A central question in cognitive science is whether natural language provides combinatorial operations that are essential to diverse domains of thought. In the study reported here, we addressed this issue by examining the role of linguistic mechanisms in forging the hierarchical structures of algebra. In a 3-T functional MRI experiment, we showed that processing of the syntax-like operations of algebra does not rely on the neural mechanisms of natural language. Our findings indicate that processing the syntax of language elicits the known substrate of linguistic competence, whereas algebraic operations recruit bilateral parietal brain regions previously implicated in the representation of magnitude. This double dissociation argues against the view that language provides the structure of thought across all cognitive domains.
ButterworthB. (2005). Developmental dyscalculia. In CampbellJ. I. (Ed.), Handbook of mathematical cognition (pp. 455–467). New York, NY: Psychology Press.
2.
CappellettiM.ButterworthB.KopelmanM. (2001). Spared numerical abilities in a case of semantic dementia. Neuropsychologia, 39, 1224–1239.
3.
ChomskyN. (1998). Language and the problems of knowledge. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
4.
CipolottiL.ButterworthB.DenesG. (1991). A specific deficit for numbers in a case of dense acalculia. Brain, 114, 2619–2637.
5.
Cohen KadoshR.MuggletonN.SilvantoJ.WalshV. (2010). Double dissociation of format-dependent and number-specific neurons in human parietal cortex. Cerebral Cortex, 20, 2166–2171.
6.
DehaeneS.PiazzaM.PinelP.CohenL. (2003). Three parietal circuits for number processing. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 20, 487–506.
7.
DevauchelleA.OppenheimC.RizziL.DehaeneS.PallierC. (2009). Sentence syntax and content in the human temporal lobe: An fMRI adaptation study in auditory and visual modalities. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 21, 1000–1012.
8.
FadigaL.CraigheroL.D’AusilioA. (2009). Broca’s area in language, action, and music. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1169, 448–458.
9.
FiasW.LammertynJ.CaessensB.OrbanG. (2007). Processing of abstract ordinal knowledge in the horizontal segment of the intraparietal sulcus. Journal of Neuroscience, 27, 8952–8956.
10.
FitchW. T.HauserM. D.ChomskyN. (2005). The evolution of the language faculty: Clarifications and implications. Cognition, 97, 179–210.
11.
FodorenkoE.BehrM. K.KanwisherN. (2011). Functional specificity for high-level linguistic processing in the human brain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 108, 16428–16433.
12.
FriedericiA. D.BahlmannJ.HeimS.SchubotzR. I.AnwanderA. (2006). The brain differentiates human and non-human grammars: Functional localization and structural connectivity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 103, 2458–2463.
13.
GrodzinskyY.SantiA. (2008). The battle for Broca’s region. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 12, 474–480.
14.
HagoortP. (2005). On Broca, brain, and binding: A new framework. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 9, 416–423.
15.
HanakawaT.HondaM.SawamotoN.OkadaT.YonekuraY.FukuyamaH.ShibasakiH. (2002). The role of rostral Brodmann Area 6 in mental-operation tasks: An integrative neuroimaging approach. Cerebral Cortex, 12, 1157–1170.
16.
HauserM. D.ChomskyN.FitchW. T. (2002). The faculty of language: What is it, who has it, and how did it evolve?Science, 298, 1569–1579.
17.
IschebeckA.HeimS.SiedentopfC.ZamarianL.SchockeM.KremserC.. . . DelazerM. (2008). Are numbers special? Comparing the generation of verbal materials from ordered categories (months) to numbers and other categories (animals) in an fMRI study. Human Brain Mapping, 29, 894–909.
18.
JubaultT.OdyC.KoechlinE. (2007). Serial organization of human behavior in the inferior parietal cortex. Journal of Neuroscience, 27, 11028–11036.
19.
KnopsA.ThirionB.HubbardE.MichelV.DehaeneS. (2009). Recruitment of an area involved in eye movements during mental arithmetic. Science, 324, 1583–1585.
20.
KoenigsM.BarbeyA. K.PostleB. R.GrafmanJ. (2009). Superior parietal cortex is critical for the manipulation of information in working memory. Journal of Neuroscience, 29, 14980–14986.
21.
LevinsonS. (2003). Language in mind: Let’s get the issues straight! In GentnerD.Goldin-MeadowS. (Eds.), Language in mind: Advances in the investigation of language and thought (pp. 25–46). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
22.
MazzoccoM. M.ThompsonL.SudhalterV.BelserR. C.Lesniak-KarpiakK.RossJ. L. (2006). Language use in females with fragile X or Turner syndrome during brief initial social interactions. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 27, 319–328.
23.
MontiM. M.OshersonD. N. (2012). Logic, language and the brain. Brain Research, 1428, 33–42.
24.
MontiM. M.OshersonD. N.MartinezM. J.ParsonsL. M. (2007). Functional neuroanatomy of deductive inference: A language-independent distributed network. NeuroImage, 37, 1005–1016.
25.
MontiM. M.ParsonsL. M.OshersonD. N. (2009). The boundaries of language and thought in deductive inference. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 106, 12554–12559.
26.
NiederA.DehaeneS. (2009). Representation of number in the brain. Annual Reviews of Neuroscience, 32, 185–208.
27.
NovickJ. M.TrueswellJ. C.Thompson-SchillS. L. (2010). Broca’s area and language processing: Evidence for the cognitive control connection. Language and Linguistics Compass, 4, 906–924.
28.
OsakaM.KemoriM.MorishitaM.OsakaN. (2007). Neural bases of focusing attention in working memory: An fMRI study based on group differences. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience, 7, 130–139.
29.
PallierC.DevauchelleA.DehaeneS. (2011). Cortical representation of the constituent structure of sentences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 108, 2522–2527.
30.
PiazzaM.PinelP.Le BihanD.DehaeneS. (2007). A magnitude code common to numerosities and number symbols in human intraparietal cortex. Neuron, 53, 293–305.
31.
PradoJ.NoveckI. A.Van Der HenstJ. (2010). Overlapping and distinct neural representations of numbers and verbal transitive series. Cerebral Cortex, 20, 720–729.
SmithS. M.JenkinsonM.WoolrichM. W.BeckmannC. F.BehrensT. E.Johansen-BergH.. . . MatthewsP. M. (2004). Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation as FSL. NeuroImage, 23, S208–S219.
34.
SpelkeE. S.TsivkinS. (2001). Language and number: A bilingual training study. Cognition, 78, 45–88.
35.
TettamantiM.WenigerD. (2006). Broca’s area: A supramodal hierarchical processor?Cortex, 42, 491–494.
36.
VarleyR. A.KlessingerN. C.RomanowskiC. A. J.SiegalM. (2005). Agrammatic but numerate. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 102, 3519–3524.
37.
WallentinM.RoepstorffA.GloverR.BurgessN. (2006). Parallel memory systems for talking about location and age in precuneus, caudate and Broca’s region. NeuroImage, 32, 1850–1864.
38.
WhorfB. L. (1940). Science and linguistics. Technology Review, 42, 229–231, 247–248.
39.
ZagoL.PesentiM.MelletE.CrivelloF.MazoyerB.Tzourio-MazoyerN. (2001). Neural correlates of simple and complex mental calculation. NeuroImage, 13, 314–327.
40.
ZagoL.PetitL.TurbelinM.AnderssonF.VigneauM.Tzourio-MazoyerN. (2008). How verbal and spatial manipulation networks contribute to calculation: An fMRI study. Neuropsychologia, 46, 2403–2414.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
