In vitro tests of substitute lubricants for wear testing orthopaedic biomaterials

Abstract

Bovine serum is the lubricant recommended by several international standards for the wear testing of orthopaedic biomaterials; however, there are issues over its use due to batch variation, degradation, cost and safety. For these reasons, alternative lubricants were investigated. A 50-station Super-CTPOD (circularly translating pin-on-disc) wear test rig was used, which applied multidirectional motion to ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene test pins rubbing against cobalt chromium discs. Thirteen possible alternative lubricants were tested. The use of soy protein as a lubricant gave statistically higher wear, while soya oil, olive oil, Channel Island milk, whole milk, whey, wheatgerm oil, 11 mg/mL egg white, albumin/globulin mix and albumin/globulin/chondroitin sulphate mix all gave statistically lower wear than bovine serum. The lubricants giving the closest wear results to bovine serum were 20 and 40 mg/mL egg white solutions. A light absorbance assay found that these egg white solutions suffered from a high degradation rate that increased with increasing protein content. While egg white solutions offer the best alternative lubricant to bovine serum due to the wear volumes produced, cost-effectiveness and safety of handling, protein degradation will still occur, leading to the need for regular lubricant replacement. Of the lubricants tested in this study, none were found to be superior to bovine serum.

Keywords

Wear Super-CTPOD alternative lubricants CoCr ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

National Joint Registry for England and Wales. 9th annual report (eds Porter

Borroff

Gregg

), 2012, www.njrcentre.org.uk

The Swedish Hip Arthroplasty Register. Annual report 2008 (eds Garellick

Karrholm

Rogmark

Herberts

), October 2009, www.shpr.se.

The Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register. Annual report 2010 (eds Lidgren

Sundberg

W-Dahl

Robertson

), October, 2010, www.knee.se.

Ahlroos

Saikko

. Wear of prosthetic joint materials in various lubricants. Wear 1997; 211: 113–119.

Brown

Clarke

. A review of lubrication conditions for wear simulation in artificial hip replacements. Tribol T 2006; 49(1): 72–78.

BS ISO 14243-1:2009. Implants for surgery – wear of total knee joint prostheses, in part 1: loading and displacement parameters for wear-testing machines with load control and corresponding environmental conditions for test.

BS ISO 14242-1:2002. Implants for surgery – wear of total hip joint prostheses, in part 1: Loading and displacement parameters for wear-testing machines and corresponding environmental conditions for test.

ASTM F732–00:2000. Standard testing method for wear testing of polymeric materials used in total joint prostheses.

Kaddick

Wimmer

. Hip simulator wear testing according to the newly introduced standard ISO 14242. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2001; 215(5): 429–442.

10.

Liao

Benya

McKellop

. Effect of protein lubrication on the wear properties of materials for prosthetic joints. J Biomed Mater Res 1999; 48(4): 465–473.

11.

Good

Clarke

Gustafson

. Wear of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene and polytetrafluoroethylene in a hip simulator – a dose-response study of protein concentration. Acta Orthop Scand 2000; 71(4): 365–369.

12.

DesJardins

Aurora

Tanner

. Increased total knee arthroplasty ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene wear using a clinically relevant hyaluronic acid simulator lubricant. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2006; 220(5): 609–623.

13.

Brandt

Briere

Marr

. Biochemical comparisons of osteoarthritic human synovial fluid with calf sera used in knee simulator wear testing. J Biomed Mater Res A 2010; 94(3): 961–971.

14.

Brandt

Charron

Zhao

. Calf serum constituent fractions influence polyethylene wear and microbial growth in knee simulator testing. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2012; 226(6): 427–440.

15.

Maskiewicz

Williams

Prates

. Characterization of protein degradation in serum-based lubricants during simulation wear testing of metal-on-metal hip prostheses. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 2010; 94(2): 429–440.

16.

Clarke

Good

Williams

. Ultra-low wear rates for rigid-on-rigid bearings in total hip replacements. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2000; 214(4): 331–347.

17.

Diem

Lentner

. Geigy scientific tables. 7th ed. Basle: J.R. Geigy S.A., 1970.

18.

Wang

Essner

Schmidig

. The effects of lubricant composition on in vitro wear testing of polymeric acetabular components. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 2004; 68(1): 45–52.

19.

Liao

Y-S

McNulty

Hanes

. Wear rate and surface morphology of UHMWPE cups are affected by the serum lubricant concentration in a hip simulation test. Wear 2003; 255: 1051–1056.

20.

Saikko

. Effect of lubricant protein concentration on the wear of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene sliding against a CoCr counterface. J Tribol 2003; 125(3): 638–642.

21.

Saikko

Ahlroos

. Type of motion and lubricant in wear simulation of polyethylene acetabular cup. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 1999; 213(4): 301–310.

22.

Saikko

. A hip wear simulator with 100 test stations. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2005; 219(5): 309–318.

23.

Bragdon

O’Connor

Lowenstein

. The importance of multidirectional motion on the wear of polyethylene. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 1996; 210: 157–165.

24.

Saikko

Ahlroos

. Wear simulation of UHMWPE for total hip replacement with a multidirectional motion pin-on-disk device: effects of counterface material, contact area, and lubricant. J Biomed Mater Res 2000; 49: 147–154.

25.

Saikko

Kostamo

. RandomPOD – a new method and device for advanced wear simulation of orthopaedic biomaterials. J Biomech 2011; 44(5): 810–814.

26.

Hall

Unsworth

Siney

. Wear in retrieved Charnley acetabular sockets. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 1996; 210: 197–207.

27.

Harsha

Joyce

. Challenges associated with using bovine serum in wear testing orthopaedic biopolymers. Proc IMechE, Part H: J Engineering in Medicine 2011; 225(10): 948–958.

28.

Haselberg

de Jong

Somsen

. Capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry for the analysis of intact proteins 2007–2010. Electrophoresis 2011; 32(1): 66–82.

29.

Cooke

Dowson

Wright

. The rheology of synovial fluid and some potential synthetic lubricants for degenerate synovial joints. Eng Med 1978; 7: 66–72.