“Don’t teach us what is sanitation and hygiene.” This quote from Maqbul, a middle-aged male resident in Modher Bosti, a slum in Dhaka city, summed up the frustration of many people living in urban poverty to ongoing sanitation and hygiene programmes. In the light of their experiences, such programmes provide “inappropriate sanitation”, or demand personal investments in situations of highly insecure tenure, and/or teach “hygiene practices” that relate neither to local beliefs nor to the ground realities of a complex urban poverty. A three-year ethnographic study in Chittagong, Dhaka, Nairobi and Hyderabad illustrated that excreta disposal systems, packaged and delivered as low-cost “safe sanitation”, do not match the sanitation needs of a very diverse group of urban men, women and children. It is of little surprise that the delivered systems are neither appropriate nor used, and are not sustained beyond the life of the projects. This mismatch, far more than an assumed lack of user demand for sanitation, contributes to the elusiveness of the goal of sanitation and health for all. The analysis indicates that unless and until the technical, financial and ethical discrepancies relating to sanitation for the urban poor are resolved, there is little reason to celebrate the recent global declaration on the human right to water and sanitation and health for all.
Ahmed, Iftekhar K ( 2007), Urban Poor Housing in Bangladesh and Potential Role of the ACHR, Commissioned Report for the Asian Coalition for Housing Rights, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 29 pages.
2.
Ahmed, R. ( 2006), A Case Study on Reaching the Poorest and Vulnerable , Proceedings of the 32nd WEDC International Conference, Colombo, Sri Lanka, November.
3.
Allen, Adriana, Julio Davila and Pascale Hofmann ( 2006), "The peri-urban water poor: citizens or consumers?"Environment and Urbanization Vol 18, No 2, October, pages 333-351.
4.
Banashree, B. ( 2002), "Mainstreaming the urban poor in Andhra Pradesh", in David Westendorff and Deborah Eade (editors), Development and Cities, UNRISD, Geneva, and Oxfam, Oxford, 368 pages.
5.
Beall, Jo, Owen Crankshaw and Susan Parnell ( 2008), "Victims, villains and fixers: the urban environment and Johannesburg’s poor", Journal of South African Studies Vol 26, No 4, pages 833-855.
6.
Begum, A. ( 1999), Destination Dhaka: Urban Migration: Expectations and Reality, Vedams Books (P) Ltd, New Delhi, 194 pages.
7.
Bond, Patrick ( 2002), Unsustainable South Africa: Environment, Development and Social Protest, University of Natal Press, Scottsville, South Africa, 449 pages.
8.
Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions (COHRE) and Asian Coalition of Housing Rights (ACHR) (2001), Forced Evictions in Bangladesh: We Didn’t Stand A Chance, 68 pages.
9.
Christoffers, T., C van Wijk and V. Njugana ( 2005), "Making hygiene promotion cost-effective", WELL Briefing Note14, WELL , WEDC, Loughborough University .
10.
Evans, Barbara ( 2005), Securing Sanitation - The Compelling Case to Address the Crisis, Stockholm International Water Institute and the World Health Organization, Stockholm, 40 pages.
11.
Hasan, Arif ( 2006), "Orangi Pilot Project: the expansion of work beyond Orangi and the mapping of informal settlements and infrastructure", Environment and Urbanization Vol 18, No 2, October, pages 451-480.
12.
Hollick, J Crandall ( 2000), Apna Street, accessible at http://www.ibaradio.org/India/apna/apna.htm.
13.
Iied (2001), "Rethinking aid to urban poverty reduction: lessons for donors", Environment and Urbanization Brief No 3, International Institute for Environment and Development, London.
14.
Islam, Nazrul ( 1996), The Urban Poor in Bangladesh, Centre for Urban Studies, Dhaka.
15.
Islam, N, N Huda , D Narayan, B Francis, B Rana and B Pradumna (editors) (1997), Addressing the Urban Poverty Agenda in Bangladesh: Critical Issues and the 1995 Survey Findings, DhakaUniversity Press Limited (for the Asian Development Bank).
