Puerperal insanity has been described as a nineteenth-century diagnosis, entrenched in contemporary expectations of proper womanly behaviour. Drawing on detailed study of establishment registers and patient case notes, this paper examines the puerperal insanity diagnosis at Dundee Lunatic Asylum between 1820 and 1860. In particular, the study aims to consider whether the class or social status of the patients had a bearing on how their conditions were perceived and rationalized, and how far the puerperal insanity diagnosis, coloured by the values assigned to it by the medical officers, may have been reserved for some women and not for others. This examination of the diagnosis in a Scottish community, suggesting a contrast in the way that middle-class and working-class women were diagnosed at Dundee, engages with and expands on work on puerperal insanity elsewhere.
AD14/41/193 (1841) Precognition against Catherine Symon for the crime of murder at River Tay, Dundee; and AD14/60/61 (1860) Precognition against Bridget Kiernan for the crime of murder at Playfair’s Close, Hawkhill, Dundee.
3.
Anonymous (1859a) Revolting charge of assault by a man on his own daughter. Dundee Courier (22June).
4.
Anonymous (1859b) Supposed child-murder or concealment of pregnancy. Dundee Courier (14Sep).
5.
Anonymous (1859c) Child murder or concealment of pregnancy. Dundee Courier (12Oct).
6.
Anonymous (1860) Respite for Bridget Kiernan. Glasgow Herald (2May).
DenmanT (1807) An Introduction to the Practice of Midwifery. Brattleborough [sic], VT: William Fessenden; first published in London in 1788 (or earlier).
12.
GoochR (1820) Observations on puerperal insanity. Medical Transactions6: 263–324; paper read at the Royal College of Physicians, 16Dec.1819.
13.
JC: High Court of Justiciary processes, Catalogues and Indexes, National Records of Scotland (NRS); Catalogue entries viewed (7 Dec. 2015) at: http://www.nrscotland.gov.uk:
14.
JC26/1860/18 (1860) Trial papers relating to Bridget Kiernan for the crime of murder at Playfair’s Close, Hawkhill, Dundee.
15.
JC26/1875/333 (1875) Trial papers relating to Helen Rose Robb for the crime of murder at New Downie, Monikie parish, Forfarshire.
16.
Medical Directory (1878) London: Churchill.
17.
SkaeD (1863) A rational and practical classification of insanity. Journal of Mental Science9(47): 309–319.
18.
University of Dundee Archives (DUA), Records of (Royal) Dundee Lunatic Asylum:
19.
THB 7/4/2 Annual Reports of the Directors of the Dundee (Royal) Lunatic Asylum1820–1947.
AbramsL (2002) From demon to victim: the infanticidal mother in Shetland, 1699–1899. In: GallowayYGFergussonR (eds) (2002) Twisted Sisters: Women, Crime and Deviance in Scotland since 1400. East Linton: Tuckwell Press, 180–203.
25.
AndrewsJ (1998) Case notes, case histories and the patient’s experience of insanity at Gartnavel Royal Asylum, Glasgow, in the nineteenth century. Social History of Medicine11(2): 255–281.
26.
BerkenkotterC (2008) Patient Tales: Case Histories and the Uses of Narrative in Psychiatry. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
27.
BusfieldJCamplingJ (1996) Men, Women and Madness: Understanding Gender and Mental Disorder. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
CossinsA (2015) Female Criminality: Infanticide, Moral Panics and The Female Body. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
29.
DavisG (2005) Some historical uses of clinical psychiatric records. Scottish Archives11: 26–36.
30.
DavisG (2008) ‘The Cruel Madness of Love’: Sex, Syphilis and Psychiatry in Scotland, 1880–1930. Amsterdam: Brill Academic Publishers.
31.
DayS (1985) Puerperal insanity: the historical sociology of a disease. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Cambridge.
32.
GordonE (1987) Women, work and collective action: Dundee jute workers, 1870–1906. Journal of Social History21: 27–48.
