, Col., Commons Sitting (24June1915) Visiting Committee of the Council may receive Boarders at Maudsley Hospital, HC Deb., vol. 72, cc1423.
28.
HotchkissRD (1917) Renfrew District Asylum as a war hospital for mental invalids: some contrasts in administration. With an analysis of cases admitted during the first year. Journal of Mental Science63(April): 238–249.
29.
LomaxM (1921) The Experiences of an Asylum Doctor with Suggestions for Asylum and Lunacy Reform. London: George Allen & Unwin.
30.
ThomsonDG (1916) A descriptive record of the conversion of a country asylum into a war hospital for sick and wounded soldiers in 1915. Journal of Mental Science62(256): 109–135.
31.
Abel-SmithB (1964) The Hospitals, 1800–1948. London: Heinemann.
32.
AndrewsJ (1997) A failure to flourish? David Yellowlees and the Glasgow School of Psychiatry: Part I. History of Psychiatry8(2): 177–212.
33.
BarhamP (2007) Forgotten Lunatics of the Great War. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
34.
BeechI (2005) The universal khaki: the impact of the asylum war hospital scheme on Cardiff City Mental Hospital, 1915–1920. Llafur: Journal of the Welsh People’s History Society9(2): 4–26.
35.
BourkeJ (2003) Wartime. In: CooterRPickstoneJ (eds) Companion to Medicine in the Twentieth Century. New York, London: Routledge, 589–601.
36.
BrumbyA (2015a) The Poor Law and mental healthcare, 1888–c.1929. Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of Huddersfield.
37.
BrumbyA (2015b) ‘A painful and disagreeable position’: rediscovering patient narratives and evaluating the difference between policy and experience for institutionalised veterans with mental disabilities, 1924–1931. First World War Studies6(1): 37–55.
38.
BurleighM (1994) Death and Deliverance: ‘Euthanasia’ in Germany 1900–1945. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39.
BurnsNParrHPhiloC (2003) ‘That awful place was home’: reflections on the contested meanings of Craig Dunain asylum. Scottish Geographical Journal119(4): 341–360.
40.
CameronEA (2010) Impaled upon a Thistle: Scotland Since 1880. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
41.
CherryS (2003) Mental Health Care in Modern England: The Norfolk Lunatic Asylum/St. Andrew’s Hospital c.1810–1998. Woodbridge: Boydell Press.
42.
CrammerJL (1992) The extraordinary deaths of asylum inmates during the 1914–1918 war. Medical History36(4): 430–441.
43.
DavisG (2008) ‘The Cruel Madness of Love’: Sex, Syphilis and Psychiatry in Scotland, 1880–1930. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
44.
FinlayR (2004) Modern Scotland, 1914–2000. London: Profile Books.
45.
HarvieC (1998) No Gods and Precious Few Heroes. Twentieth-Century Scotland, 3rd edn.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
46.
KeaneAM (1987) Mental health policy in Scotland, 1908–1960. Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of Edinburgh.
47.
KellyBD (2014) Shell shock in Ireland: The Richmond War Hospital, Dublin (1916–19). History of Psychiatry26(1): 50–63.
48.
LarssonM (2009) Families and institutions for shell-shocked soldiers in Australia after the First World War. Social History of Medicine22(1): 97–114.
49.
LenmanB (1977) An Economic History of Modern Scotland 1660–1976. London: Batsford.
50.
LongV (2010) Destigmatizing Mental Illness: Professional Politics, Stigma and Public Education in Britain. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
51.
ParrHPhiloC (2004) ‘They shut them out the road’: migration, mental health and the Scottish Highlands. Scottish Geographical Journal120(1–2): 47–70.
52.
PowellJ (2017) Shock troupe: medical film and the performance of ‘shell shock’ for the British nation at war’. Social History of Medicine30(2): 323–345.
53.
ReidF (2010) Broken Men: Shell Shock, Treatment and Recovery in Britain, 1914–1930. London: London Continuum.
