This article looks into the establishment and development of two criminal asylums in Norway. Influenced by international psychiatry and a European reorientation of penal law, the country chose to institutionalize insane criminals and criminally insane in separate asylums. Norway’s first criminal asylum was opened in 1895, and a second in 1923, both in Trondheim. Both asylums quickly filled up with patients who often stayed for many years, and some for their entire lives. The official aim of these asylums was to confine and treat dangerous and disruptive lunatics. Goffman postulates that total institutions typically fall short of their official aims. This study examines records of the patients who were admitted to the two Trondheim asylums, in order to see if the official aims were achieved.
Archives from Kriminalasylet (PJ,KA, L.nr 1–173) [Patient casebooks].
3.
Archives from Reitgjerdet asylum (PJ,RG, lnr. 1–641) [Patient casebooks].
4.
(All publications and theses with translated titles are in Norwegian)
5.
AndresenK (1923) Norges Offisielle Statistikk over Sindssygehusenes Virksomhed [Official Statistics of Norwegian asylums]. In: Beretninger fra Reitgjerdet asyl [The Reitgjerdet Annual Report]. Oslo: H. Aschehoug Publishing, 1–45.
6.
BlombergW (2005) Some traits of Norwegian pre-medical reactions to madness. History of Psychiatry16(1): 99–105.
7.
DahlHThomassenØ (2015) Om sikring og farlighetserklæringer – sikkerhetspsykiatrien etableres [About declarations of dangerousness and secured sentences – the establishment of forensic psychiatry in Norway]. Tidsskrift for strafferett15(2): 177–195.
8.
EsquirolJED (1838) Des maladies mentales …. Paris: J.B. Ballière; trans. and ed. by HuntJK: Mental Maladies: A Treatise on Insanity. Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard.
GoffmanE (1991[1961]) Asylums; Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. Harmondswoth, UK: Penguin.
11.
GreigD (2002) Neither Bad nor Mad – the Competing Discourses of Psychiatry, Law and Politics. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
12.
KarmelM (1969) Total institutions and self-mortification. Journal of Health and Social Behavior10(2): 134–141.
13.
KorenE (2008) Beskytte, forme, styrke. Helsefremmende arbeid overfor norske sjøfolk i utenriksfart med hovedvekt på perioden 1890–1940 [Protect, shape, strengthen. Health-promoting work in Norwegian shipping 1890–1940]. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Bergen.
14.
KringlenE (2004) A history of Norwegian psychiatry. History of Psychiatry15(3): 259–283.
15.
LemertEM (1981) Issues in the study of deviance. Sociological Quarterly22(Spring): 285–305.
16.
LevinsonDJGallagherEB (1964) Patient-hood in the Mental Hospital. Boston, MA: Houghton-Mifflin.
17.
LinnLS (1968) The mental hospital from the patient perspective. Psychiatry31(3): 213–223.
18.
LombrosoC (1876) L’uomo delinquente studiato in rapporto alla antropologia, alla medicina legale, ed alle discipline carcerarie. Milan: Hoepli.
19.
MorelBA (1857) Traité des dégénérescences physiques, intellectuelles et morales de l’espèce humaine et des causes qui produisent ces variétés maladives. Paris: J.B. Baillière.
20.
MyhreEThomassenØ (2014) The construction of an accepted masculinity: castration in high security psychiatric institutions in Norway 1923–1945. In: LanderISigneRJonN (eds) Masculinities in the Criminological Field: Control, Vulnerability and Risk Taking. London: Ashgate, 89–109.
Norwegian Criminalist Association (1894) Stensiltrykk [Discussion]. Kristiana: H. Aschehoug & Co.
23.
NylennaM (2000) De ‘to kulturer’ i medisinen [The two ‘cultures’ of medicine]. Tidsskrift for den Norske Legeforening120: 3732–3735.
24.
Oth.Prp.No. 4 (1898) Angaaende Utfærdigelse af en Lov angaaende Kriminalasylet [On the passing of a Criminal Asylum Law] (Government White Paper).
25.
Ot.Prp.Nr. 51 (1922) Om utferdigelse av en lov om Reitgjerdet asyl [Government White Paper: On the passing of a Law for Reitgjerdet asylum].
26.
PorterR (1996) A Social History of Madness. Stories of the Insane. London: Phoenix; originally published in 1987 by Weidenfld & Nicolson.
27.
RiaunetÅ (2014) Oppdrag, pasienter og praksiser. Kriminalasylet i Trondheim 1895–1905 [Assignment, patients and practice. The Criminal Asylum in Norway 1895–1905]. Unpublished Master’s thesis, NTNU, Trondheim.
28.
SchaanningE (2002) Kampen om den forbryterske sjel [The Battle about the Criminal Soul]. Oslo: Unipub forlag.
29.
ShalinDN (2013) Goffman on mental illness: ‘Asylums’ and ‘The Insanity of Place’ revisited. Symbolic Interaction37(1): 122–144.
30.
SieglerMOsmondH (1971) Goffman’s model of mental illness. British Journal of Psychiatry119(551): 419–424.
31.
SSB: Norwegian Statistical Bureau (1965) Ekteskap, fødsler og vandringer 1865–1960 [Marriages, births and migrations in Norway 1865–1960]. (Samfunnsøkonomiske studier nr.13). Oslo: SSB.
32.
Sth.Prp.No. 73 (1894) Indstilling fra Næringskomiteen No.2 angaaende Bevilgning til Anlæg og Drift af et midlertidig Kriminalasyl I den nedlagte Afdeling B af Trondhjems Straffeanstalt [Government White Paper: Conclusions of the committee no. 2 on the appropriation for rebuilding and maintenance of a temporary criminal asylum in Trondheim].
33.
St.Prp.Nr. 206 (1919) Om bevilgning til å omdanne Reitgjerdet pleiestiftelse for spedalske til asyl for særlig vanskelige og farlige sinnssyke [On the appropriation for rebuilding the Reitgjerdet leprosy hospital as a criminal asylum for disruptive and dangerous insane male patients]. Socialdepartementets [Department of Social Affairs] innstilling av 27de juni 1919.
34.
ThomassenØ (2010) Diagnosing the criminally insane in Norway 1895–1915. In: AndresenAHubbardWRyyminT (eds) International and Local Approaches to Health and Health Care. Oslo: Novus Press, 27–86.
35.
ThomassenØ (2015a) Asylene for de sinnssyke og farlige mennene – Kriminalasylet og Reitgjerdet [The asylums for dangerous men – Kriminalasylet and Reitgjerdet asylum]. In: Norsk rettsmuseums skriftserie nr.3: Galskapens fengsel [Norwegian Museum of Justice Anthology Nr. 3: The Mental Machine]. NTNU fagtrykk, Anthology on Norwegian Criminal Asylums, Norway.