33.
HoganS (2006) The tyranny of the maternal body: madness and maternity. Women’s History Magazine54(Autumn): 21–30.
34.
KildayAM (2013) A History of Infanticide in Britain, c. 1600 to the Present. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
35.
LoudonI (1988) Puerperal insanity in the 19th century. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine81: 76–79.
36.
MarlandH (1999) At home with puerperal mania: the domestic treatment of insanity of childbirth in the nineteenth century. In: BartlettPWrightD (eds) Outside the Walls of the Asylum: The History of Care in the Community, 1750–2000. London: Athlone, 45–65.
37.
MarlandH (2003a) Disappointment and desolation: women, doctors and interpretations of puerperal insanity in the nineteenth century. History of Psychiatry14(3): 303–320.
38.
MarlandH (2003b) Maternity and madness: puerperal insanity in the nineteenth century. Unpublished paper presented at a Seminar at Warwick University, April 2003; accessed (19 Aug. 2016) at: http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/39210/
39.
MarlandH (2004) Dangerous Motherhood: Insanity and Childbirth in Victorian Britain. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
40.
MarlandH (2012) Under the shadow of maternity: birth, death and puerperal insanity in Victorian Britain. History of Psychiatry23(1): 78–90.
41.
MiskellL (2000) Civic leadership and the manufacturing elite: Dundee, 1820–1870. In: MiskellL and 7 others (eds) Victorian Dundee: Image and Realities. East Linton: Tuckwell Press, 51–69.
42.
NakamuraLE (1999) Puerperal insanity: women, psychiatry and the asylum in Victorian England, 1820–1895. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Washington.
43.
O’HaraMWMcCabeJE (2013) Postpartum depression: current status and future. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology9: 379–407.
44.
PeggS (2009) ‘Madness is a woman’: Constance Kent and Victorian constructions of female insanity. Liverpool Law Review30(3): 207–223.
45.
QuinnC (2002) Images and impulses: representations of puerperal insanity and infanticide in late Victorian England. In: JacksonM (ed.) Infanticide: Historical Perspectives on Child Murder and Concealment, 1550–2000. Aldershot: Ashgate, 193–215.
46.
QuinnCL (2003) Include the mother and exclude the lunatic: a social history of puerperal insanity, c.1860–1922. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Exeter.
47.
RehmanAUSt ClairDPlatzC (1990) Puerperal insanity in the 19th and 20th centuries. British Journal of Psychiatry156: 861–865.
48.
RorieJ (1887) On the treatment of the insane sixty years ago as illustrated by the earlier records of the Dundee Royal Asylum. British Journal of Psychiatry33: 1–9.
49.
ScullA (2009) Hysteria: The Biography. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
50.
ShowalterE (1980) Victorian women and insanity. Victorian Studies23: 157–181.
51.
ShowalterE (1987) The Female Malady: Women, Madness and English Culture, 1830–1980. New York: Penguin Books.
52.
TheriotNM (1990) Diagnosing unnatural motherhood: nineteenth-century physicians and ‘puerperal insanity’. American Studies26: 69–88.
53.
TheriotNM (1993) Women’s voices in nineteenth-century medical discourse: a step toward deconstructing science. Signs19: 1–31.
54.
TurnerTH (1992) A diagnostic analysis of the casebooks of Ticehurst Asylum, 1845–1890. Psychological Medicine, Monograph Supplement 21: 1–70.
55.
WalshL (1999) ‘The property of the whole community’. Charity and insanity in urban Scotland: the Dundee Royal Lunatic Asylum 1805–1850. In: MellingJ (ed) Insanity, Institutions and Society, 1800–1914: A Social History of Madness in Comparative Perspective. London: Routledge, 180–199.
56.
WhatleyCASwinfenDBSmithAM (1993) The Life and Times of Dundee. Edinburgh: John Donald.
