The debate on the causes and the nature of pellagra in Italy during the nineteenth century resembles and evokes the similar debate on General Paralysis of the Insane (GPI) that was growing at the same time in the United Kingdom. Pellagra and GPI had a massive and virulent impact on the populations of Italy and the UK, respectively, and contributed to a great extent to the increase and overcrowding of the asylum populations in these countries. This article compares the two illnesses by examining the features of their nosographic positioning, aetiology and pathogenesis. It also documents how doctors arrived at the diagnoses of the two diseases and how this affected their treatment.
BaillargerJGF (1847) De la Paralysie pellagreuse. Lu dans la sèance publique annuelle du 14 decèmbre 1847. Paris: Martinet.
2.
BalardiniL (1882) Relazione sulle cause della pellagra e sui mezzi per prevenirla e possibilmente curarla. Brescia: Tipografia Apollonio.
3.
BayleALJ (1822) Recherches sur les maladies mentales. Paris: L’imprimerie de Didot le Jeune.
4.
BayleALJ (1825) Nouvelle doctrine des maladies mentales. Paris : Gabon et Compagnie Libraires.
5.
BayleALJ (1826) Traité des maladies du cerveau et des ses membranes. Paris : Gabon et Compagnie Libraires.
6.
BerkleyHJ (1901) A Treatise on Mental Disease. London: Henry Kimpton.
7.
BerriosGE (2013) Per una nuova epistemologia della psichiatria. Rome: Fioriti Editore.
8.
BerriosGEPorterR (1995) A History of Clinical Psychiatry. The Origin and History of Psychiatric Disorders. London: The Athlone Press.
9.
BlandfordGF (1871) Insanity and its Treatment. London: Simpkin, Marshall & Co.
10.
BucknillCTukeDH (1858) A Manual of Psychological Medicine. Philadelphia: Blanchard and Lea.
11.
BucknillCTukeDH (1862) A Manual of Psychological Medicine, 2nd edn.London: John Churchill.
12.
BucknillCTukeDH (1879) A Manual of Psychological Medicine, 4th edn.London: J. & A. Churchill.
13.
BynumWF (1991) Tuke’s “Dictionary” and psychiatry at the turn of the century. In: BerriosGEFreemanH (eds) 150 years of British Psychiatry 1841–1991. London: Gaskell for The Royal College of Psychiatrists, 163–179.
14.
CabrasPLChitiSLippiD (2006) Joseph Guillaume Desmaisons Dupallance. La Francia alla ricerca del modello e l’Italia dei manicomi nel 1840. Florence: University Press.
15.
CagossiM (1989) Nascita dell’istituzionalismo secondo i resoconti di viaggio nell’ottocento. In: FerroFM (ed.) Passioni della mente e della Storia. Protagonisti, teorie e vicende della Psichiatria italiana tra ‘800 e ‘900. Milan: Vita e Pensiero, 289–308.
16.
CanosaR (1979) Storia del Manicomio in Italia. Milan: Feltrinelli.
17.
CarpenterJK (1983) The relationship of pellagra to corn and the low availability of niacin in cereals. In: Nutritional Adequacy, Nutrient Availability and Needs (Experientia Supplementum, No. 44). Basel: Springer, 197–222.
18.
DavisG (2008) ‘The Cruel Madness of Love’: Sex, Siphylis and Psychiatry in Scotland, 1880–1930. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
19.
EsquirolJED (1838) Des maladies mentales: considérées sous les rapports médicales, hygiénique et medico-legal, Tome I. Paris: Baillière.
20.
FournierJA (1894) Les affections parasyphilitiques. Paris : Rueff.
21.
FrancesA (2010) DSM in philosophyland: curiouser and curiouser. Bulletin of the Association for the Advancement of Philosophy and Psychiatry (AA.PP) 17(1): 21–25.
22.
GachJ (2008) Biological psychiatry in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In: WallaceERGachJ (eds) History of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology. New York: Springer, 381–418.
23.
GentilcoreD (2014) Peasants and pellagra in 19th-century in Italy. History Today64(9): 32–38.
GrobGN (2008) The Transformation of American Psychiatry. In: WallaceERGachJ (eds) History of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology. New York: Springer, 533–554.
26.
GucciR (1888) La pellagra nella Provincia di Firenze e in particolar modo la follia pellagrosa nel Manicomio di Bonifazio. Studi Statistici e considerazioni del Dott. Raffaello Gucci Medico del Manicomio di Firenze. Lo Sperimentale Giornale Italiano di Scienze Mediche XLII(LXI): 407–528.
27.
HoffP (1989) Immanenza e ricorsi nella nosografia: il pensiero nosologico nella psichiatria tedesca da Emil Kraepelin ad oggi. In: FerroFM (ed.) Passioni della mente e della Storia. Protagonisti, teorie e vicende della Psichiatria italiana tra ‘800 e ‘900. Milan: Vita e Pensiero, 45–55.
28.
HurnJD (1998) The history of the General Paralysis of the Insane in Britain, 1830 to 1950. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of London.
29.
KraepelinE (1989) Memorie. Pisa: Ets; translated from Lebenserinnerungen. (1983).
30.