16.
Joshi, D., J. Morgan and B. Fawcett ( 2005), Sanitation for the Urban Poor: Whose Choice, Theirs or Ours?, unpublished research report prepared for DFID, downloadable from http://www.dfid.gov.uk/r4d/PDF/Outputs/Water/R8028-FTR.pdf , 202 pages.
17.
Kabeer, N. ( 2000), The Power to Choose: Bangladeshi Women and Labour Markets Decisions in London and Dhaka, Verso, London, 464 pages.
18.
Kabir, Rachel ( 2002), "Assessment and analysis of the situation of adolescent boys in Bangladesh", Report prepared for UNICEF-Bangladesh , Dhaka.
19.
Kariuki, P.W. ( 1999), "Street children and their families in Nairobi" , in S Jones and N Nelson (editors), Urban Poverty in Africa: From Understanding to Alleviation, Intermediate Technology Publications, London, 272 pages.
20.
McKean, B. ( 2009), "Invisible lives: stories of innovation and transition in Mumbai", Intersections Vol 10, No 2, pages 1-57.
21.
Mannan Fouzia and Sabina F Rashid ( 2004), "The heterogeneity of the urban poor", unpublished paper, Dhaka.
22.
Mehta, L. ( 2007), "Liquid dynamics", STEPS Briefing6 from L. Mehta, F. Marshall, S. Movik, A. Stirling, E. Shah, A. Smith and J. Thompson (2007), Liquid Dynamics: Challenges for Sustainability in Water and Sanitation, STEPS Working Paper6, STEPS Centre , Brighton, 26 pages.
23.
Opel, Aftab E A ( 1998), Livelihoods of the Vulnerable, Paper presented at the National Workshop on Urban Livelihoods, Institute of Development Policy Analysis and Advocacy (IDPAA), Dhaka , 14-18 January.
24.
Paul-Majumder, P., S. Mahmud and R. Afsar ( 1996), The Squatters of Dhaka City: Dynamism in the Life of Agargaon Squatters, DhakaUniversity Press Limited, 116 pages.
25.
Penner, Barbara ( 2010), "Flush with inequality: sanitation in South Africa" , Places, accessible at http://places.designobserver.com/entry.html?entry=21619 .
26.
Rashid, Sabina F ( 2004), Worried Lives: Poverty, Gender and Reproductive Health of Married Adolescent Women Living in Urban Slums in Dhaka, Bangladesh , unpublished PhD thesis, the Australian National University , Canberra, Australia.
27.
Satterthwaite, David ( 2003), "The Millennium Development Goals and urban poverty reduction: great expectations and nonsense statistics", Environment and Urbanization Vol 15, No 2, October, pages 181-190.
28.
SIWI and the UN Millennium Project (2005), Health, Dignity and Development: What Will It Take? United Nations Millennium Project Task Force on Water and Sanitation, Final Report, Stockholm International Water Institute (SIWI) , Stockholm, 64 pages.
29.
Sobhan, R. ( 2002), "Moving from confrontational politics towards sustainable democracy in Bangladesh" , Dhaka Courier, 26 April.
30.
UN-Habitat (2010), State of the World’s Cities 2010- 2011. Cities for All: Bridging the Urban Divide , Nairobi, Kenya, 244 pages.
31.
Verhagen, Joep and Peter Ryan ( 2008), "Sanitation services for the urban poor", Background Paper for the Symposium on Sanitation for the Urban Poor - Partnerships and Governance, IRC, Delft, The Netherlands, 19-21 November.
32.
Wood, G. ( 1998), "Investing in networks: livelihoods and social capital in Dhaka slums", Paper presented at the National Workshop on Urban Livelihoods, Institute of Development Policy Analysis and Advocacy (IDPAA), Dhaka, 14-18 January.
33.
WSP (2009), Guidance Notes on Services for the Urban Poor: A Practical Guide for Improving Water Supply and Sanitation, Water and Sanitation Programme, World Bank, Washington DC, 76 pages.