LabusP (1847) La pellagra investigata sopra quasi duecento cadaveri di pellagrosi. Memoria con nove tavole dimostrative dedicata al nobile Signore Luigi Gianelli. Milan: Bonfanti.
31.
LopezMOlivaresJMBerriosGE (2014) Pellagra encephalopathy in the context of alcoholism: review and case report. Alcohol and Alcoholism49(1): 38–41.
32.
ManningFN (1868) Report on Lunatic Asylums. Sydney: Government Printer.
33.
MickleJWM (1886) General Paralysis of the Insane, 2nd edn.London: H.K. Lewis.
34.
PeltL (1847) Cenni storico medici intorno al Morocomio Femminile di Venezia: Giuntavi una memoria sulla pellagra localmente trattata e la statistica delle alienazioni per gli anni 1844/45/46. Venice: Naratovich.
35.
PietikainenP (2015) Madness. A History. New York: Routledge.
36.
PorroA (2007) Viaggi medici ottocenteschi in (a cura di) Albanese A – Cristini B Psicologia del turismo: prospettive future; un percorso di ricerca-formazione nazionale interdisciplinare: scritti in onore di Marcello Cesa-Bianchi. Milan: Franco Angeli, 117–121.
37.
PostelGQuetelC (2012) Nouvelle histoire de la psychiatrie. Paris: Dunod.
38.
RousselT (1866) Traité de la pellagre et des pseudo-pellagres. Paris : J.B. Baillière.
39.
SaccardoA (1847) Tavole statistiche sugli alienati che ebbero cura durante il triennio 1844–45–46 nel Morocomio centrale maschile di Venezia. Venice: Tipografia Armena.
40.
Salerio PadreP (1862) Tavole statistiche del Manicomio centrale maschile in San Servolo di Venezia del quinquiennio 1857–61. Venice: Tipografia Armena.
41.
Salerio PadreP (1871) Tavole statistiche triennali 1868–69–70 del Manicomio Centrale Maschile in San Servolo di Venezia. Cenni del P. Prosdocimo Dott. Salerio Medico Direttore. Venice: Tipografia della Società di Mutuo Soccorso.
42.
ScullA (1993) The Most Solitary of Afflictions. Madness and Society in Britain, 1700–1900. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
43.
ScullA (2015) Madness in Civilization. A Cultural History of Insanity. London: Thames & Hudson.
44.
ShepherdA (2014) Instituzionalizing the Insane in Nineteenth-Century England (Studies for the Society for the Social History of Medicine). London: Pickering & Chatto, pp. 118–125.
45.
ShorterE (1997) A History of Psychiatry. From the Era of the Asylum to the Age of Prozac. New York: Wiley; translated into Italian by NosedaA: (2000) Storia della Psichiatria. Dall’ospedale psichiatrico al Prozac. Milan: Masson.
46.
StrambioG (1826) Fallacia delle Osservazioni Critiche del Dott. Giuseppe Cerri al libro del Dott. Giovanni Strambio (junior) intitolato ‘Cagioni, natura e sede della pellagra’, ec. inserite dal Critico suddetto ne’ fascicoli 113., 116., 118. della Biblioteca Italiana. Milan: Coi tipi di Gio. Giuseppe Destefanis.
47.
ThompsonMS (1988) The wages of sin: the problem of alcoholism and general paralysis in nineteenth century Edinburgh. In: PorterRBynumWFShepherdM (eds) The Anatomy of Madness. Essays in the History of Psychiatry, Vol. 3. London: Routledge, 316–340.
48.
TuckerGA (1887) Lunacy in Many Lands. Sydney: Charles Potter.
49.
TukeDH (1892) A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, Vol. II. London: J. & A. Churchill.
50.
TukeJB (1877) The diagnosis of general paralysis of the insane. Edinburgh Medical Journal22(10): 865–869.
51.
VanniMissiroliN (1991) Ragioni e passioni epistemologiche nella polemica sulla pellagra tra Clodomiro Bonfigli e Cesare Lombroso. Rivista Sperimentale di Freniatria115(2): 763–777.
52.
VergaA (1849) Della pellagra e della paralisi generale degli alienati. Gazzetta Medica Lombarda (2. Serie) 2: 9–207.
53.
VignaC (1874) Il nuovo manicomio femminile di San Clemente : primo resoconto statistico del cav. Cesare Dott. Vigna. Venice: Antonelli.
54.
WallisJ (2013) The bones of the insane. History of Psychiatry24(2): 196–211.
55.
WallisJ (2015) Atrophied, engorged, debauched: muscle wastage, degenarate mass and moral worth in the general paralytic patient. In: KnowlesTTrowbridgeS (eds) Insanity and the Lunatic Asylum in the Nineteenth Century. London: Pickering & Chatto, 99–113.
56.
WeinerDB (2008) Philippe Pinel in the twenty-first century. In: WallaceERGachJ (eds) History of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology. New York: Springer, 305–312.
57.
WilkinsET (1871) Insanity and Insane Asylums – Report of M. D. Commissioner in Lunacy for the State of California, made to His Excellency H. H. Haight, Governor, December 2, 1871. Sacramento, CA: T.A. Springer.
